3proxy/m4-haproxy-splice.csv at ef0c98e4c115a77b18530bf2c4559f0f991254cd

mirror of https://github.com/3proxy/3proxy.git synced 2026-10-15 16:15:49 +08:00

Vladimir Dubrovin c13c048f3f Benchmarks: measure the proxy under stress, add results

bench.py:
- the proxy gets one CPU, the client four, the origin three (8 CPUs), so
  the proxy is what runs out first
- CPU time is the busy time of a role's CPUs from /proc/stat, softirqs
  included: with IRQ time accounting the cgroup's own figure leaves out
  much of the network work
- every run records which side set its pace (proxy, client, origin), by
  the busy share of the role's CPUs and of its busiest thread
- a 50 KB keep-alive scenario with 2000 clients
- haproxy with splice: haproxy::splice-auto and haproxy::splice
- wrk timeouts counted apart from errors; tools found by absolute path;
  leftovers of an interrupted run are cleaned up

report.py turns runs into Markdown tables: throughput, the proxy's CPU
per gigabyte or per request, its peak memory, splice and copying proxies
in groups of their own, the best of each group marked.

RESULTS.md has the comparison of 0.9.4, 1.0.1, devel, nginx and haproxy,
with and without splice, on an Apple M4 and an Intel Skylake virtual
machine, and how it was measured; data/ has the measurements.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

