3proxy/bench/data/results-full7/intel-mixshaped.csv
Vladimir Dubrovin bb52a5fb0e Bench: the four versions against every proxy, 30 October results
3proxy 0.9.9.2, 1.0.2, devel (c3702866) and the experimental head (5de7ae2)
against nginx (with and without proxy_half_close), haproxy (plain and
splice-auto), envoy, squid, tinyproxy and dante on the M4 and the Skylake
host: the plain suite and the mix over a shaped link (20 Mbit/s, 5 ms,
0.5% loss), three runs a cell, proxy memory capped at 6 GB (--prx-mem-mb,
new). dante re-measured on the SOCKS scenarios only; its mix behaviour
stays in its own smaller-pool table. RESULTS.md rebuilt around six uniform
tables: throughput, memory and errors, p75/p90/p99.
2026-10-30 12:21:40 +03:00

104 lines
24 KiB
Plaintext

proxy,scenario,rep,gbit,rate,p50_ms,p75_ms,p90_ms,p99_ms,errors,timeouts,retrans,prx_cpu_s,prx_task_s,cpu_s_per_gb,cpu_us_per_req,peak_mb,cli_util,prx_util,srv_util,cli_thread,srv_thread,bound
direct,mix-http,0,3.7925668444,10727.25,65.536,163.84,376.832,1769.472,0,4,0,17.95,0.0,1.8931769154185878,83.66543149455825,0.0,0.9715498119394349,0.8650602409638555,0.8373798684876075,1.5364878862552123,0.49904901782485167,client
3proxy-0.9.9.2,mix-http,0,1.4467625652,3950.8,43.008,106.496,884.736,6553.6,0,0,0,20.76,9.008863,5.7397116843786025,262.7315986635618,2995.0703125,0.6894337419731466,1.0,0.28702555197221535,1.2484590976871885,0.364399320698309,client
3proxy-1.0.2,mix-http,0,1.4151055884000001,3850.9,34.816,110.592,786.432,7340.032,0,0,0,20.66,9.595282,5.839846911596014,268.24898075774496,2296.265625,0.692036783408335,1.0,0.27752864972595914,1.2544486377978215,0.3468213178396677,client
3proxy-devel-c37,mix-http,0,1.5230865595999998,4166.45,34.816,180.224,786.432,6291.456,0,0,0,20.64,8.238496,5.4205717645937534,247.69288002976154,1490.0703125,0.708989533405067,1.0,0.2896311066799601,1.260842953285457,0.36797298930217776,client
3proxy-bp,mix-http,0,1.9767382124000001,5398.35,180.224,376.832,622.592,3670.016,0,0,0,20.35,6.99204,4.117894797064227,188.4835181120157,743.44140625,0.7923395037416305,1.0,0.31351214574898784,1.342335206485557,0.4013130933830413,client
nginx,mix-http,0,1.5846334028,4330.85,59.392,278.528,442.368,6291.456,0,0,0,20.48,9.257755999999999,5.16964995533035,236.44319244490111,261.2734375,0.7248698044610395,0.9995119570522206,0.2169576059850374,1.2842772804688178,0.2967196991121169,client
nginx-halfclose,mix-http,0,1.6181492076,4438.65,57.344,237.568,393.216,6291.456,0,0,0,20.49,9.249326,5.0650458941027505,230.81342300023655,257.96875,0.7230739185626404,0.9932137663596704,0.20966135458167331,1.2840847968417708,0.2940918363265054,client
haproxy,mix-http,0,1.6135814112,4969.05,188.416,344.064,819.2,3801.088,0,39,0,20.63,10.489118999999999,5.114089653439359,207.5849508457351,440.1328125,0.7793190416141236,0.9951760733236855,0.24022621096631425,1.4414379711469514,0.2951664012897329,client
haproxy-splice-auto,mix-http,0,2.0185862808,5706.65,237.568,442.368,819.2,1966.08,0,3,0,20.59,9.22542,4.080083213850009,180.4035642627461,410.36328125,0.8147362330022182,0.9856390617520344,0.25469626738228834,1.4023163758668042,0.3136014673330226,client
