bughz/3proxy
1
0
Fork 0
mirror of https://github.com/3proxy/3proxy.git synced 2026-10-15 16:15:49 +08:00
Code Issues Actions 12 Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

bench: RESULTS with a table for each machine, HTTPS with streams and envoy

Browse Source 
Every table is now for one machine, ARM or Intel, with no averages of
the two, the copying proxies and those using splice() in one table:
bold the best of each group and * the best of the row for the HTTP proxy
and the relay, only the best of the row for CONNECT and SOCKS. The
tables for 13 October replace those of 11-12 October, whose columns for
splice by direction and 16 KB buffers are gone with them.

The HTTPS section is measured again with today's devel, with the TLS
streams and envoy. report.py takes the TLS streams and 1 MB answers for
bulk data.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Vladimir Dubrovin 2026-10-13 13:00:21 +03:00
parent 18d3ff101a
commit ef0c98e4c1
4 changed files with 762 additions and 463 deletions
Show Stats Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

678
bench/RESULTS.md
View File

@ -1,57 +1,45 @@
# Benchmark results
3proxy against nginx, haproxy, squid, tinyproxy and dante on two machines,
as an HTTP proxy, through CONNECT and SOCKSv5 tunnels and as a TCP relay; and
3proxy's own versions against each other: 0.9.4, 1.0.1 and devel, with and
without splice(). The current figures are from 11-12 October 2026, for devel
with splice() by direction, pipes kept per connection and the automatic mode
(`-s`); the sessions before them, for the earlier devel, are at the end. How
the benchmark works is in [README.md](README.md); the measurements are in
[data/](data/), and `bench/report.py` turns them into the tables below.
3proxy against nginx, haproxy, squid, tinyproxy, dante and stunnel on two
machines, as an HTTP proxy, through CONNECT and SOCKSv5 tunnels, as a TCP
relay, ending or beginning TLS, and with 20000 connections open at once; and
devel against 1.0.1. The current figures are from 13 October 2026, for devel
with 16 KB buffers, the automatic splice() mode by default and the thread
pool; the sessions before them are at the end. How the benchmark works is in
[README.md](README.md); the measurements are in [data/](data/), and
`bench/report.py` turns them into the tables below.
## In short
* **HTTPS (13 October):** with TLS ended or begun in the proxy, devel moves
1 MB answers as fast as haproxy and nginx beginning TLS (5.4 Gbit/s), and
needs a third of their memory; it answers 59% of nginx's 1 KB requests and
does 60-94% of its handshakes. See [HTTPS](#https-tls-in-the-proxy).
* **20000 connections (13 October):** devel keeps up with nginx and haproxy
within 5-25% in throughput and CPU, but needs 65-130 KB per connection
against their 8-30 KB. See [the mix scenarios](#many-connections-the-mix-scenarios).
Ranges are over the two machines, ARM and Intel; the tables give each.
* **Bulk data, copying:** devel moves 19-21 Gbit/s per CPU core through any
of its services (HTTP, CONNECT, SOCKS, `tcppm`), as 1.0.1 does: 1.4 times
squid, 1.3 to 2.2 times dante, 1.7 to 2.3 times nginx and haproxy as TCP
relays, 2.5 to 2.9 times 0.9.4 copying and 17 times tinyproxy.
* **Bulk data, splice():** about 40 Gbit/s on one stream through every
service, level with 0.9.4 and with haproxy splicing every connection; with
16 streams devel gets 33-35 Gbit/s, ahead of 0.9.4 (25-26) and haproxy
(27). 1 MB HTTP answers go 65% faster than copied (31 against 19 Gbit/s),
15% faster than haproxy splicing.
* **The automatic mode, `-s`,** came within 5% of the best fixed mode in
every scenario measured: it splices the bulk streams in both directions and
copies small requests. Forcing splice() (`-s3`, and 0.9.4 by default) costs
1 KB requests through tunnels and relays 12-21%.
* **Small requests:** squid (CONNECT) and dante (SOCKS) answer 1 KB requests
over kept-alive tunnels 8-45% faster than devel; nginx and haproxy answer
1.9 times more as TCP relays and 2.2 to 2.4 times more as HTTP proxies, and
1.6 to 3 times more when each request opens a new connection. 3proxy runs
a thread per connection; splice() cannot change that.
* **2000 clients, 50 KB answers:** devel is level with squid and dante in
tunnels (13.1-13.6k requests per second), with nginx and haproxy splicing
as an HTTP proxy (10-11k), ahead of haproxy copying (8.5k), and with nginx as a TCP relay copying (13.5k); haproxy
relaying with splice() is the fastest there, 21.9k against devel's 15.2k.
* **1.0.1** is level with devel in tunnels and relays, but held to 6k
requests per second as an HTTP proxy over kept-alive connections by a 10 ms
sleep removed in devel (see the earlier sessions).
* **16 KB buffers (`-b16384`)** save devel 17-22% of its memory with 2000
connections and cost 20-40% of the copying throughput; with `-s` they cost
nothing. Since 13 October 16 KB is the default, and so is `-s`. The whole
suite run again with those defaults, against 1.0.1, nginx, haproxy, squid,
tinyproxy and dante, is in [data/](data/) `*-16k-*.csv`.
* **Memory:** with few connections 3proxy needs the least (8-17 MB against
30-54 MB for nginx and haproxy); with 2000 connections at once, a thread for
each costs it 150-200 MB against nginx's 90-115 MB and haproxy's 160-180 MB.
* **Bulk data:** devel splices 29-42 Gbit/s through every service (HTTP,
CONNECT, SOCKS, `tcppm`), the fastest everywhere: 2-2.9 times squid, 2-4.2
times dante, and 2.6-5.6 times nginx and haproxy copying 1 MB HTTP answers.
haproxy `splice-auto` is level with it as a relay on Intel and behind on
ARM. Copying with its 16 KB buffers (`-s0`) devel does 9.4-13.4 Gbit/s,
level with nginx and haproxy; the automatic mode, the default, is what
makes 16 KB enough.
* **Small requests:** nginx and haproxy answer 1.5-2.2 times more 1 KB
requests as relays and 1.9-2.8 times as HTTP proxies; squid 1.2-2 times
more through CONNECT; through SOCKS dante leads on ARM, devel on Intel.
3proxy runs a thread per connection; splice() cannot change that.
* **A new connection per request:** nginx and haproxy do 1.2-1.5 times more
as relays, 2.2-2.9 times as HTTP proxies, where they keep their connections
to the origin and a forward proxy cannot.
* **2000 clients, 50 KB answers:** on Intel devel leads as an HTTP proxy,
through CONNECT and through SOCKS; on ARM nginx, squid and dante are 13-47%
ahead of it. As a relay haproxy `splice-auto` leads on both.
* **HTTPS:** with TLS ended or begun in the proxy devel moves bulk data as
fast as nginx, ahead of haproxy and stunnel, with the least memory; envoy
(BoringSSL) leads, by 30-50% on ARM. devel answers half to two thirds of
nginx's 1 KB requests and does 60-95% of its handshakes. See
[HTTPS](#https-tls-in-the-proxy).
* **20000 connections:** devel keeps up with nginx and haproxy within 5-25% in
throughput and CPU, but needs 65-130 KB per connection against their 8-30
KB. See [the mix scenarios](#many-connections-the-mix-scenarios).
* **Memory with few connections:** 3proxy needs the least, 5-20 MB against
30-50 MB for nginx and haproxy.
## Setup
@ -100,28 +88,22 @@ tinyproxy and dante, is in [data/](data/) `*-16k-*.csv`.
| column | configuration |
|---|---|
| devel | devel as of 13 October: 16 KB buffers, the thread pool, splice() in its automatic mode, the default: each direction switched to splice() once two reads in a row fill 16 KB and back to copying after three small ones; an HTTP body of known length is spliced when 16 KB or more of it remain |
| devel -s0 | devel, no splice (TCP_NODELAY is on by default) |
| devel -s1 (download) | splices what the server sends: answers, downloads |
| devel -s3 (both) | splices both directions |
| devel -s (auto) | both directions, each switched to splice() once two reads in a row fill 16 KB and back to copying after three small ones; an HTTP body of known length is spliced when 16 KB or more of it remain |
| devel -b16384 | devel with 16 KB buffers instead of 64 KB |
| 0.9.4 | 0.9.4, `-s0` (no splice) `-ocTCP_NODELAY -osTCP_NODELAY` |
| 0.9.4 splice | 0.9.4, which splices both directions by default, `-ocTCP_NODELAY -osTCP_NODELAY` |
| 1.0.1 | 1.0.1, `-ocTCP_NODELAY -osTCP_NODELAY` (built without splice) |
| 1.0.1 | 1.0.1 as it starts by default: built without splice, 64 KB buffers, Nagle's algorithm on (no TCP_NODELAY, which devel sets by default) |
| nginx | `proxy_pass` to an upstream with `keepalive 1024`, `stream` for the TCP relay, `reuseport` |
| haproxy | `mode http` with `http-reuse always`, `mode tcp` for the TCP relay |
| haproxy splice-response (download) | `option splice-response` |
| haproxy splice (both) | `option splice-request` and `option splice-response` |
| haproxy splice-auto | `option splice-auto`: splices a direction once reads fill the buffer three times in a row |
| squid | no cache, no logs, `via off` |
| tinyproxy | `DisableViaHeader Yes`, critical messages only |
| dante | no authentication, one `sockd` process tree (`-N 1`) |
| stunnel | TLS scenarios only |
nginx has no splice() support. Neither nginx nor haproxy has CONNECT or SOCKS,
so they are measured as HTTP proxies and TCP relays only; squid and tinyproxy
only through CONNECT, dante only through SOCKS. 3proxy versions are built with
the Makefile they shipped with (`-O3 -flto` for 1.0.1 and devel, `-O2` for
0.9.4, which on gcc 14 also needs `-fpermissive`). Logging is off everywhere.
only as HTTP proxies and through CONNECT, dante only through SOCKS. 3proxy
versions are built with the Makefile they shipped with (`-O3 -flto`). Logging
is off everywhere.
### Scenarios
@ -142,227 +124,384 @@ a TCP relay to the origin (3proxy `tcppm`, nginx `stream`, haproxy
## How to read the tables
* Each cell: the median on the M4 / on the Skylake host / their average. TCP
streams and 1 MB HTTP answers in Gbit/s, the other HTTP scenarios in
thousands of requests per second.
* Each kind of proxying has two tables: the proxies copying through user
space (after "no proxy", the client talking to the origin with only the
kernel forwarding, for reference), then the proxies using splice().
* **Bold**: the best average of its table in the row, and any other whose runs
cannot be told apart from it: the range of its average (from the average of
each machine's slowest run to that of the fastest) reaches the best one's.
* \*: the best of the row, copying and splice tables together, by the same
rule - whether copying or splice() wins the scenario.
* A table for each machine, ARM (the M4) and Intel (the Skylake host): the
two are different machines in different conditions, and an average of them
would mean nothing. Each cell is the median of three runs; TCP streams and
1 MB answers in Gbit/s, the other HTTP scenarios in thousands of requests
per second. ‡: most runs were limited by the client or the origin rather
than by the proxy, which can then do at least that much.
* Each table has the proxies copying through user space first, then, after
`‖`, those using splice(): devel, whose automatic mode is its default, and
haproxy with `splice-auto`.
* HTTP proxy and TCP relay: **bold** is the best median of its group
(copying, or splice()) in the row, and any other of the group whose runs
cannot be told apart from it: its fastest run reaches the best one's
slowest.
\* marks the best of the row over both groups, by the same rule.
* CONNECT and SOCKS, where devel is the only proxy using splice(): only the
best of the row is marked, bold and with \*.
* CPU time per gigabyte or request and peak memory are in the data. CPU adds
little: every proxy ran at its CPU limit, so its CPU per unit of work is the
inverse of its throughput.
## HTTP proxy
Measured in one session on each machine ([data/](data/) `*-auto-http.csv`).
Measured on 13 October 2026, as were the CONNECT, SOCKS and relay tables
([data/](data/) `*-16k-*.csv`).
| scenario (M4 / Intel / average) | no proxy | ‖ | devel -s0 | devel -s0 -b16384 | nginx | haproxy |
|---|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| http-ka-1k, k req/s | 120.8 / 129.3 / 125.0 | ‖ | 16.0 / 18.2 / 17.1 | 16.0 / 18.4 / 17.2 | 37.1 / 36.5 / 36.8 | **44.7 / 36.2 / 40.4** * |
| http-ka-1m, Gbit/s | 71.2 / 65.5 / 68.3 | ‖ | **22.4 / 15.7 / 19.1** | 13.7 / 9.4 / 11.6 | 12.8 / 5.6 / 9.2 | 5.8 / 7.3 / 6.6 |
| http-ka-50k-2000, k req/s | 86.1 / 85.2 / 85.7 | ‖ | **10.5 / 11.2 / 10.9** * | 9.2 / 8.2 / 8.7 | 11.3 / 9.0 / 10.1 | 9.8 / 7.2 / 8.5 |
| http-ka-2k-50k-2000, k req/s | 73.7 / 64.8 / 69.2 | ‖ | **9.6 / 9.6 / 9.6** * | 8.4 / 8.2 / 8.3 | 10.3 / 8.2 / 9.3 | 8.9 / 6.7 / 7.8 |
| http-close-1k, k req/s | 48.5 / 46.8 / 47.6 | ‖ | 5.2 / 4.7 / 4.9 | 5.2 / 4.7 / 5.0 | 13.5 / 13.2 / 13.3 | **16.7 / 14.7 / 15.7** |
**ARM (M4)**
| scenario (M4 / Intel / average) | devel -s1 (download) | devel -s3 (both) | devel -s (auto) | devel -s -b16384 | haproxy splice-response (download) | haproxy splice (both) |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| http-ka-1k, k req/s | 16.0 / 18.6 / 17.3 | 16.0 / 19.1 / 17.6 | 15.8 / 17.8 / 16.8 | 15.9 / 18.2 / 17.0 | **44.2 / 35.3 / 39.8** * | **44.9 / 34.6 / 39.7** * |
| http-ka-1m, Gbit/s | **36.2 / 27.1 / 31.6** * | **36.2 / 26.7 / 31.5** * | **36.3 / 25.4 / 30.9** * | **35.3 / 26.3 / 30.8** * | 27.9 / 26.6 / 27.3 | 27.3 / 27.3 / 27.3 |
| http-ka-50k-2000, k req/s | **10.4 / 10.2 / 10.3** * | **10.4 / 11.1 / 10.8** * | **10.5 / 10.5 / 10.5** * | **10.2 / 10.1 / 10.2** * | **12.0 / 9.2 / 10.6** * | **12.0 / 9.4 / 10.7** * |
| http-ka-2k-50k-2000, k req/s | **9.6 / 9.6 / 9.6** * | 9.6 / 9.4 / 9.5 | 9.4 / 9.8 / 9.6 | **9.4 / 9.7 / 9.6** * | **11.4 / 8.7 / 10.1** * | **11.3 / 8.4 / 9.9** * |
| http-close-1k, k req/s | 5.2 / 4.8 / 5.0 | 5.2 / 4.4 / 4.8 | 5.2 / 4.8 / 5.0 | 5.3 / 4.6 / 4.9 | **16.8 / 15.3 / 16.1** * | **16.9 / 15.1 / 16.0** * |
| scenario (ARM) | devel -s0 | 1.0.1 | haproxy | nginx | tinyproxy | squid | ‖ | devel | haproxy splice-auto |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|
| ka-1k, k req/s | 14.5 | 1.5 | **40.3** * | 33.1 | 3.9 | 19.4 | ‖ | 14.5 | **40.1** * |
| ka-1m, Gbit/s | **12.4** | 8.1 | 5.4 ‡ | 11.8 | 1.0 | 3.0 ‡ | ‖ | **30.2 ‡** * | 5.4 ‡ |
| ka-50k-2000, k req/s | 8.6 | 8.1 | 8.6 | **10.9** * | 1.6 | 4.1 | ‖ | **9.6** | 8.5 |
| ka-2k-50k-2000, k req/s | 7.8 | 6.7 | 7.9 | **9.6** * | 1.5 | 3.1 | ‖ | **8.7** | 8.1 |
| close-1k, k req/s | 5.4 | 4.1 | **15.6** * | 12.2 | 3.9 | 6.8 | ‖ | 5.4 | **15.7** * |
* splice() pays off for 1 MB answers, in any mode: 31 against 19 Gbit/s
copied, ahead of haproxy splicing (27). With 50 KB answers splicing neither
gains nor loses; with 1 KB answers or a new connection per request the mode
makes no difference.
* Since pipes are made when first needed and kept for the connection, `-s1`
no longer loses with 50 KB answers (9.6k against 8.7k requests per second
in the earlier session, against 9.6k copying).
* nginx and haproxy answer 2.2-2.4 times more 1 KB requests, 2.7-3.2 times
more when every request opens a new connection.
**Intel (Skylake)**
| scenario (Intel) | devel -s0 | 1.0.1 | haproxy | nginx | tinyproxy | squid | ‖ | devel | haproxy splice-auto |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|
| ka-1k, k req/s | 18.9 | 1.6 | **36.2** * | **35.6** * | 3.9 | 9.3 | ‖ | 18.6 | **35.8** * |
| ka-1m, Gbit/s | **9.4** | 7.8 | 7.9 | 5.9 | 1.1 | 2.2 | ‖ | **26.3 ‡** * | 24.8 ‡ |
| ka-50k-2000, k req/s | 8.6 | **9.6** | 7.6 | 9.1 | 1.6 | 2.1 | ‖ | **10.4** * | 7.4 |
| ka-2k-50k-2000, k req/s | 7.8 | **8.0** | 7.3 | **8.1** | 1.5 | 1.8 | ‖ | **9.5** * | 6.9 |
| close-1k, k req/s | 6.0 | 3.9 | **15.8** * | 13.3 | 3.7 | 4.0 | ‖ | 6.1 | **15.5** * |
* 1 MB answers: devel splices them at 30 Gbit/s on ARM and 26 on Intel, 2.6
to 5.6 times nginx and haproxy copying. haproxy `splice-auto` keeps up on
Intel (25) but hardly splices on ARM (5.4). Copying (`-s0`), devel is ahead
of the other copying proxies too (12.4 and 9.4 Gbit/s).
* 2000 clients with 50 KB answers: nginx leads on ARM (10.9k requests a
second against devel's 9.6k), devel on Intel (10.4k against 9.1k); haproxy
is behind both on both. With a 2 KB POST each, the same order.
* nginx and haproxy answer 2.3-2.8 times more 1 KB requests over kept-alive
connections on ARM, 1.9 times on Intel, and 2.2-2.9 times more with a new
connection for each. That last gap is not the thread pool's: nginx
(`keepalive 1024`) and haproxy (`http-reuse always`) keep their connections
to the origin and only accept and close the client's, while a forward proxy
such as 3proxy also opens and closes one to the server for every client
connection. As a TCP relay, where every proxy does, the gap is 1.35-1.5
times on ARM and 1.2-1.3 on Intel.
* 1.0.1 answers 1.5k 1 KB requests a second over kept-alive connections, held
by a 10 ms sleep removed in devel.
## CONNECT tunnel
Measured in one session on each machine, as were the SOCKS and relay tables
([data/](data/) `*-tunnels.csv`).
**ARM (M4)**
| scenario (M4 / Intel / average) | devel -s0 | 0.9.4 | 1.0.1 | tinyproxy | squid |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| stream1-down, Gbit/s | **22.1 / 20.2 / 21.1** | 9.1 / 5.8 / 7.4 | **22.8 / 19.8 / 21.3** | 1.2 / 1.2 / 1.2 | 15.1 / 13.0 / 14.0 |
| stream16, Gbit/s | **21.1 / 18.9 / 20.0** | 8.7 / 6.0 / 7.3 | **21.1 / 19.1 / 20.1** | 1.3 / 1.2 / 1.2 | 17.6 / 12.1 / 14.8 |
| ka-1k, k req/s | 19.6 / 30.7 / 25.2 | 19.7 / 29.1 / 24.4 | 19.6 / 30.9 / 25.3 | 17.0 / 24.1 / 20.6 | **36.6 / 36.4 / 36.5** * |
| ka-50k-2000, k req/s | 11.2 / 11.5 / 11.3 | 8.3 / 8.2 / 8.3 | 11.2 / 12.7 / 12.0 | 2.3 / 2.4 / 2.3 | **16.3 / 11.0 / 13.6** * |
| close-1k, k req/s | **4.1 / 4.4 / 4.3** * | **4.2 / 4.6 / 4.4** * | 3.8 / 3.7 / 3.7 | **4.1 / 4.8 / 4.4** * | **5.3 / 3.4 / 4.4** * |
| scenario (ARM) | devel -s0 | 1.0.1 | tinyproxy | squid | ‖ | devel |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|
| stream1-down, Gbit/s | 13.3 | 20.5 | 1.2 | 14.3 | ‖ | **41.7 ‡** * |
| stream16, Gbit/s | 12.6 | 19.0 | 1.2 | 16.9 | ‖ | **33.6 ‡** * |
| ka-1k, k req/s | 17.4 | 17.5 | 15.4 | **35.0 ‡** * | ‖ | 17.5 |
| ka-50k-2000, k req/s | 8.4 | 10.0 | 2.1 | **15.0** * | ‖ | 10.2 |
| ka-2k-50k-2000, k req/s | 7.9 | 9.4 | 2.0 | **14.0** * | ‖ | 9.5 |
| close-1k, k req/s | 4.2 ‡ | 3.5 ‡ | 3.7 ‡ | **4.9 ‡** * | ‖ | 4.2 ‡ |
| scenario (M4 / Intel / average) | devel -s1 (download) | devel -s3 (both) | devel -s (auto) | 0.9.4 splice |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| stream1-down, Gbit/s | **47.5 / 32.0 / 39.8** * | **47.1 / 32.1 / 39.6** * | **47.5 / 31.6 / 39.5** * | **47.4 / 32.5 / 39.9** * |
| stream16, Gbit/s | 20.9 / 18.7 / 19.8 | 37.6 / 28.7 / 33.1 | **38.3 / 31.2 / 34.7** * | 24.1 / 27.7 / 25.9 |
| ka-1k, k req/s | 17.8 / 28.3 / 23.0 | 16.1 / 23.8 / 20.0 | **19.6 / 28.7 / 24.1** | 16.1 / 26.1 / 21.1 |
| ka-50k-2000, k req/s | **11.5 / 15.4 / 13.4** | 10.6 / 14.5 / 12.5 | **11.4 / 15.4 / 13.4** * | 10.6 / 15.0 / 12.8 |
| close-1k, k req/s | 4.0 / 4.2 / 4.1 | 3.8 / 3.8 / 3.8 | **4.1 / 4.4 / 4.3** * | 3.9 / 4.1 / 4.0 |
**Intel (Skylake)**
* tinyproxy stays at 1.2 Gbit/s whatever the load; squid manages 14-15 Gbit/s, devel 20 copying and 34-40 with
splice().
* With 16 upload streams `-s1` copies, as it should; `-s3` and `-s` splice
them. 0.9.4 splicing is level with devel on one stream but 25% behind it with
16.
* squid answers 1 KB requests 45% faster than devel and is level with it with
2000 clients (ahead on the M4, behind on the Skylake host).
* With a new tunnel per request the client is the limit on the M4
(proxychains does its work there): every proxy shows 4-5k requests per
second.
| scenario (Intel) | devel -s0 | 1.0.1 | tinyproxy | squid | ‖ | devel |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|
| stream1-down, Gbit/s | 9.6 | 19.1 | 1.2 | 13.4 | ‖ | **31.0** * |
| stream16, Gbit/s | 9.7 | 18.7 | 1.3 | 13.1 | ‖ | **29.5** * |
| ka-1k, k req/s | 30.7 | 30.3 | 29.0 | **36.3** * | ‖ | 30.4 |
| ka-50k-2000, k req/s | 10.0 | 13.1 | 2.5 | 11.3 | ‖ | **15.4** * |
| ka-2k-50k-2000, k req/s | 9.7 | 12.3 | 2.5 | 11.0 | ‖ | **14.1** * |
| close-1k, k req/s | **5.2 ‡** * | 3.7 | 4.9 ‡ | 3.6 | ‖ | **5.2 ‡** * |
* With splice() devel moves 31-42 Gbit/s through a tunnel, 2-2.9 times squid;
copying with 16 KB buffers (`-s0`) it does 10-13, below 1.0.1's 19-20 with
its 64 KB buffers, which is what the automatic mode is for.
* squid answers 1 KB requests twice as fast as devel on ARM, 19% faster on
Intel; with 2000 clients squid leads on ARM (15.0k against 10.2k), devel on
Intel (15.4k against 11.3k).
* With a new tunnel per request proxychains on the client sets the pace on
ARM; on Intel devel does 5.2k a second, squid 3.6k.
## SOCKSv5 tunnel
| scenario (M4 / Intel / average) | devel -s0 | 0.9.4 | 1.0.1 | dante |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| stream1-down, Gbit/s | **22.5 / 18.9 / 20.7** | 10.6 / 5.7 / 8.2 | **22.6 / 19.7 / 21.2** | 11.2 / 7.8 / 9.5 |
| stream16, Gbit/s | **21.1 / 18.5 / 19.8** | 8.7 / 5.8 / 7.3 | **21.0 / 19.2 / 20.1** | 14.5 / 15.2 / 14.8 |
| ka-1k, k req/s | 19.7 / 28.5 / 24.1 | 19.6 / 29.5 / 24.6 | 19.6 / 29.9 / 24.7 | **26.8 / 25.3 / 26.0** * |
| ka-50k-2000, k req/s | 10.9 / 13.1 / 12.0 | 8.2 / 7.3 / 7.8 | 11.0 / 12.6 / 11.8 | **14.7 / 11.6 / 13.1** * |
| close-1k, k req/s | 3.9 / 4.3 / 4.1 | **3.9 / 4.4 / 4.2** * | 3.6 / 3.8 / 3.7 | 3.8 / 1.5 / 2.7 |
**ARM (M4)**
| scenario (M4 / Intel / average) | devel -s1 (download) | devel -s3 (both) | devel -s (auto) | 0.9.4 splice |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| stream1-down, Gbit/s | **47.3 / 32.2 / 39.8** * | **47.7 / 32.7 / 40.2** * | **47.0 / 31.7 / 39.4** * | **47.5 / 31.3 / 39.4** * |
| stream16, Gbit/s | 20.9 / 17.8 / 19.4 | **37.5 / 29.4 / 33.5** * | **38.3 / 29.2 / 33.7** * | 24.2 / 26.8 / 25.5 |
| ka-1k, k req/s | 17.8 / 27.3 / 22.5 | 16.1 / 25.1 / 20.6 | **19.6 / 29.2 / 24.4** | 16.1 / 27.2 / 21.7 |
| ka-50k-2000, k req/s | **11.4 / 14.4 / 12.9** * | 10.5 / 14.4 / 12.5 | **11.4 / 15.1 / 13.2** * | **10.6 / 14.9 / 12.7** * |
| close-1k, k req/s | 3.7 / 3.7 / 3.7 | 3.6 / 3.8 / 3.7 | **3.9 / 4.1 / 4.0** | 3.7 / 4.0 / 3.8 |
| scenario (ARM) | devel -s0 | 1.0.1 | dante | ‖ | devel |
|---|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|
| stream1-down, Gbit/s | 12.9 | 19.7 | 10.6 | ‖ | **42.3 ‡** * |
| stream16, Gbit/s | 12.8 | 19.1 | 13.5 | ‖ | **33.9** * |
| ka-1k, k req/s | 17.5 | 17.6 | **25.1** * | ‖ | 17.5 |
| ka-50k-2000, k req/s | 8.5 | 10.1 | **13.3** * | ‖ | 10.2 |
| ka-2k-50k-2000, k req/s | 7.8 | 9.4 | **12.4** * | ‖ | 9.5 |
| close-1k, k req/s | **4.0** * | 3.4 | 3.6 | ‖ | **4.0** * |
* dante is 8% faster than devel with 1 KB requests and level with it with 2000
clients; devel moves 1.3-2.2 times dante's bulk data copying (20 against
9.5-15 Gbit/s) and 2.3-4.2 times with splice(). With a new tunnel per
request on the Skylake host dante manages 1.5k requests per second, devel
4.3k.
**Intel (Skylake)**
| scenario (Intel) | devel -s0 | 1.0.1 | dante | ‖ | devel |
|---|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|
| stream1-down, Gbit/s | 9.7 | 19.4 | 8.0 | ‖ | **33.7** * |
| stream16, Gbit/s | 9.7 | 18.5 | 15.8 | ‖ | **31.2** * |
| ka-1k, k req/s | **29.6** * | **30.5** * | 25.0 | ‖ | **30.9** * |
| ka-50k-2000, k req/s | 10.0 | 12.9 | 11.7 | ‖ | **15.0** * |
| ka-2k-50k-2000, k req/s | 9.2 | 12.3 | 11.1 | ‖ | **14.5** * |
| close-1k, k req/s | **4.7** * | 3.9 | 1.5 | ‖ | **5.1** * |
* devel moves 31-42 Gbit/s with splice(), 2-4.2 times dante.
* On ARM dante answers 43% more 1 KB requests and 30% more with 2000 clients;
on Intel devel leads both (by 24% and 28%).
* With a new tunnel per request devel manages 4.0-5.1k a second, dante 3.6k
on ARM and 1.5k on Intel. With 2000 clients dante needs 0.8-1.4 GB, devel
200 MB.
## TCP relay
| scenario (M4 / Intel / average) | devel -s0 | 0.9.4 | 1.0.1 | nginx | haproxy |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| stream1-down, Gbit/s | **22.4 / 19.5 / 20.9** | 10.2 / 5.7 / 8.0 | **22.0 / 19.3 / 20.6** | 13.5 / 9.0 / 11.3 | 13.2 / 8.7 / 11.0 |
| stream16, Gbit/s | **20.9 / 19.0 / 20.0** | 8.8 / 5.8 / 7.3 | **20.9 / 18.3 / 19.6** | 13.5 / 9.7 / 11.6 | 8.9 / 8.7 / 8.8 |
| ka-1k, k req/s | 20.1 / 30.2 / 25.1 | 20.1 / 31.1 / 25.6 | 20.1 / 30.4 / 25.2 | **44.0 / 49.6 / 46.8** * | **45.6 / 46.8 / 46.2** * |
| ka-50k-2000, k req/s | **12.3 / 14.9 / 13.6** | 9.1 / 8.4 / 8.7 | **12.2 / 14.9 / 13.5** | **14.4 / 12.5 / 13.5** | 11.3 / 9.8 / 10.5 |
| close-1k, k req/s | 5.6 / 5.1 / 5.4 | 5.6 / 5.5 / 5.6 | 5.1 / 4.8 / 5.0 | 8.8 / 8.4 / 8.6 | **9.7 / 8.1 / 8.9** |
**ARM (M4)**
| scenario (M4 / Intel / average) | devel -s1 (download) | devel -s3 (both) | devel -s (auto) | 0.9.4 splice | haproxy splice (both) | haproxy splice-response (download) | haproxy splice-auto |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| stream1-down, Gbit/s | 46.2 / 27.7 / 36.9 | **48.1 / 31.9 / 40.0** * | **47.8 / 32.1 / 39.9** * | **47.5 / 30.1 / 38.8** * | **46.9 / 31.2 / 39.1** * | **47.1 / 27.4 / 37.3** * | 30.2 / 30.7 / 30.5 |
| stream16, Gbit/s | 20.8 / 19.1 / 20.0 | **38.1 / 32.2 / 35.2** * | **38.3 / 30.5 / 34.4** * | 24.3 / 28.5 / 26.4 | 23.0 / 31.5 / 27.3 | 8.8 / 8.4 / 8.6 | 15.7 / 30.0 / 22.9 |
| ka-1k, k req/s | 18.1 / 28.1 / 23.1 | 16.3 / 27.4 / 21.9 | 20.0 / 29.7 / 24.9 | 16.5 / 26.4 / 21.4 | 32.7 / 37.2 / 35.0 | 39.6 / 41.5 / 40.5 | **46.4 / 46.3 / 46.4** * |
| ka-50k-2000, k req/s | 12.6 / 17.9 / 15.2 | 11.5 / 17.7 / 14.6 | 12.5 / 17.6 / 15.0 | 11.6 / 17.0 / 14.3 | 20.3 / 21.9 / 21.1 | **24.3 / 19.4 / 21.9** * | 17.5 / 19.3 / 18.4 |
| close-1k, k req/s | 5.2 / 4.9 / 5.0 | 5.1 / 4.9 / 5.0 | 5.6 / 5.3 / 5.4 | 5.2 / 4.7 / 5.0 | **10.1 / 8.8 / 9.4** * | **10.1 / 8.8 / 9.5** * | 9.6 / 8.1 / 8.9 |
| scenario (ARM) | devel -s0 | 1.0.1 | haproxy | nginx | ‖ | devel | haproxy splice-auto |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|
| stream1-down, Gbit/s | 13.4 | **20.3** | 13.1 | 12.7 | ‖ | **41.0** * | 26.2 |
| stream16, Gbit/s | 12.8 | **19.2** | 8.1 ‡ | 12.7 | ‖ | **34.1 ‡** * | 14.3 ‡ |
| ka-1k, k req/s | 17.9 | 17.9 | **39.0** * | **37.5** | ‖ | 17.9 | **39.8** * |
| ka-50k-2000, k req/s | 9.4 | 11.1 | 10.3 | **12.8** | ‖ | 11.3 | **15.8** * |
| ka-2k-50k-2000, k req/s | 8.7 | 10.3 | 10.1 | **11.9** | ‖ | 10.3 | **15.5** * |
| close-1k, k req/s | 5.9 | 4.7 | **8.9** * | 8.0 | ‖ | 5.9 | **8.9** * |
* As a relay devel copies 1.7-2.3 times what nginx and haproxy do; with splice()
it is level with haproxy splicing on one stream and 26-29% ahead with 16.
haproxy's `splice-auto` reaches 30 Gbit/s on one stream, the others 37-40.
* nginx and haproxy answer 1.9 times more 1 KB requests, 1.6 times more with
a new connection for each.
* With 2000 clients and 50 KB answers devel and nginx are level copying
(13.5k); splice() takes devel to 15.2k and haproxy from 10.5k to 21.9k. With
2000 connections devel runs 2000 threads on one CPU, haproxy one event loop.
* Where splice() is forced, 1 KB requests lose 13-24% (devel `-s3`, 0.9.4,
haproxy `splice`); `-s` and `splice-auto` lose nothing.
**Intel (Skylake)**
## 16 KB buffers
| scenario (Intel) | devel -s0 | 1.0.1 | haproxy | nginx | ‖ | devel | haproxy splice-auto |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|
| stream1-down, Gbit/s | 9.6 | **19.0** | 9.4 | 9.6 | ‖ | **32.9** * | 31.5 |
| stream16, Gbit/s | 9.9 | **18.7** | 9.1 | 9.8 | ‖ | **31.5** * | **31.0 ‡** * |
| ka-1k, k req/s | 29.5 | 29.5 | 45.1 | **48.7** * | ‖ | 29.8 | **47.1** * |
| ka-50k-2000, k req/s | 11.0 | **14.4** | 9.8 | 11.9 | ‖ | 17.5 | **18.8** * |
| ka-2k-50k-2000, k req/s | 10.4 | **13.3** | 9.5 | 11.6 | ‖ | 15.3 | **17.9** * |
| close-1k, k req/s | 6.4 | 4.8 | 7.9 | **8.6** * | ‖ | 6.5 | **8.3** |
`-b16384` against the default 64 KB, from the HTTP proxy session:
| | devel -s0 | devel -s0 -b16384 | devel -s | devel -s -b16384 |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| http-ka-1m, Gbit/s (average) | 19.1 | 11.6 | 30.9 | 30.8 |
| http-ka-50k-2000, k req/s (average) | 10.9 | 8.7 | 10.5 | 10.2 |
| peak memory with 2000 clients (POST + 50 KB), MB, M4 / Skylake | 199 / 156 | 166 / 128 | 192 / 155 | 150 / 128 |
| peak memory with 16 streams, MB, M4 | 72 | 34 | | |
Copying with 16 KB buffers takes four times as many system calls for the same
data, which costs 20-40% of the throughput; with splice() the bulk of the data
goes through the pipe and the buffer size hardly matters. The memory saved
with 2000 clients, 17-22%, is far less than the buffers' size would suggest. A smaller buffer also limits what data filters see of a body, and
`tlspr` needs more than 16 KB.
* On streams devel splices 32-41 Gbit/s; haproxy `splice-auto` is level on
Intel with one stream (31.5) and sixteen (31.0), behind on ARM (26 and 14).
* nginx and haproxy answer 2.1-2.2 times more 1 KB requests on ARM, 1.5-1.6
times on Intel.
* With 2000 clients and 50 KB answers haproxy `splice-auto` leads, 40% ahead
of devel on ARM and 7% on Intel.
## HTTPS: TLS in the proxy
Measured on 13 October 2026 with devel as of then: 16 KB buffers, `-s` by
default, the thread pool ([data/](data/) `*-tls.csv`). Every proxy relays
TCP, ending TLS (`term`: HTTPS from wrk, plain TCP to the origin) or
beginning it (`init`: plain HTTP from wrk, HTTPS to the origin): 3proxy
Measured on 13 October 2026 with devel as of the evening: 16 KB buffers,
splice() in its automatic mode, the thread pool, TLS read a record ahead and
relayed a full record per write ([data/](data/) `*-tls.csv`). Every proxy
relays TCP, ending TLS (`term`: TLS from the client, plain TCP to the origin)
or beginning it (`init`: plain TCP from the client, TLS to the origin): 3proxy
`tcppm` under `ssl_serv` / `ssl_cli`, nginx `stream` with `ssl` and
`proxy_ssl`, haproxy `mode tcp` with `ssl crt` and `server ... ssl`, stunnel.
ECDSA P-256 certificate, TLS 1.3, OpenSSL in every proxy; "no proxy" is wrk
speaking HTTPS to the origin itself. Every proxy ran at its CPU limit.
`proxy_ssl`, haproxy `mode tcp` with `ssl crt` and `server ... ssl`, envoy
`tcp_proxy` with TLS transport sockets, stunnel. ECDSA P-256 certificate,
TLS 1.3; envoy uses BoringSSL, the others OpenSSL (3.0.13 on ARM, 3.5.8 on
Intel). "no proxy" is the client speaking TLS to the origin itself. The
`*-ka-*` and `*-close-*` scenarios are wrk over HTTPS, the `*-stream*` ones
iperf3 wrapped in TLS by `bench/mix tls`; on one stream that wrapper, a Go
program on one core, can set the pace (‡).
| scenario (M4 / Intel / average) | no proxy | ‖ | devel | nginx | haproxy | stunnel |
|---|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| tls-term-ka-1k, k req/s | 140.5 / 107.2 / 123.8 | ‖ | 16.4 / 24.4 / 20.4 | **33.1 / 35.6 / 34.3** | 31.8 / 33.7 / 32.8 | 13.8 / 20.2 / 17.0 |
| tls-term-ka-1m, Gbit/s | 31.53 / 22.68 / 27.10 | ‖ | 5.95 / 4.92 / 5.44 | **6.84 / 6.05 / 6.44** | 5.00 / 5.90 / 5.45 | 4.48 / 5.13 / 4.80 |
| tls-term-close-1k, k req/s | 12.4 / 4.2 / 8.3 | ‖ | 2.7 / 1.2 / 2.0 | **3.3 / 1.4 / 2.4** | 2.9 / 1.4 / 2.1 | 2.0 / 1.1 / 1.5 |
| tls-init-ka-1k, k req/s | 140.4 / 105.9 / 123.1 | ‖ | 16.4 / 24.0 / 20.2 | **34.0 / 36.2 / 35.1** | 32.5 / 33.1 / 32.8 | 14.0 / 20.2 / 17.1 |
| tls-init-ka-1m, Gbit/s | 31.87 / 20.96 / 26.41 | ‖ | **5.60 / 5.16 / 5.38** | **5.80 / 5.43 / 5.61** | 4.58 / 5.12 / 4.85 | 4.15 / 4.56 / 4.35 |
| tls-init-close-1k, k req/s | 12.4 / 3.8 / 8.1 | ‖ | 2.0 / 0.9 / 1.4 | **3.4 / 1.3 / 2.3** | 2.5 / 1.0 / 1.7 | 2.0 / 1.0 / 1.5 |
### ARM (M4)
The proxy's CPU per request (per gigabyte for 1 MB answers), its p99
latency and its peak memory, M4 / Intel:
**throughput, Gbit/s (thousands of requests per second for HTTP)**
| scenario | devel | nginx | haproxy | stunnel |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| tls-term-ka-1k, µs | 61 / 41 | **30 / 28** | 31 / 30 | 72 / 50 |
| tls-term-ka-1m, s/GB | 1.35 / 1.63 | **1.17 / 1.33** | 1.62 / 1.37 | 1.79 / 1.57 |
| tls-term-close-1k, µs | 370 / 809 | **302 / 699** | 347 / 721 | 503 / 930 |
| tls-init-ka-1m, s/GB | 1.43 / 1.55 | **1.38 / 1.48** | 1.77 / 1.58 | 1.93 / 1.76 |
| tls-init-close-1k, µs | 501 / 1159 | **293 / 796** | 401 / 1010 | 495 / 1055 |
| tls-term-close-1k, p99 ms | 9 / 44 | **2 / 4** | 16 / 41 | 26 / 57 |
| tls-init-close-1k, p99 ms | 46 / 122 | **20 / 71** | 27 / 89 | 49 / 180 |
| peak memory, MB | **12-18 / 14-77** | 31-44 / 32-48 | 36-48 / 38-53 | 13-21 / 16-34 |
| scenario | no proxy | ‖ | devel | haproxy | nginx | envoy | stunnel |
|---|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| tls-term-ka-1k | 1.43 (139.2k/s) | ‖ | 0.17 (16.8k/s) | 0.33 (31.9k/s) | **0.34 (33.4k/s)** | 0.32 (30.9k/s) | 0.14 (13.9k/s) |
| tls-term-ka-1m | 29.81 (3.5k/s) | ‖ | 7.20 (0.9k/s) | 4.88 (0.6k/s) ‡ | 7.24 (0.9k/s) | **10.57 (1.3k/s) ‡** | 4.66 (0.6k/s) |
| tls-term-close-1k | 0.13 (12.3k/s) | ‖ | 0.03 (2.7k/s) ‡ | 0.03 (2.8k/s) ‡ | 0.03 (3.3k/s) ‡ | **0.04 (3.9k/s) ‡** | 0.02 (1.9k/s) ‡ |
| tls-term-stream1-down | 9.3 | ‖ | 9.2 ‡ | 8.8 ‡ | 8.6 ‡ | **9.6 ‡** | 4.7 |
| tls-term-stream16 | 19.3 | ‖ | 6.7 | 5.0 | 6.7 | **9.4** | 4.3 |
| tls-init-ka-1k | 1.43 (138.8k/s) | ‖ | 0.18 (17.2k/s) | 0.33 (32.4k/s) | **0.35 (33.7k/s)** | 0.32 (31.3k/s) | 0.15 (14.2k/s) |
| tls-init-ka-1m | 28.69 (3.4k/s) | ‖ | 6.14 (0.7k/s) | 4.63 (0.6k/s) | 5.84 (0.7k/s) | **8.59 (1.0k/s)** | 4.19 (0.5k/s) |
| tls-init-close-1k | 0.13 (12.2k/s) | ‖ | 0.02 (2.0k/s) | 0.03 (2.5k/s) | 0.03 (3.4k/s) | **0.06 (5.7k/s)** | 0.02 (1.9k/s) |
| tls-init-stream1-down | 9.2 | ‖ | 7.2 | 5.8 | 7.2 | **10.9** | 4.4 |
| tls-init-stream16 | 19.6 | ‖ | 8.3 ‡ | 5.9 ‡ | 7.8 ‡ | **11.0 ‡** | 5.2 ‡ |
* **1 MB answers:** devel is level with nginx beginning TLS and with haproxy
ending it, 13-25% ahead of stunnel; nginx is fastest ending it. With TLS the
cost is the cipher, so the threads matter little.
* **1 KB requests over kept-alive connections:** devel answers 59% of what
nginx does, the same share as without TLS (`relay-ka-1k`); the thread per
connection, not TLS, sets it. stunnel, a thread per connection too, is
below devel.
* **A handshake for every request:** ending TLS devel does 82-94% of nginx and
haproxy, 30% more than stunnel; beginning it 60-68% of nginx. nginx
(`proxy_ssl_session_reuse`) and haproxy resume the session to the server, so
most of their handshakes there are short; devel and stunnel make a full one
for every connection.
* Handshakes cost two to three times more on the Skylake host than on the M4,
with or without a proxy.
