bughz/3proxy
1
0
Fork 0
mirror of https://github.com/3proxy/3proxy.git synced 2026-10-16 00:25:48 +08:00
Code Issues Actions 12 Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

Benchmarks: measure the proxy under stress, add results

Browse Source 
bench.py:
- the proxy gets one CPU, the client four, the origin three (8 CPUs), so
  the proxy is what runs out first
- CPU time is the busy time of a role's CPUs from /proc/stat, softirqs
  included: with IRQ time accounting the cgroup's own figure leaves out
  much of the network work
- every run records which side set its pace (proxy, client, origin), by
  the busy share of the role's CPUs and of its busiest thread
- a 50 KB keep-alive scenario with 2000 clients
- haproxy with splice: haproxy::splice-auto and haproxy::splice
- wrk timeouts counted apart from errors; tools found by absolute path;
  leftovers of an interrupted run are cleaned up

report.py turns runs into Markdown tables: throughput, the proxy's CPU
per gigabyte or per request, its peak memory, splice and copying proxies
in groups of their own, the best of each group marked.

RESULTS.md has the comparison of 0.9.4, 1.0.1, devel, nginx and haproxy,
with and without splice, on an Apple M4 and an Intel Skylake virtual
machine, and how it was measured; data/ has the measurements.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Vladimir Dubrovin 2026-10-11 22:04:47 +03:00
parent 94feaf2728
commit c13c048f3f
11 changed files with 1127 additions and 41 deletions
Show Stats Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

58
bench/README.md
View File

@ -3,6 +3,9 @@
Compares the speed and the cost of 3proxy versions, and of other proxies doing Compares the speed and the cost of 3proxy versions, and of other proxies doing
the same job, on Linux. the same job, on Linux.
Results of the latest comparison, with the setup they were measured on, are
in [RESULTS.md](RESULTS.md); the measurements are in [data/](data/).
## How the measurement is isolated ## How the measurement is isolated
The client, the proxy and the origin each run in a network namespace of The client, the proxy and the origin each run in a network namespace of
@ -15,14 +18,29 @@ their own, linked by veth pairs:
so they share no loopback, and a packet crosses the same path whichever proxy so they share no loopback, and a packet crosses the same path whichever proxy
is measured. Each role also runs in a cgroup of its own pinned to separate is measured. Each role also runs in a cgroup of its own pinned to separate
CPUs (`--cpus`, default `cli=0-3,prx=4-5,srv=6-7`), so one does not take CPU CPUs (`--cpus`, default `cli=0-3,prx=4,srv=5-7` for 8 CPUs), so one does not
from another, and RPS steers what each veth receives to the receiver's CPUs. take CPU from another, and RPS steers what each veth receives to the
The proxy's cgroup is created anew for every run, which is what makes its receiver's CPUs, so the kernel's network work for a role is done on its own
CPU time and peak memory readable on their own. CPUs too. The proxy's cgroup is created anew for every run, which is what
makes its peak memory readable on its own.
Every proxy is given the same CPUs: nginx gets as many workers and haproxy as The proxy gets the fewest CPUs on purpose: the measurement is about the proxy,
many threads as the proxy cgroup has CPUs; 3proxy runs a thread per so it has to be what runs out first. Every proxy is given the same CPUs: nginx
connection inside the same cpuset. Logging is off everywhere. gets as many workers and haproxy as many threads as the proxy has CPUs;
3proxy runs a thread per connection inside the same cpuset. Logging is off
everywhere.
CPU time is the busy time of a role's CPUs read from `/proc/stat`: its
processes and the interrupts and softirqs handled there. The cgroup's own CPU
time is not enough: a kernel with `CONFIG_IRQ_TIME_ACCOUNTING` leaves the
softirqs out of it, and that is where much of the network work is done (a
quarter of a proxy's CPU in these tests).
Every run records which side set its pace (`bound`): the role whose CPUs were
busy at least 90% of the time, or which had a thread doing so (an iperf3
stream is one thread, so one busy core is its limit however many CPUs the
role has). A run bound by the client or the origin says only that the proxy
can do at least that much.
`none` is no proxy at all: the client reaches the origin through the proxy `none` is no proxy at all: the client reaches the origin through the proxy
namespace with the kernel forwarding, the upper bound for every scenario. namespace with the kernel forwarding, the upper bound for every scenario.
@ -35,11 +53,13 @@ For every run, in a CSV under `bench/results/`:
|---|---| |---|---|
| `gbit`, `rate` | throughput, requests per second for HTTP | | `gbit`, `rate` | throughput, requests per second for HTTP |
| `p50_ms`, `p99_ms` | latency from wrk (closed loop: compare at equal load only) | | `p50_ms`, `p99_ms` | latency from wrk (closed loop: compare at equal load only) |
| `prx_cpu_s` | CPU seconds the proxy used, all its threads and processes | | `prx_cpu_s`, `prx_task_s` | busy CPU seconds of the proxy's CPUs, network work included; the CPU time of its processes alone |
| `cpu_s_per_gb`, `cpu_us_per_req` | the proxy's cost per unit of work: the fairest figure, least affected by which side was the limit | | `cpu_s_per_gb`, `cpu_us_per_req` | the proxy's cost per unit of work: the fairest figure, least affected by which side was the limit |
| `peak_mb` | the proxy's peak memory | | `peak_mb` | the proxy's peak memory |
| `cli_util`, `prx_util`, `srv_util` | how busy each role's CPUs were: a client or origin near 100% means the result says nothing about the proxy | | `cli_util`, `prx_util`, `srv_util` | how busy each role's CPUs were |
| `errors`, `retrans` | socket errors and non-2xx answers; TCP retransmissions in the stream scenarios | | `cli_thread`, `srv_thread` | the busiest client and origin thread, as a share of one CPU |
| `bound` | `proxy`, `client`, `origin`, or `none` when nothing was busy all the time |
| `errors`, `timeouts`, `retrans` | socket errors and non-2xx answers; requests slower than wrk's 2 seconds; TCP retransmissions in the stream scenarios |
Repetitions rotate the order of the proxies, so drift over time (heat, the Repetitions rotate the order of the proxies, so drift over time (heat, the
host) falls on all of them alike; the summary gives medians. host) falls on all of them alike; the summary gives medians.
@ -51,6 +71,7 @@ host) falls on all of them alike; the summary gives medians.
| `stream1`, `stream1-down` | one iperf3 stream through a TCP relay (3proxy `tcppm`, nginx `stream`, haproxy `mode tcp`), upload and download | | `stream1`, `stream1-down` | one iperf3 stream through a TCP relay (3proxy `tcppm`, nginx `stream`, haproxy `mode tcp`), upload and download |
| `stream16` | sixteen streams | | `stream16` | sixteen streams |
| `http-ka-1k`, `http-ka-1m` | HTTP over kept-alive connections through an HTTP proxy (absolute URIs), 1 KB and 1 MB answers | | `http-ka-1k`, `http-ka-1m` | HTTP over kept-alive connections through an HTTP proxy (absolute URIs), 1 KB and 1 MB answers |
| `http-ka-50k-2000` | the same with 2000 clients at once, 50 KB answers |
| `http-close-1k` | a new connection for every request | | `http-close-1k` | a new connection for every request |
nginx is not a forward proxy: it answers absolute URIs by passing them to its nginx is not a forward proxy: it answers absolute URIs by passing them to its
@ -60,13 +81,15 @@ these scenarios compare like with like.
## Running ## Running
Root, `iproute2`, `iperf3`, `wrk`, `nginx` (with the stream module: Root, `iproute2`, `iperf3`, `wrk`, `nginx` (with the stream module:
`libnginx-mod-stream` on Debian and Ubuntu) and, to compare with it, `libnginx-mod-stream` on Debian and Ubuntu, `nginx-mod-stream` on
RHEL-like systems) and, to compare with it,
`haproxy`. `haproxy`.