2026-10-11 22:04:47 +03:00

14 KiB

Raw Blame History

1	proxy	scenario	rep	gbit	rate	p50_ms	p99_ms	retrans	prx_cpu_s	prx_task_s	cpu_s_per_gb	cpu_us_per_req	peak_mb	cli_util	prx_util	srv_util	cli_thread	srv_thread	bound
2	haproxy	stream1	0	12.470885279042667	nan	nan	nan	0	10.01	10.000143	0.6420094931512967	nan	30.35546875	0.2060312568787145	0.999001996007984	0.20981165133596144	0.12689777512488556	0.5330982979381341	proxy
3	haproxy-splice-auto	stream1	0	29.89117860621185	nan	nan	nan	0	9.98	9.507242	0.2670286748118488	nan	44.9296875	0.07797029702970297	0.9257884972170687	0.267870036101083	0.22455002102003757	0.7289534887541377	proxy
4	haproxy-splice	stream1	0	47.276622227678985	nan	nan	nan	0	9.92	9.068391	0.16783182521748577	nan	44.9765625	0.1667447306791569	0.9042844120328167	0.3173747622067216	0.38251154639763685	0.9515244508907347	origin
5	haproxy	stream16	0	9.126816993294865	nan	nan	nan	6	10.02	10.008672	0.87779780687716	nan	60.5625	0.12864186463469296	0.9515669515669516	0.7121966397013068	0.10178154529645375	1.3412808028682561	origin
6	haproxy-splice-auto	stream16	0	15.665416161722957	nan	nan	nan	10	10.01	10.009196	0.5108377207880435	nan	50.41015625	0.20893278934936654	0.9515209125475285	0.7146831530139104	0.17028929067443577	1.279742158250854	origin
7	haproxy-splice	stream16	0	21.84620025436062	nan	nan	nan	5	10.02	10.004629	0.3667854948979959	nan	60.96875	0.27884022208513265	0.9506641366223909	0.7257869249394673	0.24534597309840397	1.2156886451110003	origin
8	haproxy	stream1-down	0	13.960123370583007	nan	nan	nan	0	10.0	9.999398	0.5730096684278911	nan	35.16015625	0.142692750287687	0.9505703422053232	0.24893955461293743	0.5220067520499043	0.1168309458750056	proxy
9	haproxy-splice-auto	stream1-down	0	30.440812819799515	nan	nan	nan	0	10.0	9.77417	0.262794402388071	nan	40.4453125	0.19289074751698904	0.9398496240601504	0.2629094947251527	0.7307960970461047	0.270908729124504	proxy
10	haproxy-splice	stream1-down	0	47.62696450489736	nan	nan	nan	0	9.96	9.308399999999999	0.16728181803047182	nan	42.109375	0.2393629664844307	0.9162833486660533	0.21685991852083986	0.9514145276910632	0.38968830503606744	client
11	haproxy	http-ka-1k	0	0.44224741376	43767.86	1.4	2.12	0	10.1	10.09507	18.270316000954335	22.847732306014834	29.75390625	0.4527994201848161	0.9600760456273765	0.4640539839086426	0.6925179771661301	0.3136237673521794	proxy
12	haproxy-splice-auto	http-ka-1k	0	0.4412407808	43668.11	1.4	2.13	0	10.09	10.089706000000001	18.2938666398081	22.879247909916078	35.796875	0.45099108928896164	0.9600380589914367	0.46659761781460385	0.6936018485235806	0.32032686619155504	proxy
13	haproxy-splice	http-ka-1k	0	0.44400902144	43945.28	1.39	2.11	0	10.09	10.094142999999999	18.179810792630008	22.73300769632847	35.80078125	0.45607375271149675	0.9600380589914367	0.4628956927867151	0.698295986925665	0.3363989405582086	proxy
14	haproxy	http-ka-1m	0	5.8981141708800005	702.88	22.52	26.65	0	10.09	10.100358	1.3685730330302601	1421.3269474573883	37.34765625	0.6215240925493526	0.9600380589914367	0.16199095022624435	1.2678542450703074	0.026603372180188496	client
15	haproxy-splice-auto	http-ka-1m	0	6.25806934016	745.21	21.17	25.1	0	10.11	10.097527999999999	1.2924113748783124	1343.343077331916	44.88671875	0.5915651781686965	0.9601139601139601	0.15641103364655956	1.2825439345426253	0.026609834615750023	client
16	haproxy-splice	http-ka-1m	0	28.346784153599998	3382.78	4.66	5.72	0	9.99	9.951156	0.2819367430426858	295.2738450625129	52.44140625	0.5561823104693141	0.950523311132255	0.23213789268835142	1.6438977194646323	0.10547278904621821	client