**proxy CPU time per gigabyte or per request**
| scenario | no proxy | ‖ | devel | haproxy | nginx | envoy | stunnel |
|---|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| tls-term-ka-1k | – | ‖ | 60 µs/req | 31 µs/req | **30 µs/req** | 32 µs/req | 72 µs/req |
| tls-term-ka-1m | – | ‖ | 1.11 s/GB | 1.66 s/GB | 1.10 s/GB | **0.76 s/GB** | 1.72 s/GB |
| tls-term-close-1k | – | ‖ | 370 µs/req | 358 µs/req | 307 µs/req | **255 µs/req** | 514 µs/req |
| tls-term-stream1-down | – | ‖ | 0.85 s/GB | 0.87 s/GB | 0.91 s/GB | **0.77 s/GB** | 1.70 s/GB |
| tls-term-stream16 | – | ‖ | 1.20 s/GB | 1.60 s/GB | 1.20 s/GB | **0.85 s/GB** | 1.88 s/GB |
| tls-init-ka-1k | – | ‖ | 58 µs/req | 31 µs/req | **30 µs/req** | 32 µs/req | 71 µs/req |
| tls-init-ka-1m | – | ‖ | 1.31 s/GB | 1.75 s/GB | 1.37 s/GB | **0.93 s/GB** | 1.92 s/GB |
| tls-init-close-1k | – | ‖ | 499 µs/req | 408 µs/req | 297 µs/req | **176 µs/req** | 518 µs/req |
| tls-init-stream1-down | – | ‖ | 1.11 s/GB | 1.37 s/GB | 1.11 s/GB | **0.74 s/GB** | 1.81 s/GB |
| tls-init-stream16 | – | ‖ | 0.96 s/GB | 1.35 s/GB | 1.03 s/GB | **0.73 s/GB** | 1.53 s/GB |
**proxy peak memory, MB**
| scenario | no proxy | ‖ | devel | haproxy | nginx | envoy | stunnel |
|---|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| tls-term-ka-1k | – | ‖ | **12** | 36 | 32 | 18 | 13 |
| tls-term-ka-1m | – | ‖ | **15** | 43 | 44 | 41 | **13** |
| tls-term-close-1k | – | ‖ | **14** | 37 | 32 | 19 | 21 |
| tls-term-stream1-down | – | ‖ | 7 | 40 | 34 | 26 | **5** |
| tls-term-stream16 | – | ‖ | **26** | 55 | 53 | 66 | **21** |
| tls-init-ka-1k | – | ‖ | **13** | 37 | 33 | 17 | 14 |
| tls-init-ka-1m | – | ‖ | **16** | 49 | 44 | 41 | **18** |
| tls-init-close-1k | – | ‖ | **17** | 38 | 33 | **19** | **19** |
| tls-init-stream1-down | – | ‖ | **6** | 40 | 37 | 25 | **6** |
| tls-init-stream16 | – | ‖ | **62** | **59** | 72 | 122 | **56** |
### Intel (Skylake)
**throughput, Gbit/s (thousands of requests per second for HTTP)**
| scenario | no proxy | ‖ | devel | haproxy | nginx | envoy | stunnel |
|---|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| tls-term-ka-1k | 0.97 (95.0k/s) | ‖ | 0.23 (22.5k/s) | 0.33 (32.5k/s) | **0.34 (33.4k/s)** | 0.28 (27.1k/s) | 0.19 (18.2k/s) |
| tls-term-ka-1m | 19.50 (2.3k/s) | ‖ | **5.90 (0.7k/s)** | **5.48 (0.7k/s)** | **5.82 (0.7k/s)** | **5.80 (0.7k/s)** | 4.51 (0.5k/s) |
| tls-term-close-1k | 0.03 (3.3k/s) | ‖ | 0.01 (1.2k/s) ‡ | 0.01 (1.3k/s) ‡ | 0.01 (1.3k/s) ‡ | **0.02 (2.0k/s) ‡** | 0.01 (1.0k/s) ‡ |
| tls-term-stream1-down | 7.1 | ‖ | **5.6** | 6.1 | 5.9 | **6.9** | 5.1 |
| tls-term-stream16 | 16.2 | ‖ | 5.9 | 5.0 | 5.7 | **6.8** | 4.7 |
| tls-init-ka-1k | 0.97 (95.2k/s) | ‖ | 0.24 (23.1k/s) | **0.32 (31.1k/s)** | **0.31 (30.6k/s)** | **0.30 (29.3k/s)** | 0.19 (18.4k/s) |
| tls-init-ka-1m | 20.70 (2.5k/s) | ‖ | 5.22 (0.6k/s) | 4.85 (0.6k/s) | 5.34 (0.6k/s) | **6.35 (0.8k/s)** | 4.41 (0.5k/s) |
| tls-init-close-1k | 0.03 (3.3k/s) | ‖ | 0.01 (0.8k/s) | 0.01 (1.0k/s) | 0.01 (1.2k/s) | **0.03 (3.0k/s)** | 0.01 (0.9k/s) |
| tls-init-stream1-down | 7.5 | ‖ | 6.1 | 5.2 | 6.0 | **7.8** | 4.7 |
| tls-init-stream16 | 16.7 | ‖ | **7.1** | 5.9 ‡ | 6.8 | **7.3** | 5.6 |
**proxy CPU time per gigabyte or per request**
| scenario | no proxy | ‖ | devel | haproxy | nginx | envoy | stunnel |
|---|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| tls-term-ka-1k | – | ‖ | 44 µs/req | 31 µs/req | **30 µs/req** | 37 µs/req | 55 µs/req |
| tls-term-ka-1m | – | ‖ | **1.36 s/GB** | **1.47 s/GB** | **1.38 s/GB** | **1.38 s/GB** | 1.78 s/GB |
| tls-term-close-1k | – | ‖ | 821 µs/req | 774 µs/req | 781 µs/req | **510 µs/req** | 1,022 µs/req |
| tls-term-stream1-down | – | ‖ | **1.38 s/GB** | 1.28 s/GB | 1.32 s/GB | **1.08 s/GB** | 1.57 s/GB |
| tls-term-stream16 | – | ‖ | 1.35 s/GB | 1.61 s/GB | 1.40 s/GB | **1.18 s/GB** | 1.69 s/GB |
| tls-init-ka-1k | – | ‖ | 43 µs/req | **32 µs/req** | **33 µs/req** | **34 µs/req** | 55 µs/req |
| tls-init-ka-1m | – | ‖ | 1.53 s/GB | 1.67 s/GB | 1.50 s/GB | **1.26 s/GB** | 1.82 s/GB |
| tls-init-close-1k | – | ‖ | 1,187 µs/req | 1,041 µs/req | 828 µs/req | **336 µs/req** | 1,070 µs/req |
| tls-init-stream1-down | – | ‖ | 1.30 s/GB | 1.53 s/GB | 1.34 s/GB | **1.03 s/GB** | 1.71 s/GB |
| tls-init-stream16 | – | ‖ | **1.14 s/GB** | 1.37 s/GB | 1.17 s/GB | **1.11 s/GB** | 1.43 s/GB |
**proxy peak memory, MB**
| scenario | no proxy | ‖ | devel | haproxy | nginx | envoy | stunnel |
|---|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| tls-term-ka-1k | – | ‖ | **14** | 37 | 35 | 24 | 16 |
| tls-term-ka-1m | – | ‖ | **20** | 49 | 48 | 46 | **20** |
| tls-term-close-1k | – | ‖ | **24** | **38** | **34** | **26** | **34** |
| tls-term-stream1-down | – | ‖ | 8 | 39 | 36 | 33 | **8** |
| tls-term-stream16 | – | ‖ | 80 | **44** | 85 | 138 | 89 |
| tls-init-ka-1k | – | ‖ | **16** | 41 | 36 | 24 | 17 |
| tls-init-ka-1m | – | ‖ | **18** | 50 | 46 | 48 | 21 |
| tls-init-close-1k | – | ‖ | 59 | 40 | 35 | **27** | 34 |
| tls-init-stream1-down | – | ‖ | **11** | 39 | 35 | 32 | **10** |
| tls-init-stream16 | – | ‖ | 95 | **55** | 114 | 148 | 97 |
* **Bulk data:** devel is level with nginx and ahead of stunnel on both
machines, and ahead of haproxy but for one stream ending TLS on Intel; envoy leads on ARM by 30-50% with a third less CPU per
gigabyte, and on Intel by 0-30%. BoringSSL's ciphers on ARM are the likely
difference: on Intel, ending TLS for 1 MB answers, the four are level.
* **1 KB requests over kept-alive connections:** devel answers half of what
nginx, haproxy and envoy do on ARM and two thirds on Intel, the same share
as without TLS: the thread per connection sets it, not TLS. stunnel, a
thread per connection too, is below devel.
* **A handshake for every request:** ending TLS devel does 80-95% of nginx
and haproxy, beginning it 60-80%; nginx and haproxy resume the session to
the server, devel makes a full handshake each time. envoy does 1.2-1.5
times nginx ending TLS and 1.7-2.5 times beginning it.
* **Memory:** with one connection or a few dozen, devel and stunnel need the
least, mostly 6-24 MB (devel 59 MB beginning a TLS connection per request
on Intel), against 32-50 MB for nginx and haproxy and 17-48 MB for
envoy. With 16 streams on Intel haproxy needs the least (44-55 MB, devel
80-95), and envoy the most everywhere (66-148 MB).
## Many connections: the mix scenarios
Measured on 13 October 2026 with the same devel ([data/](data/) `*-mix.csv`),
20000 connections open through the proxy, `--mix-active` 2000; `-3k` at a
fixed 3000 exchanges a second. dante is left out on the Skylake host: with
20000 connections it needs more memory than the machine has (6.6 GB on the
M4) and the OOM killer ended the origin. ‡: limited by the client.
fixed 3000 exchanges a second. dante is left out on Intel: with 20000
connections it needs more memory than the machine has (6.6 GB on ARM) and the
OOM killer ended the origin. ‡: limited by the client.
| scenario (M4 / Intel), k exchanges/s | devel | devel -s0 | 1.0.1 | nginx | haproxy | haproxy splice-auto | squid | tinyproxy | dante |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| mix-http | 5.0 / 7.0 | 4.9 / 6.5 | 3.9 / 5.4 | **7.5‡ / 7.9** | 6.5‡ / 7.1 | 6.5‡ / **8.6** | 2.7‡ / 2.2 | 1.5 / 1.7 | |
| mix-connect | 5.7‡ / **9.1‡** | 5.5 / 8.2 | 5.5‡ / 7.3 | | | | **7.3‡** / 7.2 | 2.0 / 2.8 | |
| mix-socks | **5.7‡ / 9.0** | 5.5 / 8.0 | 5.8‡ / 8.4 | | | | | | 3.5 / - |
| mix-relay | 5.9‡ / 9.2 | 5.7 / 8.1 | 5.8‡ / 8.6 | **7.5‡ / 9.9‡** | 6.8‡ / 7.9‡ | 7.1‡ / 8.5 | | | |
### ARM (M4)
| at 3000 a second (M4 / Intel) | devel | devel -s0 | 1.0.1 | nginx | haproxy | haproxy splice-auto | squid | tinyproxy | dante |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| CPU per exchange, µs: mix-http-3k, mix-relay-3k | 236 / 201, 209 / 171 | 236 / 217, 215 / 174 | 278 / 238, 212 / 170 | 169 / 187, 178 / 162 | 162 / 168, 179 / 166 | **162 / 160, 178 / 159** | 326 / 489 | 678 / 647 | |
| peak memory, MB: mix-http-3k | 2627 / 2659 | 2614 / 2644 | 2752 / 2820 | **139 / 154** | 150 / 179 | 154 / 180 | 603 / 868 | 803 / 765 | |
| peak memory, MB: mix-connect-3k, mix-socks-3k | 2670 / 2660, 1422 / 1410 | 2653 / 2648, 1404 / 1398 | 2831 / 2834, 1559 / 1574 | | | | 1289 / 1371 | **1025 / 1038** | 6747 / - (socks) |
| peak memory, MB: mix-relay-3k | 1306 / 1376 | 1291 / 1358 | 1456 / 1531 | 574 / 604 | **267 / 314** | **264 / 318** | | | |
**throughput, Gbit/s (thousands of requests per second for HTTP)**
* Copying many small exchanges devel does 75-80% of nginx and haproxy on the
M4 and 85-95% on the Skylake host, where it is first through CONNECT and
SOCKS; at a fixed rate it takes 3-8% more CPU than they do as a relay, 7-25%
| scenario | devel -s0 | 1.0.1 | haproxy | nginx | tinyproxy | squid | dante | ‖ | devel | haproxy splice-auto |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|
| mix-http | 1.80 (4.9k/s) | 1.42 (3.9k/s) | 1.83 (6.5k/s) ‡ | **2.76 (7.5k/s) ‡** | 0.59 (1.5k/s) | 0.92 (2.7k/s) ‡ | – (–k/s) | ‖ | **1.84 (5.0k/s)** | **1.81 (6.5k/s) ‡** |
| mix-connect | 2.08 (5.5k/s) | 2.07 (5.5k/s) ‡ | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | 0.74 (2.0k/s) | **2.76 (7.3k/s) ‡** | – (–k/s) | ‖ | **2.16 (5.7k/s) ‡** | – (–k/s) |
| mix-socks | 2.03 (5.5k/s) | **2.17 (5.8k/s) ‡** | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | 1.31 (3.5k/s) | ‖ | **2.13 (5.7k/s) ‡** | – (–k/s) |
| mix-relay | 2.07 (5.7k/s) | 2.12 (5.8k/s) ‡ | 2.31 (6.8k/s) ‡ | **2.72 (7.5k/s) ‡** | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | ‖ | 2.16 (5.9k/s) ‡ | **2.50 (7.1k/s) ‡** |
| mix-http-3k | 1.09 (3.0k/s) | 1.08 (3.0k/s) | 1.08 (3.0k/s) | **1.09 (3.0k/s)** | 0.58 (1.5k/s) | **1.09 (3.0k/s) ‡** | – (–k/s) | ‖ | 1.08 (3.0k/s) | **1.08 (3.0k/s)** |
| mix-connect-3k | **1.09 (3.0k/s)** | 1.08 (3.0k/s) | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | 0.74 (2.0k/s) | 1.08 (3.0k/s) | – (–k/s) | ‖ | **1.08 (3.0k/s)** | – (–k/s) |
| mix-socks-3k | 1.08 (3.0k/s) | 1.08 (3.0k/s) | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | **1.13 (3.1k/s)** | ‖ | **1.08 (3.0k/s)** | – (–k/s) |
| mix-relay-3k | **1.08 (3.0k/s)** | 1.08 (3.0k/s) | **1.09 (3.0k/s)** | 1.08 (3.0k/s) | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | ‖ | **1.08 (3.0k/s)** | **1.09 (3.0k/s)** |
**proxy CPU time per gigabyte or per request**
| scenario | devel -s0 | 1.0.1 | haproxy | nginx | tinyproxy | squid | dante | ‖ | devel | haproxy splice-auto |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|
| mix-http | 205 µs/req | 272 µs/req | 156 µs/req | **134 µs/req** | 675 µs/req | 375 µs/req | – µs/req | ‖ | 211 µs/req | **157 µs/req** |
| mix-connect | 190 µs/req | 187 µs/req | – µs/req | – µs/req | 507 µs/req | **139 µs/req** | – µs/req | ‖ | **182 µs/req** | – µs/req |
| mix-socks | 187 µs/req | **179 µs/req** | – µs/req | – µs/req | – µs/req | – µs/req | 298 µs/req | ‖ | **179 µs/req** | – µs/req |
| mix-relay | 186 µs/req | 182 µs/req | 151 µs/req | **136 µs/req** | – µs/req | – µs/req | – µs/req | ‖ | 177 µs/req | **143 µs/req** |
| mix-http-3k | 236 µs/req | 278 µs/req | **162 µs/req** | 169 µs/req | 678 µs/req | 326 µs/req | – µs/req | ‖ | 236 µs/req | **162 µs/req** |
| mix-connect-3k | 218 µs/req | 216 µs/req | – µs/req | – µs/req | 509 µs/req | **194 µs/req** | – µs/req | ‖ | **212 µs/req** | – µs/req |
| mix-socks-3k | **215 µs/req** | **211 µs/req** | – µs/req | – µs/req | – µs/req | – µs/req | 334 µs/req | ‖ | **210 µs/req** | – µs/req |
| mix-relay-3k | 215 µs/req | 212 µs/req | **179 µs/req** | **178 µs/req** | – µs/req | – µs/req | – µs/req | ‖ | 209 µs/req | **178 µs/req** |
**proxy peak memory, MB**
| scenario | devel -s0 | 1.0.1 | haproxy | nginx | tinyproxy | squid | dante | ‖ | devel | haproxy splice-auto |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|
| mix-http | 2,407 | 2,729 | 529 | **153** | 817 | 839 | – | ‖ | 2,438 | **556** |
| mix-connect | 2,725 | 3,220 | – | – | **1,033** | 1,768 | – | ‖ | **2,760** | – |
| mix-socks | **1,482** | 2,007 | – | – | – | – | 6,580 | ‖ | **1,506** | – |
| mix-relay | 1,246 | 1,767 | **293** | 608 | – | – | – | ‖ | 1,296 | **263** |
| mix-http-3k | 2,614 | 2,752 | 150 | **139** | 803 | 603 | – | ‖ | 2,627 | **154** |
| mix-connect-3k | 2,653 | 2,831 | – | – | **1,025** | 1,289 | – | ‖ | **2,670** | – |
| mix-socks-3k | **1,404** | 1,559 | – | – | – | – | 6,747 | ‖ | **1,422** | – |
| mix-relay-3k | 1,291 | 1,456 | **267** | 574 | – | – | – | ‖ | 1,306 | **264** |
### Intel (Skylake)
**throughput, Gbit/s (thousands of requests per second for HTTP)**
| scenario | devel -s0 | 1.0.1 | haproxy | nginx | tinyproxy | squid | ‖ | devel | haproxy splice-auto |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|
| mix-http | 2.39 (6.5k/s) | 1.98 (5.4k/s) | 2.29 (7.1k/s) | **2.87 (7.9k/s)** | 0.65 (1.7k/s) | 0.80 (2.2k/s) | ‖ | 2.54 (7.0k/s) | **3.02 (8.6k/s)** |
| mix-connect | **3.08 (8.2k/s)** | 2.72 (7.3k/s) | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | 1.02 (2.8k/s) | 2.72 (7.2k/s) | ‖ | **3.39 (9.1k/s) ‡** | – (–k/s) |
| mix-socks | 2.98 (8.0k/s) | **3.12 (8.4k/s)** | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | ‖ | **3.37 (9.0k/s)** | – (–k/s) |
| mix-relay | 2.97 (8.1k/s) | 3.11 (8.6k/s) | 2.54 (7.9k/s) ‡ | **3.61 (9.9k/s) ‡** | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | ‖ | **3.35 (9.2k/s)** | 3.00 (8.5k/s) |
| mix-http-3k | **1.10 (3.0k/s)** | **1.09 (3.0k/s)** | 1.08 (3.0k/s) | 1.09 (3.0k/s) | 0.64 (1.6k/s) | 0.63 (2.1k/s) | ‖ | **1.09 (3.0k/s)** | **1.09 (3.0k/s)** |
| mix-connect-3k | **1.08 (3.0k/s)** | 1.08 (3.0k/s) | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | 1.01 (2.8k/s) | 1.08 (3.0k/s) | ‖ | **1.08 (3.0k/s)** | – (–k/s) |
| mix-socks-3k | **1.08 (3.0k/s)** | **1.08 (3.0k/s)** | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | ‖ | **1.08 (3.0k/s)** | – (–k/s) |
| mix-relay-3k | 1.08 (3.0k/s) | **1.08 (3.0k/s)** | **1.08 (3.0k/s)** | 1.08 (3.0k/s) | – (–k/s) | – (–k/s) | ‖ | **1.08 (3.0k/s)** | **1.08 (3.0k/s)** |
**proxy CPU time per gigabyte or per request**
| scenario | devel -s0 | 1.0.1 | haproxy | nginx | tinyproxy | squid | ‖ | devel | haproxy splice-auto |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|
| mix-http | 158 µs/req | 192 µs/req | 146 µs/req | **131 µs/req** | 623 µs/req | 462 µs/req | ‖ | 148 µs/req | **121 µs/req** |
| mix-connect | **125 µs/req** | **137 µs/req** | – µs/req | – µs/req | 372 µs/req | 145 µs/req | ‖ | **114 µs/req** | – µs/req |
| mix-socks | 129 µs/req | **123 µs/req** | – µs/req | – µs/req | – µs/req | – µs/req | ‖ | **115 µs/req** | – µs/req |
| mix-relay | 128 µs/req | **122 µs/req** | 131 µs/req | **105 µs/req** | – µs/req | – µs/req | ‖ | **113 µs/req** | 123 µs/req |
| mix-http-3k | 217 µs/req | 238 µs/req | **168 µs/req** | 187 µs/req | 647 µs/req | 489 µs/req | ‖ | 201 µs/req | **160 µs/req** |
| mix-connect-3k | **175 µs/req** | **172 µs/req** | – µs/req | – µs/req | 358 µs/req | 189 µs/req | ‖ | **171 µs/req** | – µs/req |
| mix-socks-3k | **181 µs/req** | **171 µs/req** | – µs/req | – µs/req | – µs/req | – µs/req | ‖ | **176 µs/req** | – µs/req |
| mix-relay-3k | 174 µs/req | 170 µs/req | 166 µs/req | **162 µs/req** | – µs/req | – µs/req | ‖ | 171 µs/req | **159 µs/req** |
**proxy peak memory, MB**
| scenario | devel -s0 | 1.0.1 | haproxy | nginx | tinyproxy | squid | ‖ | devel | haproxy splice-auto |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|
| mix-http | 2,432 | 2,828 | 486 | **222** | 786 | 639 | ‖ | 2,440 | **428** |
| mix-connect | 2,657 | 3,293 | – | – | **1,066** | 1,812 | ‖ | **2,692** | – |
| mix-socks | **1,412** | 1,985 | – | – | – | – | ‖ | **1,445** | – |
| mix-relay | 1,298 | 1,794 | **479** | 648 | – | – | ‖ | 1,328 | **334** |
| mix-http-3k | 2,644 | 2,820 | 179 | **154** | 765 | 868 | ‖ | 2,659 | **180** |
| mix-connect-3k | 2,648 | 2,834 | – | – | **1,038** | 1,371 | ‖ | **2,660** | – |
| mix-socks-3k | **1,398** | 1,574 | – | – | – | – | ‖ | **1,410** | – |
| mix-relay-3k | 1,358 | 1,531 | **314** | 604 | – | – | ‖ | 1,376 | **318** |
* Copying many small exchanges devel does 75-80% of nginx and haproxy on ARM
and 85-95% on Intel, where it is first through CONNECT and SOCKS; at a fixed rate it takes 3-8% more CPU than they do as a relay, 7-25%
more as an HTTP proxy, with the same p99.
* Memory is where a thread per connection shows: about 65 KB a connection for
a relay or a SOCKS tunnel (the thread's stack and two 16 KB buffers), about
@ -371,12 +510,21 @@ M4) and the OOM killer ended the origin. ‡: limited by the client.
* nginx relays fail exchanges whose client shuts down its sending side first
(`proxy_half_close` is off by default), 350-470 a run; with it on
(`nginx::halfclose`, [data/](data/) `*-halfclose.csv`) there are none and
nothing else changes: 7.47k against 7.44k on the M4, 9.83k against 9.71k on
the Skylake host.
nothing else changes: 7.47k against 7.44k on ARM, 9.83k against 9.71k on
Intel.
* devel itself lost 2-11 exchanges a run in the tunnels and relays, every
one half-closed by the client with a large answer, cut short. Once the
server had answered and closed, `sockmap()` took the hang-up poll() reported
on its socket for the end of it while the rest of the answer was still
unread there, if its buffer was full at the time; fixed since.
## Earlier sessions
The tables below are from devel before the automatic mode, whose `-s` then
The session of 11-12 October, devel with 64 KB buffers, splice() by direction
(`-s1`, `-s3`) and the automatic mode as an option, against 0.9.4, 1.0.1 and
the same proxies, is in [data/](data/) (`*-auto-http.csv`, `*-tunnels.csv`).
The tables below are older still: from devel before the automatic mode, whose `-s` then
spliced both directions always, making a pair of pipes for each mapping
(`sockmap()` call), and before squid, tinyproxy and dante were added. In the
first table "devel" is `-s0` and "devel splice" `-s3` of today. The haproxy
@ -398,47 +546,17 @@ M4 and 7.5% or less on the Skylake host, except for one origin-bound case
### Throughput
| scenario (M4 / Intel / average) | no proxy | ‖ | 0.9.4 | 1.0.1 | devel | nginx | haproxy | ‖ | 0.9.4 splice | devel splice | haproxy splice-auto | haproxy splice |
|---|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| stream1, Gbit/s | 62.0 / 44.4 / 53.2 | ‖ | 8.3 / 5.5 / 6.9 | 22.1 / 19.1 / 20.6 | **22.0 / 19.9 / 21.0** | 13.5 / 9.8 / 11.6 | 13.6 / 9.7 / 11.7 | ‖ | 25.1 / 29.2 / 27.1 | **45.7 / 31.4 / 38.6** * | 29.5 / 30.6 / 30.1 | **44.7 / 32.3 / 38.5** * |
| stream16, Gbit/s | 141.2 / 150.5 / 145.9 | ‖ | 8.7 / 5.6 / 7.2 | **20.9 / 18.9 / 19.9** | **20.9 / 18.8 / 19.8** | 13.5 / 9.9 / 11.7 | 9.5 / 9.2 / 9.3 | ‖ | 24.5 / 28.3 / 26.4 | **37.8 / 31.2 / 34.5** * | 15.9 / 30.3 / 23.1 | 22.1 / 31.5 / 26.8 |
| stream1-down, Gbit/s | 61.8 / 43.1 / 52.5 | ‖ | 8.8 / 5.6 / 7.2 | **22.4 / 18.8 / 20.6** | **22.1 / 19.4 / 20.8** | 13.6 / 9.7 / 11.7 | 13.6 / 9.3 / 11.5 | ‖ | **47.9 / 34.4 / 41.1** * | 47.4 / 32.0 / 39.7 | 30.4 / 31.0 / 30.7 | **47.6 / 33.7 / 40.6** * |
| http-ka-1k, k req/s | 120.3 / 127.1 / 123.7 | ‖ | 14.1 / 19.2 / 16.7 | 6.0 / 6.1 / 6.1 | 15.8 / 18.1 / 17.0 | 37.0 / 36.5 / 36.8 | **44.3 / 37.3 / 40.8** * | ‖ | 13.4 / 14.6 / 14.0 | 14.9 / 13.8 / 14.4 | **44.1 / 37.2 / 40.7** * | **44.1 / 38.0 / 41.1** * |
| http-ka-1m, Gbit/s | 71.6 / 67.5 / 69.5 | ‖ | 8.3 / 5.8 / 7.1 | 12.5 / 12.4 / 12.4 | **21.9 / 18.3 / 20.1** | 12.6 / 5.8 / 9.2 | 6.0 / 7.6 / 6.8 | ‖ | **33.0 / 26.6 / 29.8** * | **35.3 / 23.9 / 29.6** * | 5.9 / 24.2 / 15.1 | 28.0 / 26.7 / 27.4 |
| http-ka-50k-2000, k req/s | 84.5 / 85.7 / 85.1 | ‖ | 7.6 / 7.0 / 7.3 | 9.0 / 10.3 / 9.6 | **10.4 / 10.5 / 10.5** * | 11.0 / 9.2 / 10.1 | 9.6 / 7.3 / 8.4 | ‖ | 9.1 / 9.4 / 9.3 | 9.9 / 9.0 / 9.4 | 9.6 / 7.7 / 8.6 | **11.9 / 9.0 / 10.4** * |
| http-close-1k, k req/s | 48.7 / 52.1 / 50.4 | ‖ | 5.0 / 4.8 / 4.9 | 4.4 / 4.0 / 4.2 | 5.2 / 4.8 / 5.0 | 13.3 / 12.9 / 13.1 | **16.6 / 15.1 / 15.9** * | ‖ | 4.8 / 4.4 / 4.6 | 5.0 / 4.4 / 4.7 | **16.7 / 15.1 / 15.9** * | **16.8 / 15.5 / 16.1** * |
| scenario (M4 / Intel / average) | no proxy | ‖ | 0.9.4 | 1.0.1 | devel | nginx | haproxy | ‖ | 0.9.4 splice | devel splice | haproxy splice-auto |
|---|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|
| stream1, Gbit/s | 62.0 / 44.4 / 53.2 | ‖ | 8.3 / 5.5 / 6.9 | 22.1 / 19.1 / 20.6 | **22.0 / 19.9 / 21.0** | 13.5 / 9.8 / 11.6 | 13.6 / 9.7 / 11.7 | ‖ | 25.1 / 29.2 / 27.1 | **45.7 / 31.4 / 38.6** * | 29.5 / 30.6 / 30.1 |
| stream16, Gbit/s | 141.2 / 150.5 / 145.9 | ‖ | 8.7 / 5.6 / 7.2 | **20.9 / 18.9 / 19.9** | **20.9 / 18.8 / 19.8** | 13.5 / 9.9 / 11.7 | 9.5 / 9.2 / 9.3 | ‖ | 24.5 / 28.3 / 26.4 | **37.8 / 31.2 / 34.5** * | 15.9 / 30.3 / 23.1 |
| stream1-down, Gbit/s | 61.8 / 43.1 / 52.5 | ‖ | 8.8 / 5.6 / 7.2 | **22.4 / 18.8 / 20.6** | **22.1 / 19.4 / 20.8** | 13.6 / 9.7 / 11.7 | 13.6 / 9.3 / 11.5 | ‖ | **47.9 / 34.4 / 41.1** * | 47.4 / 32.0 / 39.7 | 30.4 / 31.0 / 30.7 |
| http-ka-1k, k req/s | 120.3 / 127.1 / 123.7 | ‖ | 14.1 / 19.2 / 16.7 | 6.0 / 6.1 / 6.1 | 15.8 / 18.1 / 17.0 | 37.0 / 36.5 / 36.8 | **44.3 / 37.3 / 40.8** * | ‖ | 13.4 / 14.6 / 14.0 | 14.9 / 13.8 / 14.4 | **44.1 / 37.2 / 40.7** * |
| http-ka-1m, Gbit/s | 71.6 / 67.5 / 69.5 | ‖ | 8.3 / 5.8 / 7.1 | 12.5 / 12.4 / 12.4 | **21.9 / 18.3 / 20.1** | 12.6 / 5.8 / 9.2 | 6.0 / 7.6 / 6.8 | ‖ | **33.0 / 26.6 / 29.8** * | **35.3 / 23.9 / 29.6** * | 5.9 / 24.2 / 15.1 |
| http-ka-50k-2000, k req/s | 84.5 / 85.7 / 85.1 | ‖ | 7.6 / 7.0 / 7.3 | 9.0 / 10.3 / 9.6 | **10.4 / 10.5 / 10.5** * | 11.0 / 9.2 / 10.1 | 9.6 / 7.3 / 8.4 | ‖ | 9.1 / 9.4 / 9.3 | 9.9 / 9.0 / 9.4 | 9.6 / 7.7 / 8.6 |
| http-close-1k, k req/s | 48.7 / 52.1 / 50.4 | ‖ | 5.0 / 4.8 / 4.9 | 4.4 / 4.0 / 4.2 | 5.2 / 4.8 / 5.0 | 13.3 / 12.9 / 13.1 | **16.6 / 15.1 / 15.9** * | ‖ | 4.8 / 4.4 / 4.6 | 5.0 / 4.4 / 4.7 | **16.7 / 15.1 / 15.9** * |
### Splice by direction
devel splices what the server sends with `-s1` (downloads), what the client
sends with `-s2` (uploads), both with `-s3`; haproxy's matching settings are
`option splice-response`, `option splice-request` and both. The 2000 client
scenario here sends a 2 KB POST body with each request and gets 50 KB back
(`http-ka-2k-50k-2000`). Same setup and markings as above; measured in a
session of their own ([data/](data/) `*-splice-direction.csv`).
| scenario (M4 / Intel / average) | no proxy | ‖ | devel -s0 | haproxy | ‖ | devel -s1 | devel -s3 | haproxy splice-response | haproxy splice |
|---|---:|:-:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| stream1, Gbit/s | 61.6 / 45.5 / 53.6 | ‖ | **22.4 / 19.0 / 20.7** | 13.1 / 9.5 / 11.3 | ‖ | 22.4 / 19.5 / 21.0 | **44.1 / 31.9 / 38.0** * | 13.6 / 9.7 / 11.7 | **46.3 / 30.7 / 38.5** * |
| stream16, Gbit/s | 140.6 / 147.1 / 143.8 | ‖ | **21.1 / 19.2 / 20.2** | 9.0 / 8.9 / 8.9 | ‖ | 20.9 / 18.7 / 19.8 | **38.2 / 32.3 / 35.2** * | 9.2 / 9.1 / 9.2 | 23.2 / 33.3 / 28.3 |
| stream1-down, Gbit/s | 63.7 / 47.0 / 55.3 | ‖ | **22.3 / 19.5 / 20.9** | 13.8 / 9.5 / 11.7 | ‖ | **47.9 / 33.0 / 40.5** * | **46.3 / 30.7 / 38.5** * | **46.9 / 32.3 / 39.6** * | **47.4 / 32.6 / 40.0** * |
| http-ka-1k, k req/s | 120.0 / 127.6 / 123.8 | ‖ | 15.9 / 19.5 / 17.7 | **44.2 / 37.1 / 40.7** * | ‖ | 15.3 / 17.0 / 16.1 | 15.0 / 14.9 / 14.9 | **44.0 / 37.0 / 40.5** * | **44.1 / 35.0 / 39.5** * |
| http-ka-1m, Gbit/s | 71.0 / 67.2 / 69.1 | ‖ | **22.3 / 17.5 / 19.9** | 5.8 / 7.7 / 6.8 | ‖ | **35.6 / 24.7 / 30.2** * | **34.6 / 24.5 / 29.5** * | 26.4 / 27.7 / 27.1 | 26.5 / 25.9 / 26.2 |
| http-ka-2k-50k-2000, k req/s | 73.7 / 64.7 / 69.2 | ‖ | **9.5 / 9.7 / 9.6** | 8.8 / 7.2 / 8.0 | ‖ | 9.0 / 8.4 / 8.7 | 8.7 / 7.6 / 8.1 | **11.2 / 8.7 / 10.0** * | **11.2 / 9.0 / 10.1** * |
| http-close-1k, k req/s | 49.0 / 43.4 / 46.2 | ‖ | 5.1 / 4.9 / 5.0 | **16.5 / 15.9 / 16.2** * | ‖ | 5.0 / 4.7 / 4.9 | 5.0 / 4.2 / 4.6 | **16.7 / 15.0 / 15.8** * | **16.8 / 15.5 / 16.2** * |
* Each option splices the direction it names: with `-s1` an upload stream
goes at the copying speed and a download stream at the splicing one, as with
haproxy's `splice-response`.
* For bulk downloads `-s1` gets all of splice()'s gain; `-s3` is needed only
for bulk uploads (stream1, stream16).
* Small requests and 50 KB answers gain nothing from splicing in 3proxy, in
either direction: devel `-s0` stays ahead of `-s1` and `-s3`. haproxy gains
25% with 2000 clients from splicing the answers; there it is ahead of devel by
4-5%.