```sh ```sh
bench/build.sh 0.9.9.1 1.0.1 # tags into bench/bin/ bench/build.sh 0.9.9.1 1.0.1 # tags into bench/bin/
NAME=devel bench/build.sh . # the working tree NAME=devel bench/build.sh . # the working tree
CC="gcc -fcommon" bench/build.sh 0.8.13 # before 0.9, newer gcc CC="gcc -fcommon" bench/build.sh 0.8.13 # before 0.9, newer gcc
CC="gcc -fpermissive" bench/build.sh 0.9.4 # 0.9.x with gcc 14 and later
sudo bench/bench.py \ sudo bench/bench.py \
--proxy none \ --proxy none \
@ -76,11 +99,20 @@ sudo bench/bench.py \
--proxy nginx --proxy haproxy --proxy nginx --proxy haproxy
``` ```
`bench/report.py <csv>` turns a run into Markdown tables: throughput, the
proxy's CPU per gigabyte or per request, and its peak memory.
After the binary, a 3proxy entry can carry options for both its services: After the binary, a 3proxy entry can carry options for both its services:
`-s0` keeps 0.9.0 to 0.9.8, which use splice() by default, from using it, and `-s0` keeps 0.9.0 to 0.9.8, which use splice() by default, from using it, and
`-ocTCP_NODELAY -osTCP_NODELAY` turns Nagle's algorithm off on the client and `-ocTCP_NODELAY -osTCP_NODELAY` turns Nagle's algorithm off on the client and
server sockets. server sockets.
haproxy can be measured with splice() too: `haproxy::splice-auto` lets its
heuristic splice a direction once reads fill the buffer three times in a row,
`haproxy::splice` splices both directions always (`option splice-request` and
`option splice-response`). nginx has no splice() support, so it has no such
variant.
`--scenario` picks scenarios, `--reps` and `--duration` set the repetitions `--scenario` picks scenarios, `--reps` and `--duration` set the repetitions
and their length, `--netem "delay 1ms rate 10gbit"` puts a slower, longer link and their length, `--netem "delay 1ms rate 10gbit"` puts a slower, longer link
between the client and the proxy, `--mtu` changes the links' MTU. between the client and the proxy, `--mtu` changes the links' MTU.
@ -92,6 +124,10 @@ between the client and the proxy, `--mtu` changes the links' MTU.
keep absolute figures for real hardware. keep absolute figures for real hardware.
* wrk measures latency in a closed loop, so a slower proxy is also offered * wrk measures latency in a closed loop, so a slower proxy is also offered
less load; compare latencies only between runs of similar throughput. less load; compare latencies only between runs of similar throughput.
* The roles have CPUs of their own but share the memory: memory bandwidth,
which copying proxies use most, cannot be split, and on some hosts it,
rather than the CPU, sets the limit. A CPU waiting for memory counts as
busy, so such a limit shows as less work per busy second.
* Versions are built with the Makefile they shipped with, so compiler flags * Versions are built with the Makefile they shipped with, so compiler flags
differ between them (0.8 builds with `-O2`, 0.9.9 and later with differ between them (0.8 builds with `-O2`, 0.9.9 and later with
`-O3 -flto`) as they did for their users. `-O3 -flto`) as they did for their users.

211
bench/RESULTS.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,211 @@
# Benchmark results
3proxy 0.9.4, 1.0.1 and devel against nginx and haproxy, measured on two
machines, 11 October 2026. How the benchmark works is in
[README.md](README.md); the measurements are in [data/](data/), and
`bench/report.py` turns them into the tables below.
## In short
* **Bulk TCP, no splice:** devel and 1.0.1 move 19-22 Gbit/s per CPU core,
1.5 to 2.2 times nginx and haproxy and 2.4 to 3.6 times 0.9.4, at 0.36-0.43
CPU seconds per gigabyte against 0.59-0.87 for nginx and haproxy.
* **Bulk TCP and large HTTP answers with splice():** 3proxy with splice moves
1.3 to 2.1 times what it does without, at 40-55% less CPU per gigabyte. On
the Skylake host it is level with haproxy splicing every connection with TCP
streams and 11% behind it with 1 MB HTTP answers; on the M4 it is ahead (37.8
against 22.1 Gbit/s with 16 streams, 35.3 against 28.0 with 1 MB HTTP
answers). haproxy's own heuristic (`splice-auto`) does not engage for 1 MB
HTTP answers on the M4 (haproxy 2.8) and stays at its copying speed.
* **Small requests:** nginx and haproxy answer 2 to 3 times more 1 KB requests
per core over kept-alive connections, and 3 times more when every request
opens a new connection: 3proxy runs a thread per connection. splice() makes
small requests slower (13.4-14.9k against 15.8-18.1k requests per second),
which is why it stays off unless asked for.
* **2000 clients, 50 KB answers:** devel leads the copying proxies on the
Skylake host (10.5k requests per second against nginx's 9.2k and haproxy's
7.3k), nginx leads on the M4 (11.0k against devel's 10.4k); haproxy splicing
every connection is fastest there (11.9k). splice() does not help 3proxy with
answers this small.
* **1.0.1 against devel:** 1.0.1 manages 6k requests per second over kept-alive
connections whatever the CPU, held by a 10 ms sleep each time a request is
answered; devel has it removed and also sets TCP_NODELAY by default.
* **Memory:** with few connections 3proxy needs the least (devel 8-17 MB
against 30-54 MB for nginx and haproxy; 57 MB when every request opens a new
connection on the Skylake host); with 2000 connections at once, a thread for
each costs it 150-200 MB against nginx's 90-113 MB.
## Setup
| | M4 | Skylake |
|---|---|---|
| host | Apple M4 Pro laptop, UTM (Apple Virtualization) | OpenStack virtual machine, KVM |
| virtual machine | 8 CPUs, 8 GB | 8 CPUs (Intel Xeon, Skylake, 2.0 GHz), 8 GB |
| system | Ubuntu 24.04, Linux 6.8, aarch64 | AlmaLinux 10, Linux 6.12, x86_64 |
| nginx | 1.24.0 | 1.26.3 |
| haproxy | 2.8.16 | 3.0.5 |
| wrk, iperf3 | 4.1.0, 3.16 | 4.2.0, 3.17.1 |
### How the client, the proxy and the origin were kept apart
* **Network:** each runs in a network namespace of its own, linked by veth
pairs (client 10.0.1.2 - 10.0.1.1 proxy 10.0.2.1 - 10.0.2.2 origin), so they
share no loopback and every proxy is crossed by the same path. MTU 1500.
* **CPU:** each runs in a cgroup pinned to CPUs of its own: the client
(wrk, iperf3) on CPUs 0-3, the proxy on CPU 4, the origin (nginx serving
files from tmpfs, iperf3 -s) on CPUs 5-7. RPS steers what each veth receives
to the receiving side's CPUs, so the kernel's network work for a role is
done on its own CPUs too. The proxy has the fewest CPUs on purpose: it has to
be what runs out first.
* **Every proxy gets the same CPU:** one nginx worker, one haproxy thread, and
3proxy's thread per connection confined to the same CPU.
* **CPU time** is the busy time of the role's CPUs from `/proc/stat`, its own
processes plus the interrupts and softirqs handled there (a quarter of a
proxy's time here), so a proxy is also charged for the kernel's work on its
connections - which is where splice() moves the copying.
* **Which side set the pace** is recorded for every run: the role whose CPUs,
or one thread of it, were busy at least 90% of the time.
* **Repetitions:** three runs of 10 seconds per proxy and scenario, the order
of the proxies rotated between repetitions; the tables give medians. The
haproxy splice columns come from a second session an hour later, with plain
haproxy run again to see how far the conditions moved: by 2.5% or less on
the M4 and 7.5% or less on the Skylake host, except for one origin-bound
case (-9.7%).