17	haproxy	http-ka-50k-2000	0	4.07166255104	9744.89	193.14	512.74	0	10.09	10.039950999999999	1.9824825605791467	102.71183680117268	176.00390625	0.5347850156855508	0.9591254752851711	0.2985718135273511	0.8752281070644606	0.09218093276895038	proxy
18	haproxy-splice-auto	http-ka-50k-2000	0	3.9366898483200004	9421.6	200.61	570.88	0	10.09	10.047718999999999	2.050453632623551	106.2228258008822	182.140625	0.5346644481419855	0.9591254752851711	0.2891137855579869	0.884949502988458	0.09027899200636934	proxy
19	haproxy-splice	http-ka-50k-2000	0	4.9580867583999995	11984.65	161.23	393.17	0	10.12	10.072325999999999	1.6328879252231197	83.82826801852174	136.0390625	0.5424570111682325	0.9619771863117871	0.48020113136392206	0.844047476500976	0.11502621442719918	proxy
20	haproxy	http-close-1k	0	0.17045651456	16623.35	3.69	4.55	0	10.11	10.062655000000001	47.44905186450387	60.217282538774924	29.53515625	0.5420985633751592	0.9601139601139601	0.4613646633529146	0.8191778310296798	0.1492330706128941	proxy
21	haproxy-splice-auto	http-close-1k	0	0.169869312	16560.35	3.71	4.5	0	10.1	10.066307	47.565978250385804	60.38755657596575	35.7578125	0.5444001449800653	0.9600760456273765	0.46188850967007966	0.8210625053404907	0.1549161742184061	proxy
22	haproxy-splice	http-close-1k	0	0.16978542591999998	16555.02	3.72	4.42	0	10.1	10.062906	47.58947922778224	60.405253462835816	35.625	0.5433996383363472	0.9600760456273765	0.46545536114849706	0.8136549127740669	0.19295717801130827	proxy
23	haproxy-splice-auto	stream1	1	27.657705036907	nan	nan	nan	0	10.0	9.833874	0.28919158401814893	nan	40.65234375	0.15907990314769976	0.9900990099009901	0.26803708182184605	0.23978301610049976	0.698794525197252	proxy
24	haproxy-splice	stream1	1	44.66709383479124	nan	nan	nan	0	9.96	9.483912	0.17835478491282797	nan	44.984375	0.09460154241645244	0.9239332096474954	0.303347280334728	0.32433711631255135	0.838195850298805	proxy
25	haproxy	stream1	1	13.9130793718519	nan	nan	nan	0	10.0	10.001526	0.5748229081905579	nan	31.44921875	0.13121361397223466	0.9514747859181731	0.1997513468711148	0.11609297064619445	0.5218641241285665	proxy
26	haproxy-splice-auto	stream16	1	15.871037952656748	nan	nan	nan	11	10.04	10.011549	0.5056481486447681	nan	60.015625	0.22426160337552742	0.9516587677725118	0.7153581482639975	0.17497538300354495	1.2916249924400047	origin
27	haproxy-splice	stream16	1	22.562433611542634	nan	nan	nan	3	10.03	10.008068	0.3554258363877096	nan	55.68359375	0.27662203913491246	0.9516129032258065	0.7242658423493045	0.2416265140565151	1.2786892962500593	origin
28	haproxy	stream16	1	8.56274783754313	nan	nan	nan	8	10.02	10.009423	0.9354805272106242	nan	43.66015625	0.11837013430457546	0.9515669515669516	0.6884035681328822	0.09227811846283687	1.3248314087242796	origin
29	haproxy-splice-auto	stream1-down	1	29.532618920028337	nan	nan	nan	0	9.98	9.745233	0.2703355432066713	nan	40.23828125	0.18612747723620782	0.9379699248120301	0.08706208810267083	0.6914418421747642	0.23085334338816266	proxy
30	haproxy-splice	stream1-down	1	45.20745569639618	nan	nan	nan	0	9.96	9.484789000000001	0.1762340398376784	nan	44.6015625	0.2248864209994952	0.924791086350975	0.14191761855313256	0.8562900706132912	0.34591034845458013	proxy
31	haproxy	stream1-down	1	13.280333707459034	nan	nan	nan	0	10.0	10.001983	0.6023285462637666	nan	32.8359375	0.13882488479262672	0.9505703422053232	0.24791834542035993	0.5136100587673486	0.12826097080847915	proxy
32	haproxy-splice-auto	http-ka-1k	1	0.44711280639999995	44248.96	1.39	2.07	0	10.11	10.087575999999999	18.089394632020987	22.62276373644816	35.80859375	0.4535765895953757	0.9601139601139601	0.4662004662004662	0.6886438222525255	0.2945534754186057	proxy