### Grace delay with splice
`-s1` without grace delay, with the setting suggested in the documentation

270
bench/data/m4-tls.csv
View File

@ -1,91 +1,181 @@
proxy,scenario,rep,gbit,rate,p50_ms,p99_ms,errors,timeouts,retrans,prx_cpu_s,prx_task_s,cpu_s_per_gb,cpu_us_per_req,peak_mb,cli_util,prx_util,srv_util,cli_thread,srv_thread,bound
direct,tls-term-ka-1k,0,1.43923347456,139788.38,0.418,0.716,0,0,0,1.56,0.0,0.8671282471258088,1.104978637079683,0.0,0.8773911039410003,0.42048517520215634,0.9502362204724409,3.1036970032231808,0.9449767933049799,origin
3proxy-current,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.16919822336,16434.21,3.67,7.83,0,0,0,10.11,10.102077999999999,47.80192037118089,60.91168709106026,11.7578125,0.44093526435177105,0.9610266159695817,0.4682822523164647,0.5500387716770072,0.18439661348100986,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.32690405376,31753.11,1.94,3.08,0,0,0,10.02,10.02144,24.520956249398573,31.49121263168481,36.2578125,0.4317390507604911,0.9524714828897338,0.484903695991671,0.7067207427148267,0.30119480289065775,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.34091302912,33110.79,1.91,2.29,0,0,0,10.01,10.017096,23.489861976443315,30.177325704087355,32.421875,0.4595433789954338,0.9524262607040913,0.4998720900486058,0.7783796718107615,0.3079200937141662,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.14411628544,13997.51,4.39,8.19,0,0,0,10.11,10.105061999999998,56.12134655918036,71.5124421746573,13.41796875,0.41525275494140285,0.9601139601139601,0.44391971664698937,0.46239304043982005,0.15681054770137193,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1m,0,28.518582845439997,3396.15,4.92,7.99,0,0,0,6.39,0.0,0.17925154372870206,186.29194484125827,0.0,0.8392857142857143,0.8047858942065491,0.8910614525139665,3.256266527376346,0.9575980353996528,origin
3proxy-current,tls-term-ka-1m,0,5.95389841408,709.52,22.37,36.51,0,0,0,10.03,10.015631,1.3476884289836968,1410.689170182841,12.3046875,0.32870031699585467,0.9534220532319392,0.07265774378585087,1.0561731198566409,0.024725197211463632,client
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1m,0,4.7462744063999995,565.34,28.1,35.21,0,0,0,10.1,10.098108,1.7023878748149743,1768.8266199649738,42.609375,0.48249027237354086,0.9600760456273765,0.19498847926267282,0.8580728221764721,0.021861640453726128,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1m,0,6.842252001279999,814.97,17.07,34.05,0,0,0,10.02,10.019807,1.1715441054349394,1227.0389419544454,42.1015625,0.3050129442221699,0.9524714828897338,0.11587591240875912,0.7839451741608926,0.03706187762990015,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1m,0,4.47960055808,533.79,29.8,41.51,0,0,0,10.04,10.025791,1.7930170103029432,1876.6355140186915,13.4453125,0.2036326426195958,0.952561669829222,0.0729903536977492,0.5599828036914579,0.018997196463425892,proxy
direct,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.12700352512000002,12382.0,0.558,1.43,0,0,0,5.89,0.0,37.10133238859188,47.09362756856161,0.0,0.9567078972407231,0.6770114942528735,0.9501734468621886,3.787302085470794,0.9500237647279252,origin
3proxy-current,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.02759852032,2689.77,5.42,9.96,0,0,0,10.1,10.101399,292.7693190183321,371.77457945301285,19.26953125,0.9548693586698337,0.9609895337773549,0.37130801687763715,3.78363078824788,0.04752205083144872,client
haproxy,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.02952790016,2881.39,14.06,16.23,0,0,0,10.1,10.085373,273.6395055597478,347.05518521063846,36.9921875,0.7649444918872759,0.9609895337773549,0.36055245941361763,2.831407964527035,0.056069766301595894,client
nginx,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.0339738624,3309.76,1.2,1.53,0,0,0,10.1,10.093163,237.829891251929,302.12384086150166,30.9453125,0.9542857142857143,0.9609895337773549,0.4076662908680947,3.779649775563822,0.054170596120676894,client
stunnel,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.02046820352,1998.12,17.55,26.16,0,0,0,10.01,9.925464,391.2409798043673,499.8252359314925,19.890625,0.8229471316085489,0.9533333333333334,0.27490247074122237,3.1921854543592736,0.03896556963013126,client
direct,tls-init-ka-1k,0,1.44560881664,140408.63,0.42,0.686,0,0,0,1.97,0.0,1.090198110207342,1.3891229557151832,0.0,0.888347260909935,0.49747474747474746,0.9535398230088495,3.1486030140417856,0.9549567226722561,origin
3proxy-current,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.16592666624000002,16118.5,3.77,8.46,0,0,0,10.01,10.014918,48.262284667475036,62.037507592002676,12.22265625,0.4267361111111111,0.9524262607040913,0.45854241338112306,0.46053905836101444,0.18819565851956507,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.33218887680000003,32259.89,1.94,2.87,0,0,0,10.11,10.098718000000002,24.347594290068653,31.02911703593669,36.65234375,0.4495581737849779,0.9601139601139601,0.4657842157842158,0.7123230811607429,0.3001226109723907,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.3485466624,33852.58,1.87,2.3,0,0,0,10.09,10.100526,23.159022509119286,29.51215731237551,33.13671875,0.43630632301131095,0.9600380589914367,0.458747648481591,0.6722958894310512,0.32298702524092604,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.14403239936,13992.44,4.38,8.53,0,0,0,10.12,10.105426999999999,56.20957531759609,71.60951585740366,14.359375,0.39872521246458925,0.9601518026565465,0.4342925659472422,0.38535774385386845,0.16155219887809816,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1m,0,31.86865733632,3802.24,4.21,6.77,0,0,0,7.48,0.0,0.18777069698446844,194.77644975652944,0.0,0.9059233449477352,0.85,0.9536131271694541,3.508252963448141,0.9571120725212797,origin
3proxy-current,tls-init-ka-1m,0,5.599983042560001,667.35,21.46,52.65,0,0,0,10.04,9.997523,1.434290057479927,1500.5230907188761,18.234375,0.17424826522744796,0.9534662867996201,0.16935985083903046,0.43199750231871964,0.17489734078750313,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1m,0,4.5562724351999995,542.44,29.34,37.3,0,0,0,10.1,10.096542,1.7733794708097441,1843.7385907265425,47.91015625,0.44719237786336913,0.9600760456273765,0.20470798569725865,0.6888261180458144,0.1910789643970402,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1m,0,5.8494602444799995,697.07,22.4,35.93,0,0,0,10.03,10.018901999999999,1.371750497419324,1436.139747995418,46.23828125,0.17391304347826086,0.9525166191832859,0.1887599266951741,0.4518170555555568,0.16343421309998707,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1m,0,4.09624117248,488.1,29.94,80.2,0,0,0,10.04,10.018036,1.960822046797884,2052.33033524121,14.28125,0.1614650502966211,0.9516587677725118,0.12625,0.39455826463615057,0.17000018816441312,proxy
direct,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.1270874112,12387.5,0.557,1.42,0,0,0,5.89,0.0,37.07684306028259,47.074431949872526,0.0,0.9541676561386844,0.6754587155963303,0.949873896595208,3.789037266677241,0.948525093638368,origin
3proxy-current,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.02046820352,1991.68,31.58,46.36,0,0,0,10.05,10.046098,392.8043803230661,502.6005201040208,16.2265625,0.1962303664921466,0.9553231939163498,0.4414856341976174,0.11700812834357528,0.16819766016891818,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.0255852544,2497.16,25.51,27.45,0,0,0,10.05,10.018104,314.24350425845284,401.37385678341786,37.69140625,0.21621621621621623,0.95260663507109,0.48175519630484986,0.14544643294249562,0.1908854172303607,proxy
nginx,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.03506438144,3415.05,18.64,19.96,0,0,0,10.04,10.017447,229.06435733776914,293.36138382421694,31.3046875,0.3150169363944298,0.952561669829222,0.5448717948717948,0.20914579107716558,0.2763155516595777,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.020719861760000003,2020.17,30.65,50.59,0,0,0,10.04,9.952296,387.6473739562246,494.97140603431274,19.15234375,0.15156832638736564,0.9543726235741445,0.40702781844802344,0.11608036637748038,0.15210949476013474,proxy
3proxy-current,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.16961765376,16473.58,3.66,7.74,0,0,0,10.1,10.101476,47.63655091841308,60.70477644414259,11.890625,0.44235458028561475,0.9600760456273765,0.46807500593401374,0.5555511284364395,0.18530655416507485,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.3326083072,32302.05,1.91,3.02,0,0,0,10.02,10.022596,24.100420303633353,30.953440094899168,36.2421875,0.4341311894756075,0.9515669515669516,0.4884744884744885,0.7159547740664182,0.3181358575020215,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.34510733312,33517.26,1.88,2.35,0,0,0,10.03,10.020503,23.250737466102787,29.856166503941132,32.359375,0.43843107674901,0.9534220532319392,0.4723779023218575,0.7783193704900336,0.2880103536267642,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.14227079168,13818.69,4.46,8.3,0,0,0,10.02,10.021258999999999,56.34325855183151,72.3894291204901,13.26953125,0.4207980652962515,0.9533777354900095,0.4372623574144487,0.46534344959924023,0.188215713535384,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1k,1,1.4463637913599998,140480.79,0.42,0.664,0,0,0,1.72,0.0,0.9513512494018966,1.2122109106029693,0.0,0.8825017245343757,0.455026455026455,0.9526963103122044,3.143914124870164,0.9521459060053177,origin
3proxy-current,tls-term-ka-1m,1,6.05397450752,721.51,21.98,35.03,0,0,0,10.02,10.015604,1.3240888262814539,1386.0838290219947,12.7421875,0.3317904993909866,0.9524714828897338,0.07711757269279393,1.0398464274029606,0.025655603147065834,client
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1m,1,4.9979326464,594.95,26.83,29.54,0,0,0,10.1,10.101992000000001,1.6166684450659825,1680.8121151605924,41.5234375,0.4844629822732012,0.9600760456273765,0.17418213969938107,0.9117298840407279,0.02279813353131231,client
nginx,tls-term-ka-1m,1,6.531118530560001,778.22,20.01,33.74,0,0,0,10.02,10.022428000000001,1.2273548493251247,1284.944857655809,41.61328125,0.3185115843669553,0.9524714828897338,0.12767911818738517,0.7439290423295145,0.04085399320300185,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1m,1,4.425410150399999,527.41,30.23,43.92,0,0,0,10.01,10.021142,1.8095497881199059,1894.7567669884536,11.01171875,0.1969302809573361,0.9524262607040913,0.07452618053324767,0.547764871945811,0.020898337347345086,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1m,1,31.52505995264,3754.79,4.3,6.62,0,0,0,7.9,0.0,0.20047543159297765,208.30586684245222,0.0,0.913396795913629,0.8652792990142387,0.9504888047934406,3.516977670473943,0.9578710733957263,origin
3proxy-current,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.027682406399999998,2702.88,5.39,8.85,0,0,0,10.11,10.101994000000001,292.1711314808239,370.31610563715617,9.4375,0.9553231939163498,0.9601139601139601,0.3737727910238429,3.7866005305899466,0.049420228363693086,client
haproxy,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.029360128,2862.86,14.52,15.78,0,0,0,10.11,10.086215000000001,275.47563825334817,349.5729746550949,36.484375,0.795193764884174,0.9601139601139601,0.3691130767391824,2.992484396465593,0.054184394584872404,client
nginx,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.033218887679999996,3235.76,1.21,1.65,0,0,0,10.11,10.092725999999999,243.47594290068656,309.3445933541399,31.73828125,0.9547295687395759,0.9601139601139601,0.4058890147225368,3.781842488734503,0.055100514707128095,client
stunnel,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.020048773120000002,1952.73,17.8,26.94,0,0,0,10.11,10.006965,403.4162066471626,512.5735145001014,21.234375,0.8369369369369369,0.9601139601139601,0.27988565488565487,3.229551113263159,0.03894919669621939,client
direct,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.12675186688,12362.82,0.557,1.47,0,0,0,5.9,0.0,37.23811030308984,47.248382343519765,0.0,0.9557879724269075,0.6750572082379863,0.9468051621026126,3.7892235436396366,0.9464910700414535,origin
3proxy-current,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.16995319808,16510.15,3.67,8.13,0,0,0,10.1,10.104447,47.54250047237475,60.57007838127965,12.40234375,0.42960787700811887,0.9609895337773549,0.46485207100591713,0.4603220748429241,0.20899354055461175,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.33436991488,32472.92,1.92,2.91,0,0,0,10.0,10.009786,23.925597501411186,30.76042855429062,36.75,0.45118153507968495,0.9514747859181731,0.4600202429149798,0.7115378225129483,0.2812704754783617,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.35039215616,34030.39,1.86,2.41,0,0,0,10.02,10.009271,22.877224444315594,29.397095496552737,33.1796875,0.4374884579870729,0.9515669515669516,0.4701101206082853,0.6698367151793299,0.32405144493317556,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.14369685504,13957.13,4.41,8.5,0,0,0,10.11,10.105449,56.285156677566775,71.71942170452449,14.3671875,0.4037722668529514,0.9601139601139601,0.4407616361071932,0.3908161003110235,0.20042123513864932,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1k,1,1.4440988672000001,140257.87,0.41400000000000003,0.754,0,0,0,1.52,0.0,0.8420476101873366,1.072973491907521,0.0,0.8771566597653554,0.41192411924119243,0.9477494491658798,3.12287468894866,0.9481793060147322,origin
3proxy-current,tls-init-ka-1m,1,5.70232406016,679.46,21.12,53.48,0,0,0,10.03,9.987998,1.4071455629925838,1471.537558685446,20.1796875,0.19841072758877576,0.9534220532319392,0.1715170278637771,0.4375197590627391,0.17766417038041074,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1m,1,4.59922210816,547.35,29.03,37.71,0,0,0,10.1,10.098744,1.7568188293547202,1827.0622286541245,48.4453125,0.4712334038868578,0.9600760456273765,0.1909942580840133,0.6783993530642565,0.2138962635360921,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1m,1,5.79761864704,690.77,21.14,42.38,0,0,0,10.03,10.02678,1.3840165227315682,1448.584633160023,43.7734375,0.20105820105820105,0.9525166191832859,0.19914477703115455,0.45648111788411194,0.16529398143366705,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1m,1,4.14749556736,494.21,30.11,68.85,0,0,0,10.02,10.019917000000001,1.9327326261863647,2023.016353725015,16.39453125,0.16917581015565195,0.9524714828897338,0.1315128688010044,0.4003186821500213,0.11491240453161419,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1m,1,32.21225472,3837.04,4.14,9.74,0,0,0,7.21,0.0,0.17906228701273605,186.0357105996491,0.0,0.9049836981835119,0.8403263403263403,0.9338790931989924,3.5067157321961746,0.9569534940338696,origin
3proxy-current,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.02046820352,1997.24,31.37,46.46,0,0,0,10.05,10.042808,392.8043803230661,501.4219428229307,18.21875,0.19344675488342786,0.9553231939163498,0.44232558139534883,0.11608032161165885,0.16726423174861682,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.025417482239999997,2481.7,25.53,29.86,0,0,0,10.05,10.026736000000001,316.31771880801364,403.43623298944243,37.80078125,0.19936974789915968,0.9544159544159544,0.48161849710982657,0.14271647506102042,0.19102332527847646,proxy
nginx,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.03506438144,3414.92,18.63,20.03,0,0,0,10.03,10.018757,228.83620558743272,293.1034482758621,30.4296875,0.31871016122984624,0.9525166191832859,0.5444391634980988,0.20913259461550932,0.27349234155048363,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.020635975679999998,2011.13,30.86,49.35,0,0,0,10.06,9.969092,389.9985212620681,497.9951487550121,21.671875,0.14970323147944603,0.9553656220322887,0.4062423799073397,0.1160795948302106,0.1511111707292933,proxy
direct,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.12473860095999999,12161.15,0.56,2.12,0,0,0,5.88,0.0,37.710860662197376,47.86909268530956,0.0,0.9543509272467903,0.6743119266055045,0.9372844151771715,3.7915930704274428,0.9349731514323012,origin
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.32757514239999996,31813.93,1.94,3.09,0,0,0,10.03,10.02569,24.495143133302655,31.447329642008366,36.0078125,0.4365556162388494,0.9525166191832859,0.48237137633846955,0.7193656085444711,0.2879642673226588,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.33814478848,32841.24,1.93,2.33,0,0,0,10.02,10.020349,23.705821509279644,30.44325007519665,32.38671875,0.4483398256353181,0.9524714828897338,0.49432404540763675,0.766660326000989,0.32590565364239055,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.14101250048,13694.14,4.5,8.3,0,0,0,10.03,10.02326,56.90275665410284,73.10762054010715,13.234375,0.41935483870967744,0.9525166191832859,0.43829787234042555,0.4670283823043739,0.19859143792501524,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1k,2,1.45986945024,141790.49,0.41500000000000004,0.664,0,0,0,1.61,0.0,0.8822706713865786,1.1242844034519022,0.0,0.8869364161849711,0.44352617079889806,0.9548611111111112,3.1439647708458303,0.951380301378939,origin
3proxy-current,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.16827547648,16344.39,3.71,7.95,0,0,0,10.01,10.019722,47.58863363522713,61.13761154102205,11.70703125,0.4419650579484518,0.9524262607040913,0.46368848542761587,0.53861259710042,0.20248401114127337,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1m,2,5.19036731392,618.34,25.8,30.58,0,0,0,10.11,10.101577,1.558271218745707,1618.8951160928743,43.00390625,0.4926410466067048,0.9601139601139601,0.18352601156069365,0.919041208804482,0.019958293511711238,client
nginx,tls-term-ka-1m,2,6.90868977664,823.11,20.01,32.92,0,0,0,10.01,10.014739,1.1591199285104739,1213.627546071775,42.90234375,0.31381733021077285,0.9515209125475285,0.11250766400980994,0.7740125280194877,0.03514294477338386,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1m,2,4.703492505600001,560.55,28.42,41.01,0,0,0,10.02,10.028072,1.7042654985537051,1782.918149466192,16.3125,0.21539243078486156,0.9524714828897338,0.06808781419026408,0.5789818824150479,0.021848661098155486,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1m,2,31.52505995264,3761.15,4.19,6.81,0,0,0,7.3,0.0,0.18524944944667554,192.17606486600326,0.0,0.9059266227657573,0.8439306358381503,0.9573324905183312,3.511586154017881,0.9589447840056432,origin
3proxy-current,tls-term-ka-1m,2,5.743931555840001,684.37,23.33,37.04,0,0,0,10.03,10.016382,1.3969525789076989,1462.7388070584805,15.43359375,0.3208477082306555,0.9534220532319392,0.07605905006418485,1.0152254629514315,0.025662381385124753,client
haproxy,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.02961178624,2883.24,13.9,16.13,0,0,0,10.1,10.084714,272.8643228244511,346.8168395027814,37.3125,0.828,0.9600760456273765,0.34004024144869216,3.178466778286004,0.057929972653973774,client
nginx,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.0339738624,3309.07,1.2,1.53,0,0,0,10.11,10.093905,238.0653663917824,302.48631182120096,30.9921875,0.9547619047619048,0.9601139601139601,0.4078590785907859,3.7809801968316314,0.05509837817054535,client
stunnel,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.02038431744,1989.2,17.45,25.85,0,0,0,10.1,10.005118000000001,396.38315208654836,502.71265740879,23.3359375,0.8371460928652321,0.9600760456273765,0.2772869022869023,3.254544592720068,0.038007282343487485,client
direct,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.12767461376,12452.45,0.554,1.39,0,0,0,5.88,0.0,36.84365953001806,46.749405694204825,0.0,0.9560361216730038,0.6758620689655173,0.9499370277078085,3.786575286683947,0.9457882376167059,origin
3proxy-current,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.02793406464,2721.22,5.42,9.08,0,0,0,10.1,10.101989999999999,289.2525704415353,367.4865376218891,14.08984375,0.9557248274220423,0.9609895337773549,0.3702576112412178,3.7892973863571653,0.04753876423631224,client
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.33420214272000004,32462.97,1.91,3.39,0,0,0,10.02,10.022186,23.98548356021743,30.798075888672024,36.73046875,0.4501100513573001,0.9533777354900095,0.46357448953869423,0.709869290340063,0.2813518223778306,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.35072770048,34063.66,1.85,2.28,0,0,0,10.01,10.014167,22.832527881431623,29.338147798613107,33.171875,0.4212902012413015,0.9515209125475285,0.46594222104426186,0.6460985894525442,0.333599490097434,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.14361296896,13952.27,4.41,8.45,0,0,0,10.1,10.102834000000001,56.26232824592946,71.68051780302761,14.4609375,0.41027859491261465,0.9600760456273765,0.4431924882629108,0.39277794381787956,0.17478874644588616,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1k,2,1.44703488,140540.9,0.417,0.6930000000000001,0,0,0,1.6,0.0,0.884567481884058,1.1271479212574462,0.0,0.8832675794847993,0.43360433604336046,0.9536569987389659,3.128451216037277,0.9547420572619894,origin
3proxy-current,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.16936599552,16447.73,3.68,8.2,0,0,0,10.12,10.104624,47.80180327900569,60.92018372371613,12.2734375,0.4296861453095197,0.9601518026565465,0.46746817538896746,0.4622866558988936,0.21663472696348368,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1m,2,4.57690841088,544.94,29.26,35.93,0,0,0,10.1,10.103178000000002,1.765383808160247,1835.0290697674418,48.20703125,0.4741463414634146,0.9609895337773549,0.207396449704142,0.6994235656888089,0.14259669133018518,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1m,2,5.71062878208,680.35,19.63,40.59,0,0,0,10.02,10.019193000000001,1.4036983151757776,1470.2861335289801,42.8359375,0.21492760858711932,0.9524714828897338,0.20980511571254568,0.454465383622178,0.2051962373631917,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1m,2,4.1693898342399995,496.86,29.68,73.53,0,0,0,10.03,10.017989,1.9245022219090775,2014.4607350873669,14.3203125,0.1612071189063709,0.9525166191832859,0.12788521522145976,0.40020245897368467,0.12629547315655576,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1m,2,31.3532612608,3740.53,4.17,7.43,0,0,0,7.55,0.0,0.19264343666703732,199.8253182648281,0.0,0.9028264424199953,0.8521444695259593,0.950566750629723,3.4989447089055448,0.9585365268418932,origin
3proxy-current,tls-init-ka-1m,2,5.57389447168,664.14,21.7,53.53,0,0,0,10.04,9.994436,1.4410032412363043,1508.4134615384614,15.921875,0.18035714285714285,0.9534662867996201,0.1760519801980198,0.4338860462906276,0.18060928631957865,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.0255852544,2494.53,25.49,27.15,0,0,0,10.04,10.024525,313.9308241547131,401.0866091403004,37.68359375,0.2095970087245534,0.9534662867996201,0.48092485549132946,0.14549104844711475,0.1947076871070426,proxy
nginx,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.03498049536,3409.86,18.67,19.87,0,0,0,10.02,10.016498,229.1562745897032,293.0595770816882,33.66796875,0.3164628410159925,0.9533777354900095,0.5445473984319316,0.20930352375326866,0.27551384990636907,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.02080374784,2025.37,30.67,48.34,0,0,0,10.04,9.959099,386.08427970640116,493.92433708860136,19.828125,0.14982425307557118,0.9534662867996201,0.4061433447098976,0.11692732046212614,0.15287396711535206,proxy
direct,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.12826181632,12507.42,0.558,1.48,0,0,0,5.89,0.0,36.73735594266065,46.62060013139252,0.0,0.9543726235741445,0.6754587155963303,0.9480968858131488,3.78625065105561,0.9399542676846688,origin
3proxy-current,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.0205520896,2007.95,31.25,46.3,0,0,0,10.02,10.025754000000001,390.03333266900506,497.6903591119058,16.20703125,0.19590215346017145,0.9542857142857143,0.44217371110078957,0.11512995354814924,0.1625629104397623,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1k,0,1.3920894976,135203.73,0.433,1.07,0,0,0,1.77,0.0,1.0171759807406222,1.296234183379788,0.0,0.8580835603996367,0.43596059113300495,0.9349517584811703,3.0248309276281193,0.9358171938778904,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.17507024896,17001.38,3.53,7.88,0,0,0,10.09,10.104890000000001,46.10720580996196,58.75947052417641,12.08984375,0.429058908045977,0.960952380952381,0.4549483013293944,0.5766794859348302,0.22720038990652688,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.32933675007999996,31988.77,1.93,3.04,0,0,0,10.02,10.023767,24.339828452344946,31.246978990928397,36.26171875,0.408785727987723,0.9524714828897338,0.46326140398798143,0.7161813017483875,0.286939172841326,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.34351349760000005,33361.89,1.89,2.33,0,0,0,10.02,10.013692,23.3353275955815,29.973974692632147,32.47265625,0.4407484407484408,0.9515669515669516,0.4747123360984747,0.7827712011784499,0.33442126498782127,proxy
envoy,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.31801212927999994,30886.15,1.98,3.06,0,0,0,10.09,10.084401,25.382679642677562,32.34295715279403,17.52734375,0.517204682511529,0.9591254752851711,0.5630252100840336,0.9037871159143464,0.3431329766735917,client
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.14503903231999998,14084.55,4.35,8.21,0,0,0,10.11,10.107971000000001,55.76429924156847,71.07255587034004,13.49609375,0.4050044682752458,0.9610266159695817,0.41683217477656404,0.47576815277289547,0.18724993216172428,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1m,0,29.377576304639998,3499.4,4.82,7.73,0,0,0,6.43,0.0,0.17509953668940134,181.91591693543825,0.0,0.8574433278803458,0.8027465667915106,0.8941139831828091,3.2694043456181623,0.9565431983124729,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-ka-1m,0,7.03368003584,838.24,18.66,31.09,0,0,0,10.02,10.006776,1.1396594612144149,1193.7097927090779,14.80859375,0.26465495918872123,0.9524714828897338,0.07633829585049097,0.7677964352440629,0.029453518646857354,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1m,0,4.8792338432,581.2,27.54,30.64,0,0,0,10.11,10.104375000000001,1.6576372971490048,1722.3168654173764,41.4765625,0.510533569600315,0.9601139601139601,0.14507299270072993,0.8962550719293447,0.02185952816643344,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1m,0,7.27619469312,866.88,15.74,37.69,0,0,0,10.02,10.017831000000001,1.1016747541925345,1154.3778801843318,43.4296875,0.2948284195263412,0.9524714828897338,0.08377618005626758,0.7801570989336393,0.033263906937601666,proxy
envoy,tls-term-ka-1m,0,10.565619548159999,1261.88,12.68,16.97,0,0,0,10.01,10.00575,0.7579299977155235,792.3064745923698,41.40625,0.3592592592592593,0.9515209125475285,0.11862864077669903,1.0442960505988186,0.05415495596845124,client
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1m,0,4.61230833664,549.65,29.07,41.36,0,0,0,10.02,9.988987,1.737958396302607,1819.8329095532147,12.859375,0.2089171974522293,0.9515669515669516,0.06509829197550758,0.5717750085376905,0.027555417032560613,proxy
direct,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.12499025920000001,12190.24,0.555,1.43,0,0,0,5.65,0.0,36.16281803822358,45.8879521790686,0.0,0.9543400713436385,0.6608187134502924,0.9436220472440945,3.78107836386332,0.9352217747404032,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.02776629248,2708.48,5.25,8.62,0,0,0,10.12,10.082897,291.57655836952415,369.9100811462826,12.88671875,0.9533222195760895,0.9601518026565465,0.3292407917815084,3.7798582845450444,0.04846762861987139,client
haproxy,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.028940697600000002,2825.09,14.24,18.98,0,0,0,10.03,9.995154,277.25662010303444,354.2166972736262,37.11328125,0.7877919788453063,0.9525166191832859,0.31592621460119513,2.988125024992129,0.0569891153108287,client
nginx,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.03338665984,3255.28,1.21,1.61,0,0,0,10.09,10.08296,241.77321237535332,306.8828127376137,31.3203125,0.9545021438780371,0.9600380589914367,0.37815326035221325,3.7767875149066468,0.055129953873606335,client
envoy,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.04018143232,3916.26,12.03,14.65,0,0,0,10.09,10.030517000000001,200.8888069423604,255.10075089120926,18.6875,0.904420273084934,0.9582146248812915,0.33026315789473687,3.54912460888683,0.07412408106946165,client
stunnel,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.020048773120000002,1957.62,17.56,26.03,0,0,0,10.11,10.001994,403.4162066471626,511.2257281553398,23.7890625,0.8398446424491661,0.9610266159695817,0.23870791130577607,3.2471492042191374,0.03801439829195942,client
direct,tls-term-stream1-down,0,9.293834923854945,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,0.09,0.0,0.00774636463727282,nan,0.0,0.474320987654321,0.010101010101010102,0.36843800322061193,1.0746396247321204,0.8176578992239385,client
3proxy-devel,tls-term-stream1-down,0,9.163430408938526,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.76,9.108672,0.8519879017494479,nan,6.35546875,0.5072658772874058,0.9207547169811321,0.04691358024691358,1.0566006975425148,0.09849937659157491,client
haproxy,tls-term-stream1-down,0,8.77996528514481,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.52,8.860667,0.8673907989096684,nan,41.08984375,0.46992970580577975,0.8592057761732852,0.06592,1.0556821915231327,0.0910933624177118,client
nginx,tls-term-stream1-down,0,7.51396851840779,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.96,9.718259,1.0603034804198586,nan,33.1484375,0.4508174009420892,0.9205175600739371,0.05337262606417813,1.0368524567142539,0.08161489142052755,client
envoy,tls-term-stream1-down,0,9.727648676631553,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.31,6.887653,0.7656286105433424,nan,24.40625,0.48361270953214913,0.7550689375506894,0.06654170571696345,1.0675906263818422,0.0995115775407132,client
stunnel,tls-term-stream1-down,0,4.716006741302276,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.03,10.012193,1.7012633870261782,nan,4.4375,0.3495561677379859,0.9400187441424555,0.019162065605716143,0.8897344251098557,0.05254501244348075,proxy
direct,tls-term-stream16,0,18.925880502955465,nan,nan,nan,0,0,705,0.24,0.0,0.0101050467848037,nan,0.0,0.5121503897294819,0.030303030303030304,0.9310453400503779,1.5156926322014015,2.758691947536444,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-stream16,0,6.744539040269984,nan,nan,nan,0,0,406,10.08,10.028887,1.1925920272156314,nan,32.1328125,0.2334340850964892,0.9438202247191011,0.20575815738963532,0.6048301032185484,0.4510193750789299,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-stream16,0,5.0508450944870456,nan,nan,nan,0,0,730,10.02,10.022953,1.5859289505450904,nan,57.16796875,0.21203703703703702,0.9408450704225352,0.5180420458111076,0.4983960403619521,0.8873812098975168,proxy
nginx,tls-term-stream16,0,6.6625112543267475,nan,nan,nan,0,0,464,10.07,10.051921,1.2043516887648529,nan,61.03515625,0.208363201911589,0.943767572633552,0.2315270935960591,0.5925187446976511,0.45838061659597235,proxy
envoy,tls-term-stream16,0,9.443206579037609,nan,nan,nan,0,0,907,10.04,10.055330000000001,0.8478981746042726,nan,65.64453125,0.27735849056603773,0.9444967074317968,0.1190176322418136,0.7685936825864172,0.23934200455094362,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-stream16,0,4.246478882892315,nan,nan,nan,0,0,471,10.05,10.016542,1.8893481270251706,nan,17.46875,0.1544256120527307,0.9418931583880038,0.18260217472815898,0.3906179274582188,0.3914421897839879,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1k,0,1.42891548672,138786.21,0.422,0.729,0,0,0,1.57,0.0,0.8789883038380959,1.1200517078648318,0.0,0.8772413793103448,0.42091152815013405,0.9508816120906801,3.1069088993629594,0.9498230194007785,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.17557356544,17054.78,3.53,8.48,0,0,0,10.12,10.103021,46.11172518887362,58.75386080211793,12.5625,0.4164285714285714,0.9601518026565465,0.45169261181121817,0.4748139450569951,0.21860738817753814,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.33529266176,32566.71,1.92,2.86,0,0,0,10.11,10.100397000000001,24.12221000467147,30.73845255758519,36.84765625,0.42901115813774526,0.9601139601139601,0.41986827661909987,0.7136189922365787,0.270835638298258,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.34452013056,33463.74,1.89,2.33,0,0,0,10.03,10.015092000000001,23.290366188348397,29.925916201467356,33.1953125,0.42545523520485584,0.9525166191832859,0.455810147299509,0.6670143148430631,0.29940655350770856,proxy
envoy,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.32405192704,31476.65,1.95,3.01,0,0,0,10.1,10.086791999999999,24.934275422477672,31.770197667249644,17.42578125,0.5011361650061178,0.9591642924976258,0.5558217537134643,0.7600478003035748,0.2946446738179909,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.14612955136000003,14195.24,4.34,8.37,0,0,0,10.02,10.013202,54.855434273195314,70.50528789659225,14.453125,0.3845597541131803,0.9524714828897338,0.40935233808452115,0.39571583490682516,0.16057848338674605,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1m,0,27.74548873216,3302.69,5.22,7.36,0,0,0,6.48,0.0,0.18684118524793503,194.2737220806476,0.0,0.8270607250057723,0.8039702233250621,0.8671732522796353,3.0923785505514267,0.953336216453813,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-ka-1m,0,5.84056832,696.0,20.27,61.66,0,0,0,10.02,9.989832,1.3724691777939857,1438.208698148414,20.171875,0.19264668849156383,0.9524714828897338,0.18023617153511498,0.4434411792478279,0.27271998232683625,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1m,0,4.6313504768,551.57,28.9,36.95,0,0,0,10.11,10.096093,1.7463588731873187,1814.7549811523963,49.21875,0.4540692989524577,0.9610266159695817,0.17063369397217928,0.7050437766371025,0.1491894355858182,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1m,0,5.8539062067200005,697.54,21.17,43.06,0,0,0,10.02,10.016183,1.3693420627064403,1434.2971657600915,43.91015625,0.20135236664162284,0.9515669515669516,0.18321327904791732,0.4564925550297905,0.1852465234565511,proxy
envoy,tls-init-ka-1m,0,8.41813590016,1002.47,15.76,23.84,0,0,0,10.01,10.0073,0.9512794869286675,996.4164841728051,40.79296875,0.1663172606568833,0.9515209125475285,0.2652689152233364,0.39577915164922567,0.30409122909425207,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1m,0,4.1721580748800005,497.09,29.48,77.56,0,0,0,10.03,10.015576,1.923225308338967,2013.6518771331057,17.89453125,0.15694372741352608,0.9516129032258065,0.12350346565847511,0.3994475964951075,0.17938605756051504,proxy
direct,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.12532580352,12218.5,0.5630000000000001,1.98,0,0,0,5.99,0.0,38.236339727399184,48.53621579574275,0.0,0.9517126546146527,0.6737907761529809,0.9413241292751804,3.7872712953261907,0.9411646148728162,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.020635975679999998,2009.76,31.18,46.26,0,0,0,10.03,10.025792,388.83550380303603,498.1870560770874,15.3203125,0.1654315605928509,0.9534220532319392,0.41494082840236685,0.11895511321300963,0.1682994717210808,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.02499805184,2436.74,26.03,28.43,0,0,0,10.02,10.015318,320.66498826814177,410.18503356803666,37.8203125,0.17112998040496408,0.9524714828897338,0.4559748427672956,0.1417205035275168,0.19192313229100294,proxy
nginx,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.03447717888,3361.32,18.79,23.41,0,0,0,10.01,10.003511000000001,232.2695841174346,297.3326204479297,33.03515625,0.26715092816787733,0.9533333333333334,0.5357056402808037,0.210250244059997,0.27654611918467026,proxy
envoy,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.05804916736,5657.94,10.9,16.77,0,0,0,9.99,9.91711,137.67639336558437,176.1780474040632,19.2109375,0.24180934263369266,0.9496197718631179,0.5218150087260035,0.27486978755602454,0.23085421138047788,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.01920991232,1872.01,33.09,54.5,0,0,0,10.03,9.928395,417.7010215526064,534.7051924512208,19.0,0.134568176746262,0.9534220532319392,0.37035123966942146,0.11227889987212178,0.15206495973371348,proxy
direct,tls-init-stream1-down,0,9.2074792391595,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,0.37,0.0,0.03214644729780898,nan,0.0,0.4862340216322517,0.04057017543859649,0.3595758354755784,1.078637185575463,0.8151964992838053,client
3proxy-devel,tls-init-stream1-down,0,7.308803248275543,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,10.002157,1.0944476447066418,nan,4.70703125,0.1378241262683202,0.9514747859181731,0.33733417561591916,0.47579304380184495,0.6988019660576581,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-stream1-down,0,5.821160810375183,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,9.995925999999999,1.374145734271717,nan,40.66796875,0.10997150997150996,0.9505703422053232,0.2651635439822166,0.43946900720116777,0.5454691540590876,proxy
nginx,tls-init-stream1-down,0,7.229744269623417,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.99,10.000118,1.1054046608729153,nan,36.828125,0.12457240592930445,0.9496197718631179,0.2848205465920316,0.46892265628063223,0.6496471681828438,proxy
envoy,tls-init-stream1-down,0,10.853111653192572,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1,9.98,9.976779,0.73560132376774,nan,24.9453125,0.06754082137555666,0.9486692015209125,0.3833116036505867,0.22926516893050844,0.8208024804285621,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-stream1-down,0,4.426390368581383,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1,10.0,10.001557,1.8071425769221658,nan,5.9140625,0.1052335396736072,0.9505703422053232,0.21188055908513342,0.4004110010905507,0.4114237983316316,proxy
direct,tls-init-stream16,0,18.283828112558886,nan,nan,nan,0,0,743,0.39,0.0,0.017015777126283136,nan,0.0,0.508459076360311,0.04797047970479705,0.9268830759533564,1.4860198345701823,1.953350246579136,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-stream16,0,7.85990244478347,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1032,10.07,10.039336,1.0220159223349807,nan,44.359375,0.07603578154425612,0.956315289648623,0.6354202698028364,0.09130866194988724,1.0447423890358685,origin
haproxy,tls-init-stream16,0,5.86128438345321,nan,nan,nan,0,0,9,10.03,10.025364999999999,1.368238219647359,nan,65.19921875,0.03711790393013101,0.9516129032258065,0.855525965379494,0.07035385453858682,1.2534061634240694,origin
nginx,tls-init-stream16,0,7.792840054565132,nan,nan,nan,0,0,454,10.07,10.060383999999999,1.0290383462320856,nan,72.234375,0.06873094065212292,0.956315289648623,0.6355074991280084,0.08370469003431631,1.0536350634348823,origin
envoy,tls-init-stream16,0,10.864147201801515,nan,nan,nan,0,0,8190,10.04,10.04179,0.7371821331730954,nan,125.82421875,0.07728337236533958,0.9543726235741445,0.6989898989898989,0.12366100208998754,1.3354274559546866,origin
stunnel,tls-init-stream16,0,5.254997688734296,nan,nan,nan,0,0,906,10.04,10.002109,1.5273697651841438,nan,56.0078125,0.037926068170907344,0.9534662867996201,0.566410537870472,0.05707554613487713,0.9207344244023087,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.17272143872,16779.08,3.59,7.93,0,0,0,10.1,10.10052,46.78052741963635,59.596865558912384,12.01953125,0.4264917325664989,0.9600760456273765,0.4481132075471698,0.563270684334641,0.24708187130673714,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.32480690176,31546.14,1.96,3.14,0,0,0,10.03,10.017436,24.703908557734213,31.734982835266013,36.23046875,0.39679165056049476,0.9525166191832859,0.45339565576024193,0.6954535418365821,0.29740529997501947,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.33688649728,32718.93,1.94,2.37,0,0,0,10.01,10.008228,23.770617298870924,30.5605930159428,32.4609375,0.4192982456140351,0.9524262607040913,0.4618760285244103,0.7640349644007383,0.32229591570628036,proxy
envoy,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.31784435712000003,30874.68,1.98,3.01,0,0,0,10.08,10.06195,25.370908179928744,32.3244761703192,17.54296875,0.5158506516379007,0.9572649572649573,0.5584072919165267,0.8959950160342254,0.3648243385606514,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.14235467776,13824.27,4.42,8.49,0,0,0,10.1,10.14796,56.75963815971199,72.33868830620035,13.578125,0.3925763393673432,0.9609895337773549,0.4120603015075377,0.4653459096080538,0.17875867582282284,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1k,1,1.43294201856,139176.18,0.369,0.849,0,0,0,1.64,0.0,0.9155988051201558,1.166678523155723,0.0,0.8827331486611265,0.4444444444444444,0.9510886715052067,3.1294172907604505,0.9562392105780603,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-ka-1m,1,7.3014444032,871.73,17.94,30.29,0,0,0,10.02,10.009905,1.09786496442907,1147.3720371006527,18.25,0.2613806903451726,0.9524714828897338,0.0740043900909376,0.7760446635763213,0.04177642800938439,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1m,1,5.08290924544,605.36,26.23,32.27,0,0,0,10.1,10.101548,1.5896408158868394,1651.9463526333006,43.8203125,0.48774008990600737,0.9591642924976258,0.1387618176273254,0.912195062191311,0.03324629169014147,client
nginx,tls-term-ka-1m,1,6.911458017279999,823.51,16.6,35.58,0,0,0,10.01,10.017724,1.1586556671513346,1214.0691328077623,43.640625,0.30174682938502034,0.9515209125475285,0.09606986899563319,0.7579814584045789,0.0370401569429093,proxy
envoy,tls-term-ka-1m,1,10.39382085632,1242.31,12.78,18.35,0,0,0,10.02,10.016006999999998,0.7712274543509996,805.4014950566675,39.97265625,0.3582776882339397,0.9515669515669516,0.12507534659433395,1.055930244987573,0.053193587238450246,client
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1m,1,4.65542578176,554.79,28.75,41.13,0,0,0,10.02,10.020218999999999,1.7218618394490917,1803.7803780378038,13.1640625,0.2159376571141277,0.9524714828897338,0.07064868336544637,0.5765733690493384,0.0209101453966468,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1m,1,29.807073034240002,3549.46,3.91,9.65,0,0,0,6.84,0.0,0.1835805881950972,190.80562374469986,0.0,0.8698197143526106,0.8191616766467066,0.9052369077306733,3.311668926885409,0.9535747825977475,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.02743074816,2670.97,5.36,9.12,0,0,0,10.11,10.107229,294.85160057697817,374.74979613018013,14.109375,0.9550107117353012,0.9610266159695817,0.3282308657465496,3.7871930248964962,0.048481171862288494,client
haproxy,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.0285212672,2780.7,14.76,18.6,0,0,0,10.01,10.001138000000001,280.7729384478401,359.2964824120603,37.1015625,0.7736015918638072,0.9515209125475285,0.31197916666666664,2.93198166282422,0.05603384040518167,client
nginx,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.03179282432,3101.91,1.26,3.0,0,0,0,10.08,10.071446,253.6421400890501,321.7466245331801,32.98046875,0.9511089911757692,0.9590865842055185,0.3812380038387716,3.7716297701023414,0.06177184221568405,client
envoy,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.039845888,3888.89,11.21,15.71,0,0,0,10.05,10.016436,201.7774079975329,255.86842507255972,19.078125,0.8643533123028391,0.9571428571428572,0.2913797851831451,3.3446102026163405,0.07413301508017986,client
stunnel,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.019881000960000002,1935.27,17.91,26.69,0,0,0,10.1,9.990365,406.4181685950685,516.7033304343378,20.77734375,0.8298548094373865,0.9600760456273765,0.23940967477452857,3.2103454770571536,0.03895485929898251,client
direct,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.12717129728,12396.83,0.5670000000000001,1.5,0,0,0,5.99,0.0,37.681458807872275,47.8384832245853,0.0,0.9562737642585551,0.6814562002275313,0.9517806492278601,3.7895813705102115,0.9453739873830603,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-stream1-down,1,9.269733180405584,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.53,8.612098,0.8223599190491607,nan,10.3671875,0.4755386565272497,0.8433628318584071,0.06378927324658838,1.0546488611938987,0.09086527097403839,client