### Proxies
| column | configuration |
|---|---|
| 0.9.4 | 0.9.4, `-s0` (no splice) `-ocTCP_NODELAY -osTCP_NODELAY` |
| 1.0.1 | 1.0.1, `-ocTCP_NODELAY -osTCP_NODELAY` (built without splice) |
| devel | devel as of these tests, defaults (TCP_NODELAY is on by default) |
| nginx | `proxy_pass` to an upstream with `keepalive 1024`, `stream` for TCP, `reuseport` |
| haproxy | `mode http` with `http-reuse always`, `mode tcp` for TCP |
| 0.9.4 splice | 0.9.4, which splices by default, `-ocTCP_NODELAY -osTCP_NODELAY` |
| devel splice | devel with `-s` |
| haproxy splice-auto | `option splice-auto`: splices a direction once reads fill the buffer three times in a row |
| haproxy splice | `option splice-request` and `option splice-response`: splices always |
nginx has no splice() support. 3proxy versions are built with the Makefile
they shipped with (`-O3 -flto` for 1.0.1 and devel, `-O2` for 0.9.4, which on
gcc 14 also needs `-fpermissive`). Logging is off everywhere.
### Scenarios
| scenario | load |
|---|---|
| stream1, stream1-down | one iperf3 stream through a TCP relay (3proxy `tcppm`), upload and download |
| stream16 | 16 iperf3 streams |
| http-ka-1k, http-ka-1m | 64 (1 KB) or 16 (1 MB) kept-alive connections through the HTTP proxy |
| http-ka-50k-2000 | 2000 kept-alive connections, 50 KB answers |
| http-close-1k | 64 connections, a new one for every request |
## How to read the tables
* Columns: the client talking to the origin with no proxy (only the kernel
forwarding, for reference), then the proxies copying through user space,
then after the second ‖ the proxies using splice().
* **Bold**: the best of its group in the row, and any other of the group whose
three runs overlap the best one's - the measurement cannot tell them apart.
* ‡: the client or the origin, not the proxy, set the pace in most runs, so the
proxy can do at least that much. Single streams often end there with
splice(): one iperf3 stream is one thread, and the proxy needs less of a CPU
than it.
* CPU is per gigabyte for the bulk scenarios and per request for the small
ones.
* http-ka-50k-2000: every proxy but haproxy leaves some requests waiting longer
than wrk's 2 second limit (counted as timeouts in the data, 140-540 a run);
haproxy serves the 2000 connections more evenly, with none over 2 seconds but
a median wait 2 to 3 times longer.
## M4 (Apple M4 Pro, virtual machine)
#### Throughput, Gbit/s (thousands of requests per second for HTTP)
| scenario | no proxy | ‖ | 0.9.4 | 1.0.1 | devel | nginx | haproxy | ‖ | 0.9.4 splice | devel splice | haproxy splice-auto | haproxy splice |
|---|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| stream1 | 62.0 | ‖ | 8.3 | **22.1** | **22.0** | 13.5 | 13.6 | ‖ | 25.1 | **45.7 ‡** | 29.5 | **44.7** |
| stream16 | 141.2 | ‖ | 8.7 | **20.9** | **20.9** | 13.5 | 9.5 ‡ | ‖ | 24.5 | **37.8 ‡** | 15.9 ‡ | 22.1 ‡ |
| stream1-down | 61.8 | ‖ | 8.8 | **22.4** | **22.1** | 13.6 | 13.6 | ‖ | **47.9 ‡** | **47.4 ‡** | 30.4 | **47.6 ‡** |
| http-ka-1k | 1.24 (120.3k/s) | ‖ | 0.14 (14.1k/s) | 0.06 (6.0k/s) | 0.16 (15.8k/s) | 0.38 (37.0k/s) | **0.45 (44.3k/s)** | ‖ | 0.14 (13.4k/s) | 0.15 (14.9k/s) | **0.45 (44.1k/s)** | **0.45 (44.1k/s)** |
| http-ka-1m | 71.55 (8.5k/s) | ‖ | 8.33 (1.0k/s) | 12.46 (1.5k/s) | **21.90 (2.6k/s) ‡** | 12.63 (1.5k/s) | 6.02 (0.7k/s) ‡ | ‖ | 32.99 (3.9k/s) ‡ | **35.30 (4.2k/s) ‡** | 5.91 (0.7k/s) ‡ | 28.00 (3.3k/s) ‡ |
| http-ka-50k-2000 | 34.79 (84.5k/s) | ‖ | 3.12 (7.6k/s) | 3.69 (9.0k/s) | 4.27 (10.4k/s) | **4.55 (11.0k/s)** | 4.01 (9.6k/s) | ‖ | 3.73 (9.1k/s) | 4.07 (9.9k/s) | 4.00 (9.6k/s) | **4.92 (11.9k/s)** |
| http-close-1k | 0.50 (48.7k/s) | ‖ | 0.05 (5.0k/s) | 0.05 (4.4k/s) | 0.05 (5.2k/s) | 0.14 (13.3k/s) | **0.17 (16.6k/s)** | ‖ | 0.05 (4.8k/s) | 0.05 (5.0k/s) | **0.17 (16.7k/s)** | **0.17 (16.8k/s)** |
#### Proxy CPU time per gigabyte or per request
| scenario | no proxy | ‖ | 0.9.4 | 1.0.1 | devel | nginx | haproxy | ‖ | 0.9.4 splice | devel splice | haproxy splice-auto | haproxy splice |
|---|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| stream1 | – | ‖ | 0.96 s/GB | **0.36 s/GB** | **0.36 s/GB** | 0.59 s/GB | 0.59 s/GB | ‖ | 0.32 s/GB | **0.17 s/GB** | 0.27 s/GB | **0.18 s/GB** |
| stream16 | – | ‖ | 0.92 s/GB | **0.38 s/GB** | **0.38 s/GB** | 0.59 s/GB | 0.84 s/GB | ‖ | 0.33 s/GB | **0.21 s/GB** | 0.51 s/GB | 0.36 s/GB |
| stream1-down | – | ‖ | 0.91 s/GB | **0.36 s/GB** | **0.36 s/GB** | 0.59 s/GB | 0.59 s/GB | ‖ | **0.17 s/GB** | **0.17 s/GB** | 0.26 s/GB | **0.17 s/GB** |
| http-ka-1k | – | ‖ | 71 µs/req | 105 µs/req | 63 µs/req | 27 µs/req | **23 µs/req** | ‖ | 74 µs/req | 67 µs/req | **23 µs/req** | **23 µs/req** |
| http-ka-1m | – | ‖ | 0.96 s/GB | 0.44 s/GB | **0.37 s/GB** | 0.64 s/GB | 1.34 s/GB | ‖ | 0.24 s/GB | **0.23 s/GB** | 1.37 s/GB | 0.29 s/GB |
| http-ka-50k-2000 | – | ‖ | 2.67 s/GB | 2.27 s/GB | 1.95 s/GB | **1.79 s/GB** | 2.01 s/GB | ‖ | 2.23 s/GB | 2.04 s/GB | 2.02 s/GB | **1.65 s/GB** |
| http-close-1k | – | ‖ | 201 µs/req | 227 µs/req | 194 µs/req | 75 µs/req | **60 µs/req** | ‖ | 208 µs/req | 200 µs/req | **60 µs/req** | **60 µs/req** |