33	haproxy-splice	http-ka-1k	1	0.44593840127999995	44132.54	1.39	2.1	0	10.1	10.087207	18.11909442382078	22.658491662348094	35.796875	0.45339366515837104	0.9600760456273765	0.46313603322949115	0.6945662425374509	0.3221811798409665	proxy
34	haproxy	http-ka-1k	1	0.44862275584	44402.84	1.38	2.08	0	10.1	10.091105	18.01067800243666	22.52262297129146	29.70703125	0.45520100955471426	0.9600760456273765	0.4665288188162316	0.6924554721759041	0.29546388241465266	proxy
35	haproxy-splice-auto	http-ka-1m	1	5.906922209279999	703.12	22.55	26.06	0	10.09	10.096472	1.3665323012581037	1420.9266300521053	43.19921875	0.6057525951557093	0.9591254752851711	0.13498452012383902	1.2206981774202692	0.020907726724359123	client
36	haproxy-splice	http-ka-1m	1	28.00318676992	3338.12	4.72	6.53	0	10.0	9.953499	0.28568177135444134	299.43705833033897	52.203125	0.5647553686074829	0.9505703422053232	0.2257247396566282	1.6406109424173014	0.09314792662013098	client
37	haproxy	http-ka-1m	1	5.91371698176	704.32	22.55	25.24	0	10.09	10.092942	1.3649621760555857	1418.5294531140166	38.8359375	0.624	0.9600380589914367	0.15222623345367028	1.253629079008308	0.030413129775669574	client
38	haproxy-splice-auto	http-ka-50k-2000	1	4.0017854464000004	9573.19	198.04	506.2	0	10.08	10.040982	2.0151005365003662	104.48410970831519	184.0	0.5310818333642605	0.9581749049429658	0.29093886462882096	0.877336596256015	0.0921928976926707	proxy
39	haproxy-splice	http-ka-50k-2000	1	4.850209259520001	11724.01	164.56	467.97	0	10.11	10.057952	1.6675569170804037	85.57643473844591	132.6796875	0.5495367070563079	0.9610266159695817	0.48620045652625027	0.8827828822617122	0.11212372578867655	proxy
40	haproxy	http-ka-50k-2000	1	4.05740191744	9702.65	195.76	645.83	0	10.09	10.040626	1.9894504326288172	103.36843830676555	177.29296875	0.5312326227988878	0.9582146248812915	0.2982786444324906	0.8723025194799039	0.09122591365490804	proxy
41	haproxy-splice-auto	http-close-1k	1	0.17246978048	16820.23	3.67	4.28	0	10.0	9.971963	46.384937568397376	59.415235254623994	35.59375	0.5402319681043857	0.9514747859181731	0.46653279785809904	0.812422387488307	0.20048900026686614	proxy
42	haproxy-splice	http-close-1k	1	0.17339252736000002	16905.08	3.65	4.24	0	10.11	10.064707	46.64560879955097	59.21318503681057	35.70703125	0.5444988218234548	0.959203036053131	0.4523154516276937	0.8220920443166914	0.22048409460256574	proxy
43	haproxy	http-close-1k	1	0.17221812224000002	16794.68	3.68	4.25	0	10.09	10.066023999999999	46.87079324178793	59.48731251768701	29.53515625	0.5452406804198335	0.9600380589914367	0.4732519422863485	0.8219748116165262	0.1681692979728716	proxy
44	haproxy-splice	stream1	2	44.025537299292175	nan	nan	nan	0	9.98	9.64556	0.18131571189526788	nan	44.91796875	0.15224166866458883	0.9327102803738317	0.3000352982703848	0.3729495374137985	0.8229787358803089	proxy
45	haproxy	stream1	2	13.420193637999308	nan	nan	nan	0	10.0	10.00282	0.5958974733855598	nan	31.4140625	0.05717791411042945	0.9514747859181731	0.19552609776304888	0.12086002113679797	0.5182343923337167	proxy
46	haproxy-splice-auto	stream1	2	29.507297892950234	nan	nan	nan	0	9.97	9.623803	0.2702392892979522	nan	44.4609375	0.07093881856540084	0.9774509803921568	0.27580772261623326	0.2157945829744378	0.7366131461399941	proxy
47	haproxy-splice	stream16	2	22.12554165032845	nan	nan	nan	2	10.02	10.003693	0.36212735525203216	nan	54.74609375	0.2913907284768212	0.9506641366223909	0.7249082007343941	0.23862270559995377	1.2426461145422065	origin
48	haproxy	stream16	2	8.580147028941548	nan	nan	nan	6	10.03	10.00947	0.9346185347163698	nan	51.703125	0.17872340425531916	0.9516129032258065	0.6840330983757279	0.09415712324018922	1.340238855783671	origin