haproxy,tls-term-stream1-down,1,7.519094674708266,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1,9.88,9.61274,1.0510683525119917,nan,40.09375,0.45240793201133145,0.9114391143911439,0.04571611253196931,1.0427517178910461,0.07037176596326697,client
nginx,tls-term-stream1-down,1,9.104725019391479,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.56,8.81892,0.8399591371899257,nan,39.859375,0.48488664987405544,0.855863921217547,0.13503222026947861,1.0526915771243328,0.08811322576773059,client
envoy,tls-term-stream1-down,1,9.42879598589367,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.41,7.081422,0.7983786410491476,nan,27.40625,0.4868080703569581,0.7732128184059162,0.050588609608654155,1.0863265860845686,0.09468485594659978,client
stunnel,tls-term-stream1-down,1,4.524189666969606,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.02,10.010884,1.7716461924246814,nan,4.6015625,0.3325115562403698,0.9390815370196813,0.016787360105332456,0.8789332503100277,0.04504085122005321,proxy
direct,tls-term-stream1-down,1,9.10875118930647,nan,nan,nan,0,0,2,0.26,0.0,0.02283434722893716,nan,0.0,0.4829965500246427,0.02905027932960894,0.3766111285759195,1.0793943246836857,0.7859091664243235,client
3proxy-devel,tls-term-stream16,1,6.697351563038402,nan,nan,nan,0,0,445,10.06,10.021135,1.1984589641856127,nan,26.359375,0.2403443462075384,0.9428303655107779,0.20544269835185894,0.6180199618605883,0.4509232551261653,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-stream16,1,5.004658686563269,nan,nan,nan,0,0,617,10.02,10.026729,1.6004047397392551,nan,53.2578125,0.21793390339727295,0.9408450704225352,0.5203488372093024,0.4983626788859683,0.8901862338824181,proxy
nginx,tls-term-stream16,1,6.682945302994012,nan,nan,nan,0,0,603,10.05,10.038772000000002,1.2006610456939681,nan,46.66015625,0.22403595930920275,0.9410112359550562,0.2548375319459657,0.60745653551399,0.46860140105462306,proxy
envoy,tls-term-stream16,1,9.480483179061055,nan,nan,nan,0,0,726,10.06,10.056433,0.8463177340622898,nan,76.984375,0.27601597369039227,0.9428303655107779,0.11945928953159383,0.7571363232770778,0.23529033093508328,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-stream16,1,4.269192969026591,nan,nan,nan,0,0,461,10.06,10.027892999999999,1.8789587980898699,nan,21.15625,0.16828478964401294,0.9419475655430711,0.18892630003741115,0.39458049083242813,0.3935539468825128,proxy
direct,tls-term-stream16,1,19.743686764960216,nan,nan,nan,0,0,758,0.55,0.0,0.02222746217714254,nan,0.0,0.528691313222953,0.06798516687268233,0.9303058971933144,1.5665236665604825,16.89637765654046,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.17758683136,17250.12,3.5,8.1,0,0,0,10.12,10.107277,45.58896590472956,58.08814244222756,12.6953125,0.41420959147424513,0.9601518026565465,0.4562424242424242,0.4747393192948892,0.2108943989320829,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.333447168,32387.18,1.92,3.04,0,0,0,10.02,10.020069,24.039790315448112,30.88979249581508,36.734375,0.4266792809839167,0.9506641366223909,0.429831595829992,0.6989222614929111,0.2706432240165258,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.34745614336,33748.56,1.86,2.59,0,0,0,10.1,10.066616,23.254733451721687,29.62989039874205,33.21484375,0.42716795767995464,0.9582542694497154,0.4670078103959063,0.6706931422430661,0.2956026697567241,proxy
envoy,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.31927042048000004,31007.9,1.97,3.15,0,0,0,10.08,10.0391,25.257585678862323,32.18699109110068,17.46484375,0.49156455336529925,0.9590865842055185,0.5488519785051295,0.7573484689334815,0.30988612174344554,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.14436794368,14025.62,4.38,9.04,0,0,0,10.03,10.001055,55.58020565691276,71.44281725454442,14.42578125,0.36625744047619047,0.9525166191832859,0.3876331514679137,0.39864048976106936,0.21190585517352017,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1k,1,1.4241339801600001,138315.47,0.41100000000000003,0.842,0,0,0,1.86,0.0,1.0448455136452994,1.331388265745098,0.0,0.8664998862861042,0.4603960396039604,0.945716975211798,3.0800727871449856,0.9478631858416178,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-ka-1m,1,6.14868189184,732.73,19.62,47.55,0,0,0,10.04,9.971608,1.3062962341017148,1368.22022349414,15.73046875,0.19650872817955112,0.9534662867996201,0.17011278195488722,0.4538056345323639,0.15672117794804047,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1m,1,4.69351006208,558.9,28.52,31.7,0,0,0,10.09,10.10157,1.7198216032848497,1787.422497785651,48.83203125,0.46153846153846156,0.9600380589914367,0.17016029593094945,0.7010050630755602,0.1339659252668233,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1m,1,5.8355351552,695.41,21.47,44.05,0,0,0,10.02,10.013459,1.3736529361590777,1439.0348987505386,43.09765625,0.19281376518218624,0.9515669515669516,0.18042526579111945,0.4557887752731992,0.1654046191203913,proxy
envoy,tls-init-ka-1m,1,8.76173328384,1046.7,15.28,20.39,0,0,0,10.0,10.005844999999999,0.9130613476622339,953.6524890329964,42.25,0.17040981708728872,0.9523809523809523,0.26814454904342544,0.40727643382389644,0.31557469261748955,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1m,1,4.25059155968,506.53,29.42,74.82,0,0,0,10.03,10.009055,1.8877372448845862,1977.5236593059938,16.53125,0.1719969780911609,0.9525166191832859,0.12606905289832118,0.4033243735928517,0.1425615490538313,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1m,1,28.69038153728,3414.19,5.04,8.61,0,0,0,6.88,0.0,0.19184129680702072,199.5186033697764,0.0,0.865546218487395,0.8309178743961353,0.9150650960942344,3.277400414027292,0.9556988618574584,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.0205520896,2005.61,31.29,46.51,0,0,0,10.04,10.028074,390.81184231505097,499.42794607769986,20.33984375,0.16630481980026052,0.9534662867996201,0.4135635018495684,0.11894297993036855,0.16824515511381852,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.025417482239999997,2480.38,25.64,28.03,0,0,0,10.02,10.014808,315.37348681157175,403.02469632370685,37.859375,0.17990907122753844,0.9533777354900095,0.4598698481561822,0.14461803605679738,0.19294756256333243,proxy
nginx,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.034812723200000006,3396.92,18.72,20.49,0,0,0,10.03,10.009061,230.49044321818522,294.92193242965095,32.4609375,0.2654133818475844,0.9525166191832859,0.5373854317414375,0.20830536739664013,0.27548694290475495,proxy
envoy,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.06048186368,5893.82,10.5,14.56,0,0,0,9.99,9.925229,132.13878531065797,169.195853939435,19.1796875,0.25120570350178234,0.9496197718631179,0.5250436082731124,0.2834379861127693,0.23271254204393688,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.02038431744,1983.51,31.48,51.65,0,0,0,10.03,9.939901,393.63594212159205,504.704875962361,20.08203125,0.1386535889433794,0.9534220532319392,0.3755784061696658,0.11414184021191724,0.15294220722219815,proxy
direct,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.12683575296,12370.37,0.5690000000000001,1.65,0,0,0,5.9,0.0,37.213481923259764,47.220777141942456,0.0,0.9520190023752969,0.6758304696449027,0.9468720528135807,3.787419660653997,0.9393004327061868,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-stream1-down,1,6.778821779722053,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,10.001936,1.1800161675431136,nan,6.90625,0.12013828867761452,0.9514747859181731,0.2888028396256857,0.46055110506776037,0.6084823476155924,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-stream1-down,1,5.846312769726175,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.003052,1.369599527587606,nan,35.765625,0.11402508551881414,0.9506172839506173,0.263884430176565,0.4413979082194608,0.5587704439401219,proxy
nginx,tls-init-stream1-down,1,7.6017539162414725,nan,nan,nan,0,0,2,10.0,10.000609,1.0522722237738609,nan,33.7890625,0.12517740562021004,0.9505703422053232,0.28846792954469924,0.47366796962412583,0.6688308040119565,proxy
envoy,tls-init-stream1-down,1,10.955224848848047,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,9.998869000000001,0.7309485864206171,nan,24.67578125,0.1174812030075188,0.9515209125475285,0.4,0.23601588200569462,0.8395756468434993,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-stream1-down,1,4.795608625183398,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1,10.01,10.000457,1.6698423364559418,nan,5.7421875,0.11237830319888735,0.9506172839506173,0.17884297520661158,0.4215543965934909,0.42401484662024624,proxy
direct,tls-init-stream1-down,1,8.845369392159736,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,0.19,0.0,0.01718230262475553,nan,0.0,0.5005027652086476,0.023543990086741014,0.3837906023336487,1.1188734081266047,0.8206808597482219,client
3proxy-devel,tls-init-stream16,1,8.348526041879582,nan,nan,nan,0,0,868,10.06,10.039975,0.961174535194798,nan,65.45703125,0.07860975040821087,0.9553656220322887,0.6574106213120444,0.09511296521841255,1.096991829366749,origin
haproxy,tls-init-stream16,1,5.937518659306832,nan,nan,nan,0,0,189,10.03,10.025227999999998,1.3502995738285455,nan,59.19921875,0.029081133919843596,0.9534220532319392,0.8708708708708709,0.06656302739661958,1.2897569968599922,origin
nginx,tls-init-stream16,1,7.838572817371034,nan,nan,nan,0,0,276,10.1,10.077734,1.024392927143987,nan,91.29296875,0.07186046511627907,0.957345971563981,0.6445066480055983,0.07988570806653485,1.0723465706063984,origin
envoy,tls-init-stream16,1,10.981565296725723,nan,nan,nan,0,0,7529,10.07,10.046444999999999,0.7313052365375371,nan,121.828125,0.08134083450539147,0.9554079696394687,0.6933154182062479,0.12175028292203176,1.3100040220041085,origin
stunnel,tls-init-stream16,1,5.157615200482038,nan,nan,nan,0,0,623,10.06,10.028229,1.5558830120489562,nan,56.29296875,0.027489751627682663,0.9553656220322887,0.5785369476420349,0.05801598681117103,0.941318332710401,origin
direct,tls-init-stream16,1,19.66306247313523,nan,nan,nan,0,0,767,0.51,0.0,0.02070314890198838,nan,0.0,0.5320643553138454,0.06480304955527319,0.9295154185022027,1.5642678563259558,28.347345127194817,origin
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.3288334336,31936.39,1.93,3.1,0,0,0,10.03,10.013764,24.40141171825175,31.351587896974245,36.015625,0.4109277177006261,0.9525166191832859,0.45345345345345345,0.7146669159365351,0.332579233598512,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.34410070016000005,33420.64,1.89,2.35,0,0,0,10.02,10.069127,23.29550621743204,29.92125513991621,32.46875,0.42587601078167114,0.9524714828897338,0.4678774735700732,0.7751503992672535,0.30497461469923043,proxy
envoy,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.3212836864,31204.57,1.96,2.98,0,0,0,10.09,10.105414,25.124213714201208,32.014569960878134,17.55078125,0.5137630971408276,0.9591254752851711,0.562905941784941,0.8884373344802152,0.3107348750724679,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.1430257664,13894.73,4.42,8.6,0,0,0,10.02,10.026845000000002,56.04584545683651,72.00965878057895,13.48046875,0.406758669497523,0.9533777354900095,0.41379310344827586,0.45961210744019154,0.17874150323549828,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1k,2,1.4377235251199998,139641.48,0.423,0.662,0,0,0,1.59,0.0,0.8847319931652592,1.1274316893393888,0.0,0.8828578056135468,0.43089430894308944,0.9529820132533923,3.1301228964205388,0.9510357842846556,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.17263755264,16769.6,3.6,7.88,0,0,0,10.02,10.022396,46.432539603452994,59.63930718409618,12.06640625,0.4245810055865922,0.9524714828897338,0.4507529005183905,0.5565802004880921,0.20526765339971662,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1m,2,4.88233762816,581.52,27.41,35.73,0,0,0,10.11,10.103785,1.6565835089631262,1721.4370849650945,42.8984375,0.5081123862287297,0.9601139601139601,0.14822673537435588,0.9134818371799617,0.024710959111089923,client
nginx,tls-term-ka-1m,2,7.24289191936,863.15,16.18,33.62,0,0,0,10.0,10.018656,1.1045311857569318,1157.0056693277797,43.71875,0.29292929292929293,0.9514747859181731,0.08688881968234195,0.8124892632445389,0.03136062583842448,proxy
envoy,tls-term-ka-1m,2,10.65151889408,1264.58,12.62,16.87,0,0,0,10.03,10.019421,0.7533197922091329,792.0713890863144,41.12890625,0.35921658986175115,0.9516129032258065,0.11940749697702539,1.0567530907363607,0.046561906006665855,client
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1m,2,4.85650071552,578.79,27.55,40.0,0,0,0,10.03,10.023925,1.6522184325758602,1730.2052785923754,15.66796875,0.21747916140439505,0.9525166191832859,0.061661341853035144,0.587862486055989,0.024702653428661635,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1m,2,31.86865733632,3797.73,4.18,6.6,0,0,0,7.23,0.0,0.18149493839541536,188.5119808098454,0.0,0.906857009127077,0.8387470997679815,0.9492113564668769,3.5375807901289584,0.9502110922461952,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-ka-1m,2,7.204220436479999,858.41,18.21,30.58,0,0,0,10.01,10.006914,1.111570650927046,1163.953488372093,15.359375,0.270303628733646,0.9524262607040913,0.07348748812163447,0.7831167601209016,0.032324450163658494,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.02860515328,2791.55,15.0,16.49,0,0,0,10.1,10.081886,282.46658638425583,358.24495442131024,36.52734375,0.8370253164556962,0.9600760456273765,0.3230690274570182,3.2458036071078893,0.05511654276584143,client
nginx,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.033470545920000004,3260.1,1.21,1.62,0,0,0,10.1,10.087979,241.40628059406325,306.7484662576687,31.7890625,0.9519505233111323,0.9591642924976258,0.3795811518324607,3.777672140618581,0.05606441963521189,client
envoy,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.0402653184,3929.47,11.79,15.35,0,0,0,10.06,10.0202,199.8742421468099,253.45796276233906,19.01171875,0.9000230361667818,0.9571836346336822,0.3164929163325314,3.50386950987268,0.0731608214001628,client
stunnel,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.01996488704,1947.87,17.85,26.89,0,0,0,10.11,10.004071,405.1112327255121,513.928426189508,20.63671875,0.825663114939923,0.9601139601139601,0.2408619749045281,3.199547979016617,0.038952692175190734,client
direct,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.1266679808,12348.0,0.561,1.47,0,0,0,5.97,0.0,37.70487197977028,47.8679901858593,0.0,0.9524714828897338,0.6791808873720137,0.9464735516372796,3.792224525260157,0.941483701506363,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.027850178559999998,2713.89,5.3,8.93,0,0,0,10.11,10.104875,290.4110644237105,368.83003173908287,14.0625,0.954772673173054,0.9610266159695817,0.32941470735367684,3.786314827126038,0.048477728487604,client
haproxy,tls-term-stream1-down,2,8.968599375780224,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1,9.63,8.850935000000002,0.8589691740820903,nan,38.27734375,0.471606824548001,0.8598214285714286,0.1500146498681512,1.0473339437508125,0.08830739845965337,client
nginx,tls-term-stream1-down,2,8.636059642597564,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.82,9.239968,0.9095734353564449,nan,34.4765625,0.4688576729393056,0.8870822041553749,0.08398621121905359,1.0531026050569805,0.08534777220768175,client
envoy,tls-term-stream1-down,2,9.64194246382679,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1,9.02,6.594320000000001,0.7483133289679001,nan,26.2109375,0.4697935253632424,0.7297734627831716,0.0610062893081761,1.0598768657246265,0.09573663899930611,client
stunnel,tls-term-stream1-down,2,4.727783514453538,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.03,10.004134,1.6970001363501541,nan,4.7578125,0.3436827543805718,0.9391385767790262,0.01818772328678142,0.8941120954913153,0.05346378262222705,proxy
direct,tls-term-stream1-down,2,9.280568456863806,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,0.23,0.0,0.019825564819653148,nan,0.0,0.48358430017279685,0.025755879059350503,0.39379184418746194,1.0751779725198674,0.8094679506634208,client
3proxy-devel,tls-term-stream1-down,2,7.483711544983906,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.86,9.567825000000001,1.0539077878075176,nan,6.95703125,0.465326917633739,0.9087557603686636,0.0685805422647528,1.0525559116722494,0.07785224580457077,client
haproxy,tls-term-stream16,2,4.825166495188452,nan,nan,nan,0,0,661,10.03,10.020363,1.6614448553657888,nan,55.234375,0.21141016793190706,0.9409005628517824,0.5207373271889401,0.48198378635282196,0.8550742835264348,proxy
nginx,tls-term-stream16,2,6.80332160424798,nan,nan,nan,0,0,520,10.05,10.052991,1.1779545111390417,nan,53.390625,0.21821631878557876,0.9427767354596623,0.2176560121765601,0.5990328463711426,0.46895727829320333,proxy
envoy,tls-term-stream16,2,9.350486773219757,nan,nan,nan,0,0,729,10.07,10.067895,0.8586724814154829,nan,61.42578125,0.2726628895184136,0.9446529080675422,0.11827618748033973,0.7550716753873961,0.23141995069069154,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-stream16,2,4.328418471651339,nan,nan,nan,0,0,479,10.07,10.025249,1.8559281797682747,nan,22.92578125,0.16020551144325082,0.943767572633552,0.18752348741074784,0.3898960057929893,0.3918973778300262,proxy
direct,tls-term-stream16,2,19.267557448239685,nan,nan,nan,0,0,770,0.51,0.0,0.021120634928308554,nan,0.0,0.519927536231884,0.06319702602230483,0.9336895034569453,1.525441135865811,1.9436265325616784,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-stream16,2,6.525649907980567,nan,nan,nan,0,0,503,10.05,10.010306,1.2290484249521128,nan,15.41796875,0.24103631737219525,0.9418931583880038,0.20954198473282443,0.5961738622476135,0.4472656045201327,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.33361494016000004,32400.88,1.92,2.92,0,0,0,10.11,10.099167,24.2435185789972,30.89409528582386,36.7265625,0.42649310872894336,0.9601139601139601,0.4293770139634801,0.7089433284844637,0.27944815575151094,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.34997272576,33988.5,1.86,2.33,0,0,0,10.01,10.01811,22.881783094982172,29.407098832529364,33.20703125,0.4274132730015083,0.9524262607040913,0.4494658997534922,0.6716650770493547,0.2888964333763196,proxy
envoy,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.32220643328,31297.27,1.96,3.05,0,0,0,10.0,9.989739,24.828802822344446,31.886738305538728,17.46875,0.49851007887817705,0.9505703422053232,0.553567167740396,0.7593842531004811,0.3070797150729684,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.14604566528000001,14187.81,4.33,8.64,0,0,0,10.03,10.023702,54.94171966430032,70.58806970132026,14.453125,0.3899517253709995,0.9507109004739337,0.41609251968503935,0.39661778215746857,0.16135901979361764,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1k,2,1.43260647424,139139.45,0.41500000000000004,0.746,0,0,0,2.33,0.0,1.3011249310379216,1.6580231240855967,0.0,0.8789618741387231,0.5393518518518519,0.951496062992126,3.1239657884918812,0.951668403483684,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.1769996288,17191.73,3.52,8.07,0,0,0,10.02,10.019112,45.288230570571685,58.21452225746854,12.43359375,0.4183401457259641,0.9524714828897338,0.45017182130584193,0.4776990446520995,0.2242895288315792,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1m,2,4.614153830399999,549.43,29.0,38.12,0,0,0,10.1,10.102464,1.7511336416149668,1820.147774373761,48.37109375,0.4638196915776987,0.9591642924976258,0.1913991520290733,0.7077436581546265,0.12540260862770147,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1m,2,5.8165769011199995,692.99,21.61,44.26,0,0,0,10.02,10.020264000000001,1.3781301504767338,1443.5960236277194,44.0859375,0.1933028919330289,0.9515669515669516,0.18346333853354135,0.45558047273462804,0.17384430798558817,proxy
envoy,tls-init-ka-1m,2,8.589934592,1020.64,15.56,21.68,0,0,0,10.0,10.000572,0.9313225746154785,978.3778495254868,39.65234375,0.17091245947197778,0.9514747859181731,0.2697070371488976,0.39958115838789576,0.26797225398575725,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1m,2,4.19329736704,499.67,29.15,77.7,0,0,0,10.04,10.01838,1.915437732399526,2005.1927301777512,18.15625,0.15841073271413827,0.952561669829222,0.12373417721518987,0.39957156932750854,0.13873068821903145,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1m,2,30.4942678016,3635.82,4.43,7.95,0,0,0,6.94,0.0,0.18206700472764567,188.97723559525107,0.0,0.8992686954470394,0.8232502965599051,0.9318323952470294,3.489327784596196,0.955611981392214,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-ka-1m,2,6.143397068800001,732.14,19.61,47.43,0,0,0,10.01,9.984368,1.3035133347752526,1365.0620482749216,15.52734375,0.19990079365079366,0.9515209125475285,0.1783359497645212,0.4556760218601475,0.18814525834964735,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.025165824,2452.58,25.91,28.92,0,0,0,10.03,10.019024,318.84511311848956,407.9889358932639,38.03125,0.1740073768713387,0.9525166191832859,0.45713595749818886,0.14362115394287908,0.19379040243355145,proxy
nginx,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.03456106496,3371.32,18.79,21.65,0,0,0,10.03,10.009682,232.16877168822052,297.0531615578262,33.36328125,0.26589945487583283,0.9525166191832859,0.5369208494208494,0.20739408911666185,0.2736890449391615,proxy
envoy,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.05813305344,5667.53,10.87,16.19,0,0,0,9.98,9.900231,137.34011078981786,175.61147281365476,19.25,0.24025423728813558,0.9477682811016145,0.5211864406779662,0.2786747697771259,0.23460509573367108,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.019797114879999998,1931.59,32.12,52.34,0,0,0,10.04,9.932929,405.7156837592691,518.3808343659645,18.0234375,0.13486915678819056,0.9543726235741445,0.375224877923413,0.11322497308445967,0.1511396879125909,proxy
direct,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.12490637312000001,12179.95,0.58,2.0,0,0,0,6.01,0.0,38.492831709882886,48.84630076642365,0.0,0.9545670789724072,0.685290763968073,0.945528967254408,3.7883910301492008,0.9416777150247672,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.0201326592,1959.36,31.94,47.36,0,0,0,10.04,10.031596,398.95375569661456,510.88947689802563,16.5703125,0.16138894955230398,0.9543726235741445,0.41196834817012856,0.11703460326425069,0.16918514107144272,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-stream1-down,2,6.2095089349680475,nan,nan,nan,0,0,2,9.98,9.924361,1.285628660563529,nan,39.59375,0.11718086611944523,0.9477682811016145,0.2666232073011734,0.45369101490501135,0.5595078051772462,proxy
nginx,tls-init-stream1-down,2,6.95793759706339,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.99,10.000771,1.1484788645528825,nan,39.546875,0.12242562929061784,0.950523311132255,0.2855747313578639,0.46794344780213487,0.6289645114261664,proxy
envoy,tls-init-stream1-down,2,10.602435969850474,nan,nan,nan,0,0,5,9.97,9.95305,0.7522182679815519,nan,23.296875,0.10244147998993204,0.9930278884462151,0.39627842866988283,0.224566693722654,0.8365168777145631,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-stream1-down,2,4.296702701740668,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.99,10.004566,1.8597835968763725,nan,3.80859375,0.09842075578116187,0.950523311132255,0.20205589463539994,0.3937244983993934,0.40275029697538167,proxy
direct,tls-init-stream1-down,2,9.246768142707195,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,0.33,0.0,0.028548914210530792,nan,0.0,0.4900437105390966,0.03650442477876106,0.3407821229050279,1.0804634142923428,0.8393525065936837,client
3proxy-devel,tls-init-stream1-down,2,7.22981240533617,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.00555,1.1075052461361792,nan,5.58984375,0.12827822120866592,0.9506172839506173,0.33886626996554964,0.479473441600731,0.6650384319639997,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-stream16,2,5.96259483329159,nan,nan,nan,0,0,3,10.02,10.024015,1.3436187641156672,nan,47.4140625,0.041939393939393936,0.9515669515669516,0.8697534976682212,0.07989339792745656,1.2757819328115165,origin
nginx,tls-init-stream16,2,7.686542335357298,nan,nan,nan,0,0,629,10.05,10.054053,1.0418987802894677,nan,70.05078125,0.05486641221374046,0.9553231939163498,0.6394819740987049,0.08276288491161637,1.0491590720549449,origin
envoy,tls-init-stream16,2,11.062095301183447,nan,nan,nan,0,0,8642,10.05,10.037702,0.7250835961215212,nan,117.53125,0.0774812734082397,0.9544159544159544,0.7045148247978437,0.12270659389069657,1.3424051373589132,origin
stunnel,tls-init-stream16,2,5.239605769183789,nan,nan,nan,0,0,631,10.05,10.033299999999999,1.530080919521522,nan,46.265625,0.02703355056722182,0.9544159544159544,0.5678373382624768,0.058032006675349565,0.9224683534584275,origin
direct,tls-init-stream16,2,19.643355063016077,nan,nan,nan,0,0,802,0.52,0.0,0.021148139109517843,nan,0.0,0.5287981859410431,0.06508135168961202,0.9277374566109182,1.5566616672365599,1.938116030685343,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-stream16,2,8.42007141579248,nan,nan,nan,0,0,900,10.06,10.041384,0.9526444944502712,nan,61.51953125,0.07548054383497421,0.9562737642585551,0.6500172235618326,0.09035494427132373,1.090465747761052,origin

1 proxy scenario rep gbit rate p50_ms p99_ms errors timeouts retrans prx_cpu_s prx_task_s cpu_s_per_gb cpu_us_per_req peak_mb cli_util prx_util srv_util cli_thread srv_thread bound
2 direct tls-term-ka-1k 0 1.43923347456 1.3920894976 139788.38 135203.73 0.418 0.433 0.716 1.07 0 0 0 1.56 1.77 0.0 0.8671282471258088 1.0171759807406222 1.104978637079683 1.296234183379788 0.0 0.8773911039410003 0.8580835603996367 0.42048517520215634 0.43596059113300495 0.9502362204724409 0.9349517584811703 3.1036970032231808 3.0248309276281193 0.9449767933049799 0.9358171938778904 origin
3 3proxy-current 3proxy-devel tls-term-ka-1k 0 0.16919822336 0.17507024896 16434.21 17001.38 3.67 3.53 7.83 7.88 0 0 0 10.11 10.09 10.102077999999999 10.104890000000001 47.80192037118089 46.10720580996196 60.91168709106026 58.75947052417641 11.7578125 12.08984375 0.44093526435177105 0.429058908045977 0.9610266159695817 0.960952380952381 0.4682822523164647 0.4549483013293944 0.5500387716770072 0.5766794859348302 0.18439661348100986 0.22720038990652688 proxy
4 haproxy tls-term-ka-1k 0 0.32690405376 0.32933675007999996 31753.11 31988.77 1.94 1.93 3.08 3.04 0 0 0 10.02 10.02144 10.023767 24.520956249398573 24.339828452344946 31.49121263168481 31.246978990928397 36.2578125 36.26171875 0.4317390507604911 0.408785727987723 0.9524714828897338 0.484903695991671 0.46326140398798143 0.7067207427148267 0.7161813017483875 0.30119480289065775 0.286939172841326 proxy
5 nginx tls-term-ka-1k 0 0.34091302912 0.34351349760000005 33110.79 33361.89 1.91 1.89 2.29 2.33 0 0 0 10.01 10.02 10.017096 10.013692 23.489861976443315 23.3353275955815 30.177325704087355 29.973974692632147 32.421875 32.47265625 0.4595433789954338 0.4407484407484408 0.9524262607040913 0.9515669515669516 0.4998720900486058 0.4747123360984747 0.7783796718107615 0.7827712011784499 0.3079200937141662 0.33442126498782127 proxy
6 stunnel envoy tls-term-ka-1k 0 0.14411628544 0.31801212927999994 13997.51 30886.15 4.39 1.98 8.19 3.06 0 0 0 10.11 10.09 10.105061999999998 10.084401 56.12134655918036 25.382679642677562 71.5124421746573 32.34295715279403 13.41796875 17.52734375 0.41525275494140285 0.517204682511529 0.9601139601139601 0.9591254752851711 0.44391971664698937 0.5630252100840336 0.46239304043982005 0.9037871159143464 0.15681054770137193 0.3431329766735917 proxy client
7 direct stunnel tls-term-ka-1m tls-term-ka-1k 0 28.518582845439997 0.14503903231999998 3396.15 14084.55 4.92 4.35 7.99 8.21 0 0 0 6.39 10.11 0.0 10.107971000000001 0.17925154372870206 55.76429924156847 186.29194484125827 71.07255587034004 0.0 13.49609375 0.8392857142857143 0.4050044682752458 0.8047858942065491 0.9610266159695817 0.8910614525139665 0.41683217477656404 3.256266527376346 0.47576815277289547 0.9575980353996528 0.18724993216172428 origin proxy
8 3proxy-current direct tls-term-ka-1m 0 5.95389841408 29.377576304639998 709.52 3499.4 22.37 4.82 36.51 7.73 0 0 0 10.03 6.43 10.015631 0.0 1.3476884289836968 0.17509953668940134 1410.689170182841 181.91591693543825 12.3046875 0.0 0.32870031699585467 0.8574433278803458 0.9534220532319392 0.8027465667915106 0.07265774378585087 0.8941139831828091 1.0561731198566409 3.2694043456181623 0.024725197211463632 0.9565431983124729 client origin
9 haproxy 3proxy-devel tls-term-ka-1m 0 4.7462744063999995 7.03368003584 565.34 838.24 28.1 18.66 35.21 31.09 0 0 0 10.1 10.02 10.098108 10.006776 1.7023878748149743 1.1396594612144149 1768.8266199649738 1193.7097927090779 42.609375 14.80859375 0.48249027237354086 0.26465495918872123 0.9600760456273765 0.9524714828897338 0.19498847926267282 0.07633829585049097 0.8580728221764721 0.7677964352440629 0.021861640453726128 0.029453518646857354 proxy
10 nginx haproxy tls-term-ka-1m 0 6.842252001279999 4.8792338432 814.97 581.2 17.07 27.54 34.05 30.64 0 0 0 10.02 10.11 10.019807 10.104375000000001 1.1715441054349394 1.6576372971490048 1227.0389419544454 1722.3168654173764 42.1015625 41.4765625 0.3050129442221699 0.510533569600315 0.9524714828897338 0.9601139601139601 0.11587591240875912 0.14507299270072993 0.7839451741608926 0.8962550719293447 0.03706187762990015 0.02185952816643344 proxy
11 stunnel nginx tls-term-ka-1m 0 4.47960055808 7.27619469312 533.79 866.88 29.8 15.74 41.51 37.69 0 0 0 10.04 10.02 10.025791 10.017831000000001 1.7930170103029432 1.1016747541925345 1876.6355140186915 1154.3778801843318 13.4453125 43.4296875 0.2036326426195958 0.2948284195263412 0.952561669829222 0.9524714828897338 0.0729903536977492 0.08377618005626758 0.5599828036914579 0.7801570989336393 0.018997196463425892 0.033263906937601666 proxy
12 direct envoy tls-term-close-1k tls-term-ka-1m 0 0.12700352512000002 10.565619548159999 12382.0 1261.88 0.558 12.68 1.43 16.97 0 0 0 5.89 10.01 0.0 10.00575 37.10133238859188 0.7579299977155235 47.09362756856161 792.3064745923698 0.0 41.40625 0.9567078972407231 0.3592592592592593 0.6770114942528735 0.9515209125475285 0.9501734468621886 0.11862864077669903 3.787302085470794 1.0442960505988186 0.9500237647279252 0.05415495596845124 origin client
13 3proxy-current stunnel tls-term-close-1k tls-term-ka-1m 0 0.02759852032 4.61230833664 2689.77 549.65 5.42 29.07 9.96 41.36 0 0 0 10.1 10.02 10.101399 9.988987 292.7693190183321 1.737958396302607 371.77457945301285 1819.8329095532147 19.26953125 12.859375 0.9548693586698337 0.2089171974522293 0.9609895337773549 0.9515669515669516 0.37130801687763715 0.06509829197550758 3.78363078824788 0.5717750085376905 0.04752205083144872 0.027555417032560613 client proxy
14 haproxy direct tls-term-close-1k 0 0.02952790016 0.12499025920000001 2881.39 12190.24 14.06 0.555 16.23 1.43 0 0 0 10.1 5.65 10.085373 0.0 273.6395055597478 36.16281803822358 347.05518521063846 45.8879521790686 36.9921875 0.0 0.7649444918872759 0.9543400713436385 0.9609895337773549 0.6608187134502924 0.36055245941361763 0.9436220472440945 2.831407964527035 3.78107836386332 0.056069766301595894 0.9352217747404032 client origin
15 nginx 3proxy-devel tls-term-close-1k 0 0.0339738624 0.02776629248 3309.76 2708.48 1.2 5.25 1.53 8.62 0 0 0 10.1 10.12 10.093163 10.082897 237.829891251929 291.57655836952415 302.12384086150166 369.9100811462826 30.9453125 12.88671875 0.9542857142857143 0.9533222195760895 0.9609895337773549 0.9601518026565465 0.4076662908680947 0.3292407917815084 3.779649775563822 3.7798582845450444 0.054170596120676894 0.04846762861987139 client
16 stunnel haproxy tls-term-close-1k 0 0.02046820352 0.028940697600000002 1998.12 2825.09 17.55 14.24 26.16 18.98 0 0 0 10.01 10.03 9.925464 9.995154 391.2409798043673 277.25662010303444 499.8252359314925 354.2166972736262 19.890625 37.11328125 0.8229471316085489 0.7877919788453063 0.9533333333333334 0.9525166191832859 0.27490247074122237 0.31592621460119513 3.1921854543592736 2.988125024992129 0.03896556963013126 0.0569891153108287 client
17 direct nginx tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-close-1k 0 1.44560881664 0.03338665984 140408.63 3255.28 0.42 1.21 0.686 1.61 0 0 0 1.97 10.09 0.0 10.08296 1.090198110207342 241.77321237535332 1.3891229557151832 306.8828127376137 0.0 31.3203125 0.888347260909935 0.9545021438780371 0.49747474747474746 0.9600380589914367 0.9535398230088495 0.37815326035221325 3.1486030140417856 3.7767875149066468 0.9549567226722561 0.055129953873606335 origin client
18 3proxy-current envoy tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-close-1k 0 0.16592666624000002 0.04018143232 16118.5 3916.26 3.77 12.03 8.46 14.65 0 0 0 10.01 10.09 10.014918 10.030517000000001 48.262284667475036 200.8888069423604 62.037507592002676 255.10075089120926 12.22265625 18.6875 0.4267361111111111 0.904420273084934 0.9524262607040913 0.9582146248812915 0.45854241338112306 0.33026315789473687 0.46053905836101444 3.54912460888683 0.18819565851956507 0.07412408106946165 proxy client
19 haproxy stunnel tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-close-1k 0 0.33218887680000003 0.020048773120000002 32259.89 1957.62 1.94 17.56 2.87 26.03 0 0 0 10.11 10.098718000000002 10.001994 24.347594290068653 403.4162066471626 31.02911703593669 511.2257281553398 36.65234375 23.7890625 0.4495581737849779 0.8398446424491661 0.9601139601139601 0.9610266159695817 0.4657842157842158 0.23870791130577607 0.7123230811607429 3.2471492042191374 0.3001226109723907 0.03801439829195942 proxy client
20 nginx direct tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-stream1-down 0 0.3485466624 9.293834923854945 33852.58 nan 1.87 nan 2.3 nan 0 0 0 10.09 0.09 10.100526 0.0 23.159022509119286 0.00774636463727282 29.51215731237551 nan 33.13671875 0.0 0.43630632301131095 0.474320987654321 0.9600380589914367 0.010101010101010102 0.458747648481591 0.36843800322061193 0.6722958894310512 1.0746396247321204 0.32298702524092604 0.8176578992239385 proxy client
21 stunnel 3proxy-devel tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-stream1-down 0 0.14403239936 9.163430408938526 13992.44 nan 4.38 nan 8.53 nan 0 0 0 10.12 9.76 10.105426999999999 9.108672 56.20957531759609 0.8519879017494479 71.60951585740366 nan 14.359375 6.35546875 0.39872521246458925 0.5072658772874058 0.9601518026565465 0.9207547169811321 0.4342925659472422 0.04691358024691358 0.38535774385386845 1.0566006975425148 0.16155219887809816 0.09849937659157491 proxy client
22 direct haproxy tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream1-down 0 31.86865733632 8.77996528514481 3802.24 nan 4.21 nan 6.77 nan 0 0 0 7.48 9.52 0.0 8.860667 0.18777069698446844 0.8673907989096684 194.77644975652944 nan 0.0 41.08984375 0.9059233449477352 0.46992970580577975 0.85 0.8592057761732852 0.9536131271694541 0.06592 3.508252963448141 1.0556821915231327 0.9571120725212797 0.0910933624177118 origin client
23 3proxy-current nginx tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream1-down 0 5.599983042560001 7.51396851840779 667.35 nan 21.46 nan 52.65 nan 0 0 0 10.04 9.96 9.997523 9.718259 1.434290057479927 1.0603034804198586 1500.5230907188761 nan 18.234375 33.1484375 0.17424826522744796 0.4508174009420892 0.9534662867996201 0.9205175600739371 0.16935985083903046 0.05337262606417813 0.43199750231871964 1.0368524567142539 0.17489734078750313 0.08161489142052755 proxy client
24 haproxy envoy tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream1-down 0 4.5562724351999995 9.727648676631553 542.44 nan 29.34 nan 37.3 nan 0 0 0 10.1 9.31 10.096542 6.887653 1.7733794708097441 0.7656286105433424 1843.7385907265425 nan 47.91015625 24.40625 0.44719237786336913 0.48361270953214913 0.9600760456273765 0.7550689375506894 0.20470798569725865 0.06654170571696345 0.6888261180458144 1.0675906263818422 0.1910789643970402 0.0995115775407132 proxy client
25 nginx stunnel tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream1-down 0 5.8494602444799995 4.716006741302276 697.07 nan 22.4 nan 35.93 nan 0 0 0 10.03 10.018901999999999 10.012193 1.371750497419324 1.7012633870261782 1436.139747995418 nan 46.23828125 4.4375 0.17391304347826086 0.3495561677379859 0.9525166191832859 0.9400187441424555 0.1887599266951741 0.019162065605716143 0.4518170555555568 0.8897344251098557 0.16343421309998707 0.05254501244348075 proxy
26 stunnel direct tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream16 0 4.09624117248 18.925880502955465 488.1 nan 29.94 nan 80.2 nan 0 0 0 705 10.04 0.24 10.018036 0.0 1.960822046797884 0.0101050467848037 2052.33033524121 nan 14.28125 0.0 0.1614650502966211 0.5121503897294819 0.9516587677725118 0.030303030303030304 0.12625 0.9310453400503779 0.39455826463615057 1.5156926322014015 0.17000018816441312 2.758691947536444 proxy origin
27 direct 3proxy-devel tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 0 0.1270874112 6.744539040269984 12387.5 nan 0.557 nan 1.42 nan 0 0 0 406 5.89 10.08 0.0 10.028887 37.07684306028259 1.1925920272156314 47.074431949872526 nan 0.0 32.1328125 0.9541676561386844 0.2334340850964892 0.6754587155963303 0.9438202247191011 0.949873896595208 0.20575815738963532 3.789037266677241 0.6048301032185484 0.948525093638368 0.4510193750789299 origin proxy
28 3proxy-current haproxy tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 0 0.02046820352 5.0508450944870456 1991.68 nan 31.58 nan 46.36 nan 0 0 0 730 10.05 10.02 10.046098 10.022953 392.8043803230661 1.5859289505450904 502.6005201040208 nan 16.2265625 57.16796875 0.1962303664921466 0.21203703703703702 0.9553231939163498 0.9408450704225352 0.4414856341976174 0.5180420458111076 0.11700812834357528 0.4983960403619521 0.16819766016891818 0.8873812098975168 proxy
29 haproxy nginx tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 0 0.0255852544 6.6625112543267475 2497.16 nan 25.51 nan 27.45 nan 0 0 0 464 10.05 10.07 10.018104 10.051921 314.24350425845284 1.2043516887648529 401.37385678341786 nan 37.69140625 61.03515625 0.21621621621621623 0.208363201911589 0.95260663507109 0.943767572633552 0.48175519630484986 0.2315270935960591 0.14544643294249562 0.5925187446976511 0.1908854172303607 0.45838061659597235 proxy
30 nginx envoy tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 0 0.03506438144 9.443206579037609 3415.05 nan 18.64 nan 19.96 nan 0 0 0 907 10.04 10.017447 10.055330000000001 229.06435733776914 0.8478981746042726 293.36138382421694 nan 31.3046875 65.64453125 0.3150169363944298 0.27735849056603773 0.952561669829222 0.9444967074317968 0.5448717948717948 0.1190176322418136 0.20914579107716558 0.7685936825864172 0.2763155516595777 0.23934200455094362 proxy
31 stunnel tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 0 0.020719861760000003 4.246478882892315 2020.17 nan 30.65 nan 50.59 nan 0 0 0 471 10.04 10.05 9.952296 10.016542 387.6473739562246 1.8893481270251706 494.97140603431274 nan 19.15234375 17.46875 0.15156832638736564 0.1544256120527307 0.9543726235741445 0.9418931583880038 0.40702781844802344 0.18260217472815898 0.11608036637748038 0.3906179274582188 0.15210949476013474 0.3914421897839879 proxy
32 3proxy-current direct tls-term-ka-1k tls-init-ka-1k 1 0 0.16961765376 1.42891548672 16473.58 138786.21 3.66 0.422 7.74 0.729 0 0 0 10.1 1.57 10.101476 0.0 47.63655091841308 0.8789883038380959 60.70477644414259 1.1200517078648318 11.890625 0.0 0.44235458028561475 0.8772413793103448 0.9600760456273765 0.42091152815013405 0.46807500593401374 0.9508816120906801 0.5555511284364395 3.1069088993629594 0.18530655416507485 0.9498230194007785 proxy origin
33 haproxy 3proxy-devel tls-term-ka-1k tls-init-ka-1k 1 0 0.3326083072 0.17557356544 32302.05 17054.78 1.91 3.53 3.02 8.48 0 0 0 10.02 10.12 10.022596 10.103021 24.100420303633353 46.11172518887362 30.953440094899168 58.75386080211793 36.2421875 12.5625 0.4341311894756075 0.4164285714285714 0.9515669515669516 0.9601518026565465 0.4884744884744885 0.45169261181121817 0.7159547740664182 0.4748139450569951 0.3181358575020215 0.21860738817753814 proxy
34 nginx haproxy tls-term-ka-1k tls-init-ka-1k 1 0 0.34510733312 0.33529266176 33517.26 32566.71 1.88 1.92 2.35 2.86 0 0 0 10.03 10.11 10.020503 10.100397000000001 23.250737466102787 24.12221000467147 29.856166503941132 30.73845255758519 32.359375 36.84765625 0.43843107674901 0.42901115813774526 0.9534220532319392 0.9601139601139601 0.4723779023218575 0.41986827661909987 0.7783193704900336 0.7136189922365787 0.2880103536267642 0.270835638298258 proxy
35 stunnel nginx tls-term-ka-1k tls-init-ka-1k 1 0 0.14227079168 0.34452013056 13818.69 33463.74 4.46 1.89 8.3 2.33 0 0 0 10.02 10.03 10.021258999999999 10.015092000000001 56.34325855183151 23.290366188348397 72.3894291204901 29.925916201467356 13.26953125 33.1953125 0.4207980652962515 0.42545523520485584 0.9533777354900095 0.9525166191832859 0.4372623574144487 0.455810147299509 0.46534344959924023 0.6670143148430631 0.188215713535384 0.29940655350770856 proxy
36 direct envoy tls-term-ka-1k tls-init-ka-1k 1 0 1.4463637913599998 0.32405192704 140480.79 31476.65 0.42 1.95 0.664 3.01 0 0 0 1.72 10.1 0.0 10.086791999999999 0.9513512494018966 24.934275422477672 1.2122109106029693 31.770197667249644 0.0 17.42578125 0.8825017245343757 0.5011361650061178 0.455026455026455 0.9591642924976258 0.9526963103122044 0.5558217537134643 3.143914124870164 0.7600478003035748 0.9521459060053177 0.2946446738179909 origin proxy
37 3proxy-current stunnel tls-term-ka-1m tls-init-ka-1k 1 0 6.05397450752 0.14612955136000003 721.51 14195.24 21.98 4.34 35.03 8.37 0 0 0 10.02 10.015604 10.013202 1.3240888262814539 54.855434273195314 1386.0838290219947 70.50528789659225 12.7421875 14.453125 0.3317904993909866 0.3845597541131803 0.9524714828897338 0.07711757269279393 0.40935233808452115 1.0398464274029606 0.39571583490682516 0.025655603147065834 0.16057848338674605 client proxy
38 haproxy direct tls-term-ka-1m tls-init-ka-1m 1 0 4.9979326464 27.74548873216 594.95 3302.69 26.83 5.22 29.54 7.36 0 0 0 10.1 6.48 10.101992000000001 0.0 1.6166684450659825 0.18684118524793503 1680.8121151605924 194.2737220806476 41.5234375 0.0 0.4844629822732012 0.8270607250057723 0.9600760456273765 0.8039702233250621 0.17418213969938107 0.8671732522796353 0.9117298840407279 3.0923785505514267 0.02279813353131231 0.953336216453813 client origin
39 nginx 3proxy-devel tls-term-ka-1m tls-init-ka-1m 1 0 6.531118530560001 5.84056832 778.22 696.0 20.01 20.27 33.74 61.66 0 0 0 10.02 10.022428000000001 9.989832 1.2273548493251247 1.3724691777939857 1284.944857655809 1438.208698148414 41.61328125 20.171875 0.3185115843669553 0.19264668849156383 0.9524714828897338 0.12767911818738517 0.18023617153511498 0.7439290423295145 0.4434411792478279 0.04085399320300185 0.27271998232683625 proxy
40 stunnel haproxy tls-term-ka-1m tls-init-ka-1m 1 0 4.425410150399999 4.6313504768 527.41 551.57 30.23 28.9 43.92 36.95 0 0 0 10.01 10.11 10.021142 10.096093 1.8095497881199059 1.7463588731873187 1894.7567669884536 1814.7549811523963 11.01171875 49.21875 0.1969302809573361 0.4540692989524577 0.9524262607040913 0.9610266159695817 0.07452618053324767 0.17063369397217928 0.547764871945811 0.7050437766371025 0.020898337347345086 0.1491894355858182 proxy
41 direct nginx tls-term-ka-1m tls-init-ka-1m 1 0 31.52505995264 5.8539062067200005 3754.79 697.54 4.3 21.17 6.62 43.06 0 0 0 7.9 10.02 0.0 10.016183 0.20047543159297765 1.3693420627064403 208.30586684245222 1434.2971657600915 0.0 43.91015625 0.913396795913629 0.20135236664162284 0.8652792990142387 0.9515669515669516 0.9504888047934406 0.18321327904791732 3.516977670473943 0.4564925550297905 0.9578710733957263 0.1852465234565511 origin proxy
42 3proxy-current envoy tls-term-close-1k tls-init-ka-1m 1 0 0.027682406399999998 8.41813590016 2702.88 1002.47 5.39 15.76 8.85 23.84 0 0 0 10.11 10.01 10.101994000000001 10.0073 292.1711314808239 0.9512794869286675 370.31610563715617 996.4164841728051 9.4375 40.79296875 0.9553231939163498 0.1663172606568833 0.9601139601139601 0.9515209125475285 0.3737727910238429 0.2652689152233364 3.7866005305899466 0.39577915164922567 0.049420228363693086 0.30409122909425207 client proxy