#### Proxy peak memory, MB
| scenario | no proxy | ‖ | 0.9.4 | 1.0.1 | devel | nginx | haproxy | ‖ | 0.9.4 splice | devel splice | haproxy splice-auto | haproxy splice |
|---|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| stream1 | – | ‖ | **2** | 10 | 8 | 32 | 32 | ‖ | **5** | 11 | 44 | 45 |
| stream16 | – | ‖ | **31** | 75 | 63 | 75 | 48 | ‖ | **61** | 85 | **60** | **56** |
| stream1-down | – | ‖ | **2** | 6 | 10 | 34 | 31 | ‖ | **11** | 11 | 40 | 45 |
| http-ka-1k | – | ‖ | **5** | 9 | 9 | 30 | 30 | ‖ | **5** | 9 | 36 | 36 |
| http-ka-1m | – | ‖ | **11** | **10** | 16 | 45 | 39 | ‖ | **15** | **17** | 44 | 52 |
| http-ka-50k-2000 | – | ‖ | 126 | 199 | 194 | **90** | 176 | ‖ | **97** | 187 | 182 | 136 |
| http-close-1k | – | ‖ | **10** | 31 | 14 | 30 | 30 | ‖ | **10** | 12 | 36 | 36 |
## Skylake (Intel Xeon, OpenStack virtual machine)
#### Throughput, Gbit/s (thousands of requests per second for HTTP)
| scenario | no proxy | ‖ | 0.9.4 | 1.0.1 | devel | nginx | haproxy | ‖ | 0.9.4 splice | devel splice | haproxy splice-auto | haproxy splice |
|---|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| stream1 | 44.4 | ‖ | 5.5 | 19.1 | **19.9** | 9.8 | 9.7 | ‖ | **29.2** | **31.4** | **30.6** | **32.3** |
| stream16 | 150.5 | ‖ | 5.6 | **18.9** | **18.8** | 9.9 | 9.2 | ‖ | 28.3 | **31.2** | **30.3 ‡** | **31.5 ‡** |
| stream1-down | 43.1 | ‖ | 5.6 | **18.8** | **19.4** | 9.7 | 9.3 | ‖ | **34.4** | 32.0 | 31.0 | **33.7** |
| http-ka-1k | 1.30 (127.1k/s) | ‖ | 0.19 (19.2k/s) | 0.06 (6.1k/s) | 0.18 (18.1k/s) | **0.37 (36.5k/s)** | **0.37 (37.3k/s)** | ‖ | 0.15 (14.6k/s) | 0.14 (13.8k/s) | **0.37 (37.2k/s)** | **0.38 (38.0k/s)** |
| http-ka-1m | 67.52 (8.0k/s) | ‖ | 5.84 (0.7k/s) | 12.37 (1.5k/s) | **18.30 (2.2k/s) ‡** | 5.77 (0.7k/s) | 7.56 (0.9k/s) | ‖ | **26.63 (3.2k/s) ‡** | 23.88 (2.8k/s) ‡ | 24.22 (2.9k/s) ‡ | **26.71 (3.2k/s) ‡** |
| http-ka-50k-2000 | 35.30 (85.7k/s) | ‖ | 2.89 (7.0k/s) | 4.24 (10.3k/s) | **4.33 (10.5k/s)** | 3.77 (9.2k/s) | 3.01 (7.3k/s) | ‖ | **3.89 (9.4k/s)** | 3.71 (9.0k/s) | 3.19 (7.7k/s) | **3.72 (9.0k/s)** |
| http-close-1k | 0.53 (52.1k/s) | ‖ | 0.05 (4.8k/s) | 0.04 (4.0k/s) | 0.05 (4.8k/s) | 0.13 (12.9k/s) | **0.15 (15.1k/s)** | ‖ | 0.04 (4.4k/s) | 0.04 (4.4k/s) | **0.15 (15.1k/s)** | **0.16 (15.5k/s)** |
#### Proxy CPU time per gigabyte or per request
| scenario | no proxy | ‖ | 0.9.4 | 1.0.1 | devel | nginx | haproxy | ‖ | 0.9.4 splice | devel splice | haproxy splice-auto | haproxy splice |
|---|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| stream1 | – | ‖ | 1.45 s/GB | 0.42 s/GB | **0.40 s/GB** | 0.82 s/GB | 0.82 s/GB | ‖ | **0.27 s/GB** | **0.25 s/GB** | **0.26 s/GB** | **0.25 s/GB** |
| stream16 | – | ‖ | 1.43 s/GB | **0.42 s/GB** | **0.43 s/GB** | 0.81 s/GB | 0.87 s/GB | ‖ | 0.28 s/GB | **0.26 s/GB** | **0.26 s/GB** | **0.25 s/GB** |
| stream1-down | – | ‖ | 1.43 s/GB | **0.43 s/GB** | **0.41 s/GB** | 0.82 s/GB | 0.86 s/GB | ‖ | **0.23 s/GB** | 0.25 s/GB | 0.26 s/GB | **0.24 s/GB** |
| http-ka-1k | – | ‖ | 52 µs/req | 72 µs/req | 55 µs/req | **27 µs/req** | **27 µs/req** | ‖ | 68 µs/req | 72 µs/req | **27 µs/req** | **26 µs/req** |
| http-ka-1m | – | ‖ | 1.37 s/GB | 0.53 s/GB | **0.44 s/GB** | 1.39 s/GB | 1.07 s/GB | ‖ | **0.30 s/GB** | 0.34 s/GB | 0.33 s/GB | **0.30 s/GB** |
| http-ka-50k-2000 | – | ‖ | 2.88 s/GB | 1.98 s/GB | **1.93 s/GB** | 2.15 s/GB | 2.70 s/GB | ‖ | **2.15 s/GB** | 2.26 s/GB | 2.55 s/GB | **2.18 s/GB** |
| http-close-1k | – | ‖ | 211 µs/req | 250 µs/req | 210 µs/req | 77 µs/req | **66 µs/req** | ‖ | 229 µs/req | 230 µs/req | **66 µs/req** | **65 µs/req** |
#### Proxy peak memory, MB
| scenario | no proxy | ‖ | 0.9.4 | 1.0.1 | devel | nginx | haproxy | ‖ | 0.9.4 splice | devel splice | haproxy splice-auto | haproxy splice |
|---|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|:-:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| stream1 | – | ‖ | **2** | 5 | 8 | 34 | 30 | ‖ | 10 | **8** | 44 | 42 |
| stream16 | – | ‖ | 93 | 96 | 91 | 107 | **59** | ‖ | 79 | 88 | 107 | **62** |
| stream1-down | – | ‖ | **3** | 8 | 8 | 32 | 31 | ‖ | **9** | 11 | 43 | 46 |
| http-ka-1k | – | ‖ | **5** | 10 | 10 | 32 | 32 | ‖ | **5** | 10 | 37 | 40 |
| http-ka-1m | – | ‖ | **14** | **14** | 17 | 45 | 45 | ‖ | **15** | **18** | 54 | 53 |
| http-ka-50k-2000 | – | ‖ | 185 | 137 | **153** | **113** | 178 | ‖ | **91** | 160 | 185 | 195 |
| http-close-1k | – | ‖ | **16** | 23 | 57 | 31 | 29 | ‖ | **22** | 42 | 40 | 38 |
## Caveats
* Both machines are virtual: their CPUs cannot be pinned to physical cores, so
absolute figures move between sessions; compare within a table.
* The roles have CPUs of their own but share the memory, and memory bandwidth,
which copying proxies use most, cannot be split. On the Skylake host it may
well be the limit; a CPU waiting for memory counts as busy, so this shows as
less work per busy second rather than as idle time.
* wrk measures in a closed loop: a slower proxy is offered less load, so
latencies compare only between runs of similar throughput, and requests over
2 seconds are left out of its latency figures.
* The haproxy versions differ between the machines (2.8 and 3.0).