envoy,mix-http,0,1.1995963336,3288,557.056,622.592,720.896,950.272,0,0,0,20.81,11.875276000000001,6.939000867916623,316.4537712895377,625.40625,0.5822397631968427,1.0,0.14584855125395665,1.0923209205131004,0.18605516981557174,client
squid,mix-http,0,0.6077446688,1800.4,425.984,753.664,1703.936,8388.608,0,38,0,20.28,15.800038999999998,13.347710669379055,563.2081759608976,835.13671875,0.3101328574261352,1.0,0.10644118378512808,0.5934712848768224,0.1317623923723369,proxy
tinyproxy,mix-http,0,0.5666371388,1500.9,851.968,1572.864,3276.8,6291.456,22350,0,0,20.53,12.693909000000001,14.49251988210837,683.9229795456059,791.7578125,0.4528169718803162,0.9932268988872762,0.24519467718087729,0.9638063686529155,0.3039245025794935,client
direct,mix-connect,0,3.6153283976,10193.7,65.536,172.032,393.216,1900.544,0,4,0,18.28,0.0,2.0224995341651395,89.66322336344997,0.0,0.9342673447845696,0.8738049713193117,0.820125786163522,1.4500701556394027,0.5191932367541435,client
3proxy-0.9.9.2,mix-connect,0,1.6900707687999998,4565.1,32.768,122.88,425.984,6029.312,2,0,0,20.81,8.220649000000002,4.925237542514438,227.92490854526736,3319.94921875,0.7384630237497587,1.0,0.2810327706057597,1.3106575587548626,0.3473923061346837,client
3proxy-1.0.2,mix-connect,0,1.7307813708,4641.25,31.744,110.592,507.904,5505.024,0,0,0,20.47,7.922498,4.730811261398862,220.52248855373014,2036.71484375,0.7441974822974036,1.0,0.27079158316633267,1.310631519271125,0.33620499017120886,client
3proxy-devel-c37,mix-connect,0,1.8860430572,5100.3,26.624,77.824,458.752,4980.736,0,0,0,20.38,7.284199999999999,4.32227672050201,199.79216908809286,1488.49609375,0.7816352697504685,1.0,0.2905679513184584,1.3474692448735348,0.37643805731994967,client
3proxy-bp,mix-connect,0,2.2890777611999997,6236.85,81.92,245.76,524.288,3145.728,0,0,0,20.54,6.210869000000001,3.5892183914682465,164.66645822811194,472.5859375,0.8387159722899795,1.0,0.3202793714143178,1.4282841927555807,0.41094814782379163,client
squid,mix-connect,0,1.6080350356,4344.75,55.296,188.416,294.912,6029.312,405,0,0,20.35,9.524004,5.062078760592895,234.19068991311352,1859.65625,0.7141578842712268,1.0,0.23809523809523808,1.3000750895568514,0.2913961152864117,client
tinyproxy,mix-connect,0,0.934820032,2511.5,51.2,122.88,1441.792,11534.336,312,0,0,20.6,12.030831000000001,8.814530837952775,410.1134780011945,1089.69140625,0.5735603405107661,1.0,0.2013888888888889,1.191796227460615,0.23947323186459699,client
direct,mix-socks,0,3.6719007628,10353.9,69.632,172.032,393.216,1835.008,0,6,0,17.91,0.0,1.951033119570777,86.4891490163127,0.0,0.9565980688578952,0.8719571567672834,0.8428025477707006,1.4326749639352325,0.5207522372332187,client
3proxy-0.9.9.2,mix-socks,0,1.7944482335999998,4828.4,32.768,110.592,409.6,5242.88,0,0,0,20.4,7.881349,4.547358818832855,211.25010355397234,1963.234375,0.7578325123152709,1.0,0.2866902834008097,1.3128129195510476,0.36438839512255655,client
3proxy-1.0.2,mix-socks,0,1.76257236,4740.15,32.768,118.784,376.832,5767.168,0,0,0,20.54,8.091188,4.661368909699684,216.65981034355454,1959.38671875,0.7571330522600255,1.0,0.2778894472361809,1.3145673613371134,0.34908622473349077,client