43 haproxy stunnel tls-term-close-1k tls-init-ka-1m 1 0 0.029360128 4.1721580748800005 2862.86 497.09 14.52 29.48 15.78 77.56 0 0 0 10.11 10.03 10.086215000000001 10.015576 275.47563825334817 1.923225308338967 349.5729746550949 2013.6518771331057 36.484375 17.89453125 0.795193764884174 0.15694372741352608 0.9601139601139601 0.9516129032258065 0.3691130767391824 0.12350346565847511 2.992484396465593 0.3994475964951075 0.054184394584872404 0.17938605756051504 client proxy
44 nginx direct tls-term-close-1k tls-init-close-1k 1 0 0.033218887679999996 0.12532580352 3235.76 12218.5 1.21 0.5630000000000001 1.65 1.98 0 0 0 10.11 5.99 10.092725999999999 0.0 243.47594290068656 38.236339727399184 309.3445933541399 48.53621579574275 31.73828125 0.0 0.9547295687395759 0.9517126546146527 0.9601139601139601 0.6737907761529809 0.4058890147225368 0.9413241292751804 3.781842488734503 3.7872712953261907 0.055100514707128095 0.9411646148728162 client origin
45 stunnel 3proxy-devel tls-term-close-1k tls-init-close-1k 1 0 0.020048773120000002 0.020635975679999998 1952.73 2009.76 17.8 31.18 26.94 46.26 0 0 0 10.11 10.03 10.006965 10.025792 403.4162066471626 388.83550380303603 512.5735145001014 498.1870560770874 21.234375 15.3203125 0.8369369369369369 0.1654315605928509 0.9601139601139601 0.9534220532319392 0.27988565488565487 0.41494082840236685 3.229551113263159 0.11895511321300963 0.03894919669621939 0.1682994717210808 client proxy
46 direct haproxy tls-term-close-1k tls-init-close-1k 1 0 0.12675186688 0.02499805184 12362.82 2436.74 0.557 26.03 1.47 28.43 0 0 0 5.9 10.02 0.0 10.015318 37.23811030308984 320.66498826814177 47.248382343519765 410.18503356803666 0.0 37.8203125 0.9557879724269075 0.17112998040496408 0.6750572082379863 0.9524714828897338 0.9468051621026126 0.4559748427672956 3.7892235436396366 0.1417205035275168 0.9464910700414535 0.19192313229100294 origin proxy
47 3proxy-current nginx tls-init-ka-1k tls-init-close-1k 1 0 0.16995319808 0.03447717888 16510.15 3361.32 3.67 18.79 8.13 23.41 0 0 0 10.1 10.01 10.104447 10.003511000000001 47.54250047237475 232.2695841174346 60.57007838127965 297.3326204479297 12.40234375 33.03515625 0.42960787700811887 0.26715092816787733 0.9609895337773549 0.9533333333333334 0.46485207100591713 0.5357056402808037 0.4603220748429241 0.210250244059997 0.20899354055461175 0.27654611918467026 proxy
48 haproxy envoy tls-init-ka-1k tls-init-close-1k 1 0 0.33436991488 0.05804916736 32472.92 5657.94 1.92 10.9 2.91 16.77 0 0 0 10.0 9.99 10.009786 9.91711 23.925597501411186 137.67639336558437 30.76042855429062 176.1780474040632 36.75 19.2109375 0.45118153507968495 0.24180934263369266 0.9514747859181731 0.9496197718631179 0.4600202429149798 0.5218150087260035 0.7115378225129483 0.27486978755602454 0.2812704754783617 0.23085421138047788 proxy
49 nginx stunnel tls-init-ka-1k tls-init-close-1k 1 0 0.35039215616 0.01920991232 34030.39 1872.01 1.86 33.09 2.41 54.5 0 0 0 10.02 10.03 10.009271 9.928395 22.877224444315594 417.7010215526064 29.397095496552737 534.7051924512208 33.1796875 19.0 0.4374884579870729 0.134568176746262 0.9515669515669516 0.9534220532319392 0.4701101206082853 0.37035123966942146 0.6698367151793299 0.11227889987212178 0.32405144493317556 0.15206495973371348 proxy
50 stunnel direct tls-init-ka-1k tls-init-stream1-down 1 0 0.14369685504 9.2074792391595 13957.13 nan 4.41 nan 8.5 nan 0 0 0 10.11 0.37 10.105449 0.0 56.285156677566775 0.03214644729780898 71.71942170452449 nan 14.3671875 0.0 0.4037722668529514 0.4862340216322517 0.9601139601139601 0.04057017543859649 0.4407616361071932 0.3595758354755784 0.3908161003110235 1.078637185575463 0.20042123513864932 0.8151964992838053 proxy client
51 direct 3proxy-devel tls-init-ka-1k tls-init-stream1-down 1 0 1.4440988672000001 7.308803248275543 140257.87 nan 0.41400000000000003 nan 0.754 nan 0 0 0 1.52 10.0 0.0 10.002157 0.8420476101873366 1.0944476447066418 1.072973491907521 nan 0.0 4.70703125 0.8771566597653554 0.1378241262683202 0.41192411924119243 0.9514747859181731 0.9477494491658798 0.33733417561591916 3.12287468894866 0.47579304380184495 0.9481793060147322 0.6988019660576581 origin proxy
52 3proxy-current haproxy tls-init-ka-1m tls-init-stream1-down 1 0 5.70232406016 5.821160810375183 679.46 nan 21.12 nan 53.48 nan 0 0 0 10.03 10.0 9.987998 9.995925999999999 1.4071455629925838 1.374145734271717 1471.537558685446 nan 20.1796875 40.66796875 0.19841072758877576 0.10997150997150996 0.9534220532319392 0.9505703422053232 0.1715170278637771 0.2651635439822166 0.4375197590627391 0.43946900720116777 0.17766417038041074 0.5454691540590876 proxy
53 haproxy nginx tls-init-ka-1m tls-init-stream1-down 1 0 4.59922210816 7.229744269623417 547.35 nan 29.03 nan 37.71 nan 0 0 0 10.1 9.99 10.098744 10.000118 1.7568188293547202 1.1054046608729153 1827.0622286541245 nan 48.4453125 36.828125 0.4712334038868578 0.12457240592930445 0.9600760456273765 0.9496197718631179 0.1909942580840133 0.2848205465920316 0.6783993530642565 0.46892265628063223 0.2138962635360921 0.6496471681828438 proxy
54 nginx envoy tls-init-ka-1m tls-init-stream1-down 1 0 5.79761864704 10.853111653192572 690.77 nan 21.14 nan 42.38 nan 0 0 0 1 10.03 9.98 10.02678 9.976779 1.3840165227315682 0.73560132376774 1448.584633160023 nan 43.7734375 24.9453125 0.20105820105820105 0.06754082137555666 0.9525166191832859 0.9486692015209125 0.19914477703115455 0.3833116036505867 0.45648111788411194 0.22926516893050844 0.16529398143366705 0.8208024804285621 proxy
55 stunnel tls-init-ka-1m tls-init-stream1-down 1 0 4.14749556736 4.426390368581383 494.21 nan 30.11 nan 68.85 nan 0 0 0 1 10.02 10.0 10.019917000000001 10.001557 1.9327326261863647 1.8071425769221658 2023.016353725015 nan 16.39453125 5.9140625 0.16917581015565195 0.1052335396736072 0.9524714828897338 0.9505703422053232 0.1315128688010044 0.21188055908513342 0.4003186821500213 0.4004110010905507 0.11491240453161419 0.4114237983316316 proxy
56 direct tls-init-ka-1m tls-init-stream16 1 0 32.21225472 18.283828112558886 3837.04 nan 4.14 nan 9.74 nan 0 0 0 743 7.21 0.39 0.0 0.17906228701273605 0.017015777126283136 186.0357105996491 nan 0.0 0.9049836981835119 0.508459076360311 0.8403263403263403 0.04797047970479705 0.9338790931989924 0.9268830759533564 3.5067157321961746 1.4860198345701823 0.9569534940338696 1.953350246579136 origin
57 3proxy-current 3proxy-devel tls-init-close-1k tls-init-stream16 1 0 0.02046820352 7.85990244478347 1997.24 nan 31.37 nan 46.46 nan 0 0 0 1032 10.05 10.07 10.042808 10.039336 392.8043803230661 1.0220159223349807 501.4219428229307 nan 18.21875 44.359375 0.19344675488342786 0.07603578154425612 0.9553231939163498 0.956315289648623 0.44232558139534883 0.6354202698028364 0.11608032161165885 0.09130866194988724 0.16726423174861682 1.0447423890358685 proxy origin
58 haproxy tls-init-close-1k tls-init-stream16 1 0 0.025417482239999997 5.86128438345321 2481.7 nan 25.53 nan 29.86 nan 0 0 0 9 10.05 10.03 10.026736000000001 10.025364999999999 316.31771880801364 1.368238219647359 403.43623298944243 nan 37.80078125 65.19921875 0.19936974789915968 0.03711790393013101 0.9544159544159544 0.9516129032258065 0.48161849710982657 0.855525965379494 0.14271647506102042 0.07035385453858682 0.19102332527847646 1.2534061634240694 proxy origin
59 nginx tls-init-close-1k tls-init-stream16 1 0 0.03506438144 7.792840054565132 3414.92 nan 18.63 nan 20.03 nan 0 0 0 454 10.03 10.07 10.018757 10.060383999999999 228.83620558743272 1.0290383462320856 293.1034482758621 nan 30.4296875 72.234375 0.31871016122984624 0.06873094065212292 0.9525166191832859 0.956315289648623 0.5444391634980988 0.6355074991280084 0.20913259461550932 0.08370469003431631 0.27349234155048363 1.0536350634348823 proxy origin
60 stunnel envoy tls-init-close-1k tls-init-stream16 1 0 0.020635975679999998 10.864147201801515 2011.13 nan 30.86 nan 49.35 nan 0 0 0 8190 10.06 10.04 9.969092 10.04179 389.9985212620681 0.7371821331730954 497.9951487550121 nan 21.671875 125.82421875 0.14970323147944603 0.07728337236533958 0.9553656220322887 0.9543726235741445 0.4062423799073397 0.6989898989898989 0.1160795948302106 0.12366100208998754 0.1511111707292933 1.3354274559546866 proxy origin
61 direct stunnel tls-init-close-1k tls-init-stream16 1 0 0.12473860095999999 5.254997688734296 12161.15 nan 0.56 nan 2.12 nan 0 0 0 906 5.88 10.04 0.0 10.002109 37.710860662197376 1.5273697651841438 47.86909268530956 nan 0.0 56.0078125 0.9543509272467903 0.037926068170907344 0.6743119266055045 0.9534662867996201 0.9372844151771715 0.566410537870472 3.7915930704274428 0.05707554613487713 0.9349731514323012 0.9207344244023087 origin
62 haproxy 3proxy-devel tls-term-ka-1k 2 1 0.32757514239999996 0.17272143872 31813.93 16779.08 1.94 3.59 3.09 7.93 0 0 0 10.03 10.1 10.02569 10.10052 24.495143133302655 46.78052741963635 31.447329642008366 59.596865558912384 36.0078125 12.01953125 0.4365556162388494 0.4264917325664989 0.9525166191832859 0.9600760456273765 0.48237137633846955 0.4481132075471698 0.7193656085444711 0.563270684334641 0.2879642673226588 0.24708187130673714 proxy
63 nginx haproxy tls-term-ka-1k 2 1 0.33814478848 0.32480690176 32841.24 31546.14 1.93 1.96 2.33 3.14 0 0 0 10.02 10.03 10.020349 10.017436 23.705821509279644 24.703908557734213 30.44325007519665 31.734982835266013 32.38671875 36.23046875 0.4483398256353181 0.39679165056049476 0.9524714828897338 0.9525166191832859 0.49432404540763675 0.45339565576024193 0.766660326000989 0.6954535418365821 0.32590565364239055 0.29740529997501947 proxy
64 stunnel nginx tls-term-ka-1k 2 1 0.14101250048 0.33688649728 13694.14 32718.93 4.5 1.94 8.3 2.37 0 0 0 10.03 10.01 10.02326 10.008228 56.90275665410284 23.770617298870924 73.10762054010715 30.5605930159428 13.234375 32.4609375 0.41935483870967744 0.4192982456140351 0.9525166191832859 0.9524262607040913 0.43829787234042555 0.4618760285244103 0.4670283823043739 0.7640349644007383 0.19859143792501524 0.32229591570628036 proxy
65 direct envoy tls-term-ka-1k 2 1 1.45986945024 0.31784435712000003 141790.49 30874.68 0.41500000000000004 1.98 0.664 3.01 0 0 0 1.61 10.08 0.0 10.06195 0.8822706713865786 25.370908179928744 1.1242844034519022 32.3244761703192 0.0 17.54296875 0.8869364161849711 0.5158506516379007 0.44352617079889806 0.9572649572649573 0.9548611111111112 0.5584072919165267 3.1439647708458303 0.8959950160342254 0.951380301378939 0.3648243385606514 origin proxy
66 3proxy-current stunnel tls-term-ka-1k 2 1 0.16827547648 0.14235467776 16344.39 13824.27 3.71 4.42 7.95 8.49 0 0 0 10.01 10.1 10.019722 10.14796 47.58863363522713 56.75963815971199 61.13761154102205 72.33868830620035 11.70703125 13.578125 0.4419650579484518 0.3925763393673432 0.9524262607040913 0.9609895337773549 0.46368848542761587 0.4120603015075377 0.53861259710042 0.4653459096080538 0.20248401114127337 0.17875867582282284 proxy
67 haproxy direct tls-term-ka-1m tls-term-ka-1k 2 1 5.19036731392 1.43294201856 618.34 139176.18 25.8 0.369 30.58 0.849 0 0 0 10.11 1.64 10.101577 0.0 1.558271218745707 0.9155988051201558 1618.8951160928743 1.166678523155723 43.00390625 0.0 0.4926410466067048 0.8827331486611265 0.9601139601139601 0.4444444444444444 0.18352601156069365 0.9510886715052067 0.919041208804482 3.1294172907604505 0.019958293511711238 0.9562392105780603 client origin
68 nginx 3proxy-devel tls-term-ka-1m 2 1 6.90868977664 7.3014444032 823.11 871.73 20.01 17.94 32.92 30.29 0 0 0 10.01 10.02 10.014739 10.009905 1.1591199285104739 1.09786496442907 1213.627546071775 1147.3720371006527 42.90234375 18.25 0.31381733021077285 0.2613806903451726 0.9515209125475285 0.9524714828897338 0.11250766400980994 0.0740043900909376 0.7740125280194877 0.7760446635763213 0.03514294477338386 0.04177642800938439 proxy
69 stunnel haproxy tls-term-ka-1m 2 1 4.703492505600001 5.08290924544 560.55 605.36 28.42 26.23 41.01 32.27 0 0 0 10.02 10.1 10.028072 10.101548 1.7042654985537051 1.5896408158868394 1782.918149466192 1651.9463526333006 16.3125 43.8203125 0.21539243078486156 0.48774008990600737 0.9524714828897338 0.9591642924976258 0.06808781419026408 0.1387618176273254 0.5789818824150479 0.912195062191311 0.021848661098155486 0.03324629169014147 proxy client
70 direct nginx tls-term-ka-1m 2 1 31.52505995264 6.911458017279999 3761.15 823.51 4.19 16.6 6.81 35.58 0 0 0 7.3 10.01 0.0 10.017724 0.18524944944667554 1.1586556671513346 192.17606486600326 1214.0691328077623 0.0 43.640625 0.9059266227657573 0.30174682938502034 0.8439306358381503 0.9515209125475285 0.9573324905183312 0.09606986899563319 3.511586154017881 0.7579814584045789 0.9589447840056432 0.0370401569429093 origin proxy
71 3proxy-current envoy tls-term-ka-1m 2 1 5.743931555840001 10.39382085632 684.37 1242.31 23.33 12.78 37.04 18.35 0 0 0 10.03 10.02 10.016382 10.016006999999998 1.3969525789076989 0.7712274543509996 1462.7388070584805 805.4014950566675 15.43359375 39.97265625 0.3208477082306555 0.3582776882339397 0.9534220532319392 0.9515669515669516 0.07605905006418485 0.12507534659433395 1.0152254629514315 1.055930244987573 0.025662381385124753 0.053193587238450246 client
72 haproxy stunnel tls-term-close-1k tls-term-ka-1m 2 1 0.02961178624 4.65542578176 2883.24 554.79 13.9 28.75 16.13 41.13 0 0 0 10.1 10.02 10.084714 10.020218999999999 272.8643228244511 1.7218618394490917 346.8168395027814 1803.7803780378038 37.3125 13.1640625 0.828 0.2159376571141277 0.9600760456273765 0.9524714828897338 0.34004024144869216 0.07064868336544637 3.178466778286004 0.5765733690493384 0.057929972653973774 0.0209101453966468 client proxy
73 nginx direct tls-term-close-1k tls-term-ka-1m 2 1 0.0339738624 29.807073034240002 3309.07 3549.46 1.2 3.91 1.53 9.65 0 0 0 10.11 6.84 10.093905 0.0 238.0653663917824 0.1835805881950972 302.48631182120096 190.80562374469986 30.9921875 0.0 0.9547619047619048 0.8698197143526106 0.9601139601139601 0.8191616766467066 0.4078590785907859 0.9052369077306733 3.7809801968316314 3.311668926885409 0.05509837817054535 0.9535747825977475 client origin
74 stunnel 3proxy-devel tls-term-close-1k 2 1 0.02038431744 0.02743074816 1989.2 2670.97 17.45 5.36 25.85 9.12 0 0 0 10.1 10.11 10.005118000000001 10.107229 396.38315208654836 294.85160057697817 502.71265740879 374.74979613018013 23.3359375 14.109375 0.8371460928652321 0.9550107117353012 0.9600760456273765 0.9610266159695817 0.2772869022869023 0.3282308657465496 3.254544592720068 3.7871930248964962 0.038007282343487485 0.048481171862288494 client
75 direct haproxy tls-term-close-1k 2 1 0.12767461376 0.0285212672 12452.45 2780.7 0.554 14.76 1.39 18.6 0 0 0 5.88 10.01 0.0 10.001138000000001 36.84365953001806 280.7729384478401 46.749405694204825 359.2964824120603 0.0 37.1015625 0.9560361216730038 0.7736015918638072 0.6758620689655173 0.9515209125475285 0.9499370277078085 0.31197916666666664 3.786575286683947 2.93198166282422 0.9457882376167059 0.05603384040518167 origin client
76 3proxy-current nginx tls-term-close-1k 2 1 0.02793406464 0.03179282432 2721.22 3101.91 5.42 1.26 9.08 3.0 0 0 0 10.1 10.08 10.101989999999999 10.071446 289.2525704415353 253.6421400890501 367.4865376218891 321.7466245331801 14.08984375 32.98046875 0.9557248274220423 0.9511089911757692 0.9609895337773549 0.9590865842055185 0.3702576112412178 0.3812380038387716 3.7892973863571653 3.7716297701023414 0.04753876423631224 0.06177184221568405 client
77 haproxy envoy tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-close-1k 2 1 0.33420214272000004 0.039845888 32462.97 3888.89 1.91 11.21 3.39 15.71 0 0 0 10.02 10.05 10.022186 10.016436 23.98548356021743 201.7774079975329 30.798075888672024 255.86842507255972 36.73046875 19.078125 0.4501100513573001 0.8643533123028391 0.9533777354900095 0.9571428571428572 0.46357448953869423 0.2913797851831451 0.709869290340063 3.3446102026163405 0.2813518223778306 0.07413301508017986 proxy client
78 nginx stunnel tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-close-1k 2 1 0.35072770048 0.019881000960000002 34063.66 1935.27 1.85 17.91 2.28 26.69 0 0 0 10.01 10.1 10.014167 9.990365 22.832527881431623 406.4181685950685 29.338147798613107 516.7033304343378 33.171875 20.77734375 0.4212902012413015 0.8298548094373865 0.9515209125475285 0.9600760456273765 0.46594222104426186 0.23940967477452857 0.6460985894525442 3.2103454770571536 0.333599490097434 0.03895485929898251 proxy client
79 stunnel direct tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-close-1k 2 1 0.14361296896 0.12717129728 13952.27 12396.83 4.41 0.5670000000000001 8.45 1.5 0 0 0 10.1 5.99 10.102834000000001 0.0 56.26232824592946 37.681458807872275 71.68051780302761 47.8384832245853 14.4609375 0.0 0.41027859491261465 0.9562737642585551 0.9600760456273765 0.6814562002275313 0.4431924882629108 0.9517806492278601 0.39277794381787956 3.7895813705102115 0.17478874644588616 0.9453739873830603 proxy origin
80 direct 3proxy-devel tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-stream1-down 2 1 1.44703488 9.269733180405584 140540.9 nan 0.417 nan 0.6930000000000001 nan 0 0 0 1.6 9.53 0.0 8.612098 0.884567481884058 0.8223599190491607 1.1271479212574462 nan 0.0 10.3671875 0.8832675794847993 0.4755386565272497 0.43360433604336046 0.8433628318584071 0.9536569987389659 0.06378927324658838 3.128451216037277 1.0546488611938987 0.9547420572619894 0.09086527097403839 origin client
81 3proxy-current haproxy tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-stream1-down 2 1 0.16936599552 7.519094674708266 16447.73 nan 3.68 nan 8.2 nan 0 0 0 1 10.12 9.88 10.104624 9.61274 47.80180327900569 1.0510683525119917 60.92018372371613 nan 12.2734375 40.09375 0.4296861453095197 0.45240793201133145 0.9601518026565465 0.9114391143911439 0.46746817538896746 0.04571611253196931 0.4622866558988936 1.0427517178910461 0.21663472696348368 0.07037176596326697 proxy client
82 haproxy nginx tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream1-down 2 1 4.57690841088 9.104725019391479 544.94 nan 29.26 nan 35.93 nan 0 0 0 10.1 9.56 10.103178000000002 8.81892 1.765383808160247 0.8399591371899257 1835.0290697674418 nan 48.20703125 39.859375 0.4741463414634146 0.48488664987405544 0.9609895337773549 0.855863921217547 0.207396449704142 0.13503222026947861 0.6994235656888089 1.0526915771243328 0.14259669133018518 0.08811322576773059 proxy client
83 nginx envoy tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream1-down 2 1 5.71062878208 9.42879598589367 680.35 nan 19.63 nan 40.59 nan 0 0 0 10.02 9.41 10.019193000000001 7.081422 1.4036983151757776 0.7983786410491476 1470.2861335289801 nan 42.8359375 27.40625 0.21492760858711932 0.4868080703569581 0.9524714828897338 0.7732128184059162 0.20980511571254568 0.050588609608654155 0.454465383622178 1.0863265860845686 0.2051962373631917 0.09468485594659978 proxy client
84 stunnel tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream1-down 2 1 4.1693898342399995 4.524189666969606 496.86 nan 29.68 nan 73.53 nan 0 0 0 10.03 10.02 10.017989 10.010884 1.9245022219090775 1.7716461924246814 2014.4607350873669 nan 14.3203125 4.6015625 0.1612071189063709 0.3325115562403698 0.9525166191832859 0.9390815370196813 0.12788521522145976 0.016787360105332456 0.40020245897368467 0.8789332503100277 0.12629547315655576 0.04504085122005321 proxy
85 direct tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream1-down 2 1 31.3532612608 9.10875118930647 3740.53 nan 4.17 nan 7.43 nan 0 0 0 2 7.55 0.26 0.0 0.19264343666703732 0.02283434722893716 199.8253182648281 nan 0.0 0.9028264424199953 0.4829965500246427 0.8521444695259593 0.02905027932960894 0.950566750629723 0.3766111285759195 3.4989447089055448 1.0793943246836857 0.9585365268418932 0.7859091664243235 origin client
86 3proxy-current 3proxy-devel tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream16 2 1 5.57389447168 6.697351563038402 664.14 nan 21.7 nan 53.53 nan 0 0 0 445 10.04 10.06 9.994436 10.021135 1.4410032412363043 1.1984589641856127 1508.4134615384614 nan 15.921875 26.359375 0.18035714285714285 0.2403443462075384 0.9534662867996201 0.9428303655107779 0.1760519801980198 0.20544269835185894 0.4338860462906276 0.6180199618605883 0.18060928631957865 0.4509232551261653 proxy
87 haproxy tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 2 1 0.0255852544 5.004658686563269 2494.53 nan 25.49 nan 27.15 nan 0 0 0 617 10.04 10.02 10.024525 10.026729 313.9308241547131 1.6004047397392551 401.0866091403004 nan 37.68359375 53.2578125 0.2095970087245534 0.21793390339727295 0.9534662867996201 0.9408450704225352 0.48092485549132946 0.5203488372093024 0.14549104844711475 0.4983626788859683 0.1947076871070426 0.8901862338824181 proxy
88 nginx tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 2 1 0.03498049536 6.682945302994012 3409.86 nan 18.67 nan 19.87 nan 0 0 0 603 10.02 10.05 10.016498 10.038772000000002 229.1562745897032 1.2006610456939681 293.0595770816882 nan 33.66796875 46.66015625 0.3164628410159925 0.22403595930920275 0.9533777354900095 0.9410112359550562 0.5445473984319316 0.2548375319459657 0.20930352375326866 0.60745653551399 0.27551384990636907 0.46860140105462306 proxy
89 stunnel envoy tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 2 1 0.02080374784 9.480483179061055 2025.37 nan 30.67 nan 48.34 nan 0 0 0 726 10.04 10.06 9.959099 10.056433 386.08427970640116 0.8463177340622898 493.92433708860136 nan 19.828125 76.984375 0.14982425307557118 0.27601597369039227 0.9534662867996201 0.9428303655107779 0.4061433447098976 0.11945928953159383 0.11692732046212614 0.7571363232770778 0.15287396711535206 0.23529033093508328 proxy
90 direct stunnel tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 2 1 0.12826181632 4.269192969026591 12507.42 nan 0.558 nan 1.48 nan 0 0 0 461 5.89 10.06 0.0 10.027892999999999 36.73735594266065 1.8789587980898699 46.62060013139252 nan 0.0 21.15625 0.9543726235741445 0.16828478964401294 0.6754587155963303 0.9419475655430711 0.9480968858131488 0.18892630003741115 3.78625065105561 0.39458049083242813 0.9399542676846688 0.3935539468825128 origin proxy
91 3proxy-current direct tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 2 1 0.0205520896 19.743686764960216 2007.95 nan 31.25 nan 46.3 nan 0 0 0 758 10.02 0.55 10.025754000000001 0.0 390.03333266900506 0.02222746217714254 497.6903591119058 nan 16.20703125 0.0 0.19590215346017145 0.528691313222953 0.9542857142857143 0.06798516687268233 0.44217371110078957 0.9303058971933144 0.11512995354814924 1.5665236665604825 0.1625629104397623 16.89637765654046 proxy origin
92 3proxy-devel tls-init-ka-1k 1 0.17758683136 17250.12 3.5 8.1 0 0 0 10.12 10.107277 45.58896590472956 58.08814244222756 12.6953125 0.41420959147424513 0.9601518026565465 0.4562424242424242 0.4747393192948892 0.2108943989320829 proxy
93 haproxy tls-init-ka-1k 1 0.333447168 32387.18 1.92 3.04 0 0 0 10.02 10.020069 24.039790315448112 30.88979249581508 36.734375 0.4266792809839167 0.9506641366223909 0.429831595829992 0.6989222614929111 0.2706432240165258 proxy
94 nginx tls-init-ka-1k 1 0.34745614336 33748.56 1.86 2.59 0 0 0 10.1 10.066616 23.254733451721687 29.62989039874205 33.21484375 0.42716795767995464 0.9582542694497154 0.4670078103959063 0.6706931422430661 0.2956026697567241 proxy
95 envoy tls-init-ka-1k 1 0.31927042048000004 31007.9 1.97 3.15 0 0 0 10.08 10.0391 25.257585678862323 32.18699109110068 17.46484375 0.49156455336529925 0.9590865842055185 0.5488519785051295 0.7573484689334815 0.30988612174344554 proxy
96 stunnel tls-init-ka-1k 1 0.14436794368 14025.62 4.38 9.04 0 0 0 10.03 10.001055 55.58020565691276 71.44281725454442 14.42578125 0.36625744047619047 0.9525166191832859 0.3876331514679137 0.39864048976106936 0.21190585517352017 proxy
97 direct tls-init-ka-1k 1 1.4241339801600001 138315.47 0.41100000000000003 0.842 0 0 0 1.86 0.0 1.0448455136452994 1.331388265745098 0.0 0.8664998862861042 0.4603960396039604 0.945716975211798 3.0800727871449856 0.9478631858416178 origin
98 3proxy-devel tls-init-ka-1m 1 6.14868189184 732.73 19.62 47.55 0 0 0 10.04 9.971608 1.3062962341017148 1368.22022349414 15.73046875 0.19650872817955112 0.9534662867996201 0.17011278195488722 0.4538056345323639 0.15672117794804047 proxy
99 haproxy tls-init-ka-1m 1 4.69351006208 558.9 28.52 31.7 0 0 0 10.09 10.10157 1.7198216032848497 1787.422497785651 48.83203125 0.46153846153846156 0.9600380589914367 0.17016029593094945 0.7010050630755602 0.1339659252668233 proxy
100 nginx tls-init-ka-1m 1 5.8355351552 695.41 21.47 44.05 0 0 0 10.02 10.013459 1.3736529361590777 1439.0348987505386 43.09765625 0.19281376518218624 0.9515669515669516 0.18042526579111945 0.4557887752731992 0.1654046191203913 proxy
101 envoy tls-init-ka-1m 1 8.76173328384 1046.7 15.28 20.39 0 0 0 10.0 10.005844999999999 0.9130613476622339 953.6524890329964 42.25 0.17040981708728872 0.9523809523809523 0.26814454904342544 0.40727643382389644 0.31557469261748955 proxy
102 stunnel tls-init-ka-1m 1 4.25059155968 506.53 29.42 74.82 0 0 0 10.03 10.009055 1.8877372448845862 1977.5236593059938 16.53125 0.1719969780911609 0.9525166191832859 0.12606905289832118 0.4033243735928517 0.1425615490538313 proxy
103 direct tls-init-ka-1m 1 28.69038153728 3414.19 5.04 8.61 0 0 0 6.88 0.0 0.19184129680702072 199.5186033697764 0.0 0.865546218487395 0.8309178743961353 0.9150650960942344 3.277400414027292 0.9556988618574584 origin
104 3proxy-devel tls-init-close-1k 1 0.0205520896 2005.61 31.29 46.51 0 0 0 10.04 10.028074 390.81184231505097 499.42794607769986 20.33984375 0.16630481980026052 0.9534662867996201 0.4135635018495684 0.11894297993036855 0.16824515511381852 proxy
105 haproxy tls-init-close-1k 1 0.025417482239999997 2480.38 25.64 28.03 0 0 0 10.02 10.014808 315.37348681157175 403.02469632370685 37.859375 0.17990907122753844 0.9533777354900095 0.4598698481561822 0.14461803605679738 0.19294756256333243 proxy
106 nginx tls-init-close-1k 1 0.034812723200000006 3396.92 18.72 20.49 0 0 0 10.03 10.009061 230.49044321818522 294.92193242965095 32.4609375 0.2654133818475844 0.9525166191832859 0.5373854317414375 0.20830536739664013 0.27548694290475495 proxy
107 envoy tls-init-close-1k 1 0.06048186368 5893.82 10.5 14.56 0 0 0 9.99 9.925229 132.13878531065797 169.195853939435 19.1796875 0.25120570350178234 0.9496197718631179 0.5250436082731124 0.2834379861127693 0.23271254204393688 proxy
108 stunnel tls-init-close-1k 1 0.02038431744 1983.51 31.48 51.65 0 0 0 10.03 9.939901 393.63594212159205 504.704875962361 20.08203125 0.1386535889433794 0.9534220532319392 0.3755784061696658 0.11414184021191724 0.15294220722219815 proxy
109 direct tls-init-close-1k 1 0.12683575296 12370.37 0.5690000000000001 1.65 0 0 0 5.9 0.0 37.213481923259764 47.220777141942456 0.0 0.9520190023752969 0.6758304696449027 0.9468720528135807 3.787419660653997 0.9393004327061868 origin
110 3proxy-devel tls-init-stream1-down 1 6.778821779722053 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 10.001936 1.1800161675431136 nan 6.90625 0.12013828867761452 0.9514747859181731 0.2888028396256857 0.46055110506776037 0.6084823476155924 proxy
111 haproxy tls-init-stream1-down 1 5.846312769726175 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.003052 1.369599527587606 nan 35.765625 0.11402508551881414 0.9506172839506173 0.263884430176565 0.4413979082194608 0.5587704439401219 proxy
112 nginx tls-init-stream1-down 1 7.6017539162414725 nan nan nan 0 0 2 10.0 10.000609 1.0522722237738609 nan 33.7890625 0.12517740562021004 0.9505703422053232 0.28846792954469924 0.47366796962412583 0.6688308040119565 proxy
113 envoy tls-init-stream1-down 1 10.955224848848047 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 9.998869000000001 0.7309485864206171 nan 24.67578125 0.1174812030075188 0.9515209125475285 0.4 0.23601588200569462 0.8395756468434993 proxy
114 stunnel tls-init-stream1-down 1 4.795608625183398 nan nan nan 0 0 1 10.01 10.000457 1.6698423364559418 nan 5.7421875 0.11237830319888735 0.9506172839506173 0.17884297520661158 0.4215543965934909 0.42401484662024624 proxy
115 direct tls-init-stream1-down 1 8.845369392159736 nan nan nan 0 0 0 0.19 0.0 0.01718230262475553 nan 0.0 0.5005027652086476 0.023543990086741014 0.3837906023336487 1.1188734081266047 0.8206808597482219 client
116 3proxy-devel tls-init-stream16 1 8.348526041879582 nan nan nan 0 0 868 10.06 10.039975 0.961174535194798 nan 65.45703125 0.07860975040821087 0.9553656220322887 0.6574106213120444 0.09511296521841255 1.096991829366749 origin
117 haproxy tls-init-stream16 1 5.937518659306832 nan nan nan 0 0 189 10.03 10.025227999999998 1.3502995738285455 nan 59.19921875 0.029081133919843596 0.9534220532319392 0.8708708708708709 0.06656302739661958 1.2897569968599922 origin
118 nginx tls-init-stream16 1 7.838572817371034 nan nan nan 0 0 276 10.1 10.077734 1.024392927143987 nan 91.29296875 0.07186046511627907 0.957345971563981 0.6445066480055983 0.07988570806653485 1.0723465706063984 origin
119 envoy tls-init-stream16 1 10.981565296725723 nan nan nan 0 0 7529 10.07 10.046444999999999 0.7313052365375371 nan 121.828125 0.08134083450539147 0.9554079696394687 0.6933154182062479 0.12175028292203176 1.3100040220041085 origin
120 stunnel tls-init-stream16 1 5.157615200482038 nan nan nan 0 0 623 10.06 10.028229 1.5558830120489562 nan 56.29296875 0.027489751627682663 0.9553656220322887 0.5785369476420349 0.05801598681117103 0.941318332710401 origin
121 direct tls-init-stream16 1 19.66306247313523 nan nan nan 0 0 767 0.51 0.0 0.02070314890198838 nan 0.0 0.5320643553138454 0.06480304955527319 0.9295154185022027 1.5642678563259558 28.347345127194817 origin
122 haproxy tls-term-ka-1k 2 0.3288334336 31936.39 1.93 3.1 0 0 0 10.03 10.013764 24.40141171825175 31.351587896974245 36.015625 0.4109277177006261 0.9525166191832859 0.45345345345345345 0.7146669159365351 0.332579233598512 proxy
123 nginx tls-term-ka-1k 2 0.34410070016000005 33420.64 1.89 2.35 0 0 0 10.02 10.069127 23.29550621743204 29.92125513991621 32.46875 0.42587601078167114 0.9524714828897338 0.4678774735700732 0.7751503992672535 0.30497461469923043 proxy
124 envoy tls-term-ka-1k 2 0.3212836864 31204.57 1.96 2.98 0 0 0 10.09 10.105414 25.124213714201208 32.014569960878134 17.55078125 0.5137630971408276 0.9591254752851711 0.562905941784941 0.8884373344802152 0.3107348750724679 proxy
125 stunnel tls-term-ka-1k 2 0.1430257664 13894.73 4.42 8.6 0 0 0 10.02 10.026845000000002 56.04584545683651 72.00965878057895 13.48046875 0.406758669497523 0.9533777354900095 0.41379310344827586 0.45961210744019154 0.17874150323549828 proxy
126 direct tls-term-ka-1k 2 1.4377235251199998 139641.48 0.423 0.662 0 0 0 1.59 0.0 0.8847319931652592 1.1274316893393888 0.0 0.8828578056135468 0.43089430894308944 0.9529820132533923 3.1301228964205388 0.9510357842846556 origin
127 3proxy-devel tls-term-ka-1k 2 0.17263755264 16769.6 3.6 7.88 0 0 0 10.02 10.022396 46.432539603452994 59.63930718409618 12.06640625 0.4245810055865922 0.9524714828897338 0.4507529005183905 0.5565802004880921 0.20526765339971662 proxy
128 haproxy tls-term-ka-1m 2 4.88233762816 581.52 27.41 35.73 0 0 0 10.11 10.103785 1.6565835089631262 1721.4370849650945 42.8984375 0.5081123862287297 0.9601139601139601 0.14822673537435588 0.9134818371799617 0.024710959111089923 client
129 nginx tls-term-ka-1m 2 7.24289191936 863.15 16.18 33.62 0 0 0 10.0 10.018656 1.1045311857569318 1157.0056693277797 43.71875 0.29292929292929293 0.9514747859181731 0.08688881968234195 0.8124892632445389 0.03136062583842448 proxy
130 envoy tls-term-ka-1m 2 10.65151889408 1264.58 12.62 16.87 0 0 0 10.03 10.019421 0.7533197922091329 792.0713890863144 41.12890625 0.35921658986175115 0.9516129032258065 0.11940749697702539 1.0567530907363607 0.046561906006665855 client
131 stunnel tls-term-ka-1m 2 4.85650071552 578.79 27.55 40.0 0 0 0 10.03 10.023925 1.6522184325758602 1730.2052785923754 15.66796875 0.21747916140439505 0.9525166191832859 0.061661341853035144 0.587862486055989 0.024702653428661635 proxy
132 direct tls-term-ka-1m 2 31.86865733632 3797.73 4.18 6.6 0 0 0 7.23 0.0 0.18149493839541536 188.5119808098454 0.0 0.906857009127077 0.8387470997679815 0.9492113564668769 3.5375807901289584 0.9502110922461952 origin
133 3proxy-devel tls-term-ka-1m 2 7.204220436479999 858.41 18.21 30.58 0 0 0 10.01 10.006914 1.111570650927046 1163.953488372093 15.359375 0.270303628733646 0.9524262607040913 0.07348748812163447 0.7831167601209016 0.032324450163658494 proxy
134 haproxy tls-term-close-1k 2 0.02860515328 2791.55 15.0 16.49 0 0 0 10.1 10.081886 282.46658638425583 358.24495442131024 36.52734375 0.8370253164556962 0.9600760456273765 0.3230690274570182 3.2458036071078893 0.05511654276584143 client
135 nginx tls-term-close-1k 2 0.033470545920000004 3260.1 1.21 1.62 0 0 0 10.1 10.087979 241.40628059406325 306.7484662576687 31.7890625 0.9519505233111323 0.9591642924976258 0.3795811518324607 3.777672140618581 0.05606441963521189 client
136 envoy tls-term-close-1k 2 0.0402653184 3929.47 11.79 15.35 0 0 0 10.06 10.0202 199.8742421468099 253.45796276233906 19.01171875 0.9000230361667818 0.9571836346336822 0.3164929163325314 3.50386950987268 0.0731608214001628 client
137 stunnel tls-term-close-1k 2 0.01996488704 1947.87 17.85 26.89 0 0 0 10.11 10.004071 405.1112327255121 513.928426189508 20.63671875 0.825663114939923 0.9601139601139601 0.2408619749045281 3.199547979016617 0.038952692175190734 client
138 direct tls-term-close-1k 2 0.1266679808 12348.0 0.561 1.47 0 0 0 5.97 0.0 37.70487197977028 47.8679901858593 0.0 0.9524714828897338 0.6791808873720137 0.9464735516372796 3.792224525260157 0.941483701506363 origin
139 3proxy-devel tls-term-close-1k 2 0.027850178559999998 2713.89 5.3 8.93 0 0 0 10.11 10.104875 290.4110644237105 368.83003173908287 14.0625 0.954772673173054 0.9610266159695817 0.32941470735367684 3.786314827126038 0.048477728487604 client
140 haproxy tls-term-stream1-down 2 8.968599375780224 nan nan nan 0 0 1 9.63 8.850935000000002 0.8589691740820903 nan 38.27734375 0.471606824548001 0.8598214285714286 0.1500146498681512 1.0473339437508125 0.08830739845965337 client
141 nginx tls-term-stream1-down 2 8.636059642597564 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.82 9.239968 0.9095734353564449 nan 34.4765625 0.4688576729393056 0.8870822041553749 0.08398621121905359 1.0531026050569805 0.08534777220768175 client
142 envoy tls-term-stream1-down 2 9.64194246382679 nan nan nan 0 0 1 9.02 6.594320000000001 0.7483133289679001 nan 26.2109375 0.4697935253632424 0.7297734627831716 0.0610062893081761 1.0598768657246265 0.09573663899930611 client
143 stunnel tls-term-stream1-down 2 4.727783514453538 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.03 10.004134 1.6970001363501541 nan 4.7578125 0.3436827543805718 0.9391385767790262 0.01818772328678142 0.8941120954913153 0.05346378262222705 proxy
144 direct tls-term-stream1-down 2 9.280568456863806 nan nan nan 0 0 0 0.23 0.0 0.019825564819653148 nan 0.0 0.48358430017279685 0.025755879059350503 0.39379184418746194 1.0751779725198674 0.8094679506634208 client
145 3proxy-devel tls-term-stream1-down 2 7.483711544983906 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.86 9.567825000000001 1.0539077878075176 nan 6.95703125 0.465326917633739 0.9087557603686636 0.0685805422647528 1.0525559116722494 0.07785224580457077 client
146 haproxy tls-term-stream16 2 4.825166495188452 nan nan nan 0 0 661 10.03 10.020363 1.6614448553657888 nan 55.234375 0.21141016793190706 0.9409005628517824 0.5207373271889401 0.48198378635282196 0.8550742835264348 proxy
147 nginx tls-term-stream16 2 6.80332160424798 nan nan nan 0 0 520 10.05 10.052991 1.1779545111390417 nan 53.390625 0.21821631878557876 0.9427767354596623 0.2176560121765601 0.5990328463711426 0.46895727829320333 proxy
148 envoy tls-term-stream16 2 9.350486773219757 nan nan nan 0 0 729 10.07 10.067895 0.8586724814154829 nan 61.42578125 0.2726628895184136 0.9446529080675422 0.11827618748033973 0.7550716753873961 0.23141995069069154 proxy
149 stunnel tls-term-stream16 2 4.328418471651339 nan nan nan 0 0 479 10.07 10.025249 1.8559281797682747 nan 22.92578125 0.16020551144325082 0.943767572633552 0.18752348741074784 0.3898960057929893 0.3918973778300262 proxy
150 direct tls-term-stream16 2 19.267557448239685 nan nan nan 0 0 770 0.51 0.0 0.021120634928308554 nan 0.0 0.519927536231884 0.06319702602230483 0.9336895034569453 1.525441135865811 1.9436265325616784 origin
151 3proxy-devel tls-term-stream16 2 6.525649907980567 nan nan nan 0 0 503 10.05 10.010306 1.2290484249521128 nan 15.41796875 0.24103631737219525 0.9418931583880038 0.20954198473282443 0.5961738622476135 0.4472656045201327 proxy
152 haproxy tls-init-ka-1k 2 0.33361494016000004 32400.88 1.92 2.92 0 0 0 10.11 10.099167 24.2435185789972 30.89409528582386 36.7265625 0.42649310872894336 0.9601139601139601 0.4293770139634801 0.7089433284844637 0.27944815575151094 proxy
153 nginx tls-init-ka-1k 2 0.34997272576 33988.5 1.86 2.33 0 0 0 10.01 10.01811 22.881783094982172 29.407098832529364 33.20703125 0.4274132730015083 0.9524262607040913 0.4494658997534922 0.6716650770493547 0.2888964333763196 proxy
154 envoy tls-init-ka-1k 2 0.32220643328 31297.27 1.96 3.05 0 0 0 10.0 9.989739 24.828802822344446 31.886738305538728 17.46875 0.49851007887817705 0.9505703422053232 0.553567167740396 0.7593842531004811 0.3070797150729684 proxy
155 stunnel tls-init-ka-1k 2 0.14604566528000001 14187.81 4.33 8.64 0 0 0 10.03 10.023702 54.94171966430032 70.58806970132026 14.453125 0.3899517253709995 0.9507109004739337 0.41609251968503935 0.39661778215746857 0.16135901979361764 proxy
156 direct tls-init-ka-1k 2 1.43260647424 139139.45 0.41500000000000004 0.746 0 0 0 2.33 0.0 1.3011249310379216 1.6580231240855967 0.0 0.8789618741387231 0.5393518518518519 0.951496062992126 3.1239657884918812 0.951668403483684 origin
157 3proxy-devel tls-init-ka-1k 2 0.1769996288 17191.73 3.52 8.07 0 0 0 10.02 10.019112 45.288230570571685 58.21452225746854 12.43359375 0.4183401457259641 0.9524714828897338 0.45017182130584193 0.4776990446520995 0.2242895288315792 proxy
158 haproxy tls-init-ka-1m 2 4.614153830399999 549.43 29.0 38.12 0 0 0 10.1 10.102464 1.7511336416149668 1820.147774373761 48.37109375 0.4638196915776987 0.9591642924976258 0.1913991520290733 0.7077436581546265 0.12540260862770147 proxy
159 nginx tls-init-ka-1m 2 5.8165769011199995 692.99 21.61 44.26 0 0 0 10.02 10.020264000000001 1.3781301504767338 1443.5960236277194 44.0859375 0.1933028919330289 0.9515669515669516 0.18346333853354135 0.45558047273462804 0.17384430798558817 proxy
160 envoy tls-init-ka-1m 2 8.589934592 1020.64 15.56 21.68 0 0 0 10.0 10.000572 0.9313225746154785 978.3778495254868 39.65234375 0.17091245947197778 0.9514747859181731 0.2697070371488976 0.39958115838789576 0.26797225398575725 proxy
161 stunnel tls-init-ka-1m 2 4.19329736704 499.67 29.15 77.7 0 0 0 10.04 10.01838 1.915437732399526 2005.1927301777512 18.15625 0.15841073271413827 0.952561669829222 0.12373417721518987 0.39957156932750854 0.13873068821903145 proxy
162 direct tls-init-ka-1m 2 30.4942678016 3635.82 4.43 7.95 0 0 0 6.94 0.0 0.18206700472764567 188.97723559525107 0.0 0.8992686954470394 0.8232502965599051 0.9318323952470294 3.489327784596196 0.955611981392214 origin
163 3proxy-devel tls-init-ka-1m 2 6.143397068800001 732.14 19.61 47.43 0 0 0 10.01 9.984368 1.3035133347752526 1365.0620482749216 15.52734375 0.19990079365079366 0.9515209125475285 0.1783359497645212 0.4556760218601475 0.18814525834964735 proxy
164 haproxy tls-init-close-1k 2 0.025165824 2452.58 25.91 28.92 0 0 0 10.03 10.019024 318.84511311848956 407.9889358932639 38.03125 0.1740073768713387 0.9525166191832859 0.45713595749818886 0.14362115394287908 0.19379040243355145 proxy
165 nginx tls-init-close-1k 2 0.03456106496 3371.32 18.79 21.65 0 0 0 10.03 10.009682 232.16877168822052 297.0531615578262 33.36328125 0.26589945487583283 0.9525166191832859 0.5369208494208494 0.20739408911666185 0.2736890449391615 proxy
166 envoy tls-init-close-1k 2 0.05813305344 5667.53 10.87 16.19 0 0 0 9.98 9.900231 137.34011078981786 175.61147281365476 19.25 0.24025423728813558 0.9477682811016145 0.5211864406779662 0.2786747697771259 0.23460509573367108 proxy
167 stunnel tls-init-close-1k 2 0.019797114879999998 1931.59 32.12 52.34 0 0 0 10.04 9.932929 405.7156837592691 518.3808343659645 18.0234375 0.13486915678819056 0.9543726235741445 0.375224877923413 0.11322497308445967 0.1511396879125909 proxy
168 direct tls-init-close-1k 2 0.12490637312000001 12179.95 0.58 2.0 0 0 0 6.01 0.0 38.492831709882886 48.84630076642365 0.0 0.9545670789724072 0.685290763968073 0.945528967254408 3.7883910301492008 0.9416777150247672 origin
169 3proxy-devel tls-init-close-1k 2 0.0201326592 1959.36 31.94 47.36 0 0 0 10.04 10.031596 398.95375569661456 510.88947689802563 16.5703125 0.16138894955230398 0.9543726235741445 0.41196834817012856 0.11703460326425069 0.16918514107144272 proxy
170 haproxy tls-init-stream1-down 2 6.2095089349680475 nan nan nan 0 0 2 9.98 9.924361 1.285628660563529 nan 39.59375 0.11718086611944523 0.9477682811016145 0.2666232073011734 0.45369101490501135 0.5595078051772462 proxy
171 nginx tls-init-stream1-down 2 6.95793759706339 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.99 10.000771 1.1484788645528825 nan 39.546875 0.12242562929061784 0.950523311132255 0.2855747313578639 0.46794344780213487 0.6289645114261664 proxy
172 envoy tls-init-stream1-down 2 10.602435969850474 nan nan nan 0 0 5 9.97 9.95305 0.7522182679815519 nan 23.296875 0.10244147998993204 0.9930278884462151 0.39627842866988283 0.224566693722654 0.8365168777145631 proxy
173 stunnel tls-init-stream1-down 2 4.296702701740668 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.99 10.004566 1.8597835968763725 nan 3.80859375 0.09842075578116187 0.950523311132255 0.20205589463539994 0.3937244983993934 0.40275029697538167 proxy
174 direct tls-init-stream1-down 2 9.246768142707195 nan nan nan 0 0 0 0.33 0.0 0.028548914210530792 nan 0.0 0.4900437105390966 0.03650442477876106 0.3407821229050279 1.0804634142923428 0.8393525065936837 client
175 3proxy-devel tls-init-stream1-down 2 7.22981240533617 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.00555 1.1075052461361792 nan 5.58984375 0.12827822120866592 0.9506172839506173 0.33886626996554964 0.479473441600731 0.6650384319639997 proxy
176 haproxy tls-init-stream16 2 5.96259483329159 nan nan nan 0 0 3 10.02 10.024015 1.3436187641156672 nan 47.4140625 0.041939393939393936 0.9515669515669516 0.8697534976682212 0.07989339792745656 1.2757819328115165 origin
177 nginx tls-init-stream16 2 7.686542335357298 nan nan nan 0 0 629 10.05 10.054053 1.0418987802894677 nan 70.05078125 0.05486641221374046 0.9553231939163498 0.6394819740987049 0.08276288491161637 1.0491590720549449 origin
178 envoy tls-init-stream16 2 11.062095301183447 nan nan nan 0 0 8642 10.05 10.037702 0.7250835961215212 nan 117.53125 0.0774812734082397 0.9544159544159544 0.7045148247978437 0.12270659389069657 1.3424051373589132 origin
179 stunnel tls-init-stream16 2 5.239605769183789 nan nan nan 0 0 631 10.05 10.033299999999999 1.530080919521522 nan 46.265625 0.02703355056722182 0.9544159544159544 0.5678373382624768 0.058032006675349565 0.9224683534584275 origin
180 direct tls-init-stream16 2 19.643355063016077 nan nan nan 0 0 802 0.52 0.0 0.021148139109517843 nan 0.0 0.5287981859410431 0.06508135168961202 0.9277374566109182 1.5566616672365599 1.938116030685343 origin
181 3proxy-devel tls-init-stream16 2 8.42007141579248 nan nan nan 0 0 900 10.06 10.041384 0.9526444944502712 nan 61.51953125 0.07548054383497421 0.9562737642585551 0.6500172235618326 0.09035494427132373 1.090465747761052 origin

270
bench/data/skylake-tls.csv
View File

@ -1,91 +1,181 @@