206
bench/bench.py
View File

@ -27,6 +27,7 @@ import statistics
import subprocess import subprocess
import sys import sys
import tempfile import tempfile
import threading
import time import time
CG = "/sys/fs/cgroup/3proxy-bench" CG = "/sys/fs/cgroup/3proxy-bench"
@ -35,7 +36,7 @@ CG = "/sys/fs/cgroup/3proxy-bench"
CLI_ADDR, PRX_IN, PRX_OUT, SRV_ADDR = "10.0.1.2", "10.0.1.1", "10.0.2.1", "10.0.2.2" CLI_ADDR, PRX_IN, PRX_OUT, SRV_ADDR = "10.0.1.2", "10.0.1.1", "10.0.2.1", "10.0.2.2"
HTTP_PORT, TCP_PORT, ORIGIN_HTTP, ORIGIN_TCP = 3128, 5201, 8080, 5201 HTTP_PORT, TCP_PORT, ORIGIN_HTTP, ORIGIN_TCP = 3128, 5201, 8080, 5201
FILES = {"1k": 1024, "100k": 100 * 1024, "1m": 1024 * 1024} FILES = {"1k": 1024, "50k": 50 * 1024, "100k": 100 * 1024, "1m": 1024 * 1024}
# name: (kind, parameters) # name: (kind, parameters)
SCENARIOS = { SCENARIOS = {
@ -44,10 +45,26 @@ SCENARIOS = {
"stream1-down": ("stream", {"streams": 1, "reverse": True}), "stream1-down": ("stream", {"streams": 1, "reverse": True}),
"http-ka-1k": ("http", {"file": "1k", "conns": 64}), "http-ka-1k": ("http", {"file": "1k", "conns": 64}),
"http-ka-1m": ("http", {"file": "1m", "conns": 16}), "http-ka-1m": ("http", {"file": "1m", "conns": 16}),
"http-ka-50k-2000": ("http", {"file": "50k", "conns": 2000}),
"http-close-1k": ("http", {"file": "1k", "conns": 64, "close": True}), "http-close-1k": ("http", {"file": "1k", "conns": 64, "close": True}),
} }
TOOLS = {}
def tool(name):
"""A tool by its absolute path: sudo's secure_path may leave out where
it was installed, /usr/local/bin for a wrk built by hand."""
if name not in TOOLS:
path = shutil.which(name) or shutil.which(
name, path="/usr/local/bin:/usr/local/sbin:/usr/sbin:/usr/bin")
if not path:
sys.exit(f"{name} not found")
TOOLS[name] = path
return TOOLS[name]
def sh(cmd, check=True, **kw): def sh(cmd, check=True, **kw):
return subprocess.run(cmd, shell=True, check=check, text=True, return subprocess.run(cmd, shell=True, check=check, text=True,
stdout=subprocess.PIPE, stderr=subprocess.STDOUT, **kw).stdout stdout=subprocess.PIPE, stderr=subprocess.STDOUT, **kw).stdout
@ -142,8 +159,22 @@ def cg_remove(role):
time.sleep(0.1) time.sleep(0.1)
def cg_kill(role):
"""Whatever is left in a role's cgroup, e.g. after an interrupted run."""
try:
pids = cg_read(f"{CG}/{role}/cgroup.procs").split()
except OSError:
return
for pid in pids:
try:
os.kill(int(pid), signal.SIGKILL)
except ProcessLookupError:
pass
def cg_down(): def cg_down():
for role in ("cli", "prx", "srv"): for role in ("cli", "prx", "srv"):
cg_kill(role)
cg_remove(role) cg_remove(role)
try: try:
os.rmdir(CG) os.rmdir(CG)
@ -160,6 +191,60 @@ def cg_usage(role):
return 0.0 return 0.0
TICK = os.sysconf("SC_CLK_TCK")
def cpu_busy():
"""Busy and total ticks per CPU. Busy counts interrupts and softirqs too:
a kernel with IRQ time accounting leaves them out of the cgroup's CPU
time, and that is where much of the network work is done."""
busy = {}
with open("/proc/stat") as f:
for line in f:
if not line.startswith("cpu") or line.startswith("cpu "):
continue
name, *v = line.split()
v = [int(x) for x in v]
# user nice system idle iowait irq softirq steal
busy[int(name[3:])] = (v[0] + v[1] + v[2] + v[5] + v[6] + v[7], sum(v[:8]))
return busy
def role_busy(before, after, cpus):
"""Busy seconds of a role's CPUs, and the share of them that was busy."""
b = t = 0
for c in cpus:
b += after[c][0] - before[c][0]
t += after[c][1] - before[c][1]
return b / TICK, (b / t if t else 0.0)
def thread_times(role):
"""CPU ticks per thread of everything in a role's cgroup."""
times = {}
try:
tids = cg_read(f"{CG}/{role}/cgroup.threads").split()
except OSError:
return times
for tid in tids:
try:
with open(f"/proc/{tid}/stat") as f:
v = f.read().rsplit(")", 1)[1].split()
times[tid] = int(v[11]) + int(v[12])
except (OSError, IndexError, ValueError):
pass
return times
def busiest_thread(before, after, wall):
"""The busiest thread's share of one CPU: one thread at 100% is a limit
however many CPUs its role has (iperf3 runs a stream in a thread)."""
top = 0
for tid, t in after.items():
top = max(top, t - before.get(tid, 0))
return top / TICK / wall if wall else 0.0
def cg_peak(role): def cg_peak(role):
try: try:
return int(cg_read(f"{CG}/{role}/memory.peak")) / 2**20 return int(cg_read(f"{CG}/{role}/memory.peak")) / 2**20
@ -183,10 +268,26 @@ def spawn(ns, role, argv, log):
stderr=subprocess.STDOUT, preexec_fn=enter) stderr=subprocess.STDOUT, preexec_fn=enter)
LAST_CLIENT_THREAD = [0.0]
def run_in(ns, role, argv, timeout): def run_in(ns, role, argv, timeout):
"""Run a load generator to its end. Its busiest thread's share of a CPU
is kept in LAST_CLIENT_THREAD, read just before it exits."""
p = spawn(ns, role, argv, subprocess.PIPE) p = spawn(ns, role, argv, subprocess.PIPE)
out, _ = p.communicate(timeout=timeout) t0 = time.time()
return out.decode("utf-8", "replace") top = {}
buf = []
reader = threading.Thread(target=lambda: buf.append(p.stdout.read()))
reader.start()
while p.poll() is None:
for tid, t in thread_times(role).items():
top[tid] = t
time.sleep(0.5)
reader.join(timeout)
wall = time.time() - t0
LAST_CLIENT_THREAD[0] = max(top.values()) / TICK / wall if top and wall else 0.0
return (buf[0] if buf else b"").decode("utf-8", "replace")
def stop(p): def stop(p):
@ -245,9 +346,11 @@ http {{
}} }}
""") """)
log = open(os.path.join(work, "origin.out"), "w") log = open(os.path.join(work, "origin.out"), "w")
procs = [spawn("bsrv", "srv", ["nginx", "-c", conf, "-p", work], log), procs = [spawn("bsrv", "srv", [tool("nginx"), "-c", conf, "-p", work], log),
spawn("bsrv", "srv", ["iperf3", "-s", "-B", SRV_ADDR, "-p", str(ORIGIN_TCP)], log)] spawn("bsrv", "srv", [tool("iperf3"), "-s", "-B", SRV_ADDR, "-p", str(ORIGIN_TCP)], log)]
if not (wait_port("bsrv", SRV_ADDR, ORIGIN_HTTP) and wait_port("bsrv", SRV_ADDR, ORIGIN_TCP)): if not (wait_port("bsrv", SRV_ADDR, ORIGIN_HTTP) and wait_port("bsrv", SRV_ADDR, ORIGIN_TCP)):
for p in procs:
stop(p)
sys.exit("the origin did not start, see " + work) sys.exit("the origin did not start, see " + work)
return procs return procs
@ -271,8 +374,12 @@ tcppm {opts} -i{PRX_IN} -e{PRX_OUT} {TCP_PORT} {SRV_ADDR} {ORIGIN_TCP}
conf = os.path.join(work, f"{label}.conf") conf = os.path.join(work, f"{label}.conf")
with open(conf, "w") as f: with open(conf, "w") as f:
# distributions build the stream module as a dynamic one # distributions build the stream module as a dynamic one
stream = "/usr/lib/nginx/modules/ngx_stream_module.so" load = ""
load = f"load_module {stream};\n" if os.path.exists(stream) else "" for d in ("/usr/lib/nginx/modules", "/usr/lib64/nginx/modules"):