3proxy-devel-c37,mix-socks,0,1.796491708,4919.8,32.768,126.976,524.288,5242.88,0,0,0,20.61,7.672556,4.588944086570757,209.45973413553398,1504.609375,0.7391134924500731,1.0,0.28475336322869954,1.30208882254255,0.3593807481501423,client
3proxy-bp,mix-socks,0,2.1377239684,5819.8,118.784,278.528,524.288,3407.872,0,0,0,20.74,6.323697999999999,3.880762962212198,178.18481734767516,492.765625,0.8068952159597134,1.0,0.3036688150718889,1.3744089189276907,0.3840376980315564,client
direct,mix-relay,0,3.827851382,10747.2,69.632,163.84,376.832,1769.472,0,4,0,17.37,0.0,1.8151174919361068,80.81174631531934,0.0,0.962244312750908,0.8259629101283881,0.8241319010741943,1.5151292421763203,0.5108124253676186,client
3proxy-0.9.9.2,mix-relay,0,1.7917519204,4810.2,32.768,102.4,491.52,5505.024,0,0,0,20.34,7.755694,4.5408071884101435,211.42572034426843,1930.81640625,0.7588153724247226,1.0,0.2782564622402433,1.3044425883654622,0.3480937955476714,client
3proxy-1.0.2,mix-relay,0,1.7645891864,4720.65,30.72,98.304,491.52,5767.168,0,0,0,20.43,7.820682000000001,4.631106244435275,216.38969209748657,1916.5,0.7490909090909091,1.0,0.2702498107494323,1.297280755992803,0.33780392472243176,client
3proxy-devel-c37,mix-relay,0,1.7757536592,4821.9,27.648,86.016,475.136,5242.88,0,0,0,20.67,7.574277,4.656051224878141,214.33459839482362,1412.56640625,0.7482224603097302,1.0,0.279,1.3036156173816653,0.355436918246683,client
3proxy-bp,mix-relay,0,2.2193804052,6030.3,86.016,262.144,524.288,3276.8,0,0,0,20.35,5.960249,3.667690307136177,168.7312405684626,472.24609375,0.834927521940637,1.0,0.3160687215765538,1.3963002490687673,0.39122361021221325,client
nginx,mix-relay,0,2.0307971447999997,5496.75,36.864,131.072,262.144,4718.592,529,0,0,20.37,6.584405000000001,4.012217577153647,185.29130850047756,687.8984375,0.7958017147925496,1.0,0.29763104838709675,1.3434880452279363,0.37404407809510726,client
nginx-halfclose,mix-relay,0,2.1935230816,5962.95,32.768,122.88,262.144,4063.232,0,0,0,20.83,7.092056,3.7984555849407657,174.66187038294802,695.1171875,0.8063023995374385,1.0,0.31206726013847674,1.3587232676856518,0.3951868895727012,client
haproxy,mix-relay,0,1.8882960296,5426.2,204.8,327.68,622.592,2621.44,0,9,0,20.73,10.311071,4.3912606233443725,191.01765508090375,458.44140625,0.8189663531465141,1.0,0.3071782178217822,1.5221507806344918,0.3741606714000323,client
haproxy-splice-auto,mix-relay,0,2.1297471024,5841.4,253.952,393.216,589.824,1245.184,0,1,0,20.83,8.809908,3.91220158985577,178.29629883247168,418.4375,0.8451494341812554,1.0,0.31526005888125613,1.438389290566383,0.3836921333681207,client
envoy,mix-relay,0,1.8583825148,5103.6,360.448,409.6,491.52,720.896,0,0,0,20.38,8.006368,4.386610364162473,199.66298299239753,720.8515625,0.7546103509815586,1.0,0.2510702593805087,1.3263414255523684,0.3171597273081297,client
3proxy-0.9.9.2,mix-http,1,1.5365483195999998,4206.9,38.912,90.112,753.664,6291.456,0,0,0,20.32,8.77051,5.289778327385052,241.50799876393543,3032.76953125,0.7283815946053154,1.0,0.29883603238866396,1.2722538188091126,0.3784581469791765,client
3proxy-1.0.2,mix-http,1,1.359447512,3713.55,36.864,131.072,851.968,7340.032,0,0,0,20.42,9.356383000000001,6.00832318121893,274.9390744705201,2276.79296875,0.6811997219187605,1.0,0.2702431687139634,1.2506480939002742,0.3364080238519106,client