proxy,scenario,rep,gbit,rate,p50_ms,p99_ms,errors,timeouts,retrans,prx_cpu_s,prx_task_s,cpu_s_per_gb,cpu_us_per_req,peak_mb,cli_util,prx_util,srv_util,cli_thread,srv_thread,bound
direct,tls-term-ka-1k,0,1.1194597376,109493.64,0.5640000000000001,0.88,0,0,0,7.37,0.0,5.266826310913498,6.664604889306068,0.0,0.6467110125646711,0.7155339805825243,0.9559848005066498,1.9942851466688527,0.8402770418544304,origin
3proxy-current,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.25014829056,24470.78,2.49,4.56,0,0,0,10.1,7.472335,32.30084036117748,40.867689842558235,14.01953125,0.237912876974629,0.9600760456273765,0.3274647887323944,0.6650230362408502,0.3032660986708979,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.34493956096,33737.22,1.75,3.11,0,0,0,10.02,7.024958,23.238853721767086,29.674205652314264,39.1171875,0.27087242026266417,0.9524714828897338,0.3939868462261196,0.7478065772405075,0.32990281828206053,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.36683382783999996,35883.47,1.66,2.63,0,0,0,10.11,6.714439,22.04813020550466,27.89681214766823,34.90625,0.27857988165680475,0.9601139601139601,0.410288582183187,0.7848410024270118,0.34317401568043043,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.20308819968,19862.73,2.99,6.95,0,0,0,10.04,7.650684,39.54931902816501,50.49742986188651,18.52734375,0.20702844848195076,0.9543726235741445,0.28337612323491657,0.5784034584947134,0.23670157509482284,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1m,0,22.67742732288,2705.24,5.81,10.12,0,0,0,8.19,0.0,0.2889216623523018,299.75843642485904,0.0,0.7610872675250357,0.8297872340425532,0.9534957291996203,2.5895535072121367,0.8562784735233212,origin
3proxy-current,tls-term-ka-1m,0,4.92251906048,586.56,26.44,59.84,0,0,0,10.02,7.145911,1.6284345274263603,1706.984667802385,19.08984375,0.2776717557251908,0.9524714828897338,0.05218216318785579,0.8296491258355196,0.042785272849970885,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1m,0,5.8997080064,702.39,22.17,32.44,0,0,0,10.1,7.309323,1.3695593055172934,1423.7383704539047,46.52734375,0.29105771612583603,0.9600760456273765,0.07271577616187164,0.8048629147918888,0.03422650828012293,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1m,0,6.29657305088,750.4,20.67,31.44,0,0,0,10.03,7.495661,1.2743439860319856,1334.664005322688,47.80859375,0.25861244019138757,0.9525166191832859,0.06675062972292191,0.7496642279925745,0.046582996396474605,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1m,0,5.1266977792,610.99,25.42,59.16,0,0,0,10.03,7.741818,1.5651400463969054,1639.9607586657946,20.0234375,0.2268440145102781,0.9534220532319392,0.05780164245104232,0.6507519932640717,0.04087871882467707,proxy
direct,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.04286578688,4207.33,1.55,5.34,0,0,0,3.6,0.0,67.18644890533268,84.96577767288176,0.0,0.9538973384030418,0.3474903474903475,0.9068736141906873,3.583540794177188,0.8232646501143567,origin
3proxy-current,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.01098907648,1080.27,22.53,48.39,0,0,0,10.12,8.900212,736.7316093153624,927.5043534048208,42.8046875,0.9548371761350131,0.9619771863117871,0.06321473951715374,3.6999085064935566,0.028521737238229684,client
haproxy,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.01400897536,1372.98,27.29,41.4,0,0,0,10.1,8.908869,576.7730895630614,728.2428437522532,38.1015625,0.7685163134079542,0.9619047619047619,0.07070386810399493,2.932285448471752,0.02947374185889227,client
nginx,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.01400897536,1377.42,3.1,4.85,0,0,0,10.11,8.769033,577.3441520279753,726.710753306498,33.359375,0.9557774607703281,0.9610266159695817,0.08386277001270648,3.705869538524049,0.037064883202621905,client
stunnel,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.01098907648,1076.02,21.55,52.77,0,0,0,10.11,8.96967,736.0036136539836,930.253956569746,34.19921875,0.9465304182509505,0.9628571428571429,0.06482364156339371,3.687378250238888,0.029471449078566612,client
direct,tls-init-ka-1k,0,1.08263374848,105887.95,0.5650000000000001,0.94,0,0,0,7.27,0.0,5.37208451904032,6.797670652389376,0.0,0.6480750246791708,0.7044573643410853,0.9579113924050633,1.9966754355184562,0.8476755626979373,origin
3proxy-current,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.23815258112,23295.97,2.55,9.15,0,0,0,10.1,7.479255,33.92782879782714,42.9272107513537,15.453125,0.17768199233716475,0.9600760456273765,0.36823453608247425,0.4386048730614794,0.33643266951347556,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.34301018112,33545.49,1.81,14.6,0,0,0,10.09,7.09971,23.53282918204711,29.781142545121824,42.10546875,0.224934194783441,0.960952380952381,0.43178973717146435,0.5679634627033696,0.3802972087446423,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.34091302912,33343.45,1.78,3.2,0,0,0,10.09,6.803458,23.677593141090213,29.96101208239427,38.4453125,0.22347575612097936,0.9591254752851711,0.45906801007556675,0.559362248529181,0.42001702694852067,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.20644364288,20193.48,2.92,12.26,0,0,0,10.14,7.714791,39.29401693766508,49.7175806072017,16.58984375,0.16155321188878236,0.9629629629629629,0.3395081443628234,0.39387222180360004,0.27941077827725713,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1m,0,20.95944040448,2493.51,6.78,13.24,0,0,0,8.04,0.0,0.30687842212739536,319.23764145324594,0.0,0.7303290414878397,0.8080402010050252,0.9269680682895984,2.466781691288365,0.8196875576746906,origin
3proxy-current,tls-init-ka-1m,0,5.164865945600001,615.45,25.05,57.51,0,0,0,10.03,7.472096,1.5535737199211772,1628.5111219353792,18.375,0.17719341361513885,0.9507109004739337,0.26473369051370943,0.4613840727624356,0.23945357085597052,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1m,0,5.1099205632,608.02,25.44,37.1,0,0,0,10.1,7.5443940000000005,1.5812378881561397,1644.6832763393584,54.546875,0.19995050730017322,0.9600760456273765,0.2572692793931732,0.5051365812803598,0.2785377466673379,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1m,0,5.44319995904,648.56,24.08,34.66,0,0,0,10.03,7.373113999999999,1.4741328741145798,1545.4545454545455,43.8984375,0.1904527559055118,0.9516129032258065,0.2863422291993721,0.4860833250705032,0.2946700749773043,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1m,0,4.20957126656,501.63,30.5,71.58,0,0,0,10.03,7.781262,1.9061323569317057,1997.6100378410674,20.43359375,0.1535635562086701,0.9534220532319392,0.2157545080670674,0.3881396735403182,0.22816363189430924,proxy
direct,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.034393292799999996,3378.49,1.52,4.64,0,0,0,2.63,0.0,61.17471834508383,77.50338893145518,0.0,0.9528907922912205,0.25191570881226055,0.8751979727589484,3.599362891586791,0.86689710796206,client
3proxy-current,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.0088080384,864.36,70.96,121.97,0,0,0,10.04,9.072577,911.894298735119,1159.2194896663202,76.5703125,0.03870814533364996,0.9561904761904761,0.2731012658227848,0.0646956757172168,0.23294151831009602,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.00973078528,951.83,62.48,96.56,0,0,0,10.03,8.9932,824.5994304788524,1051.8036912751677,42.62890625,0.04185493460166469,0.9534220532319392,0.28748019017432647,0.068502521929934,0.24624148261424658,proxy
nginx,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.01283457024,1261.4,48.86,71.27,0,0,0,10.05,8.818029000000001,626.4331294041053,795.598480050665,31.62109375,0.05712254088646599,0.9553231939163498,0.35991175543649545,0.09704781724589216,0.30791304706611916,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.00973078528,952.99,60.54,330.32,0,0,0,10.07,8.896381,827.8879626043912,1055.2237241957455,28.5625,0.04579971523493118,0.956315289648623,0.24723713293337543,0.075160811692268,0.20726306873233175,proxy
3proxy-current,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.24184356863999998,23655.24,2.57,4.9,0,0,0,10.1,7.463227,33.410026346524894,42.27444907184564,14.09765625,0.23694298035457595,0.9600760456273765,0.3238308776425368,0.662156994575174,0.25667947228469246,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.34921775104,34157.4,1.75,2.93,0,0,0,10.03,7.021541999999999,22.977067964339867,29.305463438293447,38.75,0.2665879574970484,0.9534220532319392,0.39593114241001565,0.753481525112189,0.34700718616226184,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.36096180224,35302.14,1.69,2.78,0,0,0,10.02,6.681599,22.207335929329826,28.329573020746746,35.01171875,0.2880833925610045,0.9524714828897338,0.410288582183187,0.8077387679797692,0.3744450896339174,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.21692940287999998,21218.28,2.84,6.57,0,0,0,10.12,7.70104,37.320897455650616,47.22506101459217,16.0234375,0.21948889419632195,0.9619771863117871,0.30248883216336947,0.6070026201252147,0.2719186248164488,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1k,1,1.0890090905599998,106518.51,0.56,0.95,0,0,0,7.25,0.0,5.325942685214383,6.739208435815779,0.0,0.6322836598065956,0.7018393030009681,0.9572243346007605,1.9457815100926927,0.8492458801910123,origin
3proxy-current,tls-term-ka-1m,1,4.83049603072,575.61,26.94,62.46,0,0,0,10.02,7.147285999999999,1.6594569065001779,1739.281374761326,18.0703125,0.2709477202196228,0.9515669515669516,0.050933248971844355,0.8020386626920842,0.04088170992854504,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1m,1,5.71834630144,680.79,22.24,32.3,0,0,0,10.09,7.391886,1.4115969153472396,1467.4229203025016,48.6875,0.2883617494440326,0.960952380952381,0.06622516556291391,0.7943766224387107,0.03612636365880328,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1m,1,6.0456697856,720.52,21.42,32.06,0,0,0,10.02,7.475741,1.3259076800875018,1388.9658996395897,48.23046875,0.2518002880460874,0.9524714828897338,0.06236220472440945,0.7268675747928643,0.04373694304635185,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1m,1,5.47306340352,652.13,24.04,55.44,0,0,0,10.04,7.784278,1.467551060131008,1538.9331698344574,20.05859375,0.2372718539865514,0.9534662867996201,0.062460567823343846,0.6736025246218889,0.04088345494128453,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1m,1,22.849226014720003,2725.64,5.89,11.59,0,0,0,8.21,0.0,0.2874495615636496,298.2526246957533,0.0,0.7637963843958135,0.8360488798370672,0.9464851171627613,2.5974012039744174,0.8588979777160687,origin
3proxy-current,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.012582912,1237.99,19.37,44.4,0,0,0,10.12,8.865654999999999,643.4122721354166,809.3410108765195,53.9765625,0.9531621493105088,0.9610636277302944,0.06743002544529263,3.699060414906116,0.030413040186725,client
haproxy,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.01417674752,1393.81,26.76,43.86,0,0,0,10.01,8.84597,564.8686335637019,717.4598623853211,38.14453125,0.7505949547834364,0.9524262607040913,0.06622306717363752,2.87981288526459,0.0304195615733104,client
nginx,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.0150994944,1485.46,3.01,4.23,0,0,0,10.13,8.809959,536.7067125108508,675.1532924553452,34.2578125,0.9536376604850214,0.961100569259962,0.08436409768474469,3.703024618254623,0.037079432561640494,client
stunnel,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.011240734720000001,1105.87,22.33,58.85,0,0,0,10.12,8.990985,720.2376180620334,906.0793267078521,33.6484375,0.9365343475160447,0.9628924833491912,0.06263910969793322,3.640140800258993,0.026619042119849314,client
direct,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.044459622399999996,4368.77,1.37,4.12,0,0,0,3.06,0.0,55.06119638119104,69.8582288884323,0.0,0.9522678698646402,0.29423076923076924,0.9164027865737808,3.5838588862622704,0.8535331102029736,origin
3proxy-current,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.25467813888,24909.29,2.45,9.6,0,0,0,10.1,7.445309,31.726319485188153,40.14627553859607,15.453125,0.17972681524083392,0.9600760456273765,0.3825588796944621,0.44718341123734623,0.3118851039676552,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.33160167424000003,32433.37,1.82,3.17,0,0,0,10.01,7.015357,24.14945587459287,30.834724643752658,42.5625,0.22458741927768477,0.9515209125475285,0.43470149253731344,0.5679230139372056,0.3916792412681567,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.37044092928,36231.05,1.68,2.58,0,0,0,10.1,6.750587,21.81184464606686,27.602265025470604,37.9921875,0.23570566948130278,0.9600760456273765,0.48954372623574144,0.6050895101616365,0.42590048431961447,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.20057161728,19614.83,3.06,7.43,0,0,0,10.14,7.742308,40.44440639213457,51.18446092263272,16.53125,0.15878378378378377,0.9629629629629629,0.34713879228580463,0.3967153990647493,0.29566125559174905,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1k,1,1.09689438208,107289.65,0.5740000000000001,0.97,0,0,0,7.52,0.0,5.484575450730345,6.9395227970706355,0.0,0.6395262768319763,0.735812133072407,0.9582410629547612,1.9627920411500144,0.844395054470617,origin
3proxy-current,tls-init-ka-1m,1,5.15547070464,614.33,25.29,56.81,0,0,0,10.0,7.447799,1.551749676862654,1627.0745200130166,19.98828125,0.19309100283578243,0.999000999000999,0.2816015883520847,0.46749050126567226,0.33340386717275095,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1m,1,5.1187286016,609.75,25.05,39.17,0,0,0,10.11,7.567824,1.580079865432184,1641.7668074050016,52.67578125,0.19812252964426877,0.9601139601139601,0.25962145110410095,0.4947301677400869,0.3536716902270825,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1m,1,5.42801657856,646.82,23.59,36.77,0,0,0,10.01,7.3381739999999995,1.4753086848759116,1546.1847389558234,45.08984375,0.1848387890721142,0.9515209125475285,0.27835375431982406,0.4794874384374446,0.24717662919930292,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1m,1,4.56038285312,543.48,28.92,61.02,0,0,0,10.02,7.748921999999999,1.7577471581176194,1841.9117647058824,19.328125,0.16544117647058823,0.9533777354900095,0.23479357075323037,0.4214135455095488,0.2452523290157053,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1m,1,24.30951489536,2893.37,5.24,10.82,0,0,0,8.25,0.0,0.27149863040910593,282.31187763063343,0.0,0.7631141704248754,0.840122199592668,0.9569347688410387,2.590333892278712,0.8539590235113941,origin
3proxy-current,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.008724152320000001,853.33,72.04,123.14,0,0,0,10.08,9.078254000000001,924.3304912860576,1177.2950245269797,106.28515625,0.03732762719923918,0.9572649572649573,0.2735312697409981,0.0646964799238412,0.2338931695429387,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.010317987839999999,1014.39,61.2,89.13,0,0,0,10.03,9.006401,777.6710076060721,987.2047244094488,40.25390625,0.04085510688836105,0.9552380952380952,0.2985781990521327,0.06945446102926073,0.2519581519683936,proxy
nginx,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.0130023424,1280.33,48.97,65.27,0,0,0,10.07,8.833155999999999,619.5806687878024,785.1239669421487,33.2734375,0.05444602948169282,0.956315289648623,0.3599621092516577,0.096097654203865,0.3118427993095415,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.0100663296,987.32,60.97,179.83,0,0,0,10.07,8.884551,800.2916971842449,1017.7885587224581,26.97265625,0.04238095238095238,0.956315289648623,0.25370779425686335,0.07610681090710829,0.21579858590296877,proxy
direct,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.0390070272,3833.45,1.35,4.49,0,0,0,2.97,0.0,60.912101499495975,77.23312963203745,0.0,0.9522451888809693,0.28557692307692306,0.8707526198793267,3.599204587241182,0.7957784211213861,client
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.3388997632,33146.84,1.8,3.07,0,0,0,10.03,7.025264,23.676617310778926,30.20756785408811,38.6328125,0.2640661938534279,0.9525166191832859,0.3856516290726817,0.7468796501643881,0.362099393159481,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.36373004288,35576.38,1.64,2.72,0,0,0,10.02,6.674969,22.03832253318871,28.118738529406812,35.046875,0.279613025011798,0.9524714828897338,0.4095894703854591,0.7849563178023642,0.3289797478182464,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.20627587072,20172.31,2.93,6.77,0,0,0,10.03,7.639314000000001,38.89936312954326,49.69011795829597,16.109375,0.20660761311946374,0.9534220532319392,0.2871696911811525,0.5822243005878621,0.23768837393448636,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1k,2,1.09613940736,107215.88,0.519,1.18,0,0,0,7.24,0.0,5.28399942663293,6.68562774720201,0.0,0.6309435821630943,0.7029126213592233,0.9585311807534029,1.928793342330788,0.8492639797650146,origin
3proxy-current,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.24905777152,24356.11,2.49,5.12,0,0,0,10.11,7.467399,32.47439319254694,41.09856337959462,14.01171875,0.23248026787849796,0.9601139601139601,0.3248326426522155,0.648899048000669,0.27860010218781583,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1m,2,6.06773182464,722.77,21.77,29.9,0,0,0,10.1,7.316416,1.3316343295180795,1383.5616438356165,48.5078125,0.2947290274684484,0.9600760456273765,0.07561436672967864,0.8123886312990025,0.03707507168062021,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1m,2,5.82177783808,693.84,21.17,35.66,0,0,0,10.0,7.48522,1.3741506842930937,1440.2995823131212,47.0625,0.24687199230028875,0.9514747859181731,0.055888853804862644,0.7107182919596713,0.04086582169203762,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1m,2,4.642339553279999,553.13,27.4,70.17,0,0,0,10.03,7.776821,1.728438841646282,1812.1047877145438,19.6953125,0.20920096852300243,0.9534220532319392,0.04724159797083069,0.5917782925101898,0.03612834129274017,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1m,2,22.59152797696,2687.25,4.87,15.31,0,0,0,7.98,0.0,0.2825838078110844,293.9767913059495,0.0,0.7588838540424517,0.806060606060606,0.9553656220322887,2.5740331857966865,0.8729504556873563,origin
3proxy-current,tls-term-ka-1m,2,4.91790532608,585.98,26.45,61.09,0,0,0,10.02,7.152266,1.6299622437810228,1708.4398976982097,18.70703125,0.279446828803052,0.9524714828897338,0.05083675402589201,0.8285317016944691,0.03232033074241261,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.01409286144,1387.75,27.01,39.65,0,0,0,10.11,8.923624,573.9075796944753,721.318493150685,38.125,0.7507149666348903,0.961941008563273,0.06586064269805918,2.86757815205729,0.03042395324596571,client
nginx,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.01459617792,1432.73,3.04,4.44,0,0,0,10.12,8.793505999999999,554.6657518408765,699.3296938704996,32.4140625,0.9582047019710282,0.9619771863117871,0.08290978398983481,3.7058639902721384,0.0370772087119028,client
stunnel,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.01023410176,1006.86,23.44,57.25,0,0,0,10.13,8.976559,791.8623627209273,996.0668633235005,44.88671875,0.9324774132192106,0.9629277566539924,0.056615776081424936,3.6263739757288787,0.02660811878950716,client
direct,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.03539992576,3472.31,1.36,4.65,0,0,0,2.8,0.0,63.2769688610782,80.45052292839904,0.0,0.9515324305060584,0.2697495183044316,0.859493670886076,3.5989094224272002,0.8078214488024834,client
3proxy-current,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.01291845632,1265.46,19.2,43.25,0,0,0,10.13,8.866699,627.3195341035918,792.5827400046944,26.51171875,0.9517585551330798,0.961100569259962,0.06925031766200762,3.6878071840084887,0.03137736114803411,client
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.33839644672,33094.55,1.81,3.17,0,0,0,10.1,7.065385,23.877319275416767,30.216632311452702,37.65234375,0.22140133460438513,0.9600760456273765,0.425512104283054,0.548914173442944,0.4049978454420713,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.375390208,36713.93,1.65,2.71,0,0,0,10.1,6.743352,21.524269487604748,27.237889252360393,36.015625,0.24158653846153846,0.9600760456273765,0.5014344915524387,0.6107614796798443,0.44380242302070183,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.21877489664,21400.55,2.82,7.15,0,0,0,10.12,7.670164000000001,37.00607393416891,46.821721207186116,16.2265625,0.16017316017316016,0.9619771863117871,0.3560126582278481,0.4034064305763258,0.285231512111838,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1k,2,1.0775166976,105386.82,0.597,1.04,0,0,0,7.4,0.0,5.494114395800896,6.952240923332754,0.0,0.629866929521932,0.7212475633528265,0.9585049097244219,1.9318361435249158,0.8442186732191183,origin
3proxy-current,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.24486346752000002,23952.57,2.52,6.79,0,0,0,10.1,7.466133,32.99798080062735,41.74899347723647,15.53125,0.1762866762866763,0.9600760456273765,0.3820366856419987,0.4433571685833449,0.3318177913299525,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1m,2,5.15161194496,613.07,25.1,36.43,0,0,0,10.11,7.561844000000001,1.5699940302981807,1632.7519379844962,48.96875,0.20385947550717468,0.9610266159695817,0.25702557625513106,0.509897082368172,0.2785221479454837,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1m,2,5.39672707072,643.07,24.31,33.38,0,0,0,10.02,7.355081,1.4853447089238385,1557.109557109557,45.12109375,0.1896212493851451,0.9524714828897338,0.2780395852968897,0.4823316183459257,0.29186636453340337,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1m,2,4.606184652800001,548.86,28.55,58.96,0,0,0,10.04,7.74968,1.743742512605855,1828.1136198106337,19.22265625,0.16042385411532775,0.9534662867996201,0.23423707440100883,0.39953144165606513,0.34316182816272983,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1m,2,20.95944040448,2500.99,6.86,13.27,0,0,0,7.96,0.0,0.30382490548931185,315.09777531470195,0.0,0.7287043664996421,0.8008048289738431,0.9344729344729344,2.4373570409781307,0.8358760954322354,origin
3proxy-current,tls-init-ka-1m,2,5.04801263616,601.58,25.75,57.86,0,0,0,10.01,7.463358,1.586366868941051,1662.7906976744187,17.8671875,0.1805213969503197,0.9515209125475285,0.26418663303909207,0.46422173811209644,0.3127123492444544,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.01015021568,992.76,62.58,83.25,0,0,0,10.05,9.013471,792.1013950316375,1010.4564649105168,40.19921875,0.04467680608365019,0.9553231939163498,0.31021437578814626,0.07706499279148822,0.2605029856855648,proxy
nginx,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.01291845632,1265.49,49.44,70.91,0,0,0,10.08,8.822935999999999,624.2231889204546,795.5173230210718,31.58203125,0.05611031859248693,0.9581749049429658,0.3640654499685337,0.09894778197969596,0.30901439407837994,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.00939524096,919.55,64.89,159.59,0,0,0,10.07,8.890711000000001,857.4553898402622,1093.1393834129397,35.2890625,0.04349893035417162,0.9572243346007605,0.24677368586717027,0.07515966943447495,0.2014633377112483,proxy
direct,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.039258685439999996,3851.0,1.39,4.23,0,0,0,2.94,0.0,59.91030962039263,76.22109302084414,0.0,0.9519961977186312,0.2829643888354187,0.879277566539924,3.5797071030662435,0.8374755337159332,client
3proxy-current,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.009227468800000001,902.41,67.44,116.26,0,0,0,10.1,9.073845,875.6464177911932,1116.8859891628883,74.41015625,0.03851640513552068,0.957345971563981,0.29058749210360074,0.06752228756023755,0.2508956313242431,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.9432989696,92260.06,0.665,1.12,0,0,0,7.33,0.0,6.216480870838429,7.866174163320234,0.0,0.6291913214990138,0.7095837366892546,0.9559708584098828,1.927090841878114,0.8392698396127815,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.20401094656,19954.33,3.07,7.89,0,0,0,10.11,7.432369,39.64493149205258,50.166228353098795,14.7421875,0.25184304399524376,0.9601139601139601,0.3185161496642149,0.6991874125041462,0.2555947816036184,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.33277607936000003,32550.27,1.8,3.11,0,0,0,10.02,7.036519,24.088269852257685,30.740251014704395,37.1484375,0.27379830348727613,0.9524714828897338,0.40442781415653256,0.775291905522719,0.36011944890466585,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.3414163456,33389.97,1.78,2.74,0,0,0,10.03,6.733183,23.50209679006066,29.992045977836387,34.94921875,0.2888154789995281,0.9525166191832859,0.4136634283923535,0.812413432243309,0.3650203770458889,proxy
envoy,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.27338473472,26737.41,2.32,4.09,0,0,0,10.1,7.345412,29.555417599580007,37.40006591298745,22.74609375,0.27153736316039984,0.9591642924976258,0.36795440151994935,0.7629207873309807,0.3032087888519814,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1k,0,0.16642998272,16282.1,3.78,12.43,0,0,0,10.12,7.75016,48.645081058625244,61.53883574846913,16.23046875,0.21561161351737268,0.9619771863117871,0.28066263141127745,0.5812563023193552,0.2443092578206486,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1m,0,19.49915152384,2322.98,6.73,11.05,0,0,0,7.97,0.0,0.32698858677028037,339.68375740527637,0.0,0.7356239560963971,0.813265306122449,0.9575546404814698,2.476173005554468,0.8529648878713005,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-ka-1m,0,5.42440947712,646.39,23.53,55.27,0,0,0,10.02,7.486255999999999,1.477764544474611,1548.2076637824475,20.20703125,0.25281033245635015,0.9515669515669516,0.06204724409448819,0.7220149760631065,0.06271281714312446,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1m,0,4.7294133043199995,563.48,28.85,37.06,0,0,0,10.09,7.410545,1.7067656135332416,1772.974872605869,47.94140625,0.26380368098159507,0.9600380589914367,0.0591584941474217,0.7220079347290078,0.033269254791884945,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1m,0,5.81674467328,693.24,22.12,32.09,0,0,0,10.01,7.468177000000001,1.3767150613960808,1442.3631123919308,48.2578125,0.25968436154949787,0.9524262607040913,0.06509433962264151,0.752396395476189,0.04847659691732909,proxy
envoy,tls-term-ka-1m,0,5.8040778752,691.44,22.41,35.79,0,0,0,10.01,7.548457,1.3797195992522853,1446.5317919075144,46.5625,0.25225439012814427,0.9515209125475285,0.06649858178380082,0.7429351786134916,0.046581616452105526,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1m,0,4.1498443776,494.44,30.92,84.04,0,0,0,10.04,7.829454,1.9354942665693853,2028.6926651848858,19.4921875,0.2041062801932367,0.9534662867996201,0.04946100190234623,0.5774295187816934,0.03517211745717436,proxy
direct,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.03145728,3087.8,1.78,4.9,0,0,0,2.54,0.0,64.59554036458334,82.02279846287983,0.0,0.9527091254752852,0.24423076923076922,0.9006664550936211,3.584391528635113,0.8564716246802538,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.01241513984,1219.79,19.92,41.48,0,0,0,10.12,8.815469,652.107032569679,821.4285714285714,23.6484375,0.9548264384213029,0.9610636277302944,0.07516650808753568,3.6910616152080116,0.03232031755726188,client
haproxy,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.01224736768,1199.44,30.57,50.81,0,0,0,10.12,8.913373,661.0400056185787,835.3281056541477,42.41015625,0.7505355867650559,0.9610636277302944,0.06351222610352493,2.871992444901631,0.028517067016256066,client
nginx,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.01040187392,1024.81,4.03,5.29,0,0,0,10.12,8.833620999999999,778.3212969380039,977.6833156216791,34.234375,0.9581450653983353,0.9619771863117871,0.07577679137603044,3.7032775538284626,0.032316796774519076,client
envoy,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.01904214016,1872.39,24.79,37.26,0,0,0,9.99,8.37075,419.7007233875964,532.8284175156008,26.3359375,0.8705155618911855,0.950523311132255,0.09490667510281557,3.330418014767844,0.041824944417735765,client
stunnel,tls-term-close-1k,0,0.009227468800000001,903.02,22.46,51.81,0,0,0,10.13,8.976982,878.2473477450285,1110.6238351057998,34.3359375,0.9512601046124584,0.9629277566539924,0.06778587266392144,3.6925623055568226,0.028513045064273084,client
direct,tls-term-stream1-down,0,6.783526652335611,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,1.12,0.0,0.13208213860636228,nan,0.0,0.4068665129387651,0.10980392156862745,0.36882003955174686,0.7877991910485717,0.7715536520324874,none
3proxy-devel,tls-term-stream1-down,0,5.262776090987485,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.85,7.536672,1.4971816578238932,nan,8.015625,0.38275265628860883,0.9257518796992481,0.07125,0.7503795100068791,0.10799432329246171,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-stream1-down,0,6.112343512559425,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.79,7.79017,1.2812064300822925,nan,40.96875,0.38974736325729703,0.9183864915572233,0.07653858169322086,0.7750593590707735,0.12019293163689658,proxy
nginx,tls-term-stream1-down,0,5.931179961755962,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.79,7.651082,1.3203424511390753,nan,35.58203125,0.38706516413522785,0.9175257731958762,0.07176433719837041,0.7551686024054629,0.11461406856791828,proxy
envoy,tls-term-stream1-down,0,6.601938240534079,nan,nan,nan,0,0,51,9.35,7.677902,1.132928434323632,nan,33.484375,0.38018545632015616,0.8746492048643593,0.07149547299406805,0.7532599921061515,0.1305880549952942,none
stunnel,tls-term-stream1-down,0,5.112206699803147,nan,nan,nan,0,0,4,10.02,7.87134,1.5678767218328273,nan,7.61328125,0.3762644954354799,0.9417293233082706,0.06193306224585549,0.7323742166486193,0.0939037635440876,proxy
direct,tls-term-stream16,0,16.189406506042417,nan,nan,nan,0,0,449,1.84,0.0,0.09048365037545522,nan,0.0,0.5880281690140845,0.1727699530516432,0.926821608040201,1.6943030654309574,2.495587768870536,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-stream16,0,5.498303398582655,nan,nan,nan,0,0,255,10.05,7.440002,1.4572365402638408,nan,79.53515625,0.2265975005894836,0.9427767354596623,0.21279373368146215,0.637124348090757,0.3476513426658661,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-stream16,0,4.78856326565202,nan,nan,nan,0,0,379,10.04,7.588107000000001,1.676239602025297,nan,49.16796875,0.21227863046044865,0.9400749063670412,0.21428571428571427,0.5736924021728917,0.37621692329806006,proxy
nginx,tls-term-stream16,0,5.747591231298047,nan,nan,nan,0,0,168,10.12,7.5756049999999995,1.3951586103657325,nan,93.7265625,0.22637051039697542,0.9484536082474226,0.2144026186579378,0.6340051976388752,0.3512914393348748,proxy
envoy,tls-term-stream16,0,6.665260370341934,nan,nan,nan,0,0,436,10.09,8.901069999999999,1.2044401980835575,nan,132.4140625,0.2591369959915114,0.9465290806754222,0.08705148205928237,0.7180528038523158,0.15005205850380832,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-stream16,0,4.737174937751008,nan,nan,nan,0,0,224,10.06,7.887934,1.6948594233051786,nan,88.6171875,0.18702651515151514,0.9446009389671362,0.17488494411571334,0.5298015200391204,0.29820060230862616,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.97324630016,95190.89,0.609,1.12,0,0,0,7.72,0.0,6.345772903513402,8.09917927617257,0.0,0.6185643564356436,0.7509727626459144,0.9490022172949002,1.9210891704573578,0.835270770120478,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.23714594816,23195.71,2.54,11.98,0,0,0,10.1,7.376012,34.07184505024098,43.1108075806727,15.6015625,0.18319327731092436,0.9600760456273765,0.38293778062860806,0.45473484308340345,0.30894826610664666,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.31776047104000005,31082.96,1.93,3.18,0,0,0,10.03,7.039405,25.25172490378745,32.2291450440058,42.71875,0.2213231794383627,0.9516129032258065,0.4260355029585799,0.5498434737168942,0.3850016249369103,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.31255953408,30570.98,1.96,3.14,0,0,0,10.1,6.808431000000001,25.851075136079242,32.71212680645433,38.265625,0.23767352800382957,0.9600760456273765,0.48128172588832485,0.588864108100041,0.45629824283106335,proxy
envoy,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.29997662208,29339.74,2.12,3.68,0,0,0,10.02,7.2529129999999995,26.72208235567848,34.11342543731232,24.3046875,0.20966969842029679,0.9497630331753555,0.43020667726550077,0.5327364630345152,0.4097274363879263,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1k,0,0.18429771775999998,18025.81,3.3,13.14,0,0,0,10.12,7.747776,43.928921629637,55.58454398154505,18.3515625,0.16063294174058979,0.9619771863117871,0.3333333333333333,0.3881199282654151,0.3022825202934192,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1m,0,20.358144983040003,2424.8,6.56,10.89,0,0,0,8.09,0.0,0.31790715732654934,330.2849677472034,0.0,0.7418815663801337,0.8138832997987927,0.9597464342313787,2.4950566222836454,0.8561016612763134,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-ka-1m,0,5.21763028992,621.79,24.78,55.53,0,0,0,10.01,7.305898,1.534796364447429,1608.5489313835772,18.234375,0.18661108386463954,0.9515209125475285,0.28917558212712396,0.47941424412812983,0.3051091966802041,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1m,0,4.84559552512,577.33,26.34,37.58,0,0,0,10.12,7.546633,1.6707956654717904,1735.551363402504,50.06640625,0.20716049382716048,0.9601518026565465,0.25679090334807325,0.5108422421578771,0.2726915883044597,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1m,0,4.686631403520001,558.53,26.99,39.46,0,0,0,10.0,7.402639000000001,1.7069829716054519,1789.5490336435219,46.67578125,0.18256833419288293,0.999000999000999,0.27695351137487634,0.4453863161567847,0.32628643046837874,proxy
envoy,tls-init-ka-1m,0,6.215958528,740.81,21.32,32.13,0,0,0,10.01,8.448684,1.2882968835663378,1345.6109692162925,48.98828125,0.12704432329936005,0.9533333333333334,0.31930926216640504,0.3957752734324336,0.3660257255032095,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1m,0,4.395211161600001,523.72,29.56,65.8,0,0,0,10.04,7.7572719999999995,1.827443484439116,1915.2995040061046,21.109375,0.15467714215565923,0.9543726235741445,0.23510872990860385,0.4033770768913009,0.21294925752198746,proxy
direct,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.0402653184,3951.09,1.44,4.63,0,0,0,2.96,0.0,58.809916178385414,74.6833526769945,0.0,0.9520417853751187,0.28516377649325625,0.888712745719721,3.5843472601022723,0.8161202135512972,client
3proxy-devel,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.00864026624,846.34,72.94,118.91,0,0,0,10.06,9.036869,931.4527789365898,1186.8806040585182,34.76953125,0.040152055119980996,0.9571836346336822,0.2846299810246679,0.06849818529302429,0.24146591432248135,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.009479127039999998,931.86,65.2,94.5,0,0,0,10.05,9.000262000000001,848.179369901134,1076.247590490469,42.4609375,0.04183503684335631,0.956232159847764,0.3029728020240354,0.07230383355337092,0.2576277078522508,proxy
nginx,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.012331253759999999,1213.67,51.87,64.22,0,0,0,10.06,8.803065,652.6505866018283,827.7110416323844,34.97265625,0.0600664767331434,0.9562737642585551,0.3702302112898139,0.10274951297821974,0.3165987754612421,proxy
envoy,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.03036676096,2982.08,20.65,32.39,0,0,0,10.03,7.5244480000000005,264.23628158990846,335.9121202987374,27.05859375,0.09073679222932954,0.9525166191832859,0.32179161372299875,0.17980738156982373,0.23672427519203304,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-close-1k,0,0.009898557439999999,968.76,61.9,266.92,0,0,0,10.07,8.876617,813.8559632382152,1036.9683863659768,31.78125,0.047019710282593205,0.959047619047619,0.2644367308299148,0.07991876231528308,0.21676266771260233,proxy
direct,tls-init-stream1-down,0,7.51032531588814,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,1.47,0.0,0.15657359394850548,nan,0.0,0.3944349524041982,0.13828786453433678,0.3574575204531152,0.8018173519591436,0.7570818855351054,none
3proxy-devel,tls-init-stream1-down,0,6.091370550384604,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.99,7.412558000000001,1.311880811167123,nan,10.7890625,0.16613418530351437,0.950523311132255,0.29310344827586204,0.3710849233465248,0.6274470011467818,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-stream1-down,0,5.22049901865726,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.98,7.435752,1.5291885729007673,nan,38.7890625,0.13622828784119106,0.9486692015209125,0.2842476740455566,0.31206799999373924,0.5968167494416051,proxy
nginx,tls-init-stream1-down,0,5.819827488827418,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.02,7.378045,1.3772164949759493,nan,36.5703125,0.16601178781925344,0.9524714828897338,0.30380556443875917,0.3653853490708076,0.6493793133839354,proxy
envoy,tls-init-stream1-down,0,7.788301416058057,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.98,8.656368,1.0250172640021944,nan,32.48046875,0.06501182033096926,0.9504761904761905,0.3600638977635783,0.1465382931598391,0.7673225486173552,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-stream1-down,0,4.702044255838254,nan,nan,nan,0,0,8,10.04,7.908345,1.7080480108315121,nan,10.13671875,0.1281165144408788,0.9534662867996201,0.23504956827630316,0.29207382522659653,0.5048360994072054,proxy
direct,tls-init-stream16,0,16.499858853486494,nan,nan,nan,0,0,357,1.8,0.0,0.086889656161025,nan,0.0,0.5853543677890275,0.16901408450704225,0.9235368156073002,1.682704799217022,8.10781805270257,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-stream16,0,6.842659828981578,nan,nan,nan,0,0,338,10.07,7.837721,1.1716229439974304,nan,94.38671875,0.05892135899263483,0.9572243346007605,0.5597589554737195,0.13211400166511136,0.8271743928075266,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-stream16,0,5.862325867743212,nan,nan,nan,0,0,10,10.03,7.438014,1.3676024439439092,nan,54.84375,0.06178707224334601,0.9525166191832859,0.7143330023171135,0.11787160954103942,1.0741883155495973,origin
nginx,tls-init-stream16,0,6.8431736274537,nan,nan,nan,0,0,422,10.11,7.917688,1.1710265790814582,nan,114.35546875,0.056769596199524944,0.9601139601139601,0.5375703409467064,0.12737086928086372,0.7633546910784156,proxy
envoy,tls-init-stream16,0,7.334330547432625,nan,nan,nan,0,0,5705,10.07,7.92617,1.0932946682844875,nan,148.0234375,0.06285578747628083,0.956315289648623,0.5339425587467362,0.14637366469341512,0.8619641543333603,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-stream16,0,5.626352686394712,nan,nan,nan,0,0,283,10.08,8.019518,1.427484442866689,nan,102.74609375,0.04898929845422117,0.9572649572649573,0.5078464106844741,0.10932185788223023,0.6904925012520765,proxy
3proxy-devel,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.24058527744,23533.73,2.51,5.95,0,0,0,10.12,7.394785,33.651269463149404,42.576286018402044,14.36328125,0.2523386903334133,0.9610636277302944,0.33365384615384613,0.7163582660819358,0.2728282563404937,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.33185333248000004,32458.11,1.84,3.11,0,0,0,10.02,7.041486,24.155249369035957,30.825173276236008,37.1640625,0.2658317580340265,0.9524714828897338,0.3942337825133187,0.7515882214030223,0.3156306999875652,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.3686793216,36056.55,1.65,2.6,0,0,0,10.02,6.6448030000000005,21.742472469603243,27.77238836996591,37.1015625,0.2921908378827439,0.9515669515669516,0.4232469993682881,0.8352639706876831,0.38311186136133746,proxy
envoy,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.27749515263999996,27141.48,2.31,4.03,0,0,0,10.07,7.345847,29.031137745498604,36.73546814921823,23.97265625,0.25587529976019185,0.9581351094196003,0.35412026726057905,0.7325621669718656,0.3204048794971974,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1k,1,0.20073938944,19637.33,2.95,12.2,0,0,0,10.12,7.700559,40.330898796620346,51.025295840833344,16.22265625,0.21466346153846153,0.9619771863117871,0.2859897172236504,0.6136469613029831,0.22911792815524312,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1k,1,1.0461433036799999,102325.03,0.595,1.05,0,0,0,7.36,0.0,5.628292012468929,7.121721443929022,0.0,0.638909541511772,0.7104247104247104,0.9563567362428842,1.9680999514500503,0.8508707648756154,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-ka-1m,1,6.1052289023999995,727.53,21.3,49.18,0,0,0,10.01,7.450235,1.311662531908019,1374.6223564954682,18.7421875,0.2612872238232469,0.9515209125475285,0.06255924170616113,0.7590859466090741,0.051330857901977084,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1m,1,5.480361492479999,653.02,23.66,34.7,0,0,0,10.1,7.325695,1.474355297745806,1531.4632297194844,48.7890625,0.2999752903385224,0.9600760456273765,0.06409851594568992,0.8247263038649035,0.03707373395550695,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1m,1,5.654676766720001,673.85,22.58,35.56,0,0,0,10.02,7.461974,1.4175876589758971,1485.7651245551601,47.93359375,0.2518625330449411,0.9524714828897338,0.06200818382121498,0.7276811631277783,0.04752599678496451,proxy
envoy,tls-term-ka-1m,1,5.73512351744,683.39,22.52,36.18,0,0,0,10.01,7.545095,1.3963082007995793,1463.8783269961978,46.14453125,0.24554737592020898,0.9524262607040913,0.06186868686868687,0.7249132469004583,0.05418122027883975,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1m,1,4.50921234432,537.25,27.95,76.75,0,0,0,10.05,7.799951,1.783016497355139,1869.419642857143,20.16796875,0.21642512077294687,0.9535104364326376,0.05439595192915876,0.6163941318855918,0.03230501831404746,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1m,1,21.131239096319998,2515.02,6.18,11.69,0,0,0,8.22,0.0,0.3111980310300501,323.5838286816518,0.0,0.7578571428571429,0.8311425682507584,0.9588216661387393,2.5521928184605907,0.8548553913300087,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.01241513984,1223.08,19.6,42.72,0,0,0,10.1,8.805891,650.8182834934544,817.3504896010359,20.01171875,0.9517814726840855,0.9609895337773549,0.07419150285351934,3.6931023490886203,0.03230757767299401,client
haproxy,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.01350565888,1326.3,28.11,50.66,0,0,0,10.11,8.914606,598.8600831594525,754.533920441824,38.5,0.7743162901307967,0.9601139601139601,0.06571428571428571,2.9645510598126523,0.030401723835461417,client
nginx,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.013841203199999999,1359.44,3.15,4.74,0,0,0,10.13,8.756054,585.498231830019,737.7467045371786,32.37890625,0.9581749049429658,0.9620132953466287,0.08507936507936507,3.7055384378513323,0.03612375334975298,client
envoy,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.022481469440000002,2208.11,21.02,31.49,0,0,0,10.0,8.389932,355.84862552472015,451.9569736961041,27.546875,0.8848441589340947,0.9505703422053232,0.0922930542340628,3.3868945881353416,0.041831216601638604,client
stunnel,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.01040187392,1023.22,22.04,53.28,0,0,0,10.06,8.91971,773.7067437941029,981.6549570647932,32.15625,0.9448538150701212,0.9562737642585551,0.061010486177311724,3.6922447212409866,0.027569361636001734,client
direct,tls-term-close-1k,1,0.03388997632,3325.48,1.51,4.39,0,0,0,2.66,0.0,62.79142776338181,79.70992778160678,0.0,0.952007602755999,0.2550335570469799,0.8679544015199493,3.6044816494783274,0.84014239731083,client
3proxy-devel,tls-term-stream1-down,1,6.777909340164613,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.55,7.609268,1.1270723288902251,nan,8.5,0.39004658004412845,0.895032802249297,0.07538317172349077,0.764707997581304,0.12218539457260721,none
haproxy,tls-term-stream1-down,1,6.511348322089533,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.79,7.76732,1.2027660621729064,nan,38.328125,0.3940511307767945,0.9175257731958762,0.07142857142857142,0.7846908957395419,0.11176733864119884,proxy
nginx,tls-term-stream1-down,1,6.388193022225373,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.96,7.455176,1.2472715109193422,nan,35.66015625,0.398369967893307,0.9369708372530574,0.07478097622027534,0.7523181694608292,0.11835996641196735,proxy