stream = os.path.join(d, "ngx_stream_module.so")
if os.path.exists(stream):
load = f"load_module {stream};\n"
break
f.write(f"""{load}daemon off; f.write(f"""{load}daemon off;
worker_processes {ncpu}; worker_processes {ncpu};
pid {work}/{label}.pid; pid {work}/{label}.pid;
@ -303,13 +410,20 @@ stream {{
""") """)
return ["-c", conf, "-p", work] return ["-c", conf, "-p", work]
if kind == "haproxy": if kind == "haproxy":
# splice-auto: haproxy's heuristic, splicing a direction once reads
# fill its buffer three times in a row; splice: both directions always
splice = {"": "", "splice-auto": " option splice-auto\n",
"splice": " option splice-request\n option splice-response\n"}
if opts not in splice:
sys.exit("haproxy options: splice-auto or splice")
splice = splice[opts]
conf = os.path.join(work, f"{label}.cfg") conf = os.path.join(work, f"{label}.cfg")
with open(conf, "w") as f: with open(conf, "w") as f:
f.write(f"""global f.write(f"""global
nbthread {ncpu} nbthread {ncpu}
maxconn 200000 maxconn 200000
defaults defaults
timeout connect 5s {splice} timeout connect 5s
timeout client 60s timeout client 60s
timeout server 60s timeout server 60s
frontend http frontend http
@ -344,8 +458,11 @@ class Proxy:
self.binary = os.path.abspath(path) self.binary = os.path.abspath(path)
self.label = os.path.basename(path) + (self.opts.replace(" ", "") if self.opts else "") self.label = os.path.basename(path) + (self.opts.replace(" ", "") if self.opts else "")
elif kind in ("nginx", "haproxy"): elif kind in ("nginx", "haproxy"):
self.binary = path or shutil.which(kind) path, _, self.opts = path.partition(":")
self.label = kind if kind == "nginx" and self.opts:
sys.exit("nginx takes no options (it does not use splice() at all)")
self.binary = path or tool(kind)
self.label = kind + ("-" + self.opts if self.opts else "")
elif kind == "none": elif kind == "none":
self.binary = None self.binary = None
self.label = "direct" self.label = "direct"
@ -400,7 +517,7 @@ def run_http(proxy, params, args, work):
SRV_ADDR, ORIGIN_HTTP)) SRV_ADDR, ORIGIN_HTTP))
threads = len(cpulist(args.cpus["cli"])) threads = len(cpulist(args.cpus["cli"]))
conns = max(params["conns"], threads) conns = max(params["conns"], threads)
out = run_in("bcli", "cli", ["wrk", "-t", str(threads), "-c", str(conns), out = run_in("bcli", "cli", [tool("wrk"), "-t", str(threads), "-c", str(conns),
"-d", f"{args.duration}s", "--latency", "-s", script, "-d", f"{args.duration}s", "--latency", "-s", script,
f"http://{host}:{port}/"], args.duration + 30) f"http://{host}:{port}/"], args.duration + 30)
res = {"raw": out} res = {"raw": out}
@ -414,12 +531,17 @@ def run_http(proxy, params, args, work):
m = re.search(rf"^\s+{pct}%\s+(\S+)", out, re.M) m = re.search(rf"^\s+{pct}%\s+(\S+)", out, re.M)
res[f"p{pct}_ms"] = to_ms(m.group(1)) if m else float("nan") res[f"p{pct}_ms"] = to_ms(m.group(1)) if m else float("nan")
errors = 0 errors = 0
res["timeouts"] = 0
m = re.search(r"Socket errors: connect (\d+), read (\d+), write (\d+), timeout (\d+)", out) m = re.search(r"Socket errors: connect (\d+), read (\d+), write (\d+), timeout (\d+)", out)
if m: if m:
errors += sum(int(x) for x in m.groups()) errors += sum(int(x) for x in m.groups()[:3])
# requests slower than wrk's 2 seconds: a latency tail, not a failure
res["timeouts"] = int(m.group(4))
m = re.search(r"Non-2xx or 3xx responses: (\d+)", out) m = re.search(r"Non-2xx or 3xx responses: (\d+)", out)
if m: if m:
errors += int(m.group(1)) errors += int(m.group(1))
if not res["requests"]:
errors += 1 # wrk did not run, or reported nothing
res["errors"] = errors res["errors"] = errors
res["retrans"] = 0 res["retrans"] = 0
res["bytes"] = res["gbit"] * 1e9 / 8 * args.duration res["bytes"] = res["gbit"] * 1e9 / 8 * args.duration
@ -430,13 +552,13 @@ def run_stream(proxy, params, args, work):
direct = proxy.kind == "none" direct = proxy.kind == "none"
host = SRV_ADDR if direct else PRX_IN host = SRV_ADDR if direct else PRX_IN
port = ORIGIN_TCP if direct else TCP_PORT port = ORIGIN_TCP if direct else TCP_PORT
argv = ["iperf3", "-c", host, "-p", str(port), "-t", str(args.duration), argv = [tool("iperf3"), "-c", host, "-p", str(port), "-t", str(args.duration),
"-P", str(params["streams"]), "-J"] "-P", str(params["streams"]), "-J"]
if params.get("reverse"): if params.get("reverse"):
argv.append("-R") argv.append("-R")
out = run_in("bcli", "cli", argv, args.duration + 30) out = run_in("bcli", "cli", argv, args.duration + 30)
res = {"raw": out, "rate": float("nan"), "p50_ms": float("nan"), res = {"raw": out, "rate": float("nan"), "p50_ms": float("nan"),
"p99_ms": float("nan"), "requests": 0, "errors": 0, "retrans": 0} "p99_ms": float("nan"), "requests": 0, "errors": 0, "retrans": 0, "timeouts": 0}
try: try:
j = json.loads(out) j = json.loads(out)
s = j["end"]["sum_received"] s = j["end"]["sum_received"]
@ -450,24 +572,45 @@ def run_stream(proxy, params, args, work):
return res return res
BUSY = 0.9
def measure(proxy, scenario, args, work): def measure(proxy, scenario, args, work):
kind, params = SCENARIOS[scenario] kind, params = SCENARIOS[scenario]
p = proxy.start(args, work) p = proxy.start(args, work)
try: try:
time.sleep(0.5) time.sleep(0.5)
before = {r: cg_usage(r) for r in ("cli", "prx", "srv")} task0 = cg_usage("prx")
cpu0 = cpu_busy()
thr0 = {r: thread_times(r) for r in ("cli", "srv")}
t0 = time.time() t0 = time.time()
res = (run_http if kind == "http" else run_stream)(proxy, params, args, work) res = (run_http if kind == "http" else run_stream)(proxy, params, args, work)
res["cli_thread"] = LAST_CLIENT_THREAD[0]
wall = time.time() - t0 wall = time.time() - t0
after = {r: cg_usage(r) for r in ("cli", "prx", "srv")} cpu1 = cpu_busy()
# threads of the load generator have ended by now: take what the
# client's cgroup reports for the run instead
thr1 = {r: thread_times(r) for r in ("cli", "srv")}
res["prx_task_s"] = cg_usage("prx") - task0
res["peak_mb"] = cg_peak("prx") res["peak_mb"] = cg_peak("prx")
finally: finally:
stop(p) stop(p)
for r in ("cli", "prx", "srv"): for r in ("cli", "prx", "srv"):
used = after[r] - before[r] # the busy time of the role's CPUs, its own processes and the network
res[f"{r}_cpu_s"] = used # work done there for it
# share of the CPUs given to that role, to see which side was the limit res[f"{r}_cpu_s"], res[f"{r}_util"] = role_busy(cpu0, cpu1, cpulist(args.cpus[r]))
res[f"{r}_util"] = used / (wall * len(cpulist(args.cpus[r]))) res["srv_thread"] = busiest_thread(thr0["srv"], thr1["srv"], wall)