3proxy-devel-c37,mix-http,1,1.5380163992,4224.55,36.864,212.992,950.272,6291.456,0,0,0,20.39,8.096017,5.30293435378345,241.32747866636683,1510.56640625,0.7151767151767152,1.0,0.2861825516893596,1.2677805775530817,0.36432120358638664,client
3proxy-bp,mix-http,1,2.0086143008,5501.9,147.456,344.064,589.824,3538.944,0,0,0,20.47,7.086851999999999,4.076442150560635,186.0266453407005,723.9765625,0.8003329416372895,1.0,0.3245481927710843,1.3478210543649503,0.4103385005337802,client
nginx,mix-http,1,1.5908382328,4348.85,57.344,253.952,458.752,6029.312,0,0,0,20.49,9.215694000000001,5.152000895511794,235.57952102279913,266.64453125,0.7229895190518171,0.9965953307392996,0.22150323544051767,1.2877644061833837,0.3060161174396406,client
nginx-halfclose,mix-http,1,1.6568009095999998,4524.45,51.2,262.144,409.6,5767.168,0,0,0,20.54,9.336031,4.958954303075305,226.98891577981854,263.65234375,0.7320236136649569,0.9908345393150024,0.22140039447731755,1.279656678164035,0.3042659325764226,client
haproxy,mix-http,1,1.592423668,4885.6,188.416,344.064,819.2,3932.16,0,39,0,20.7,10.494652,5.19962128570925,211.84706074995907,446.484375,0.7699123661148978,1.0,0.23353884093711466,1.4068875489147645,0.2867959232356858,client
haproxy-splice-auto,mix-http,1,1.8236510436,5202.35,253.952,491.52,917.504,2097.152,0,2,0,20.59,9.024701,4.5162148914968,197.8913375685988,415.86328125,0.7813498595913625,0.9899038461538462,0.23058074001470227,1.3685043793296976,0.2897346419517138,client
envoy,mix-http,1,1.1892162072,3253.1,589.824,622.592,720.896,983.04,0,0,0,20.84,11.922498999999998,7.009658924534039,320.30985828901663,601.10546875,0.5706148104498134,1.0,0.1436544528027178,1.0817599228001442,0.1808471416260037,client
squid,mix-http,1,0.6057821852,1783.2,425.984,753.664,1703.936,8388.608,0,38,0,20.73,16.146137,13.688088231353952,581.2584118438762,825.78125,0.3061917701863354,1.0,0.10546780072904009,0.5961457683502721,0.12696931312174825,proxy
tinyproxy,mix-http,1,0.5747426852,1538.15,819.2,1835.008,3407.872,6291.456,22353,1,0,20.52,12.682466999999999,14.28117349095755,667.035074602607,799.04296875,0.4581916383276655,0.9922630560928434,0.25036891293654695,0.9725895440690138,0.30708251227285777,client
direct,mix-http,1,3.6029852008,10150.1,73.728,172.032,393.216,1900.544,0,4,0,17.47,0.0,1.9395028318318925,86.05826543580851,0.0,0.952362358453729,0.8526110297706199,0.8487780040733197,1.4213961946610139,0.5151995952200122,client
3proxy-0.9.9.2,mix-connect,1,1.6476152432,4447.05,34.816,147.456,458.752,5767.168,2,0,0,20.58,7.972580000000001,4.996312114721518,231.38934799473807,3310.51171875,0.741549916723817,1.0,0.27802690582959644,1.312922240175881,0.3424850828539742,client
3proxy-1.0.2,mix-connect,1,1.6954633224000002,4561.75,30.72,102.4,524.288,5767.168,0,0,0,20.44,7.9329469999999995,4.822280666282139,224.03682797172138,2028.36328125,0.7422629607727184,1.0,0.27450980392156865,1.3142266060283878,0.33999975506367935,client
3proxy-devel-c37,mix-connect,1,1.7868406652,4826,27.648,90.112,507.904,5242.88,0,0,0,20.53,7.606198000000001,4.595821082391158,212.70203066721922,1484.234375,0.7673214111208834,1.0,0.28900576008014023,1.3340946051973475,0.36570614623811737,client