envoy,tls-term-stream1-down,1,6.878771710384555,nan,nan,nan,0,0,37,9.33,7.673685,1.084962976718731,nan,32.8671875,0.3852178169358786,0.8744142455482662,0.07211988760536997,0.7818843898862599,0.13058873653378722,none
stunnel,tls-term-stream1-down,1,5.477174966278608,nan,nan,nan,0,0,3,9.95,7.847276,1.4531484606802736,nan,7.87890625,0.3928202479338843,0.9822309970384995,0.07056120774532326,0.7170010577723507,0.11234308108424469,proxy
direct,tls-term-stream1-down,1,7.7124235050519285,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,1.43,0.0,0.14831678217060454,nan,0.0,0.41544401544401544,0.14102564102564102,0.37532981530343007,0.8039674922719308,0.7897114282891569,none
3proxy-devel,tls-term-stream16,1,6.399134395557837,nan,nan,nan,0,0,286,10.06,7.417442,1.2537646239504552,nan,76.8671875,0.23665564478034956,0.9428303655107779,0.2221487603305785,0.66607419779506,0.36788902552055647,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-stream16,1,5.25119474979544,nan,nan,nan,0,0,507,10.04,7.545478,1.528894055882118,nan,43.83203125,0.21996695775312722,0.9409559512652296,0.20805592543275633,0.5918508233665358,0.3714092144411958,proxy
nginx,tls-term-stream16,1,5.685491239876813,nan,nan,nan,0,0,214,10.09,7.545533,1.4079926623315013,nan,85.4921875,0.2238241550460884,0.9483082706766918,0.21896383186705767,0.621425753292232,0.3547280028887528,proxy
envoy,tls-term-stream16,1,6.811969600638648,nan,nan,nan,0,0,432,10.1,8.923905999999999,1.1789248304156084,nan,139.29296875,0.26030624263839813,0.9465791940018744,0.08502657080337606,0.7219528311862721,0.14917633696485025,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-stream16,1,4.482254556558468,nan,nan,nan,0,0,275,10.07,7.845625,1.792366623033023,nan,81.6875,0.18577168518080833,0.9446529080675422,0.17371353654539495,0.5233774799132344,0.29346149200910193,proxy
direct,tls-term-stream16,1,16.015143423796545,nan,nan,nan,0,0,396,1.89,0.0,0.09412058291327519,nan,0.0,0.5851938895417156,0.17746478873239438,0.9249371859296482,1.683811797303392,1.7502437122495316,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.23379050496,22864.77,2.6,14.44,0,0,0,10.1,7.405217,34.56085610227171,43.73525017862169,15.765625,0.185789726356217,0.9600760456273765,0.3856082607292675,0.4623346985270433,0.3127445963278598,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.30685528064,30009.61,1.98,4.1,0,0,0,10.11,7.101384,26.357701855842503,33.35510818140428,40.796875,0.22169249106078665,0.9601139601139601,0.429821819318537,0.5488927974373623,0.36310268041072635,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.32690405376,31971.09,1.84,3.09,0,0,0,10.11,6.791938,24.74120435942311,31.308936518111803,36.09765625,0.2318562874251497,0.9601139601139601,0.47014218009478675,0.5793548719560367,0.4591288786848607,proxy
envoy,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.3112173568,30438.3,2.01,3.87,0,0,0,10.08,7.339404999999999,25.911151238207548,32.7896582458834,23.56640625,0.2147297943567671,0.9590865842055185,0.44992050874403816,0.546028495545099,0.42755951301028444,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.18975031296,18562.92,3.17,12.61,0,0,0,10.12,7.720931,42.666596295452024,53.97477266060428,16.71484375,0.15832335329341318,0.9619771863117871,0.3290570878768441,0.3852942957659553,0.2918545363042167,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1k,1,0.98977185792,96806.69,0.582,1.31,0,0,0,7.29,0.0,5.89226694347111,7.455947012660792,0.0,0.632112815437902,0.7063953488372093,0.9578446909667195,1.935960064564296,0.8469917496875562,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-ka-1m,1,5.01311602688,597.33,25.49,59.61,0,0,0,10.01,7.292004,1.5974096663754893,1674.4730679156908,19.8046875,0.18762230919765166,0.9515209125475285,0.27851291745431633,0.4755833541381246,0.25281457203352964,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1m,1,4.639403540479999,552.38,27.07,40.96,0,0,0,10.09,7.514806,1.7398788291576075,1808.5678436995877,50.35546875,0.1948629291183008,0.9600380589914367,0.24456350456980774,0.48605896317095715,0.29179928444947434,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1m,1,5.34404661248,636.87,24.15,37.14,0,0,0,10.02,7.348424,1.499986916521305,1572.0112958895513,44.85546875,0.19219440353460973,0.9515669515669516,0.2951181102362205,0.49089435273934007,0.27568115684768685,proxy
envoy,tls-init-ka-1m,1,6.35252506624,757.1,20.76,32.78,0,0,0,10.03,8.454549,1.2631197699073906,1320.9535098116687,48.328125,0.1295287710158655,0.9525166191832859,0.31798245614035087,0.40147456427613315,0.284247782539958,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1m,1,4.412072263680001,525.71,29.48,64.35,0,0,0,10.03,7.735322,1.8186465498430844,1906.8441064638782,20.3203125,0.16351583599312547,0.9534220532319392,0.2371491643014822,0.41763576489220217,0.25097826572548027,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1m,1,22.3338299392,2660.21,5.84,10.38,0,0,0,8.29,0.0,0.2969486209062429,308.556965794469,0.0,0.80732635585157,0.8382204246713852,0.9585443037974684,2.7559459621246556,0.83378802605234,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.00661086208,649.15,92.14,167.06,0,0,0,10.21,9.229690999999999,1235.5423394341938,1570.7692307692307,245.3125,0.03233475986685687,0.9677725118483412,0.23042929292929293,0.05327597843602479,0.19478849580430974,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.009814671359999999,964.15,64.22,89.94,0,0,0,10.05,8.996122999999999,819.1817846053688,1040.588113481052,40.48828125,0.042972459639126305,0.9535104364326376,0.3013003488740882,0.0723029348335669,0.25658274132482833,proxy
nginx,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.01199570944,1179.71,52.05,72.02,0,0,0,10.06,8.821459,670.9065470662151,851.748370163407,31.71484375,0.05767861381438405,0.9562737642585551,0.3602523659305994,0.09799210874810978,0.3051810942577959,proxy
envoy,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.02701131776,2648.78,25.85,33.13,0,0,0,10.0,7.53495,296.1721479522515,376.9601930036188,25.37109375,0.08483412322274882,0.9514747859181731,0.3000952683391553,0.17028274795259593,0.22149084640344327,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.00956301312,940.82,64.09,134.51,0,0,0,10.08,8.880436000000001,843.2488692434213,1069.609507640068,34.0625,0.044016178919819175,0.9581749049429658,0.2582886011998737,0.0780159399501272,0.21478690327275426,proxy
direct,tls-init-close-1k,1,0.0339738624,3336.8,1.48,4.44,0,0,0,2.58,0.0,60.75258608217593,77.12082262210797,0.0,0.9515669515669516,0.2473633748801534,0.8701298701298701,3.596700224334168,0.8504363119407453,client
3proxy-devel,tls-init-stream1-down,1,6.133944966178552,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,7.496550999999999,1.3040808374213728,nan,10.62890625,0.16373840897999023,0.9514747859181731,0.29824,0.3749050152067912,0.6428098887296081,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-stream1-down,1,4.9296750490498304,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.02,7.670416,1.6258992982076013,nan,39.8046875,0.14485637122514117,0.9515669515669516,0.25143769968051116,0.31400832008877133,0.5391051676669245,proxy
nginx,tls-init-stream1-down,1,5.960508081584328,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,7.2652589999999995,1.3434820873922508,nan,33.0859375,0.1706837186424004,0.9515209125475285,0.3100899742930591,0.3787020849981426,0.6646366554210981,proxy
envoy,tls-init-stream1-down,1,7.391248288658627,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.94,8.38443,1.0757515552744128,nan,30.41796875,0.0689410092395167,0.9466666666666667,0.35768985322271857,0.1560433694609397,0.7397200738212938,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-stream1-down,1,4.647629931634322,nan,nan,nan,0,0,7,10.03,7.7758970000000005,1.7262864814211671,nan,6.1796875,0.13894324853228962,0.9525166191832859,0.2464833759590793,0.3120326945206376,0.5190391453461016,proxy
direct,tls-init-stream1-down,1,7.424191430329656,nan,nan,nan,0,0,2,1.52,0.0,0.16378334422004096,nan,0.0,0.4142270159219312,0.15004935834155972,0.3711169861202908,0.806835386562984,0.7853450250871016,none
3proxy-devel,tls-init-stream16,1,7.0580551345748965,nan,nan,nan,0,0,361,10.06,7.850505999999999,1.1359180230934023,nan,99.46484375,0.05827783063748811,0.9553656220322887,0.5584329349269588,0.1321325179278397,0.8063560646592222,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-stream16,1,4.817428192038526,nan,nan,nan,0,0,249,10.01,7.571764000000001,1.661378334010888,nan,55.43359375,0.05576649264356905,0.9515209125475285,0.606425702811245,0.09979419689304676,0.8640512357873212,proxy
nginx,tls-init-stream16,1,6.734199711767152,nan,nan,nan,0,0,363,10.11,7.896966,1.1888774289205675,nan,114.54296875,0.055687767729652546,0.961941008563273,0.529431216931217,0.12547183040801566,0.7332136585318135,proxy
envoy,tls-init-stream16,1,7.226866948849155,nan,nan,nan,0,0,5520,10.07,7.894514,1.1100708413478906,nan,146.3984375,0.061804404451811505,0.956315289648623,0.516590761223162,0.1397480801155369,0.8206870463097911,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-stream16,1,5.672833873410656,nan,nan,nan,0,0,262,10.09,8.017217,1.41722064178196,nan,96.6328125,0.04966730038022814,0.9573055028462998,0.5086493679308051,0.11122284289756777,0.6924045799893166,proxy
direct,tls-init-stream16,1,16.669870786761685,nan,nan,nan,0,0,351,1.8,0.0,0.08614673932646646,nan,0.0,0.5733051841426225,0.16901408450704225,0.9123857548061771,1.6547693509923322,1.730440452660327,origin
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.329252864,32202.84,1.82,3.19,0,0,0,10.02,7.0114920000000005,24.346029682523884,31.0670701458478,37.1640625,0.2688222799150342,0.9524714828897338,0.39617314930991215,0.7610692311183535,0.30325132758570317,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.3372220416,32984.98,1.8,2.74,0,0,0,10.03,6.7356940000000005,23.79441142675295,30.341439509212847,35.05078125,0.28277330809275913,0.9525166191832859,0.4054820415879017,0.80005281595184,0.3897619751259341,proxy
envoy,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.3112173568,30436.36,1.95,3.75,0,0,0,10.09,7.336266,25.93685674538831,32.82464353217889,24.3828125,0.2793628150261531,0.9591254752851711,0.3863204559848005,0.7924550687823478,0.3202520254040063,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.1862270976,18211.81,3.22,11.18,0,0,0,10.13,7.726447,43.51676047385276,55.07559982384507,16.23046875,0.21734985700667303,0.9620132953466287,0.28917969996808174,0.5878981119594319,0.2661752418622385,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.97106526208,94977.36,0.622,1.03,0,0,0,7.45,0.0,6.137589544943471,7.766451846956072,0.0,0.6391089108910891,0.7233009708737864,0.9588347055098163,1.9585169070902544,0.8379191384919805,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-ka-1k,2,0.22984785919999998,22480.59,2.67,6.03,0,0,0,10.1,7.388892,35.15368830548586,44.4835939220436,14.37109375,0.24719101123595505,0.9600760456273765,0.3267931810871663,0.683053267403589,0.3023032110186354,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-ka-1m,2,5.78419687424,688.76,22.31,35.24,0,0,0,10.11,7.352988,1.3982926542524892,1453.421506612996,49.4921875,0.29149198520345254,0.9601139601139601,0.06719242902208201,0.799161700451357,0.038978444116790405,proxy
nginx,tls-term-ka-1m,2,5.92797761536,706.47,21.82,33.15,0,0,0,10.01,7.509201999999999,1.350882294030674,1415.6413520011313,48.171875,0.2593480345158197,0.9515209125475285,0.06090249289996844,0.7562664402028803,0.043728221841974155,proxy
envoy,tls-term-ka-1m,2,6.31133700096,751.94,21.0,31.48,0,0,0,10.03,7.5293719999999995,1.2713629455659698,1332.890365448505,45.64453125,0.2587594696969697,0.9516129032258065,0.06614173228346457,0.7676486679977432,0.0456090921779366,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-ka-1m,2,4.83452256256,575.93,26.25,69.91,0,0,0,10.02,7.787783,1.658074793585269,1738.3761276891048,20.01171875,0.22013034033309195,0.9533777354900095,0.05203045685279188,0.6307144379513957,0.0351734766358953,proxy
direct,tls-term-ka-1m,2,19.49915152384,2325.01,6.72,13.14,0,0,0,8.12,0.0,0.3331427006994575,345.81150717601463,0.0,0.7318409145034532,0.8193743693239153,0.9537974683544304,2.4733511309377647,0.8453802202803354,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-ka-1m,2,5.89668810752,702.67,21.49,52.53,0,0,0,10.02,7.462343,1.359407154293485,1424.7120716621641,21.1953125,0.25538535184298705,0.9515669515669516,0.061198738170347,0.7343611511208081,0.05132466972602156,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.013170114560000001,1290.81,28.57,53.51,0,0,0,10.09,8.915245,612.9027931553542,773.9510623609726,38.18359375,0.7568403521294313,0.960952380952381,0.06630710659898477,2.8871627857227327,0.030418026958914324,client
nginx,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.01308622848,1282.22,3.27,5.44,0,0,0,10.12,8.743829,618.6656462840544,781.4671814671815,34.26171875,0.9538863798431186,0.9610636277302944,0.091426763682379,3.6960002972247388,0.03992728533245066,client
envoy,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.01996488704,1958.38,22.97,33.36,0,0,0,10.0,8.365652,400.7034942883404,509.7879282218597,24.765625,0.9170233000475512,0.9514747859181731,0.09838146620120597,3.5248328330071175,0.04468149465514618,client
stunnel,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.00998244352,981.56,21.22,53.08,0,0,0,10.13,8.965724,811.8252794281776,1021.7873713939883,39.875,0.9524714828897338,0.9629277566539924,0.06414734836456018,3.7055428924816685,0.027568887986306533,client
direct,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.03632267264,3569.56,1.73,5.33,0,0,0,2.73,0.0,60.127734036698904,76.04880494735083,0.0,0.9534331195058209,0.2619961612284069,0.9041574103459219,3.588052577307687,0.8343079303115016,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-close-1k,2,0.00931135488,915.19,25.74,51.8,0,0,0,10.09,8.895892,866.8985452737893,1091.28271685053,62.00390625,0.9510107015457788,0.9591254752851711,0.06253968253968253,3.704490114385741,0.026617144126606217,client
haproxy,tls-term-stream1-down,2,5.302554843793358,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.85,7.7463049999999996,1.4860203700305017,nan,38.76171875,0.368986568986569,0.9257518796992481,0.0699344364658133,0.7323634714766126,0.10888657700448262,proxy
nginx,tls-term-stream1-down,2,5.25909138117809,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.84,7.618736999999999,1.4968246872196194,nan,36.03515625,0.38342351205115593,0.924812030075188,0.06887914840325611,0.7303719745619792,0.10706374951805704,proxy
envoy,tls-term-stream1-down,2,6.917778773006712,nan,nan,nan,0,0,51,9.12,7.569824,1.0545631725522884,nan,32.0078125,0.3991801178580579,0.8941176470588236,0.07730101539469375,0.7569942127826226,0.13990350085749714,none
stunnel,tls-term-stream1-down,2,4.724236505582047,nan,nan,nan,0,0,8,9.99,7.856866,1.6902324388971128,nan,6.9921875,0.3659135559921415,0.9389097744360902,0.06924516531503432,0.6971319212187429,0.09958308780794305,proxy
direct,tls-term-stream1-down,2,7.12681696258761,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,1.68,0.0,0.18857134384516924,nan,0.0,0.4154043645699615,0.16535433070866143,0.38365194462755436,0.798939947914091,0.795692847977105,none
3proxy-devel,tls-term-stream1-down,2,5.589366736662486,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.67,7.574899,1.3840398671266767,nan,8.40625,0.4052590873936582,0.9517716535433071,0.08120497707924033,0.7498378177438761,0.12415641967975921,proxy
haproxy,tls-term-stream16,2,4.96613614028804,nan,nan,nan,0,0,466,10.03,7.534289,1.614712226972157,nan,43.26171875,0.21573724007561437,0.9409005628517824,0.21319120586275817,0.5794262362632789,0.37798477295436833,proxy
nginx,tls-term-stream16,2,6.108448277671506,nan,nan,nan,0,0,221,10.1,7.5052389999999995,1.3145825403146698,nan,80.41015625,0.2256689557186834,0.9465791940018744,0.21903820816864294,0.6280822074124501,0.35563504646872457,proxy
envoy,tls-term-stream16,2,7.257016197788897,nan,nan,nan,0,0,535,10.07,8.925799999999999,1.106027711582965,nan,138.19140625,0.26298394711992445,0.9455399061032864,0.08320300281513919,0.732572825428969,0.15015417969546402,proxy
stunnel,tls-term-stream16,2,4.93465688449111,nan,nan,nan,0,0,250,10.08,7.863481,1.6297426649783842,nan,94.40625,0.1862884160756501,0.9447047797563262,0.18262586377097728,0.5232369679199749,0.3093901908498831,proxy
direct,tls-term-stream16,2,17.61709791981296,nan,nan,nan,0,0,448,1.95,0.0,0.08829426836049009,nan,0.0,0.6038488617695377,0.18327067669172933,0.9182903834066625,1.742694135125302,1.7426340139672905,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-term-stream16,2,5.936625616234798,nan,nan,nan,0,0,291,10.06,7.430306,1.3509057288458155,nan,94.56640625,0.22995031937544358,0.9428303655107779,0.21864740643466843,0.6468909149467797,0.3610874148838743,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.33151778816000005,32428.72,1.86,6.39,0,0,0,10.11,7.107836000000001,24.3968809181862,30.868249669486843,37.9140625,0.23448275862068965,0.9601139601139601,0.4529008109794136,0.5812056025910589,0.39825676089187356,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.30643585024000003,29971.31,2.08,3.03,0,0,0,10.11,6.847041,26.393778644585783,33.39797101545028,36.0,0.22458233890214796,0.9610266159695817,0.4601381042059008,0.5564684768960839,0.3744680837178592,proxy
envoy,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.28596764672,27967.51,2.22,4.0,0,0,0,10.06,7.35279,28.143043775438176,35.614905864776645,22.72265625,0.20828374196619853,0.9590085795996187,0.42987997473152245,0.5156140540364486,0.3679052006028204,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.1879048192,18378.01,3.2,13.32,0,0,0,10.13,7.726971,43.128217969621936,54.57562468348293,16.4296875,0.15950334288443171,0.9620132953466287,0.33110687022900764,0.3786416986892288,0.2869732693516453,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.94262788096,92194.83,0.617,1.51,0,0,0,7.1,0.0,6.025707614562938,7.624971674841137,0.0,0.6228698444060262,0.6873184898354308,0.9585180493983534,1.8976348522690194,0.8397667601400569,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-ka-1k,2,0.23655874559999998,23138.93,2.57,11.49,0,0,0,10.1,7.3944469999999995,34.15642055213874,43.218170459310734,15.703125,0.18974604695735506,0.9591642924976258,0.39451880178457616,0.46614134967155574,0.36408252675269875,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-ka-1m,2,4.91756978176,585.68,26.58,37.15,0,0,0,10.1,7.541793,1.643088020828891,1707.5232459847844,50.94140625,0.19707848477345877,0.9609895337773549,0.25701671397035636,0.4966247525837884,0.23482604770459523,proxy
nginx,tls-init-ka-1m,2,5.49386715136,654.75,23.46,35.21,0,0,0,10.02,7.363644,1.4590815138323192,1529.070654661987,45.5390625,0.1945057640421879,0.9524714828897338,0.2866541353383459,0.49564436941189216,0.2956667776866136,proxy
envoy,tls-init-ka-1m,2,6.6190311424,788.86,20.2,28.69,0,0,0,10.02,8.465634,1.2110533743603857,1268.6756140795137,40.92578125,0.13119810201660737,0.9515669515669516,0.32610744580584355,0.4157245533238602,0.4239715728250539,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-ka-1m,2,4.427339530239999,527.6,29.33,64.28,0,0,0,10.03,7.752134,1.812375117199342,1899.621212121212,20.8203125,0.1608237313066928,0.9525166191832859,0.23768939393939395,0.41280827049799834,0.28608684313989863,proxy
direct,tls-init-ka-1m,2,20.70174236672,2466.35,6.09,13.26,0,0,0,8.03,0.0,0.31031204457104944,322.3604977920513,0.0,0.7590073968026724,0.8135764944275583,0.9433185560481318,2.58756715545147,0.8647377835930178,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-ka-1m,2,5.44118669312,648.4,23.92,53.52,0,0,0,10.0,7.283727,1.4702675080264092,1541.0695022345508,17.33984375,0.18867924528301888,0.9514747859181731,0.2910753705455692,0.4860933020282822,0.39922826177484244,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.009898557439999999,971.68,63.22,87.65,0,0,0,10.06,8.991831,813.0477646649896,1033.066338057096,40.4140625,0.04598246029864897,0.9553656220322887,0.3114909781576448,0.07420891244025199,0.26240220709934997,proxy
nginx,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.01249902592,1226.33,50.61,73.25,0,0,0,10.05,8.809909,643.2501261666317,818.6705767350928,34.82421875,0.06105063890203502,0.956232159847764,0.36561514195583594,0.1008433222599802,0.31656271034531436,proxy
envoy,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.033554432,3298.66,19.22,28.01,0,0,0,10.03,7.52569,239.13383483886716,302.8015940103852,27.10546875,0.09157769869513642,0.9534220532319392,0.34790874524714827,0.19218400391023552,0.2614521204420928,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.00931135488,917.07,64.49,282.03,0,0,0,10.07,8.893132999999999,865.1802131721564,1096.47212543554,42.8046875,0.04510921177587844,0.9572243346007605,0.25410872313527183,0.07611102140043158,0.21010458273517538,proxy
direct,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.032380026879999996,3182.26,1.71,4.86,0,0,0,2.59,0.0,63.99006423554891,81.09716003381658,0.0,0.9524827750059397,0.2483221476510067,0.891566265060241,3.594582602385835,0.868531410399534,client
3proxy-devel,tls-init-close-1k,2,0.008724152320000001,854.51,70.94,130.96,0,0,0,10.03,9.019395999999999,919.7455186110276,1170.7715653087428,59.45703125,0.03983874792506521,0.9525166191832859,0.2871161760050649,0.06659426008973492,0.247076553129968,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-stream1-down,2,5.30983748687016,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,7.443982,1.5064755017869838,nan,35.140625,0.15938430983118174,0.9514747859181731,0.28630838131797826,0.3643463829261043,0.6102902686360547,proxy
nginx,tls-init-stream1-down,2,6.122829390865141,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,7.421562,1.3064479145261825,nan,34.765625,0.16845180136319376,0.9487666034155597,0.3047923322683706,0.38059470645108456,0.6493674048897675,proxy
envoy,tls-init-stream1-down,2,7.999160223164411,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.97,8.580546,0.9969992853509123,nan,33.28515625,0.06983901515151515,0.9477186311787072,0.36058767167039285,0.15890472448885026,0.7578210005940405,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-stream1-down,2,4.99521013590384,nan,nan,nan,0,0,11,10.02,7.927848999999999,1.6045700985060765,nan,10.63671875,0.15476480623933708,0.9515669515669516,0.2399103139013453,0.34256203830421034,0.520834406924631,proxy
direct,tls-init-stream1-down,2,7.575648412068668,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1,1.33,0.0,0.1404461615601946,nan,0.0,0.4143334189571025,0.1310344827586207,0.3648380700594845,0.8089368670720193,0.770897273935217,none
3proxy-devel,tls-init-stream1-down,2,6.5616980626696195,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.96,7.428655,1.214188443232296,nan,11.21484375,0.1782250242483026,0.9485714285714286,0.304694985627595,0.39666298169177927,0.6558373533562405,proxy
haproxy,tls-init-stream16,2,6.1118228658999,nan,nan,nan,0,0,7,10.04,7.414294,1.313045255905343,nan,55.0859375,0.06579572446555819,0.9516587677725118,0.7479379742659188,0.1273587095064298,1.1262821310115851,origin
nginx,tls-init-stream16,2,6.87073422596113,nan,nan,nan,0,0,487,10.11,7.865257,1.1658229604748571,nan,112.50390625,0.05589914367269267,0.9610266159695817,0.5361405835543767,0.1273765617651751,0.7455949793916397,proxy
envoy,tls-init-stream16,2,7.250423926236643,nan,nan,nan,0,0,4922,10.09,7.947361000000001,1.1084477936372372,nan,153.49609375,0.06331515295233578,0.9563981042654028,0.5267275097783573,0.14637536633339554,0.8405408179005287,proxy
stunnel,tls-init-stream16,2,5.505053569840967,nan,nan,nan,0,0,270,10.1,7.992601,1.4612649529824777,nan,95.6484375,0.049168646080760096,0.957345971563981,0.5093395597064709,0.10836711168852431,0.6895314756957547,proxy
direct,tls-init-stream16,2,17.9537542328526,nan,nan,nan,0,0,424,1.83,0.0,0.0813396718411371,nan,0.0,0.6075533661740559,0.17231638418079095,0.9185790631876768,1.7678203990168668,1.736464051627823,origin
3proxy-devel,tls-init-stream16,2,7.39921253835151,nan,nan,nan,0,0,350,10.06,7.851057,1.0835586377024127,nan,95.4453125,0.06012357414448669,0.9553656220322887,0.5556293590169379,0.13688854209297033,0.8042317032742594,proxy

1 proxy scenario rep gbit rate p50_ms p99_ms errors timeouts retrans prx_cpu_s prx_task_s cpu_s_per_gb cpu_us_per_req peak_mb cli_util prx_util srv_util cli_thread srv_thread bound
2 direct tls-term-ka-1k 0 1.1194597376 0.9432989696 109493.64 92260.06 0.5640000000000001 0.665 0.88 1.12 0 0 0 7.37 7.33 0.0 5.266826310913498 6.216480870838429 6.664604889306068 7.866174163320234 0.0 0.6467110125646711 0.6291913214990138 0.7155339805825243 0.7095837366892546 0.9559848005066498 0.9559708584098828 1.9942851466688527 1.927090841878114 0.8402770418544304 0.8392698396127815 origin
3 3proxy-current 3proxy-devel tls-term-ka-1k 0 0.25014829056 0.20401094656 24470.78 19954.33 2.49 3.07 4.56 7.89 0 0 0 10.1 10.11 7.472335 7.432369 32.30084036117748 39.64493149205258 40.867689842558235 50.166228353098795 14.01953125 14.7421875 0.237912876974629 0.25184304399524376 0.9600760456273765 0.9601139601139601 0.3274647887323944 0.3185161496642149 0.6650230362408502 0.6991874125041462 0.3032660986708979 0.2555947816036184 proxy
4 haproxy tls-term-ka-1k 0 0.34493956096 0.33277607936000003 33737.22 32550.27 1.75 1.8 3.11 0 0 0 10.02 7.024958 7.036519 23.238853721767086 24.088269852257685 29.674205652314264 30.740251014704395 39.1171875 37.1484375 0.27087242026266417 0.27379830348727613 0.9524714828897338 0.3939868462261196 0.40442781415653256 0.7478065772405075 0.775291905522719 0.32990281828206053 0.36011944890466585 proxy
5 nginx tls-term-ka-1k 0 0.36683382783999996 0.3414163456 35883.47 33389.97 1.66 1.78 2.63 2.74 0 0 0 10.11 10.03 6.714439 6.733183 22.04813020550466 23.50209679006066 27.89681214766823 29.992045977836387 34.90625 34.94921875 0.27857988165680475 0.2888154789995281 0.9601139601139601 0.9525166191832859 0.410288582183187 0.4136634283923535 0.7848410024270118 0.812413432243309 0.34317401568043043 0.3650203770458889 proxy
6 stunnel envoy tls-term-ka-1k 0 0.20308819968 0.27338473472 19862.73 26737.41 2.99 2.32 6.95 4.09 0 0 0 10.04 10.1 7.650684 7.345412 39.54931902816501 29.555417599580007 50.49742986188651 37.40006591298745 18.52734375 22.74609375 0.20702844848195076 0.27153736316039984 0.9543726235741445 0.9591642924976258 0.28337612323491657 0.36795440151994935 0.5784034584947134 0.7629207873309807 0.23670157509482284 0.3032087888519814 proxy
7 direct stunnel tls-term-ka-1m tls-term-ka-1k 0 22.67742732288 0.16642998272 2705.24 16282.1 5.81 3.78 10.12 12.43 0 0 0 8.19 10.12 0.0 7.75016 0.2889216623523018 48.645081058625244 299.75843642485904 61.53883574846913 0.0 16.23046875 0.7610872675250357 0.21561161351737268 0.8297872340425532 0.9619771863117871 0.9534957291996203 0.28066263141127745 2.5895535072121367 0.5812563023193552 0.8562784735233212 0.2443092578206486 origin proxy
8 3proxy-current direct tls-term-ka-1m 0 4.92251906048 19.49915152384 586.56 2322.98 26.44 6.73 59.84 11.05 0 0 0 10.02 7.97 7.145911 0.0 1.6284345274263603 0.32698858677028037 1706.984667802385 339.68375740527637 19.08984375 0.0 0.2776717557251908 0.7356239560963971 0.9524714828897338 0.813265306122449 0.05218216318785579 0.9575546404814698 0.8296491258355196 2.476173005554468 0.042785272849970885 0.8529648878713005 proxy origin
9 haproxy 3proxy-devel tls-term-ka-1m 0 5.8997080064 5.42440947712 702.39 646.39 22.17 23.53 32.44 55.27 0 0 0 10.1 10.02 7.309323 7.486255999999999 1.3695593055172934 1.477764544474611 1423.7383704539047 1548.2076637824475 46.52734375 20.20703125 0.29105771612583603 0.25281033245635015 0.9600760456273765 0.9515669515669516 0.07271577616187164 0.06204724409448819 0.8048629147918888 0.7220149760631065 0.03422650828012293 0.06271281714312446 proxy
10 nginx haproxy tls-term-ka-1m 0 6.29657305088 4.7294133043199995 750.4 563.48 20.67 28.85 31.44 37.06 0 0 0 10.03 10.09 7.495661 7.410545 1.2743439860319856 1.7067656135332416 1334.664005322688 1772.974872605869 47.80859375 47.94140625 0.25861244019138757 0.26380368098159507 0.9525166191832859 0.9600380589914367 0.06675062972292191 0.0591584941474217 0.7496642279925745 0.7220079347290078 0.046582996396474605 0.033269254791884945 proxy
11 stunnel nginx tls-term-ka-1m 0 5.1266977792 5.81674467328 610.99 693.24 25.42 22.12 59.16 32.09 0 0 0 10.03 10.01 7.741818 7.468177000000001 1.5651400463969054 1.3767150613960808 1639.9607586657946 1442.3631123919308 20.0234375 48.2578125 0.2268440145102781 0.25968436154949787 0.9534220532319392 0.9524262607040913 0.05780164245104232 0.06509433962264151 0.6507519932640717 0.752396395476189 0.04087871882467707 0.04847659691732909 proxy
12 direct envoy tls-term-close-1k tls-term-ka-1m 0 0.04286578688 5.8040778752 4207.33 691.44 1.55 22.41 5.34 35.79 0 0 0 3.6 10.01 0.0 7.548457 67.18644890533268 1.3797195992522853 84.96577767288176 1446.5317919075144 0.0 46.5625 0.9538973384030418 0.25225439012814427 0.3474903474903475 0.9515209125475285 0.9068736141906873 0.06649858178380082 3.583540794177188 0.7429351786134916 0.8232646501143567 0.046581616452105526 origin proxy
13 3proxy-current stunnel tls-term-close-1k tls-term-ka-1m 0 0.01098907648 4.1498443776 1080.27 494.44 22.53 30.92 48.39 84.04 0 0 0 10.12 10.04 8.900212 7.829454 736.7316093153624 1.9354942665693853 927.5043534048208 2028.6926651848858 42.8046875 19.4921875 0.9548371761350131 0.2041062801932367 0.9619771863117871 0.9534662867996201 0.06321473951715374 0.04946100190234623 3.6999085064935566 0.5774295187816934 0.028521737238229684 0.03517211745717436 client proxy
14 haproxy direct tls-term-close-1k 0 0.01400897536 0.03145728 1372.98 3087.8 27.29 1.78 41.4 4.9 0 0 0 10.1 2.54 8.908869 0.0 576.7730895630614 64.59554036458334 728.2428437522532 82.02279846287983 38.1015625 0.0 0.7685163134079542 0.9527091254752852 0.9619047619047619 0.24423076923076922 0.07070386810399493 0.9006664550936211 2.932285448471752 3.584391528635113 0.02947374185889227 0.8564716246802538 client origin
15 nginx 3proxy-devel tls-term-close-1k 0 0.01400897536 0.01241513984 1377.42 1219.79 3.1 19.92 4.85 41.48 0 0 0 10.11 10.12 8.769033 8.815469 577.3441520279753 652.107032569679 726.710753306498 821.4285714285714 33.359375 23.6484375 0.9557774607703281 0.9548264384213029 0.9610266159695817 0.9610636277302944 0.08386277001270648 0.07516650808753568 3.705869538524049 3.6910616152080116 0.037064883202621905 0.03232031755726188 client
16 stunnel haproxy tls-term-close-1k 0 0.01098907648 0.01224736768 1076.02 1199.44 21.55 30.57 52.77 50.81 0 0 0 10.11 10.12 8.96967 8.913373 736.0036136539836 661.0400056185787 930.253956569746 835.3281056541477 34.19921875 42.41015625 0.9465304182509505 0.7505355867650559 0.9628571428571429 0.9610636277302944 0.06482364156339371 0.06351222610352493 3.687378250238888 2.871992444901631 0.029471449078566612 0.028517067016256066 client
17 direct nginx tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-close-1k 0 1.08263374848 0.01040187392 105887.95 1024.81 0.5650000000000001 4.03 0.94 5.29 0 0 0 7.27 10.12 0.0 8.833620999999999 5.37208451904032 778.3212969380039 6.797670652389376 977.6833156216791 0.0 34.234375 0.6480750246791708 0.9581450653983353 0.7044573643410853 0.9619771863117871 0.9579113924050633 0.07577679137603044 1.9966754355184562 3.7032775538284626 0.8476755626979373 0.032316796774519076 origin client
18 3proxy-current envoy tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-close-1k 0 0.23815258112 0.01904214016 23295.97 1872.39 2.55 24.79 9.15 37.26 0 0 0 10.1 9.99 7.479255 8.37075 33.92782879782714 419.7007233875964 42.9272107513537 532.8284175156008 15.453125 26.3359375 0.17768199233716475 0.8705155618911855 0.9600760456273765 0.950523311132255 0.36823453608247425 0.09490667510281557 0.4386048730614794 3.330418014767844 0.33643266951347556 0.041824944417735765 proxy client
19 haproxy stunnel tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-close-1k 0 0.34301018112 0.009227468800000001 33545.49 903.02 1.81 22.46 14.6 51.81 0 0 0 10.09 10.13 7.09971 8.976982 23.53282918204711 878.2473477450285 29.781142545121824 1110.6238351057998 42.10546875 34.3359375 0.224934194783441 0.9512601046124584 0.960952380952381 0.9629277566539924 0.43178973717146435 0.06778587266392144 0.5679634627033696 3.6925623055568226 0.3802972087446423 0.028513045064273084 proxy client
20 nginx direct tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-stream1-down 0 0.34091302912 6.783526652335611 33343.45 nan 1.78 nan 3.2 nan 0 0 0 10.09 1.12 6.803458 0.0 23.677593141090213 0.13208213860636228 29.96101208239427 nan 38.4453125 0.0 0.22347575612097936 0.4068665129387651 0.9591254752851711 0.10980392156862745 0.45906801007556675 0.36882003955174686 0.559362248529181 0.7877991910485717 0.42001702694852067 0.7715536520324874 proxy none
21 stunnel 3proxy-devel tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-stream1-down 0 0.20644364288 5.262776090987485 20193.48 nan 2.92 nan 12.26 nan 0 0 0 10.14 9.85 7.714791 7.536672 39.29401693766508 1.4971816578238932 49.7175806072017 nan 16.58984375 8.015625 0.16155321188878236 0.38275265628860883 0.9629629629629629 0.9257518796992481 0.3395081443628234 0.07125 0.39387222180360004 0.7503795100068791 0.27941077827725713 0.10799432329246171 proxy
22 direct haproxy tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream1-down 0 20.95944040448 6.112343512559425 2493.51 nan 6.78 nan 13.24 nan 0 0 0 8.04 9.79 0.0 7.79017 0.30687842212739536 1.2812064300822925 319.23764145324594 nan 0.0 40.96875 0.7303290414878397 0.38974736325729703 0.8080402010050252 0.9183864915572233 0.9269680682895984 0.07653858169322086 2.466781691288365 0.7750593590707735 0.8196875576746906 0.12019293163689658 origin proxy
23 3proxy-current nginx tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream1-down 0 5.164865945600001 5.931179961755962 615.45 nan 25.05 nan 57.51 nan 0 0 0 10.03 9.79 7.472096 7.651082 1.5535737199211772 1.3203424511390753 1628.5111219353792 nan 18.375 35.58203125 0.17719341361513885 0.38706516413522785 0.9507109004739337 0.9175257731958762 0.26473369051370943 0.07176433719837041 0.4613840727624356 0.7551686024054629 0.23945357085597052 0.11461406856791828 proxy
24 haproxy envoy tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream1-down 0 5.1099205632 6.601938240534079 608.02 nan 25.44 nan 37.1 nan 0 0 0 51 10.1 9.35 7.5443940000000005 7.677902 1.5812378881561397 1.132928434323632 1644.6832763393584 nan 54.546875 33.484375 0.19995050730017322 0.38018545632015616 0.9600760456273765 0.8746492048643593 0.2572692793931732 0.07149547299406805 0.5051365812803598 0.7532599921061515 0.2785377466673379 0.1305880549952942 proxy none
25 nginx stunnel tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream1-down 0 5.44319995904 5.112206699803147 648.56 nan 24.08 nan 34.66 nan 0 0 0 4 10.03 10.02 7.373113999999999 7.87134 1.4741328741145798 1.5678767218328273 1545.4545454545455 nan 43.8984375 7.61328125 0.1904527559055118 0.3762644954354799 0.9516129032258065 0.9417293233082706 0.2863422291993721 0.06193306224585549 0.4860833250705032 0.7323742166486193 0.2946700749773043 0.0939037635440876 proxy
26 stunnel direct tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream16 0 4.20957126656 16.189406506042417 501.63 nan 30.5 nan 71.58 nan 0 0 0 449 10.03 1.84 7.781262 0.0 1.9061323569317057 0.09048365037545522 1997.6100378410674 nan 20.43359375 0.0 0.1535635562086701 0.5880281690140845 0.9534220532319392 0.1727699530516432 0.2157545080670674 0.926821608040201 0.3881396735403182 1.6943030654309574 0.22816363189430924 2.495587768870536 proxy origin
27 direct 3proxy-devel tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 0 0.034393292799999996 5.498303398582655 3378.49 nan 1.52 nan 4.64 nan 0 0 0 255 2.63 10.05 0.0 7.440002 61.17471834508383 1.4572365402638408 77.50338893145518 nan 0.0 79.53515625 0.9528907922912205 0.2265975005894836 0.25191570881226055 0.9427767354596623 0.8751979727589484 0.21279373368146215 3.599362891586791 0.637124348090757 0.86689710796206 0.3476513426658661 client proxy
28 3proxy-current haproxy tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 0 0.0088080384 4.78856326565202 864.36 nan 70.96 nan 121.97 nan 0 0 0 379 10.04 9.072577 7.588107000000001 911.894298735119 1.676239602025297 1159.2194896663202 nan 76.5703125 49.16796875 0.03870814533364996 0.21227863046044865 0.9561904761904761 0.9400749063670412 0.2731012658227848 0.21428571428571427 0.0646956757172168 0.5736924021728917 0.23294151831009602 0.37621692329806006 proxy
29 haproxy nginx tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 0 0.00973078528 5.747591231298047 951.83 nan 62.48 nan 96.56 nan 0 0 0 168 10.03 10.12 8.9932 7.5756049999999995 824.5994304788524 1.3951586103657325 1051.8036912751677 nan 42.62890625 93.7265625 0.04185493460166469 0.22637051039697542 0.9534220532319392 0.9484536082474226 0.28748019017432647 0.2144026186579378 0.068502521929934 0.6340051976388752 0.24624148261424658 0.3512914393348748 proxy
30 nginx envoy tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 0 0.01283457024 6.665260370341934 1261.4 nan 48.86 nan 71.27 nan 0 0 0 436 10.05 10.09 8.818029000000001 8.901069999999999 626.4331294041053 1.2044401980835575 795.598480050665 nan 31.62109375 132.4140625 0.05712254088646599 0.2591369959915114 0.9553231939163498 0.9465290806754222 0.35991175543649545 0.08705148205928237 0.09704781724589216 0.7180528038523158 0.30791304706611916 0.15005205850380832 proxy
31 stunnel tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 0 0.00973078528 4.737174937751008 952.99 nan 60.54 nan 330.32 nan 0 0 0 224 10.07 10.06 8.896381 7.887934 827.8879626043912 1.6948594233051786 1055.2237241957455 nan 28.5625 88.6171875 0.04579971523493118 0.18702651515151514 0.956315289648623 0.9446009389671362 0.24723713293337543 0.17488494411571334 0.075160811692268 0.5298015200391204 0.20726306873233175 0.29820060230862616 proxy
32 3proxy-current direct tls-term-ka-1k tls-init-ka-1k 1 0 0.24184356863999998 0.97324630016 23655.24 95190.89 2.57 0.609 4.9 1.12 0 0 0 10.1 7.72 7.463227 0.0 33.410026346524894 6.345772903513402 42.27444907184564 8.09917927617257 14.09765625 0.0 0.23694298035457595 0.6185643564356436 0.9600760456273765 0.7509727626459144 0.3238308776425368 0.9490022172949002 0.662156994575174 1.9210891704573578 0.25667947228469246 0.835270770120478 proxy origin
33 haproxy 3proxy-devel tls-term-ka-1k tls-init-ka-1k 1 0 0.34921775104 0.23714594816 34157.4 23195.71 1.75 2.54 2.93 11.98 0 0 0 10.03 10.1 7.021541999999999 7.376012 22.977067964339867 34.07184505024098 29.305463438293447 43.1108075806727 38.75 15.6015625 0.2665879574970484 0.18319327731092436 0.9534220532319392 0.9600760456273765 0.39593114241001565 0.38293778062860806 0.753481525112189 0.45473484308340345 0.34700718616226184 0.30894826610664666 proxy
34 nginx haproxy tls-term-ka-1k tls-init-ka-1k 1 0 0.36096180224 0.31776047104000005 35302.14 31082.96 1.69 1.93 2.78 3.18 0 0 0 10.02 10.03 6.681599 7.039405 22.207335929329826 25.25172490378745 28.329573020746746 32.2291450440058 35.01171875 42.71875 0.2880833925610045 0.2213231794383627 0.9524714828897338 0.9516129032258065 0.410288582183187 0.4260355029585799 0.8077387679797692 0.5498434737168942 0.3744450896339174 0.3850016249369103 proxy
35 stunnel nginx tls-term-ka-1k tls-init-ka-1k 1 0 0.21692940287999998 0.31255953408 21218.28 30570.98 2.84 1.96 6.57 3.14 0 0 0 10.12 10.1 7.70104 6.808431000000001 37.320897455650616 25.851075136079242 47.22506101459217 32.71212680645433 16.0234375 38.265625 0.21948889419632195 0.23767352800382957 0.9619771863117871 0.9600760456273765 0.30248883216336947 0.48128172588832485 0.6070026201252147 0.588864108100041 0.2719186248164488 0.45629824283106335 proxy
36 direct envoy tls-term-ka-1k tls-init-ka-1k 1 0 1.0890090905599998 0.29997662208 106518.51 29339.74 0.56 2.12 0.95 3.68 0 0 0 7.25 10.02 0.0 7.2529129999999995 5.325942685214383 26.72208235567848 6.739208435815779 34.11342543731232 0.0 24.3046875 0.6322836598065956 0.20966969842029679 0.7018393030009681 0.9497630331753555 0.9572243346007605 0.43020667726550077 1.9457815100926927 0.5327364630345152 0.8492458801910123 0.4097274363879263 origin proxy
37 3proxy-current stunnel tls-term-ka-1m tls-init-ka-1k 1 0 4.83049603072 0.18429771775999998 575.61 18025.81 26.94 3.3 62.46 13.14 0 0 0 10.02 10.12 7.147285999999999 7.747776 1.6594569065001779 43.928921629637 1739.281374761326 55.58454398154505 18.0703125 18.3515625 0.2709477202196228 0.16063294174058979 0.9515669515669516 0.9619771863117871 0.050933248971844355 0.3333333333333333 0.8020386626920842 0.3881199282654151 0.04088170992854504 0.3022825202934192 proxy
38 haproxy direct tls-term-ka-1m tls-init-ka-1m 1 0 5.71834630144 20.358144983040003 680.79 2424.8 22.24 6.56 32.3 10.89 0 0 0 10.09 8.09 7.391886 0.0 1.4115969153472396 0.31790715732654934 1467.4229203025016 330.2849677472034 48.6875 0.0 0.2883617494440326 0.7418815663801337 0.960952380952381 0.8138832997987927 0.06622516556291391 0.9597464342313787 0.7943766224387107 2.4950566222836454 0.03612636365880328 0.8561016612763134 proxy origin
39 nginx 3proxy-devel tls-term-ka-1m tls-init-ka-1m 1 0 6.0456697856 5.21763028992 720.52 621.79 21.42 24.78 32.06 55.53 0 0 0 10.02 10.01 7.475741 7.305898 1.3259076800875018 1.534796364447429 1388.9658996395897 1608.5489313835772 48.23046875 18.234375 0.2518002880460874 0.18661108386463954 0.9524714828897338 0.9515209125475285 0.06236220472440945 0.28917558212712396 0.7268675747928643 0.47941424412812983 0.04373694304635185 0.3051091966802041 proxy
40 stunnel haproxy tls-term-ka-1m tls-init-ka-1m 1 0 5.47306340352 4.84559552512 652.13 577.33 24.04 26.34 55.44 37.58 0 0 0 10.04 10.12 7.784278 7.546633 1.467551060131008 1.6707956654717904 1538.9331698344574 1735.551363402504 20.05859375 50.06640625 0.2372718539865514 0.20716049382716048 0.9534662867996201 0.9601518026565465 0.062460567823343846 0.25679090334807325 0.6736025246218889 0.5108422421578771 0.04088345494128453 0.2726915883044597 proxy
41 direct nginx tls-term-ka-1m tls-init-ka-1m 1 0 22.849226014720003 4.686631403520001 2725.64 558.53 5.89 26.99 11.59 39.46 0 0 0 8.21 10.0 0.0 7.402639000000001 0.2874495615636496 1.7069829716054519 298.2526246957533 1789.5490336435219 0.0 46.67578125 0.7637963843958135 0.18256833419288293 0.8360488798370672 0.999000999000999 0.9464851171627613 0.27695351137487634 2.5974012039744174 0.4453863161567847 0.8588979777160687 0.32628643046837874 origin proxy
42 3proxy-current envoy tls-term-close-1k tls-init-ka-1m 1 0 0.012582912 6.215958528 1237.99 740.81 19.37 21.32 44.4 32.13 0 0 0 10.12 10.01 8.865654999999999 8.448684 643.4122721354166 1.2882968835663378 809.3410108765195 1345.6109692162925 53.9765625 48.98828125 0.9531621493105088 0.12704432329936005 0.9610636277302944 0.9533333333333334 0.06743002544529263 0.31930926216640504 3.699060414906116 0.3957752734324336 0.030413040186725 0.3660257255032095 client proxy
43 haproxy stunnel tls-term-close-1k tls-init-ka-1m 1 0 0.01417674752 4.395211161600001 1393.81 523.72 26.76 29.56 43.86 65.8 0 0 0 10.01 10.04 8.84597 7.7572719999999995 564.8686335637019 1.827443484439116 717.4598623853211 1915.2995040061046 38.14453125 21.109375 0.7505949547834364 0.15467714215565923 0.9524262607040913 0.9543726235741445 0.06622306717363752 0.23510872990860385 2.87981288526459 0.4033770768913009 0.0304195615733104 0.21294925752198746 client proxy