# Which side set the pace: a role whose CPUs, or a single thread of it,
# were busy all the time. A run limited by the client or the origin says
# only that the proxy can do at least this much.
if res["srv_util"] >= BUSY or res["srv_thread"] >= BUSY:
res["bound"] = "origin"
elif res["cli_util"] >= BUSY or res["cli_thread"] >= BUSY:
res["bound"] = "client"
elif res["prx_util"] >= BUSY:
res["bound"] = "proxy"
else:
res["bound"] = "none"
gb = res["bytes"] / 1e9 gb = res["bytes"] / 1e9
res["cpu_s_per_gb"] = res["prx_cpu_s"] / gb if gb else float("nan") res["cpu_s_per_gb"] = res["prx_cpu_s"] / gb if gb else float("nan")
res["cpu_us_per_req"] = (res["prx_cpu_s"] * 1e6 / res["requests"] res["cpu_us_per_req"] = (res["prx_cpu_s"] * 1e6 / res["requests"]
@ -477,9 +620,9 @@ def measure(proxy, scenario, args, work):
# --- main -------------------------------------------------------------------- # --- main --------------------------------------------------------------------
FIELDS = ["proxy", "scenario", "rep", "gbit", "rate", "p50_ms", "p99_ms", "errors", "retrans", FIELDS = ["proxy", "scenario", "rep", "gbit", "rate", "p50_ms", "p99_ms", "errors", "timeouts", "retrans",
"prx_cpu_s", "cpu_s_per_gb", "cpu_us_per_req", "peak_mb", "prx_cpu_s", "prx_task_s", "cpu_s_per_gb", "cpu_us_per_req", "peak_mb",
"cli_util", "prx_util", "srv_util"] "cli_util", "prx_util", "srv_util", "cli_thread", "srv_thread", "bound"]
def summary(rows): def summary(rows):
@ -503,13 +646,14 @@ def summary(rows):
def main(): def main():
ap = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__.split("\n\n")[0]) ap = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__.split("\n\n")[0])
ap.add_argument("--proxy", action="append", required=True, ap.add_argument("--proxy", action="append", required=True,
help="3proxy:<binary>[:<service options>], nginx[:<binary>], haproxy[:<binary>] " help="3proxy:<binary>[:<service options>], nginx[:<binary>], "
"haproxy[:<binary>[:splice-auto|splice]] "
"or none (the kernel routing, an upper bound); repeat") "or none (the kernel routing, an upper bound); repeat")
ap.add_argument("--scenario", action="append", choices=sorted(SCENARIOS), ap.add_argument("--scenario", action="append", choices=sorted(SCENARIOS),
help="default: all") help="default: all")
ap.add_argument("--reps", type=int, default=3) ap.add_argument("--reps", type=int, default=3)
ap.add_argument("--duration", type=int, default=10, help="seconds per run") ap.add_argument("--duration", type=int, default=10, help="seconds per run")
ap.add_argument("--cpus", default="cli=0-3,prx=4-5,srv=6-7", ap.add_argument("--cpus", default="cli=0-3,prx=4,srv=5-7",
help="CPUs per role (default %(default)s)") help="CPUs per role (default %(default)s)")
ap.add_argument("--mtu", type=int, default=1500) ap.add_argument("--mtu", type=int, default=1500)
ap.add_argument("--netem", help='netem on the client link, e.g. "delay 1ms rate 10gbit"') ap.add_argument("--netem", help='netem on the client link, e.g. "delay 1ms rate 10gbit"')
@ -520,6 +664,9 @@ def main():
args.cpus = dict(x.split("=") for x in args.cpus.split(",")) args.cpus = dict(x.split("=") for x in args.cpus.split(","))
proxies = [Proxy(s) for s in args.proxy] proxies = [Proxy(s) for s in args.proxy]
scenarios = args.scenario or list(SCENARIOS) scenarios = args.scenario or list(SCENARIOS)
# fail now rather than after the first scenarios
for name in ("nginx", "iperf3", "wrk"):
tool(name)
stamp = datetime.datetime.now().strftime("%Y%m%d-%H%M%S") stamp = datetime.datetime.now().strftime("%Y%m%d-%H%M%S")
os.makedirs(args.out, exist_ok=True) os.makedirs(args.out, exist_ok=True)
@ -531,7 +678,8 @@ def main():
f.write(" ".join(sys.argv) + "\n") f.write(" ".join(sys.argv) + "\n")
f.write(sh("uname -a; lscpu | head -20; nproc; " f.write(sh("uname -a; lscpu | head -20; nproc; "
"cat /sys/devices/system/cpu/cpu0/cpufreq/scaling_governor 2>/dev/null; " "cat /sys/devices/system/cpu/cpu0/cpufreq/scaling_governor 2>/dev/null; "
"iperf3 --version | head -1; wrk -v 2>&1 | head -1; nginx -v 2>&1; " f"{tool('iperf3')} --version | head -1; {tool('wrk')} -v 2>&1 | head -1; "
f"{tool('nginx')} -v 2>&1; "
"haproxy -v 2>/dev/null | head -1", check=False)) "haproxy -v 2>/dev/null | head -1", check=False))
rows = [] rows = []
@ -556,12 +704,14 @@ def main():
f.flush() f.flush()
raw.write(f"=== {proxy.label} {scenario} {rep}\n{res['raw']}\n") raw.write(f"=== {proxy.label} {scenario} {rep}\n{res['raw']}\n")
print("%-24s %-14s rep %d: %7.2f Gbit/s %10.0f req/s proxy cpu %5.2fs " print("%-24s %-14s rep %d: %7.2f Gbit/s %10.0f req/s proxy cpu %5.2fs "
"util cli %3.0f%% prx %3.0f%% srv %3.0f%% errors %d" % ( "busy cli %3.0f%% prx %3.0f%% srv %3.0f%% (threads %3.0f%%/%3.0f%%) "
"bound %-6s errors %d" % (
proxy.label, scenario, rep, res["gbit"], proxy.label, scenario, rep, res["gbit"],
res["rate"] if res["rate"] == res["rate"] else 0, res["rate"] if res["rate"] == res["rate"] else 0,
res["prx_cpu_s"], res["cli_util"] * 100, res["prx_cpu_s"], res["cli_util"] * 100,
res["prx_util"] * 100, res["srv_util"] * 100, res["prx_util"] * 100, res["srv_util"] * 100,
res["errors"]), flush=True) res["cli_thread"] * 100, res["srv_thread"] * 100,
res["bound"], res["errors"]), flush=True)
finally: finally:
for p in origin: for p in origin:
stop(p) stop(p)

27
bench/data/m4-env.txt Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,27 @@
bench/bench.py --reps 3 --duration 10 --out bench/results-final --proxy none --proxy 3proxy:bench/bin/3proxy-0.9.4:-ocTCP_NODELAY -osTCP_NODELAY --proxy 3proxy:bench/bin/3proxy-0.9.4:-s0 -ocTCP_NODELAY -osTCP_NODELAY --proxy 3proxy:bench/bin/3proxy-1.0.1:-ocTCP_NODELAY -osTCP_NODELAY --proxy 3proxy:bench/bin/3proxy-devel --proxy 3proxy:bench/bin/3proxy-devel:-s --proxy nginx --proxy haproxy
Linux ubuntu-virt 6.8.0-139-generic #139-Ubuntu SMP PREEMPT_DYNAMIC Sat Aug 1 03:32:48 UTC 2026 aarch64 aarch64 aarch64 GNU/Linux
Architecture: aarch64
CPU op-mode(s): 64-bit
Byte Order: Little Endian
CPU(s): 8
On-line CPU(s) list: 0-7
Vendor ID: Apple
BIOS Vendor ID: Apple Inc.