3proxy-bp,mix-connect,1,2.0114853947999998,5459.65,155.648,311.296,557.056,3538.944,0,0,0,20.58,6.077264999999999,4.09249802224813,188.47362010385282,477.390625,0.806234121555599,1.0,0.3075386919620569,1.3846196816773055,0.3882030727460537,client
squid,mix-connect,1,1.6203784336,4383,55.296,221.184,327.68,5767.168,408,0,0,20.46,9.732886,5.050672009882026,233.40177960301165,1853.41796875,0.7193138124815144,1.0,0.24099378881987576,1.30622848257598,0.291380113836862,client
tinyproxy,mix-connect,1,0.9365021352,2520.25,55.296,118.784,1507.328,11534.336,317,1,0,20.7,12.075553999999999,8.841410701355976,410.67354429124094,1094.34765625,0.5793800138655046,1.0,0.20078837152007883,1.1952656183813548,0.23333123388659077,client
direct,mix-connect,1,3.2900844384,9338.85,59.392,212.992,458.752,2097.152,0,7,0,19.66,0.0,2.3902122110350272,105.25921285811422,0.0,0.9816208818066282,0.961839530332681,0.8153885876581461,1.6885287423068878,0.49459734461741295,client
3proxy-0.9.9.2,mix-socks,1,1.5304642164000002,4100.85,36.864,155.648,475.136,6553.6,0,0,0,20.71,7.924129000000001,5.4127368096758595,252.50862626040941,1903.48046875,0.7020447906523856,1.0,0.2543597409068261,1.2770241358966545,0.31813280993460086,client
3proxy-1.0.2,mix-socks,1,1.7060475868,4579.05,32.768,122.88,393.216,5767.168,0,0,0,20.59,8.028305,4.827532399285593,224.82829407846606,1957.015625,0.7390412964951675,1.0,0.2716417910447761,1.3038548911798769,0.3340546576352663,client
3proxy-devel-c37,mix-socks,1,1.81471178,4919.25,30.72,98.304,425.984,5242.88,0,0,0,20.3,7.490137,4.474539753084096,206.33226609747422,1499.5234375,0.7676328024532595,1.0,0.2864016206634591,1.329366387702547,0.36369370839221693,client
3proxy-bp,mix-socks,1,2.0677098148,5642.9,147.456,311.296,524.288,3407.872,0,0,0,20.4,6.075062000000001,3.9463951573829905,180.75812082439882,491.578125,0.8126909055079318,1.0,0.3005547150781644,1.3815045623920386,0.3794030893939197,client
direct,mix-socks,1,3.3952261731999998,9601.65,63.488,188.416,442.368,2097.152,0,7,0,19.0,0.0,2.2384370325576874,98.94132779261898,0.0,0.9770717963664627,0.9205426356589147,0.8077809060660354,1.6345266389254174,0.4907304638749856,client
3proxy-0.9.9.2,mix-relay,1,1.6585256308,4458,34.816,114.688,458.752,5767.168,0,0,0,20.62,7.773664,4.973091670595122,231.2696276357111,1887.21484375,0.7293761593283218,1.0,0.2704056084126189,1.2858199624868625,0.33622231496656113,client
3proxy-1.0.2,mix-relay,1,1.7430399904,4700.35,31.744,114.688,524.288,5505.024,0,0,0,20.65,7.967897000000001,4.738847097882395,219.664493069665,1895.3359375,0.7376300184699135,1.0,0.27488151658767773,1.2896681992500112,0.34551033844115886,client
3proxy-devel-c37,mix-relay,1,1.810516326,4904.15,26.624,81.92,507.904,5242.88,0,0,0,20.37,7.386196,4.500373668544317,207.68124955394921,1411.46484375,0.754631454473788,1.0,0.2825757575757576,1.3104020870936561,0.35724968409507457,client
3proxy-bp,mix-relay,1,2.2048707872,6004.95,86.016,278.528,524.288,3276.8,0,0,0,20.81,6.2375940000000005,3.775277920286103,173.27371585108952,470.0234375,0.8196990160138916,1.0,0.30680137999014295,1.3848098369764548,0.3906448433910131,client