44 nginx direct tls-term-close-1k tls-init-close-1k 1 0 0.0150994944 0.0402653184 1485.46 3951.09 3.01 1.44 4.23 4.63 0 0 0 10.13 2.96 8.809959 0.0 536.7067125108508 58.809916178385414 675.1532924553452 74.6833526769945 34.2578125 0.0 0.9536376604850214 0.9520417853751187 0.961100569259962 0.28516377649325625 0.08436409768474469 0.888712745719721 3.703024618254623 3.5843472601022723 0.037079432561640494 0.8161202135512972 client
45 stunnel 3proxy-devel tls-term-close-1k tls-init-close-1k 1 0 0.011240734720000001 0.00864026624 1105.87 846.34 22.33 72.94 58.85 118.91 0 0 0 10.12 10.06 8.990985 9.036869 720.2376180620334 931.4527789365898 906.0793267078521 1186.8806040585182 33.6484375 34.76953125 0.9365343475160447 0.040152055119980996 0.9628924833491912 0.9571836346336822 0.06263910969793322 0.2846299810246679 3.640140800258993 0.06849818529302429 0.026619042119849314 0.24146591432248135 client proxy
46 direct haproxy tls-term-close-1k tls-init-close-1k 1 0 0.044459622399999996 0.009479127039999998 4368.77 931.86 1.37 65.2 4.12 94.5 0 0 0 3.06 10.05 0.0 9.000262000000001 55.06119638119104 848.179369901134 69.8582288884323 1076.247590490469 0.0 42.4609375 0.9522678698646402 0.04183503684335631 0.29423076923076924 0.956232159847764 0.9164027865737808 0.3029728020240354 3.5838588862622704 0.07230383355337092 0.8535331102029736 0.2576277078522508 origin proxy
47 3proxy-current nginx tls-init-ka-1k tls-init-close-1k 1 0 0.25467813888 0.012331253759999999 24909.29 1213.67 2.45 51.87 9.6 64.22 0 0 0 10.1 10.06 7.445309 8.803065 31.726319485188153 652.6505866018283 40.14627553859607 827.7110416323844 15.453125 34.97265625 0.17972681524083392 0.0600664767331434 0.9600760456273765 0.9562737642585551 0.3825588796944621 0.3702302112898139 0.44718341123734623 0.10274951297821974 0.3118851039676552 0.3165987754612421 proxy
48 haproxy envoy tls-init-ka-1k tls-init-close-1k 1 0 0.33160167424000003 0.03036676096 32433.37 2982.08 1.82 20.65 3.17 32.39 0 0 0 10.01 10.03 7.015357 7.5244480000000005 24.14945587459287 264.23628158990846 30.834724643752658 335.9121202987374 42.5625 27.05859375 0.22458741927768477 0.09073679222932954 0.9515209125475285 0.9525166191832859 0.43470149253731344 0.32179161372299875 0.5679230139372056 0.17980738156982373 0.3916792412681567 0.23672427519203304 proxy
49 nginx stunnel tls-init-ka-1k tls-init-close-1k 1 0 0.37044092928 0.009898557439999999 36231.05 968.76 1.68 61.9 2.58 266.92 0 0 0 10.1 10.07 6.750587 8.876617 21.81184464606686 813.8559632382152 27.602265025470604 1036.9683863659768 37.9921875 31.78125 0.23570566948130278 0.047019710282593205 0.9600760456273765 0.959047619047619 0.48954372623574144 0.2644367308299148 0.6050895101616365 0.07991876231528308 0.42590048431961447 0.21676266771260233 proxy
50 stunnel direct tls-init-ka-1k tls-init-stream1-down 1 0 0.20057161728 7.51032531588814 19614.83 nan 3.06 nan 7.43 nan 0 0 0 10.14 1.47 7.742308 0.0 40.44440639213457 0.15657359394850548 51.18446092263272 nan 16.53125 0.0 0.15878378378378377 0.3944349524041982 0.9629629629629629 0.13828786453433678 0.34713879228580463 0.3574575204531152 0.3967153990647493 0.8018173519591436 0.29566125559174905 0.7570818855351054 proxy none
51 direct 3proxy-devel tls-init-ka-1k tls-init-stream1-down 1 0 1.09689438208 6.091370550384604 107289.65 nan 0.5740000000000001 nan 0.97 nan 0 0 0 7.52 9.99 0.0 7.412558000000001 5.484575450730345 1.311880811167123 6.9395227970706355 nan 0.0 10.7890625 0.6395262768319763 0.16613418530351437 0.735812133072407 0.950523311132255 0.9582410629547612 0.29310344827586204 1.9627920411500144 0.3710849233465248 0.844395054470617 0.6274470011467818 origin proxy
52 3proxy-current haproxy tls-init-ka-1m tls-init-stream1-down 1 0 5.15547070464 5.22049901865726 614.33 nan 25.29 nan 56.81 nan 0 0 0 10.0 9.98 7.447799 7.435752 1.551749676862654 1.5291885729007673 1627.0745200130166 nan 19.98828125 38.7890625 0.19309100283578243 0.13622828784119106 0.999000999000999 0.9486692015209125 0.2816015883520847 0.2842476740455566 0.46749050126567226 0.31206799999373924 0.33340386717275095 0.5968167494416051 proxy
53 haproxy nginx tls-init-ka-1m tls-init-stream1-down 1 0 5.1187286016 5.819827488827418 609.75 nan 25.05 nan 39.17 nan 0 0 0 10.11 10.02 7.567824 7.378045 1.580079865432184 1.3772164949759493 1641.7668074050016 nan 52.67578125 36.5703125 0.19812252964426877 0.16601178781925344 0.9601139601139601 0.9524714828897338 0.25962145110410095 0.30380556443875917 0.4947301677400869 0.3653853490708076 0.3536716902270825 0.6493793133839354 proxy
54 nginx envoy tls-init-ka-1m tls-init-stream1-down 1 0 5.42801657856 7.788301416058057 646.82 nan 23.59 nan 36.77 nan 0 0 0 10.01 9.98 7.3381739999999995 8.656368 1.4753086848759116 1.0250172640021944 1546.1847389558234 nan 45.08984375 32.48046875 0.1848387890721142 0.06501182033096926 0.9515209125475285 0.9504761904761905 0.27835375431982406 0.3600638977635783 0.4794874384374446 0.1465382931598391 0.24717662919930292 0.7673225486173552 proxy
55 stunnel tls-init-ka-1m tls-init-stream1-down 1 0 4.56038285312 4.702044255838254 543.48 nan 28.92 nan 61.02 nan 0 0 0 8 10.02 10.04 7.748921999999999 7.908345 1.7577471581176194 1.7080480108315121 1841.9117647058824 nan 19.328125 10.13671875 0.16544117647058823 0.1281165144408788 0.9533777354900095 0.9534662867996201 0.23479357075323037 0.23504956827630316 0.4214135455095488 0.29207382522659653 0.2452523290157053 0.5048360994072054 proxy
56 direct tls-init-ka-1m tls-init-stream16 1 0 24.30951489536 16.499858853486494 2893.37 nan 5.24 nan 10.82 nan 0 0 0 357 8.25 1.8 0.0 0.27149863040910593 0.086889656161025 282.31187763063343 nan 0.0 0.7631141704248754 0.5853543677890275 0.840122199592668 0.16901408450704225 0.9569347688410387 0.9235368156073002 2.590333892278712 1.682704799217022 0.8539590235113941 8.10781805270257 origin
57 3proxy-current 3proxy-devel tls-init-close-1k tls-init-stream16 1 0 0.008724152320000001 6.842659828981578 853.33 nan 72.04 nan 123.14 nan 0 0 0 338 10.08 10.07 9.078254000000001 7.837721 924.3304912860576 1.1716229439974304 1177.2950245269797 nan 106.28515625 94.38671875 0.03732762719923918 0.05892135899263483 0.9572649572649573 0.9572243346007605 0.2735312697409981 0.5597589554737195 0.0646964799238412 0.13211400166511136 0.2338931695429387 0.8271743928075266 proxy
58 haproxy tls-init-close-1k tls-init-stream16 1 0 0.010317987839999999 5.862325867743212 1014.39 nan 61.2 nan 89.13 nan 0 0 0 10 10.03 9.006401 7.438014 777.6710076060721 1.3676024439439092 987.2047244094488 nan 40.25390625 54.84375 0.04085510688836105 0.06178707224334601 0.9552380952380952 0.9525166191832859 0.2985781990521327 0.7143330023171135 0.06945446102926073 0.11787160954103942 0.2519581519683936 1.0741883155495973 proxy origin
59 nginx tls-init-close-1k tls-init-stream16 1 0 0.0130023424 6.8431736274537 1280.33 nan 48.97 nan 65.27 nan 0 0 0 422 10.07 10.11 8.833155999999999 7.917688 619.5806687878024 1.1710265790814582 785.1239669421487 nan 33.2734375 114.35546875 0.05444602948169282 0.056769596199524944 0.956315289648623 0.9601139601139601 0.3599621092516577 0.5375703409467064 0.096097654203865 0.12737086928086372 0.3118427993095415 0.7633546910784156 proxy
60 stunnel envoy tls-init-close-1k tls-init-stream16 1 0 0.0100663296 7.334330547432625 987.32 nan 60.97 nan 179.83 nan 0 0 0 5705 10.07 8.884551 7.92617 800.2916971842449 1.0932946682844875 1017.7885587224581 nan 26.97265625 148.0234375 0.04238095238095238 0.06285578747628083 0.956315289648623 0.25370779425686335 0.5339425587467362 0.07610681090710829 0.14637366469341512 0.21579858590296877 0.8619641543333603 proxy
61 direct stunnel tls-init-close-1k tls-init-stream16 1 0 0.0390070272 5.626352686394712 3833.45 nan 1.35 nan 4.49 nan 0 0 0 283 2.97 10.08 0.0 8.019518 60.912101499495975 1.427484442866689 77.23312963203745 nan 0.0 102.74609375 0.9522451888809693 0.04898929845422117 0.28557692307692306 0.9572649572649573 0.8707526198793267 0.5078464106844741 3.599204587241182 0.10932185788223023 0.7957784211213861 0.6904925012520765 client proxy
62 haproxy 3proxy-devel tls-term-ka-1k 2 1 0.3388997632 0.24058527744 33146.84 23533.73 1.8 2.51 3.07 5.95 0 0 0 10.03 10.12 7.025264 7.394785 23.676617310778926 33.651269463149404 30.20756785408811 42.576286018402044 38.6328125 14.36328125 0.2640661938534279 0.2523386903334133 0.9525166191832859 0.9610636277302944 0.3856516290726817 0.33365384615384613 0.7468796501643881 0.7163582660819358 0.362099393159481 0.2728282563404937 proxy
63 nginx haproxy tls-term-ka-1k 2 1 0.36373004288 0.33185333248000004 35576.38 32458.11 1.64 1.84 2.72 3.11 0 0 0 10.02 6.674969 7.041486 22.03832253318871 24.155249369035957 28.118738529406812 30.825173276236008 35.046875 37.1640625 0.279613025011798 0.2658317580340265 0.9524714828897338 0.4095894703854591 0.3942337825133187 0.7849563178023642 0.7515882214030223 0.3289797478182464 0.3156306999875652 proxy
64 stunnel nginx tls-term-ka-1k 2 1 0.20627587072 0.3686793216 20172.31 36056.55 2.93 1.65 6.77 2.6 0 0 0 10.03 10.02 7.639314000000001 6.6448030000000005 38.89936312954326 21.742472469603243 49.69011795829597 27.77238836996591 16.109375 37.1015625 0.20660761311946374 0.2921908378827439 0.9534220532319392 0.9515669515669516 0.2871696911811525 0.4232469993682881 0.5822243005878621 0.8352639706876831 0.23768837393448636 0.38311186136133746 proxy
65 direct envoy tls-term-ka-1k 2 1 1.09613940736 0.27749515263999996 107215.88 27141.48 0.519 2.31 1.18 4.03 0 0 0 7.24 10.07 0.0 7.345847 5.28399942663293 29.031137745498604 6.68562774720201 36.73546814921823 0.0 23.97265625 0.6309435821630943 0.25587529976019185 0.7029126213592233 0.9581351094196003 0.9585311807534029 0.35412026726057905 1.928793342330788 0.7325621669718656 0.8492639797650146 0.3204048794971974 origin proxy
66 3proxy-current stunnel tls-term-ka-1k 2 1 0.24905777152 0.20073938944 24356.11 19637.33 2.49 2.95 5.12 12.2 0 0 0 10.11 10.12 7.467399 7.700559 32.47439319254694 40.330898796620346 41.09856337959462 51.025295840833344 14.01171875 16.22265625 0.23248026787849796 0.21466346153846153 0.9601139601139601 0.9619771863117871 0.3248326426522155 0.2859897172236504 0.648899048000669 0.6136469613029831 0.27860010218781583 0.22911792815524312 proxy
67 haproxy direct tls-term-ka-1m tls-term-ka-1k 2 1 6.06773182464 1.0461433036799999 722.77 102325.03 21.77 0.595 29.9 1.05 0 0 0 10.1 7.36 7.316416 0.0 1.3316343295180795 5.628292012468929 1383.5616438356165 7.121721443929022 48.5078125 0.0 0.2947290274684484 0.638909541511772 0.9600760456273765 0.7104247104247104 0.07561436672967864 0.9563567362428842 0.8123886312990025 1.9680999514500503 0.03707507168062021 0.8508707648756154 proxy origin
68 nginx 3proxy-devel tls-term-ka-1m 2 1 5.82177783808 6.1052289023999995 693.84 727.53 21.17 21.3 35.66 49.18 0 0 0 10.0 10.01 7.48522 7.450235 1.3741506842930937 1.311662531908019 1440.2995823131212 1374.6223564954682 47.0625 18.7421875 0.24687199230028875 0.2612872238232469 0.9514747859181731 0.9515209125475285 0.055888853804862644 0.06255924170616113 0.7107182919596713 0.7590859466090741 0.04086582169203762 0.051330857901977084 proxy
69 stunnel haproxy tls-term-ka-1m 2 1 4.642339553279999 5.480361492479999 553.13 653.02 27.4 23.66 70.17 34.7 0 0 0 10.03 10.1 7.776821 7.325695 1.728438841646282 1.474355297745806 1812.1047877145438 1531.4632297194844 19.6953125 48.7890625 0.20920096852300243 0.2999752903385224 0.9534220532319392 0.9600760456273765 0.04724159797083069 0.06409851594568992 0.5917782925101898 0.8247263038649035 0.03612834129274017 0.03707373395550695 proxy
70 direct nginx tls-term-ka-1m 2 1 22.59152797696 5.654676766720001 2687.25 673.85 4.87 22.58 15.31 35.56 0 0 0 7.98 10.02 0.0 7.461974 0.2825838078110844 1.4175876589758971 293.9767913059495 1485.7651245551601 0.0 47.93359375 0.7588838540424517 0.2518625330449411 0.806060606060606 0.9524714828897338 0.9553656220322887 0.06200818382121498 2.5740331857966865 0.7276811631277783 0.8729504556873563 0.04752599678496451 origin proxy
71 3proxy-current envoy tls-term-ka-1m 2 1 4.91790532608 5.73512351744 585.98 683.39 26.45 22.52 61.09 36.18 0 0 0 10.02 10.01 7.152266 7.545095 1.6299622437810228 1.3963082007995793 1708.4398976982097 1463.8783269961978 18.70703125 46.14453125 0.279446828803052 0.24554737592020898 0.9524714828897338 0.9524262607040913 0.05083675402589201 0.06186868686868687 0.8285317016944691 0.7249132469004583 0.03232033074241261 0.05418122027883975 proxy
72 haproxy stunnel tls-term-close-1k tls-term-ka-1m 2 1 0.01409286144 4.50921234432 1387.75 537.25 27.01 27.95 39.65 76.75 0 0 0 10.11 10.05 8.923624 7.799951 573.9075796944753 1.783016497355139 721.318493150685 1869.419642857143 38.125 20.16796875 0.7507149666348903 0.21642512077294687 0.961941008563273 0.9535104364326376 0.06586064269805918 0.05439595192915876 2.86757815205729 0.6163941318855918 0.03042395324596571 0.03230501831404746 client proxy
73 nginx direct tls-term-close-1k tls-term-ka-1m 2 1 0.01459617792 21.131239096319998 1432.73 2515.02 3.04 6.18 4.44 11.69 0 0 0 10.12 8.22 8.793505999999999 0.0 554.6657518408765 0.3111980310300501 699.3296938704996 323.5838286816518 32.4140625 0.0 0.9582047019710282 0.7578571428571429 0.9619771863117871 0.8311425682507584 0.08290978398983481 0.9588216661387393 3.7058639902721384 2.5521928184605907 0.0370772087119028 0.8548553913300087 client origin
74 stunnel 3proxy-devel tls-term-close-1k 2 1 0.01023410176 0.01241513984 1006.86 1223.08 23.44 19.6 57.25 42.72 0 0 0 10.13 10.1 8.976559 8.805891 791.8623627209273 650.8182834934544 996.0668633235005 817.3504896010359 44.88671875 20.01171875 0.9324774132192106 0.9517814726840855 0.9629277566539924 0.9609895337773549 0.056615776081424936 0.07419150285351934 3.6263739757288787 3.6931023490886203 0.02660811878950716 0.03230757767299401 client
75 direct haproxy tls-term-close-1k 2 1 0.03539992576 0.01350565888 3472.31 1326.3 1.36 28.11 4.65 50.66 0 0 0 2.8 10.11 0.0 8.914606 63.2769688610782 598.8600831594525 80.45052292839904 754.533920441824 0.0 38.5 0.9515324305060584 0.7743162901307967 0.2697495183044316 0.9601139601139601 0.859493670886076 0.06571428571428571 3.5989094224272002 2.9645510598126523 0.8078214488024834 0.030401723835461417 client
76 3proxy-current nginx tls-term-close-1k 2 1 0.01291845632 0.013841203199999999 1265.46 1359.44 19.2 3.15 43.25 4.74 0 0 0 10.13 8.866699 8.756054 627.3195341035918 585.498231830019 792.5827400046944 737.7467045371786 26.51171875 32.37890625 0.9517585551330798 0.9581749049429658 0.961100569259962 0.9620132953466287 0.06925031766200762 0.08507936507936507 3.6878071840084887 3.7055384378513323 0.03137736114803411 0.03612375334975298 client
77 haproxy envoy tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-close-1k 2 1 0.33839644672 0.022481469440000002 33094.55 2208.11 1.81 21.02 3.17 31.49 0 0 0 10.1 10.0 7.065385 8.389932 23.877319275416767 355.84862552472015 30.216632311452702 451.9569736961041 37.65234375 27.546875 0.22140133460438513 0.8848441589340947 0.9600760456273765 0.9505703422053232 0.425512104283054 0.0922930542340628 0.548914173442944 3.3868945881353416 0.4049978454420713 0.041831216601638604 proxy client
78 nginx stunnel tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-close-1k 2 1 0.375390208 0.01040187392 36713.93 1023.22 1.65 22.04 2.71 53.28 0 0 0 10.1 10.06 6.743352 8.91971 21.524269487604748 773.7067437941029 27.237889252360393 981.6549570647932 36.015625 32.15625 0.24158653846153846 0.9448538150701212 0.9600760456273765 0.9562737642585551 0.5014344915524387 0.061010486177311724 0.6107614796798443 3.6922447212409866 0.44380242302070183 0.027569361636001734 proxy client
79 stunnel direct tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-close-1k 2 1 0.21877489664 0.03388997632 21400.55 3325.48 2.82 1.51 7.15 4.39 0 0 0 10.12 2.66 7.670164000000001 0.0 37.00607393416891 62.79142776338181 46.821721207186116 79.70992778160678 16.2265625 0.0 0.16017316017316016 0.952007602755999 0.9619771863117871 0.2550335570469799 0.3560126582278481 0.8679544015199493 0.4034064305763258 3.6044816494783274 0.285231512111838 0.84014239731083 proxy client
80 direct 3proxy-devel tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-stream1-down 2 1 1.0775166976 6.777909340164613 105386.82 nan 0.597 nan 1.04 nan 0 0 0 7.4 9.55 0.0 7.609268 5.494114395800896 1.1270723288902251 6.952240923332754 nan 0.0 8.5 0.629866929521932 0.39004658004412845 0.7212475633528265 0.895032802249297 0.9585049097244219 0.07538317172349077 1.9318361435249158 0.764707997581304 0.8442186732191183 0.12218539457260721 origin none
81 3proxy-current haproxy tls-init-ka-1k tls-term-stream1-down 2 1 0.24486346752000002 6.511348322089533 23952.57 nan 2.52 nan 6.79 nan 0 0 0 10.1 9.79 7.466133 7.76732 32.99798080062735 1.2027660621729064 41.74899347723647 nan 15.53125 38.328125 0.1762866762866763 0.3940511307767945 0.9600760456273765 0.9175257731958762 0.3820366856419987 0.07142857142857142 0.4433571685833449 0.7846908957395419 0.3318177913299525 0.11176733864119884 proxy
82 haproxy nginx tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream1-down 2 1 5.15161194496 6.388193022225373 613.07 nan 25.1 nan 36.43 nan 0 0 0 10.11 9.96 7.561844000000001 7.455176 1.5699940302981807 1.2472715109193422 1632.7519379844962 nan 48.96875 35.66015625 0.20385947550717468 0.398369967893307 0.9610266159695817 0.9369708372530574 0.25702557625513106 0.07478097622027534 0.509897082368172 0.7523181694608292 0.2785221479454837 0.11835996641196735 proxy
83 nginx envoy tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream1-down 2 1 5.39672707072 6.878771710384555 643.07 nan 24.31 nan 33.38 nan 0 0 0 37 10.02 9.33 7.355081 7.673685 1.4853447089238385 1.084962976718731 1557.109557109557 nan 45.12109375 32.8671875 0.1896212493851451 0.3852178169358786 0.9524714828897338 0.8744142455482662 0.2780395852968897 0.07211988760536997 0.4823316183459257 0.7818843898862599 0.29186636453340337 0.13058873653378722 proxy none
84 stunnel tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream1-down 2 1 4.606184652800001 5.477174966278608 548.86 nan 28.55 nan 58.96 nan 0 0 0 3 10.04 9.95 7.74968 7.847276 1.743742512605855 1.4531484606802736 1828.1136198106337 nan 19.22265625 7.87890625 0.16042385411532775 0.3928202479338843 0.9534662867996201 0.9822309970384995 0.23423707440100883 0.07056120774532326 0.39953144165606513 0.7170010577723507 0.34316182816272983 0.11234308108424469 proxy
85 direct tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream1-down 2 1 20.95944040448 7.7124235050519285 2500.99 nan 6.86 nan 13.27 nan 0 0 0 7.96 1.43 0.0 0.30382490548931185 0.14831678217060454 315.09777531470195 nan 0.0 0.7287043664996421 0.41544401544401544 0.8008048289738431 0.14102564102564102 0.9344729344729344 0.37532981530343007 2.4373570409781307 0.8039674922719308 0.8358760954322354 0.7897114282891569 origin none
86 3proxy-current 3proxy-devel tls-init-ka-1m tls-term-stream16 2 1 5.04801263616 6.399134395557837 601.58 nan 25.75 nan 57.86 nan 0 0 0 286 10.01 10.06 7.463358 7.417442 1.586366868941051 1.2537646239504552 1662.7906976744187 nan 17.8671875 76.8671875 0.1805213969503197 0.23665564478034956 0.9515209125475285 0.9428303655107779 0.26418663303909207 0.2221487603305785 0.46422173811209644 0.66607419779506 0.3127123492444544 0.36788902552055647 proxy
87 haproxy tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 2 1 0.01015021568 5.25119474979544 992.76 nan 62.58 nan 83.25 nan 0 0 0 507 10.05 10.04 9.013471 7.545478 792.1013950316375 1.528894055882118 1010.4564649105168 nan 40.19921875 43.83203125 0.04467680608365019 0.21996695775312722 0.9553231939163498 0.9409559512652296 0.31021437578814626 0.20805592543275633 0.07706499279148822 0.5918508233665358 0.2605029856855648 0.3714092144411958 proxy
88 nginx tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 2 1 0.01291845632 5.685491239876813 1265.49 nan 49.44 nan 70.91 nan 0 0 0 214 10.08 10.09 8.822935999999999 7.545533 624.2231889204546 1.4079926623315013 795.5173230210718 nan 31.58203125 85.4921875 0.05611031859248693 0.2238241550460884 0.9581749049429658 0.9483082706766918 0.3640654499685337 0.21896383186705767 0.09894778197969596 0.621425753292232 0.30901439407837994 0.3547280028887528 proxy
89 stunnel envoy tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 2 1 0.00939524096 6.811969600638648 919.55 nan 64.89 nan 159.59 nan 0 0 0 432 10.07 10.1 8.890711000000001 8.923905999999999 857.4553898402622 1.1789248304156084 1093.1393834129397 nan 35.2890625 139.29296875 0.04349893035417162 0.26030624263839813 0.9572243346007605 0.9465791940018744 0.24677368586717027 0.08502657080337606 0.07515966943447495 0.7219528311862721 0.2014633377112483 0.14917633696485025 proxy
90 direct stunnel tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 2 1 0.039258685439999996 4.482254556558468 3851.0 nan 1.39 nan 4.23 nan 0 0 0 275 2.94 10.07 0.0 7.845625 59.91030962039263 1.792366623033023 76.22109302084414 nan 0.0 81.6875 0.9519961977186312 0.18577168518080833 0.2829643888354187 0.9446529080675422 0.879277566539924 0.17371353654539495 3.5797071030662435 0.5233774799132344 0.8374755337159332 0.29346149200910193 client proxy
91 3proxy-current direct tls-init-close-1k tls-term-stream16 2 1 0.009227468800000001 16.015143423796545 902.41 nan 67.44 nan 116.26 nan 0 0 0 396 10.1 1.89 9.073845 0.0 875.6464177911932 0.09412058291327519 1116.8859891628883 nan 74.41015625 0.0 0.03851640513552068 0.5851938895417156 0.957345971563981 0.17746478873239438 0.29058749210360074 0.9249371859296482 0.06752228756023755 1.683811797303392 0.2508956313242431 1.7502437122495316 proxy origin
92 3proxy-devel tls-init-ka-1k 1 0.23379050496 22864.77 2.6 14.44 0 0 0 10.1 7.405217 34.56085610227171 43.73525017862169 15.765625 0.185789726356217 0.9600760456273765 0.3856082607292675 0.4623346985270433 0.3127445963278598 proxy
93 haproxy tls-init-ka-1k 1 0.30685528064 30009.61 1.98 4.1 0 0 0 10.11 7.101384 26.357701855842503 33.35510818140428 40.796875 0.22169249106078665 0.9601139601139601 0.429821819318537 0.5488927974373623 0.36310268041072635 proxy
94 nginx tls-init-ka-1k 1 0.32690405376 31971.09 1.84 3.09 0 0 0 10.11 6.791938 24.74120435942311 31.308936518111803 36.09765625 0.2318562874251497 0.9601139601139601 0.47014218009478675 0.5793548719560367 0.4591288786848607 proxy
95 envoy tls-init-ka-1k 1 0.3112173568 30438.3 2.01 3.87 0 0 0 10.08 7.339404999999999 25.911151238207548 32.7896582458834 23.56640625 0.2147297943567671 0.9590865842055185 0.44992050874403816 0.546028495545099 0.42755951301028444 proxy
96 stunnel tls-init-ka-1k 1 0.18975031296 18562.92 3.17 12.61 0 0 0 10.12 7.720931 42.666596295452024 53.97477266060428 16.71484375 0.15832335329341318 0.9619771863117871 0.3290570878768441 0.3852942957659553 0.2918545363042167 proxy
97 direct tls-init-ka-1k 1 0.98977185792 96806.69 0.582 1.31 0 0 0 7.29 0.0 5.89226694347111 7.455947012660792 0.0 0.632112815437902 0.7063953488372093 0.9578446909667195 1.935960064564296 0.8469917496875562 origin
98 3proxy-devel tls-init-ka-1m 1 5.01311602688 597.33 25.49 59.61 0 0 0 10.01 7.292004 1.5974096663754893 1674.4730679156908 19.8046875 0.18762230919765166 0.9515209125475285 0.27851291745431633 0.4755833541381246 0.25281457203352964 proxy
99 haproxy tls-init-ka-1m 1 4.639403540479999 552.38 27.07 40.96 0 0 0 10.09 7.514806 1.7398788291576075 1808.5678436995877 50.35546875 0.1948629291183008 0.9600380589914367 0.24456350456980774 0.48605896317095715 0.29179928444947434 proxy
100 nginx tls-init-ka-1m 1 5.34404661248 636.87 24.15 37.14 0 0 0 10.02 7.348424 1.499986916521305 1572.0112958895513 44.85546875 0.19219440353460973 0.9515669515669516 0.2951181102362205 0.49089435273934007 0.27568115684768685 proxy
101 envoy tls-init-ka-1m 1 6.35252506624 757.1 20.76 32.78 0 0 0 10.03 8.454549 1.2631197699073906 1320.9535098116687 48.328125 0.1295287710158655 0.9525166191832859 0.31798245614035087 0.40147456427613315 0.284247782539958 proxy
102 stunnel tls-init-ka-1m 1 4.412072263680001 525.71 29.48 64.35 0 0 0 10.03 7.735322 1.8186465498430844 1906.8441064638782 20.3203125 0.16351583599312547 0.9534220532319392 0.2371491643014822 0.41763576489220217 0.25097826572548027 proxy
103 direct tls-init-ka-1m 1 22.3338299392 2660.21 5.84 10.38 0 0 0 8.29 0.0 0.2969486209062429 308.556965794469 0.0 0.80732635585157 0.8382204246713852 0.9585443037974684 2.7559459621246556 0.83378802605234 origin
104 3proxy-devel tls-init-close-1k 1 0.00661086208 649.15 92.14 167.06 0 0 0 10.21 9.229690999999999 1235.5423394341938 1570.7692307692307 245.3125 0.03233475986685687 0.9677725118483412 0.23042929292929293 0.05327597843602479 0.19478849580430974 proxy
105 haproxy tls-init-close-1k 1 0.009814671359999999 964.15 64.22 89.94 0 0 0 10.05 8.996122999999999 819.1817846053688 1040.588113481052 40.48828125 0.042972459639126305 0.9535104364326376 0.3013003488740882 0.0723029348335669 0.25658274132482833 proxy
106 nginx tls-init-close-1k 1 0.01199570944 1179.71 52.05 72.02 0 0 0 10.06 8.821459 670.9065470662151 851.748370163407 31.71484375 0.05767861381438405 0.9562737642585551 0.3602523659305994 0.09799210874810978 0.3051810942577959 proxy
107 envoy tls-init-close-1k 1 0.02701131776 2648.78 25.85 33.13 0 0 0 10.0 7.53495 296.1721479522515 376.9601930036188 25.37109375 0.08483412322274882 0.9514747859181731 0.3000952683391553 0.17028274795259593 0.22149084640344327 proxy
108 stunnel tls-init-close-1k 1 0.00956301312 940.82 64.09 134.51 0 0 0 10.08 8.880436000000001 843.2488692434213 1069.609507640068 34.0625 0.044016178919819175 0.9581749049429658 0.2582886011998737 0.0780159399501272 0.21478690327275426 proxy
109 direct tls-init-close-1k 1 0.0339738624 3336.8 1.48 4.44 0 0 0 2.58 0.0 60.75258608217593 77.12082262210797 0.0 0.9515669515669516 0.2473633748801534 0.8701298701298701 3.596700224334168 0.8504363119407453 client
110 3proxy-devel tls-init-stream1-down 1 6.133944966178552 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 7.496550999999999 1.3040808374213728 nan 10.62890625 0.16373840897999023 0.9514747859181731 0.29824 0.3749050152067912 0.6428098887296081 proxy
111 haproxy tls-init-stream1-down 1 4.9296750490498304 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.02 7.670416 1.6258992982076013 nan 39.8046875 0.14485637122514117 0.9515669515669516 0.25143769968051116 0.31400832008877133 0.5391051676669245 proxy
112 nginx tls-init-stream1-down 1 5.960508081584328 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 7.2652589999999995 1.3434820873922508 nan 33.0859375 0.1706837186424004 0.9515209125475285 0.3100899742930591 0.3787020849981426 0.6646366554210981 proxy
113 envoy tls-init-stream1-down 1 7.391248288658627 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.94 8.38443 1.0757515552744128 nan 30.41796875 0.0689410092395167 0.9466666666666667 0.35768985322271857 0.1560433694609397 0.7397200738212938 proxy
114 stunnel tls-init-stream1-down 1 4.647629931634322 nan nan nan 0 0 7 10.03 7.7758970000000005 1.7262864814211671 nan 6.1796875 0.13894324853228962 0.9525166191832859 0.2464833759590793 0.3120326945206376 0.5190391453461016 proxy
115 direct tls-init-stream1-down 1 7.424191430329656 nan nan nan 0 0 2 1.52 0.0 0.16378334422004096 nan 0.0 0.4142270159219312 0.15004935834155972 0.3711169861202908 0.806835386562984 0.7853450250871016 none
116 3proxy-devel tls-init-stream16 1 7.0580551345748965 nan nan nan 0 0 361 10.06 7.850505999999999 1.1359180230934023 nan 99.46484375 0.05827783063748811 0.9553656220322887 0.5584329349269588 0.1321325179278397 0.8063560646592222 proxy
117 haproxy tls-init-stream16 1 4.817428192038526 nan nan nan 0 0 249 10.01 7.571764000000001 1.661378334010888 nan 55.43359375 0.05576649264356905 0.9515209125475285 0.606425702811245 0.09979419689304676 0.8640512357873212 proxy
118 nginx tls-init-stream16 1 6.734199711767152 nan nan nan 0 0 363 10.11 7.896966 1.1888774289205675 nan 114.54296875 0.055687767729652546 0.961941008563273 0.529431216931217 0.12547183040801566 0.7332136585318135 proxy
119 envoy tls-init-stream16 1 7.226866948849155 nan nan nan 0 0 5520 10.07 7.894514 1.1100708413478906 nan 146.3984375 0.061804404451811505 0.956315289648623 0.516590761223162 0.1397480801155369 0.8206870463097911 proxy
120 stunnel tls-init-stream16 1 5.672833873410656 nan nan nan 0 0 262 10.09 8.017217 1.41722064178196 nan 96.6328125 0.04966730038022814 0.9573055028462998 0.5086493679308051 0.11122284289756777 0.6924045799893166 proxy
121 direct tls-init-stream16 1 16.669870786761685 nan nan nan 0 0 351 1.8 0.0 0.08614673932646646 nan 0.0 0.5733051841426225 0.16901408450704225 0.9123857548061771 1.6547693509923322 1.730440452660327 origin
122 haproxy tls-term-ka-1k 2 0.329252864 32202.84 1.82 3.19 0 0 0 10.02 7.0114920000000005 24.346029682523884 31.0670701458478 37.1640625 0.2688222799150342 0.9524714828897338 0.39617314930991215 0.7610692311183535 0.30325132758570317 proxy
123 nginx tls-term-ka-1k 2 0.3372220416 32984.98 1.8 2.74 0 0 0 10.03 6.7356940000000005 23.79441142675295 30.341439509212847 35.05078125 0.28277330809275913 0.9525166191832859 0.4054820415879017 0.80005281595184 0.3897619751259341 proxy
124 envoy tls-term-ka-1k 2 0.3112173568 30436.36 1.95 3.75 0 0 0 10.09 7.336266 25.93685674538831 32.82464353217889 24.3828125 0.2793628150261531 0.9591254752851711 0.3863204559848005 0.7924550687823478 0.3202520254040063 proxy
125 stunnel tls-term-ka-1k 2 0.1862270976 18211.81 3.22 11.18 0 0 0 10.13 7.726447 43.51676047385276 55.07559982384507 16.23046875 0.21734985700667303 0.9620132953466287 0.28917969996808174 0.5878981119594319 0.2661752418622385 proxy
126 direct tls-term-ka-1k 2 0.97106526208 94977.36 0.622 1.03 0 0 0 7.45 0.0 6.137589544943471 7.766451846956072 0.0 0.6391089108910891 0.7233009708737864 0.9588347055098163 1.9585169070902544 0.8379191384919805 origin
127 3proxy-devel tls-term-ka-1k 2 0.22984785919999998 22480.59 2.67 6.03 0 0 0 10.1 7.388892 35.15368830548586 44.4835939220436 14.37109375 0.24719101123595505 0.9600760456273765 0.3267931810871663 0.683053267403589 0.3023032110186354 proxy
128 haproxy tls-term-ka-1m 2 5.78419687424 688.76 22.31 35.24 0 0 0 10.11 7.352988 1.3982926542524892 1453.421506612996 49.4921875 0.29149198520345254 0.9601139601139601 0.06719242902208201 0.799161700451357 0.038978444116790405 proxy
129 nginx tls-term-ka-1m 2 5.92797761536 706.47 21.82 33.15 0 0 0 10.01 7.509201999999999 1.350882294030674 1415.6413520011313 48.171875 0.2593480345158197 0.9515209125475285 0.06090249289996844 0.7562664402028803 0.043728221841974155 proxy
130 envoy tls-term-ka-1m 2 6.31133700096 751.94 21.0 31.48 0 0 0 10.03 7.5293719999999995 1.2713629455659698 1332.890365448505 45.64453125 0.2587594696969697 0.9516129032258065 0.06614173228346457 0.7676486679977432 0.0456090921779366 proxy
131 stunnel tls-term-ka-1m 2 4.83452256256 575.93 26.25 69.91 0 0 0 10.02 7.787783 1.658074793585269 1738.3761276891048 20.01171875 0.22013034033309195 0.9533777354900095 0.05203045685279188 0.6307144379513957 0.0351734766358953 proxy
132 direct tls-term-ka-1m 2 19.49915152384 2325.01 6.72 13.14 0 0 0 8.12 0.0 0.3331427006994575 345.81150717601463 0.0 0.7318409145034532 0.8193743693239153 0.9537974683544304 2.4733511309377647 0.8453802202803354 origin
133 3proxy-devel tls-term-ka-1m 2 5.89668810752 702.67 21.49 52.53 0 0 0 10.02 7.462343 1.359407154293485 1424.7120716621641 21.1953125 0.25538535184298705 0.9515669515669516 0.061198738170347 0.7343611511208081 0.05132466972602156 proxy
134 haproxy tls-term-close-1k 2 0.013170114560000001 1290.81 28.57 53.51 0 0 0 10.09 8.915245 612.9027931553542 773.9510623609726 38.18359375 0.7568403521294313 0.960952380952381 0.06630710659898477 2.8871627857227327 0.030418026958914324 client
135 nginx tls-term-close-1k 2 0.01308622848 1282.22 3.27 5.44 0 0 0 10.12 8.743829 618.6656462840544 781.4671814671815 34.26171875 0.9538863798431186 0.9610636277302944 0.091426763682379 3.6960002972247388 0.03992728533245066 client
136 envoy tls-term-close-1k 2 0.01996488704 1958.38 22.97 33.36 0 0 0 10.0 8.365652 400.7034942883404 509.7879282218597 24.765625 0.9170233000475512 0.9514747859181731 0.09838146620120597 3.5248328330071175 0.04468149465514618 client
137 stunnel tls-term-close-1k 2 0.00998244352 981.56 21.22 53.08 0 0 0 10.13 8.965724 811.8252794281776 1021.7873713939883 39.875 0.9524714828897338 0.9629277566539924 0.06414734836456018 3.7055428924816685 0.027568887986306533 client
138 direct tls-term-close-1k 2 0.03632267264 3569.56 1.73 5.33 0 0 0 2.73 0.0 60.127734036698904 76.04880494735083 0.0 0.9534331195058209 0.2619961612284069 0.9041574103459219 3.588052577307687 0.8343079303115016 origin
139 3proxy-devel tls-term-close-1k 2 0.00931135488 915.19 25.74 51.8 0 0 0 10.09 8.895892 866.8985452737893 1091.28271685053 62.00390625 0.9510107015457788 0.9591254752851711 0.06253968253968253 3.704490114385741 0.026617144126606217 client
140 haproxy tls-term-stream1-down 2 5.302554843793358 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.85 7.7463049999999996 1.4860203700305017 nan 38.76171875 0.368986568986569 0.9257518796992481 0.0699344364658133 0.7323634714766126 0.10888657700448262 proxy
141 nginx tls-term-stream1-down 2 5.25909138117809 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.84 7.618736999999999 1.4968246872196194 nan 36.03515625 0.38342351205115593 0.924812030075188 0.06887914840325611 0.7303719745619792 0.10706374951805704 proxy
142 envoy tls-term-stream1-down 2 6.917778773006712 nan nan nan 0 0 51 9.12 7.569824 1.0545631725522884 nan 32.0078125 0.3991801178580579 0.8941176470588236 0.07730101539469375 0.7569942127826226 0.13990350085749714 none
143 stunnel tls-term-stream1-down 2 4.724236505582047 nan nan nan 0 0 8 9.99 7.856866 1.6902324388971128 nan 6.9921875 0.3659135559921415 0.9389097744360902 0.06924516531503432 0.6971319212187429 0.09958308780794305 proxy
144 direct tls-term-stream1-down 2 7.12681696258761 nan nan nan 0 0 0 1.68 0.0 0.18857134384516924 nan 0.0 0.4154043645699615 0.16535433070866143 0.38365194462755436 0.798939947914091 0.795692847977105 none
145 3proxy-devel tls-term-stream1-down 2 5.589366736662486 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.67 7.574899 1.3840398671266767 nan 8.40625 0.4052590873936582 0.9517716535433071 0.08120497707924033 0.7498378177438761 0.12415641967975921 proxy
146 haproxy tls-term-stream16 2 4.96613614028804 nan nan nan 0 0 466 10.03 7.534289 1.614712226972157 nan 43.26171875 0.21573724007561437 0.9409005628517824 0.21319120586275817 0.5794262362632789 0.37798477295436833 proxy
147 nginx tls-term-stream16 2 6.108448277671506 nan nan nan 0 0 221 10.1 7.5052389999999995 1.3145825403146698 nan 80.41015625 0.2256689557186834 0.9465791940018744 0.21903820816864294 0.6280822074124501 0.35563504646872457 proxy
148 envoy tls-term-stream16 2 7.257016197788897 nan nan nan 0 0 535 10.07 8.925799999999999 1.106027711582965 nan 138.19140625 0.26298394711992445 0.9455399061032864 0.08320300281513919 0.732572825428969 0.15015417969546402 proxy
149 stunnel tls-term-stream16 2 4.93465688449111 nan nan nan 0 0 250 10.08 7.863481 1.6297426649783842 nan 94.40625 0.1862884160756501 0.9447047797563262 0.18262586377097728 0.5232369679199749 0.3093901908498831 proxy
150 direct tls-term-stream16 2 17.61709791981296 nan nan nan 0 0 448 1.95 0.0 0.08829426836049009 nan 0.0 0.6038488617695377 0.18327067669172933 0.9182903834066625 1.742694135125302 1.7426340139672905 origin
151 3proxy-devel tls-term-stream16 2 5.936625616234798 nan nan nan 0 0 291 10.06 7.430306 1.3509057288458155 nan 94.56640625 0.22995031937544358 0.9428303655107779 0.21864740643466843 0.6468909149467797 0.3610874148838743 proxy
152 haproxy tls-init-ka-1k 2 0.33151778816000005 32428.72 1.86 6.39 0 0 0 10.11 7.107836000000001 24.3968809181862 30.868249669486843 37.9140625 0.23448275862068965 0.9601139601139601 0.4529008109794136 0.5812056025910589 0.39825676089187356 proxy
153 nginx tls-init-ka-1k 2 0.30643585024000003 29971.31 2.08 3.03 0 0 0 10.11 6.847041 26.393778644585783 33.39797101545028 36.0 0.22458233890214796 0.9610266159695817 0.4601381042059008 0.5564684768960839 0.3744680837178592 proxy
154 envoy tls-init-ka-1k 2 0.28596764672 27967.51 2.22 4.0 0 0 0 10.06 7.35279 28.143043775438176 35.614905864776645 22.72265625 0.20828374196619853 0.9590085795996187 0.42987997473152245 0.5156140540364486 0.3679052006028204 proxy
155 stunnel tls-init-ka-1k 2 0.1879048192 18378.01 3.2 13.32 0 0 0 10.13 7.726971 43.128217969621936 54.57562468348293 16.4296875 0.15950334288443171 0.9620132953466287 0.33110687022900764 0.3786416986892288 0.2869732693516453 proxy
156 direct tls-init-ka-1k 2 0.94262788096 92194.83 0.617 1.51 0 0 0 7.1 0.0 6.025707614562938 7.624971674841137 0.0 0.6228698444060262 0.6873184898354308 0.9585180493983534 1.8976348522690194 0.8397667601400569 origin
157 3proxy-devel tls-init-ka-1k 2 0.23655874559999998 23138.93 2.57 11.49 0 0 0 10.1 7.3944469999999995 34.15642055213874 43.218170459310734 15.703125 0.18974604695735506 0.9591642924976258 0.39451880178457616 0.46614134967155574 0.36408252675269875 proxy
158 haproxy tls-init-ka-1m 2 4.91756978176 585.68 26.58 37.15 0 0 0 10.1 7.541793 1.643088020828891 1707.5232459847844 50.94140625 0.19707848477345877 0.9609895337773549 0.25701671397035636 0.4966247525837884 0.23482604770459523 proxy
159 nginx tls-init-ka-1m 2 5.49386715136 654.75 23.46 35.21 0 0 0 10.02 7.363644 1.4590815138323192 1529.070654661987 45.5390625 0.1945057640421879 0.9524714828897338 0.2866541353383459 0.49564436941189216 0.2956667776866136 proxy
160 envoy tls-init-ka-1m 2 6.6190311424 788.86 20.2 28.69 0 0 0 10.02 8.465634 1.2110533743603857 1268.6756140795137 40.92578125 0.13119810201660737 0.9515669515669516 0.32610744580584355 0.4157245533238602 0.4239715728250539 proxy
161 stunnel tls-init-ka-1m 2 4.427339530239999 527.6 29.33 64.28 0 0 0 10.03 7.752134 1.812375117199342 1899.621212121212 20.8203125 0.1608237313066928 0.9525166191832859 0.23768939393939395 0.41280827049799834 0.28608684313989863 proxy
162 direct tls-init-ka-1m 2 20.70174236672 2466.35 6.09 13.26 0 0 0 8.03 0.0 0.31031204457104944 322.3604977920513 0.0 0.7590073968026724 0.8135764944275583 0.9433185560481318 2.58756715545147 0.8647377835930178 origin
163 3proxy-devel tls-init-ka-1m 2 5.44118669312 648.4 23.92 53.52 0 0 0 10.0 7.283727 1.4702675080264092 1541.0695022345508 17.33984375 0.18867924528301888 0.9514747859181731 0.2910753705455692 0.4860933020282822 0.39922826177484244 proxy
164 haproxy tls-init-close-1k 2 0.009898557439999999 971.68 63.22 87.65 0 0 0 10.06 8.991831 813.0477646649896 1033.066338057096 40.4140625 0.04598246029864897 0.9553656220322887 0.3114909781576448 0.07420891244025199 0.26240220709934997 proxy
165 nginx tls-init-close-1k 2 0.01249902592 1226.33 50.61 73.25 0 0 0 10.05 8.809909 643.2501261666317 818.6705767350928 34.82421875 0.06105063890203502 0.956232159847764 0.36561514195583594 0.1008433222599802 0.31656271034531436 proxy
166 envoy tls-init-close-1k 2 0.033554432 3298.66 19.22 28.01 0 0 0 10.03 7.52569 239.13383483886716 302.8015940103852 27.10546875 0.09157769869513642 0.9534220532319392 0.34790874524714827 0.19218400391023552 0.2614521204420928 proxy
167 stunnel tls-init-close-1k 2 0.00931135488 917.07 64.49 282.03 0 0 0 10.07 8.893132999999999 865.1802131721564 1096.47212543554 42.8046875 0.04510921177587844 0.9572243346007605 0.25410872313527183 0.07611102140043158 0.21010458273517538 proxy
168 direct tls-init-close-1k 2 0.032380026879999996 3182.26 1.71 4.86 0 0 0 2.59 0.0 63.99006423554891 81.09716003381658 0.0 0.9524827750059397 0.2483221476510067 0.891566265060241 3.594582602385835 0.868531410399534 client
169 3proxy-devel tls-init-close-1k 2 0.008724152320000001 854.51 70.94 130.96 0 0 0 10.03 9.019395999999999 919.7455186110276 1170.7715653087428 59.45703125 0.03983874792506521 0.9525166191832859 0.2871161760050649 0.06659426008973492 0.247076553129968 proxy
170 haproxy tls-init-stream1-down 2 5.30983748687016 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 7.443982 1.5064755017869838 nan 35.140625 0.15938430983118174 0.9514747859181731 0.28630838131797826 0.3643463829261043 0.6102902686360547 proxy
171 nginx tls-init-stream1-down 2 6.122829390865141 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 7.421562 1.3064479145261825 nan 34.765625 0.16845180136319376 0.9487666034155597 0.3047923322683706 0.38059470645108456 0.6493674048897675 proxy
172 envoy tls-init-stream1-down 2 7.999160223164411 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.97 8.580546 0.9969992853509123 nan 33.28515625 0.06983901515151515 0.9477186311787072 0.36058767167039285 0.15890472448885026 0.7578210005940405 proxy
173 stunnel tls-init-stream1-down 2 4.99521013590384 nan nan nan 0 0 11 10.02 7.927848999999999 1.6045700985060765 nan 10.63671875 0.15476480623933708 0.9515669515669516 0.2399103139013453 0.34256203830421034 0.520834406924631 proxy
174 direct tls-init-stream1-down 2 7.575648412068668 nan nan nan 0 0 1 1.33 0.0 0.1404461615601946 nan 0.0 0.4143334189571025 0.1310344827586207 0.3648380700594845 0.8089368670720193 0.770897273935217 none
175 3proxy-devel tls-init-stream1-down 2 6.5616980626696195 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.96 7.428655 1.214188443232296 nan 11.21484375 0.1782250242483026 0.9485714285714286 0.304694985627595 0.39666298169177927 0.6558373533562405 proxy
176 haproxy tls-init-stream16 2 6.1118228658999 nan nan nan 0 0 7 10.04 7.414294 1.313045255905343 nan 55.0859375 0.06579572446555819 0.9516587677725118 0.7479379742659188 0.1273587095064298 1.1262821310115851 origin
177 nginx tls-init-stream16 2 6.87073422596113 nan nan nan 0 0 487 10.11 7.865257 1.1658229604748571 nan 112.50390625 0.05589914367269267 0.9610266159695817 0.5361405835543767 0.1273765617651751 0.7455949793916397 proxy
178 envoy tls-init-stream16 2 7.250423926236643 nan nan nan 0 0 4922 10.09 7.947361000000001 1.1084477936372372 nan 153.49609375 0.06331515295233578 0.9563981042654028 0.5267275097783573 0.14637536633339554 0.8405408179005287 proxy
179 stunnel tls-init-stream16 2 5.505053569840967 nan nan nan 0 0 270 10.1 7.992601 1.4612649529824777 nan 95.6484375 0.049168646080760096 0.957345971563981 0.5093395597064709 0.10836711168852431 0.6895314756957547 proxy
180 direct tls-init-stream16 2 17.9537542328526 nan nan nan 0 0 424 1.83 0.0 0.0813396718411371 nan 0.0 0.6075533661740559 0.17231638418079095 0.9185790631876768 1.7678203990168668 1.736464051627823 origin
181 3proxy-devel tls-init-stream16 2 7.39921253835151 nan nan nan 0 0 350 10.06 7.851057 1.0835586377024127 nan 95.4453125 0.06012357414448669 0.9553656220322887 0.5556293590169379 0.13688854209297033 0.8042317032742594 proxy

7
bench/report.py
View File

@ -36,7 +36,8 @@ import csv
import statistics
STREAM = ("stream1", "stream1-down", "stream16", "connect-stream1-down", "connect-stream16",
"socks-stream1-down", "socks-stream16", "relay-stream1-down", "relay-stream16")
"socks-stream1-down", "socks-stream16", "relay-stream1-down", "relay-stream16",
"tls-term-stream1-down", "tls-term-stream16", "tls-init-stream1-down", "tls-init-stream16")
# connect-ka-1m etc. are bulk too when present
@ -117,7 +118,7 @@ def load(paths):
# In the combined table, the bulk scenarios in Gbit/s, the others in
# thousands of requests per second.
BULK = STREAM + ("http-ka-1m",)
BULK = STREAM + ("http-ka-1m", "tls-term-ka-1m", "tls-init-ka-1m")
def combined(machines, labels, splice, prefix=None, split=False, overall_only=False):
@ -288,7 +289,7 @@ def main():
sel = by.get((s, p), [])
if p == "direct":
return "–"
if s in STREAM or s in ("http-ka-1m", "http-ka-50k-2000", "http-ka-2k-50k-2000"):
if s in BULK or s in ("http-ka-50k-2000", "http-ka-2k-50k-2000"):
return fmt(median(sel, "cpu_s_per_gb"), 2) + " s/GB"
return fmt(median(sel, "cpu_us_per_req"), 0) + " µs/req"