49	haproxy-splice-auto	stream16	2	15.973129606882429	nan	nan	nan	13	10.03	10.012126	0.5019140976009596	nan	60.0	0.2711763538980361	0.9516129032258065	0.711083819465766	0.1807299535793587	1.3052893396648573	origin
50	haproxy-splice	stream1-down	2	48.59185309676415	nan	nan	nan	0	9.93	9.026188000000001	0.16346198078264335	nan	44.9375	0.23901164172012354	0.9019073569482289	0.1280977312390925	0.9513393656065166	0.34494886912870415	client
51	haproxy	stream1-down	2	13.238887720464081	nan	nan	nan	0	10.01	10.002078	0.6048169736106161	nan	31.21875	0.1375432525951557	0.9506172839506173	0.05361384458771632	0.49179301438541884	0.11592095587872998	proxy
52	haproxy-splice-auto	stream1-down	2	30.76905592533716	nan	nan	nan	0	9.99	9.65392	0.2597207502459875	nan	41.29296875	0.1940376569037657	0.9336448598130841	0.09265614275909403	0.7237916928519336	0.22990802153107426	proxy
53	haproxy-splice	http-ka-1k	2	0.44904218624000003	44444.43	1.38	2.08	0	10.1	10.094124	17.99385502653302	22.500796439081878	35.796875	0.4565061107117182	0.9591642924976258	0.46492363448097335	0.6905813584959353	0.3030430566697726	proxy
54	haproxy	http-ka-1k	2	0.44568674304	44112.76	1.39	2.09	0	10.01	10.002418	17.967776975769922	22.674504207581574	29.71484375	0.44922797456857405	0.9515209125475285	0.4595788926436184	0.6905693150174204	0.3098286205277593	proxy
55	haproxy-splice-auto	http-ka-1k	2	0.44602228736	44139.96	1.39	2.11	0	10.01	10.00352	17.954259746523533	22.658695755512447	35.79296875	0.4514140681653372	0.9515209125475285	0.4600780234070221	0.6927552847361909	0.30133454145667854	proxy
56	haproxy-splice	http-ka-1m	2	27.4877906944	3276.96	4.78	6.88	0	9.99	9.923215	0.2907472662627697	304.7961923358555	52.234375	0.5973016235993597	0.999	0.22384066587395957	1.6187790952229908	0.10784169195139078	client
57	haproxy	http-ka-1m	2	5.767839088640001	687.06	23.09	26.32	0	10.11	10.097942	1.4022582592377886	1456.9822741028968	37.94140625	0.6142604074402126	0.9601139601139601	0.15242424242424243	1.2832361890399908	0.02660297986960112	client
58	haproxy-splice-auto	http-ka-1m	2	5.5785082060799995	663.85	23.81	28.12	0	10.1	10.099212000000001	1.4484159028741108	1506.3385533184191	43.671875	0.6274887604367373	0.9600760456273765	0.1124129195693477	1.2758842161775354	0.028503600136568153	client
59	haproxy-splice	http-ka-50k-2000	2	4.92235128832	11897.29	163.37	414.88	0	10.13	10.062857	1.6463676656376751	84.49552916054985	151.32421875	0.5455516014234876	0.9620132953466287	0.483153078202995	0.8592217872562844	0.11119336969404632	proxy
60	haproxy	http-ka-50k-2000	2	4.06822322176	9736.04	194.05	680.82	0	10.09	10.042601	1.984158577342735	102.92977516627903	177.98828125	0.5328911000552792	0.9582146248812915	0.29488220958570266	0.8649197963205894	0.09123941413633474	proxy
61	haproxy-splice-auto	http-ka-50k-2000	2	4.08936251392	9784.39	191.94	569.22	0	10.08	10.042211	1.9719454982409896	102.35684765279908	181.41796875	0.5373106760251201	0.9590865842055185	0.2985756517065305	0.8915635476483981	0.09314699784890836	proxy
62	haproxy-splice	http-close-1k	2	0.17230200832	16803.03	3.67	4.27	0	10.1	10.066593	46.894404068661764	59.51819724684141	35.89453125	0.5420374069366262	0.9600760456273765	0.4473441108545035	0.8136090213947146	0.18058427193404752	proxy
63	haproxy	http-close-1k	2	0.17431527424	16996.31	3.62	4.34	0	10.09	10.064283	46.30690015658836	58.78035140047537	29.65625	0.5434585374705135	0.9600380589914367	0.43952734012974976	0.8193729517211945	0.16926621774991768	proxy
64	haproxy-splice-auto	http-close-1k	2	0.17079205888	16650.93	3.71	4.33	0	10.02	9.972787	46.93426645574963	60.12817743213077	35.7421875	0.5415685564209383	0.9515669515669516	0.4681848626925653	0.8173954622833055	0.1615753572679179	proxy

14 KiB Raw Blame History

14 KiB

Raw Blame History