nginx,mix-relay,1,2.0299592944000002,5498,36.864,155.648,311.296,4456.448,518,0,0,20.36,6.628211,4.011903106858673,185.15823935976718,693.765625,0.7903973183476289,1.0,0.29601613716591024,1.341411108277541,0.3719539344733997,client
nginx-halfclose,mix-relay,1,2.1437265536,5817.35,34.816,139.264,294.912,4194.304,0,0,0,20.39,6.80374,3.8045897161200326,175.2516180047616,707.80859375,0.8258603736479843,1.0,0.31098790322580644,1.376108486214097,0.3912898536302876,client
haproxy,mix-relay,1,1.927068968,5534.85,196.608,327.68,622.592,2621.44,0,8,0,20.67,10.319419,4.2904536045645045,186.72592753191142,462.48046875,0.8244148781198407,1.0,0.3117719950433705,1.5262346715282138,0.37951522505746105,client
haproxy-splice-auto,mix-relay,1,1.9506862852,5386.9,262.144,425.984,622.592,1376.256,0,2,0,20.82,8.638462,4.269266700230143,193.24657966548477,416.50390625,0.8116180166247825,1.0,0.3010329562223315,1.4045116836896339,0.3685872447867408,client
envoy,mix-relay,1,1.8337787124,5052.95,360.448,409.6,491.52,720.896,0,0,0,20.78,8.312922,4.532717030574251,205.62245816800086,719.38671875,0.7455586836229492,1.0,0.2569735867686991,1.3103279085891102,0.3238021066680405,client
direct,mix-relay,1,3.3566420972,9466.45,59.392,204.8,442.368,2097.152,0,6,0,20.0,0.0,2.3833342275821825,105.63622054730126,0.0,0.9345318208036916,0.9601536245799328,0.7905077825976015,1.556201360431178,0.5003262441896349,client
3proxy-1.0.2,mix-http,2,1.3754473007999999,3751.45,34.816,114.688,917.504,7340.032,0,0,0,20.41,9.400409,5.935523662194532,272.02814911567526,2288.41015625,0.6816245666171372,1.0,0.2712846347607053,1.2577646158808178,0.34402454663740406,client
3proxy-devel-c37,mix-http,2,1.532709484,4187.85,34.816,188.416,884.736,6291.456,0,0,0,20.51,8.217161999999998,5.352612537236705,244.87505521926525,1506.6953125,0.721221613155834,1.0,0.29345372460496616,1.264653334182259,0.3733221077704697,client
3proxy-bp,mix-http,2,1.8359566236,5043.55,221.184,409.6,655.36,3538.944,0,0,0,20.37,6.907209,4.438013346972846,201.94109307927948,709.66796875,0.7740124125701902,1.0,0.3036120232381915,1.317707332102975,0.3853284087718263,client
nginx,mix-http,2,1.5159070932,4135.4,59.392,262.144,442.368,6291.456,0,0,0,20.4,9.135387,5.38291563948993,246.65086811432994,257.66796875,0.714764769701154,1.0,0.2151803607214429,1.2762476652490322,0.2938223300438697,client
nginx-halfclose,mix-http,2,1.6160463892,4431.55,55.296,262.144,393.216,6291.456,0,0,0,20.57,9.305418,5.091438002638743,232.0858390405163,255.82421875,0.7147018838609439,0.9946808510638298,0.2176063303659743,1.2816511226402947,0.30132254494530014,client
haproxy,mix-http,2,1.7402751455999999,5268.7,172.032,311.296,753.664,3670.016,0,37,0,20.46,10.4611,4.702704638799158,194.16554368250232,454.7421875,0.8018071105873109,1.0,0.24275724275724275,1.4658673616262299,0.3031236145156672,client
haproxy-splice-auto,mix-http,2,1.9062484912,5450.3,245.76,458.752,851.968,2031.616,0,3,0,20.61,9.197791,4.324724734502127,189.07216116544043,414.12890625,0.8047793409134708,0.9875419262098706,0.23724676592628752,1.3732239364812082,0.2999093720351483,client
envoy,mix-http,2,1.2340669227999999,3385.8,557.056,622.592,688.128,950.272,0,0,0,20.55,11.697932999999999,6.660902944671325,303.47332978911925,627.81640625,0.5975718977012638,1.0,0.14742800886044793,1.1244047431612372,0.18587187031698424,client
squid,mix-http,2,0.590630202,1750.35,425.984,753.664,1703.936,8388.608,0,41,0,20.33,15.863612000000002,13.768344342133725,580.7409946582112,829.8828125,0.3047779206647542,1.0,0.1019139945314442,0.5810278739555177,0.12702511015429613,proxy
tinyproxy,mix-http,2,0.5927339627999999,1601.05,786.432,1769.472,3276.8,6029.312,24142,0,0,20.32,12.624711999999999,13.712728660939824,634.5835545423316,791.6015625,0.4649532710280374,1.0,0.25773453093812376,0.9795451166067912,0.3177804592301821,client
direct,mix-http,2,3.5715397064000003,10094.1,73.728,172.032,393.216,1835.008,0,7,0,17.21,0.0,1.9274600216999564,85.2478180323159,0.0,0.9570828037931371,0.8428011753183153,0.8415286624203822,1.4444425455359644,0.5118111159422316,client
3proxy-0.9.9.2,mix-http,2,1.4066522635999998,3853.7,43.008,98.304,819.2,6815.744,5,0,0,20.43,8.753055,5.809538157700513,265.06993279186236,2984.80078125,0.6920336467095497,1.0,0.2762694821518351,1.2652839845270891,0.35087519146473706,client
3proxy-1.0.2,mix-connect,2,1.6918213408,4556,31.744,102.4,524.288,5767.168,0,0,0,20.41,7.972148000000001,4.825568636070961,223.99034240561897,2026.49609375,0.7530766958747662,1.0,0.2739656912209889,1.3212704625696279,0.3427226603396365,client
3proxy-devel-c37,mix-connect,2,1.7726697884,4790.45,28.672,90.112,475.136,5505.024,0,0,0,20.57,7.596036,4.6415864104202615,214.6979928816708,1491.859375,0.7517827488522028,1.0,0.2832456799398948,1.3239430577992806,0.35939330989122453,client
3proxy-bp,mix-connect,2,2.1416514092,5834.2,102.4,278.528,557.056,3407.872,0,0,0,20.68,6.223701,3.8624399678050088,177.23081142230296,470.9375,0.80917288858722,1.0,0.30092016911216113,1.3955984400584132,0.3806648316668819,client
squid,mix-connect,2,1.7454086616,4704,49.152,180.224,294.912,5242.88,445,0,0,20.51,9.748043,4.700331893895536,218.00595238095238,1862.8671875,0.7350024545900835,1.0,0.24560099132589838,1.333955665583027,0.3002589001201667,client
tinyproxy,mix-connect,2,0.9506899268,2548.45,55.296,126.976,1572.864,11010.048,306,0,0,20.45,11.953600000000002,8.604277556125673,401.22427357805725,1088.33203125,0.5833417060182859,1.0,0.18889166875156368,1.197757209664616,0.22261143774540343,client
direct,mix-connect,2,3.4953713852,9874.3,63.488,188.416,425.984,2031.616,0,5,0,18.97,0.0,2.1708708928982166,96.05744204652481,0.0,0.94793364656247,0.9080899952130206,0.8024722502522704,1.562173597445972,0.490248955900716,client
3proxy-0.9.9.2,mix-connect,2,1.7326786375999998,4680.8,34.816,122.88,458.752,5505.024,0,0,0,20.32,7.9074349999999995,4.6910026034939785,217.05691334814563,3319.62890625,0.7512615019293559,1.0,0.27332824815662343,1.3221552673774788,0.3409526456723282,client
3proxy-1.0.2,mix-socks,2,1.6300696056,4395.8,34.816,139.264,442.368,6029.312,0,0,0,20.47,7.853095,5.023098382959016,232.83588880294826,1937.6640625,0.7241006487124042,1.0,0.2639899623588457,1.294188710699947,0.3250680578687764,client
3proxy-devel-c37,mix-socks,2,1.6845583456,4600.75,32.768,131.072,524.288,5767.168,0,0,0,20.39,7.425103,4.8416251187162205,221.59430527631363,1506.1640625,0.7462039045553145,1.0,0.27298120873539866,1.3084057915631513,0.3454200681596301,client
3proxy-bp,mix-socks,2,2.2076075432,6013.85,98.304,262.144,507.904,3276.8,0,0,0,20.62,6.293095000000001,3.7361713251098303,171.43759821079675,496.57421875,0.8154970760233918,1.0,0.30495394573064477,1.3899757122109944,0.38257344852712427,client
direct,mix-socks,2,3.4518155528000003,9740.1,69.632,188.416,425.984,2031.616,0,3,0,18.43,0.0,2.135687694558324,94.608884919046,0.0,0.9379904306220096,0.8772013326987149,0.8288220551378446,1.4562432303970338,0.49797742034473325,client
3proxy-0.9.9.2,mix-socks,2,1.7720844568,4769.2,34.816,118.784,393.216,5242.88,0,0,0,20.59,8.042478000000001,4.6476340156340115,215.86429589868322,1958.32421875,0.7479286480163758,1.0,0.2811094452773613,1.3048948223103067,0.35205504713084557,client
3proxy-1.0.2,mix-relay,2,1.6692918315999998,4503.35,31.744,118.784,491.52,6029.312,0,0,0,20.36,7.703045999999999,4.8787155402264535,226.0539376242131,1893.140625,0.7399564615080151,1.0,0.26531645569620255,1.294563840771863,0.3305635824466459,client
3proxy-devel-c37,mix-relay,2,1.8470411472000001,5008.35,26.624,86.016,524.288,4980.736,0,0,0,20.42,7.522524000000001,4.422207925569056,203.85955454391166,1394.54296875,0.7696458353772196,1.0,0.2851020922611545,1.3192738003223297,0.35951623564340873,client
3proxy-bp,mix-relay,2,2.238873266,6090.7,98.304,253.952,507.904,3276.8,0,0,0,20.39,5.954074,3.6429038319670575,167.38634311327104,472.43359375,0.838342172461206,1.0,0.3146038977474057,1.3929147050071566,0.39874964451323014,client
nginx,mix-relay,2,2.000385708,5439.1,38.912,155.648,311.296,4456.448,509,0,0,20.64,6.768864000000001,4.127204052189719,189.73727271055873,686.359375,0.7832684824902724,1.0,0.3014246438390402,1.3296376219249113,0.37756477241063496,client
nginx-halfclose,mix-relay,2,1.9782757644000002,5372.05,38.912,163.84,262.144,4718.592,0,0,0,20.38,6.653919,4.12076018252817,189.68550181029588,706.265625,0.7896395509158952,1.0,0.29750818021646114,1.3317264060925433,0.3703186087684284,client
haproxy,mix-relay,2,1.8749882612,5389.35,204.8,327.68,622.592,2621.44,0,9,0,20.39,10.093525,4.349893900018407,189.1693803519905,455.2421875,0.8252656434474617,1.0,0.3009538152610442,1.5207297952622119,0.36249783843814654,client
haproxy-splice-auto,mix-relay,2,2.151355236,5905.5,245.76,393.216,557.056,1245.184,0,0,0,20.9,8.860465,3.8859226315146773,176.9536872407078,419.60546875,0.8354770589364562,1.0,0.31146732429099877,1.420690737582743,0.3869220598551559,client
envoy,mix-relay,2,1.7560518528,4845.4,376.832,425.984,507.904,753.664,0,0,0,20.37,7.984914999999999,4.639954103296056,210.19936434556487,715.60546875,0.7405351833498514,1.0,0.24767178454568337,1.3041023853482874,0.3092077220898419,client
direct,mix-relay,2,3.5100279868000004,9934.5,73.728,180.224,409.6,1966.08,0,4,0,17.78,0.0,2.026194670454415,89.48613417887161,0.0,0.948367722561271,0.8576941630487217,0.8198883815322171,1.456038058367828,0.4935071187543634,client
3proxy-0.9.9.2,mix-relay,2,1.7400852932,4668.7,32.768,102.4,507.904,5505.024,0,0,0,20.46,7.837467,4.703217728453819,219.11881251740314,1917.41796875,0.7500244881966892,1.0,0.2730478589420655,1.301195973559325,0.3404352164834452,client