Model name: -
BIOS Model name: CPU @ 0.0GHz
BIOS CPU family: 257
Model: 0
Thread(s) per core: 1
Core(s) per cluster: 8
Socket(s): 1
Cluster(s): 1
Stepping: 0x0
BogoMIPS: 48,00
Flags: fp asimd evtstrm aes pmull sha1 sha2 crc32 atomics fphp asimdhp cpuid asimdrdm jscvt fcma lrcpc dcpop sha3 asimddp sha512 asimdfhm dit uscat ilrcpc flagm sb paca pacg dcpodp flagm2 frint i8mm bf16 bti afp
NUMA node(s): 1
NUMA node0 CPU(s): 0-7
8
iperf 3.16 (cJSON 1.7.15)
wrk debian/4.1.0-4build2 [epoll] Copyright (C) 2012 Will Glozer
nginx version: nginx/1.24.0 (Ubuntu)
HAProxy version 2.8.16-0ubuntu0.24.04.3 2026/06/19 - https://haproxy.org/

64
bench/data/m4-haproxy-splice.csv Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,64 @@
proxy,scenario,rep,gbit,rate,p50_ms,p99_ms,errors,timeouts,retrans,prx_cpu_s,prx_task_s,cpu_s_per_gb,cpu_us_per_req,peak_mb,cli_util,prx_util,srv_util,cli_thread,srv_thread,bound
haproxy,stream1,0,12.470885279042667,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.000143,0.6420094931512967,nan,30.35546875,0.2060312568787145,0.999001996007984,0.20981165133596144,0.12689777512488556,0.5330982979381341,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,stream1,0,29.89117860621185,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.98,9.507242,0.2670286748118488,nan,44.9296875,0.07797029702970297,0.9257884972170687,0.267870036101083,0.22455002102003757,0.7289534887541377,proxy
haproxy-splice,stream1,0,47.276622227678985,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.92,9.068391,0.16783182521748577,nan,44.9765625,0.1667447306791569,0.9042844120328167,0.3173747622067216,0.38251154639763685,0.9515244508907347,origin
haproxy,stream16,0,9.126816993294865,nan,nan,nan,0,0,6,10.02,10.008672,0.87779780687716,nan,60.5625,0.12864186463469296,0.9515669515669516,0.7121966397013068,0.10178154529645375,1.3412808028682561,origin
haproxy-splice-auto,stream16,0,15.665416161722957,nan,nan,nan,0,0,10,10.01,10.009196,0.5108377207880435,nan,50.41015625,0.20893278934936654,0.9515209125475285,0.7146831530139104,0.17028929067443577,1.279742158250854,origin
haproxy-splice,stream16,0,21.84620025436062,nan,nan,nan,0,0,5,10.02,10.004629,0.3667854948979959,nan,60.96875,0.27884022208513265,0.9506641366223909,0.7257869249394673,0.24534597309840397,1.2156886451110003,origin
haproxy,stream1-down,0,13.960123370583007,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,9.999398,0.5730096684278911,nan,35.16015625,0.142692750287687,0.9505703422053232,0.24893955461293743,0.5220067520499043,0.1168309458750056,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,stream1-down,0,30.440812819799515,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,9.77417,0.262794402388071,nan,40.4453125,0.19289074751698904,0.9398496240601504,0.2629094947251527,0.7307960970461047,0.270908729124504,proxy
haproxy-splice,stream1-down,0,47.62696450489736,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.96,9.308399999999999,0.16728181803047182,nan,42.109375,0.2393629664844307,0.9162833486660533,0.21685991852083986,0.9514145276910632,0.38968830503606744,client
haproxy,http-ka-1k,0,0.44224741376,43767.86,1.4,2.12,0,0,0,10.1,10.09507,18.270316000954335,22.847732306014834,29.75390625,0.4527994201848161,0.9600760456273765,0.4640539839086426,0.6925179771661301,0.3136237673521794,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-1k,0,0.4412407808,43668.11,1.4,2.13,0,0,0,10.09,10.089706000000001,18.2938666398081,22.879247909916078,35.796875,0.45099108928896164,0.9600380589914367,0.46659761781460385,0.6936018485235806,0.32032686619155504,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-ka-1k,0,0.44400902144,43945.28,1.39,2.11,0,0,0,10.09,10.094142999999999,18.179810792630008,22.73300769632847,35.80078125,0.45607375271149675,0.9600380589914367,0.4628956927867151,0.698295986925665,0.3363989405582086,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1m,0,5.8981141708800005,702.88,22.52,26.65,0,0,0,10.09,10.100358,1.3685730330302601,1421.3269474573883,37.34765625,0.6215240925493526,0.9600380589914367,0.16199095022624435,1.2678542450703074,0.026603372180188496,client
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-1m,0,6.25806934016,745.21,21.17,25.1,0,0,0,10.11,10.097527999999999,1.2924113748783124,1343.343077331916,44.88671875,0.5915651781686965,0.9601139601139601,0.15641103364655956,1.2825439345426253,0.026609834615750023,client
haproxy-splice,http-ka-1m,0,28.346784153599998,3382.78,4.66,5.72,0,0,0,9.99,9.951156,0.2819367430426858,295.2738450625129,52.44140625,0.5561823104693141,0.950523311132255,0.23213789268835142,1.6438977194646323,0.10547278904621821,client
haproxy,http-ka-50k-2000,0,4.07166255104,9744.89,193.14,512.74,0,0,0,10.09,10.039950999999999,1.9824825605791467,102.71183680117268,176.00390625,0.5347850156855508,0.9591254752851711,0.2985718135273511,0.8752281070644606,0.09218093276895038,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-50k-2000,0,3.9366898483200004,9421.6,200.61,570.88,0,0,0,10.09,10.047718999999999,2.050453632623551,106.2228258008822,182.140625,0.5346644481419855,0.9591254752851711,0.2891137855579869,0.884949502988458,0.09027899200636934,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-ka-50k-2000,0,4.9580867583999995,11984.65,161.23,393.17,0,0,0,10.12,10.072325999999999,1.6328879252231197,83.82826801852174,136.0390625,0.5424570111682325,0.9619771863117871,0.48020113136392206,0.844047476500976,0.11502621442719918,proxy
haproxy,http-close-1k,0,0.17045651456,16623.35,3.69,4.55,0,0,0,10.11,10.062655000000001,47.44905186450387,60.217282538774924,29.53515625,0.5420985633751592,0.9601139601139601,0.4613646633529146,0.8191778310296798,0.1492330706128941,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-close-1k,0,0.169869312,16560.35,3.71,4.5,0,0,0,10.1,10.066307,47.565978250385804,60.38755657596575,35.7578125,0.5444001449800653,0.9600760456273765,0.46188850967007966,0.8210625053404907,0.1549161742184061,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-close-1k,0,0.16978542591999998,16555.02,3.72,4.42,0,0,0,10.1,10.062906,47.58947922778224,60.405253462835816,35.625,0.5433996383363472,0.9600760456273765,0.46545536114849706,0.8136549127740669,0.19295717801130827,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,stream1,1,27.657705036907,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,9.833874,0.28919158401814893,nan,40.65234375,0.15907990314769976,0.9900990099009901,0.26803708182184605,0.23978301610049976,0.698794525197252,proxy
haproxy-splice,stream1,1,44.66709383479124,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.96,9.483912,0.17835478491282797,nan,44.984375,0.09460154241645244,0.9239332096474954,0.303347280334728,0.32433711631255135,0.838195850298805,proxy
haproxy,stream1,1,13.9130793718519,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,10.001526,0.5748229081905579,nan,31.44921875,0.13121361397223466,0.9514747859181731,0.1997513468711148,0.11609297064619445,0.5218641241285665,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,stream16,1,15.871037952656748,nan,nan,nan,0,0,11,10.04,10.011549,0.5056481486447681,nan,60.015625,0.22426160337552742,0.9516587677725118,0.7153581482639975,0.17497538300354495,1.2916249924400047,origin
haproxy-splice,stream16,1,22.562433611542634,nan,nan,nan,0,0,3,10.03,10.008068,0.3554258363877096,nan,55.68359375,0.27662203913491246,0.9516129032258065,0.7242658423493045,0.2416265140565151,1.2786892962500593,origin
haproxy,stream16,1,8.56274783754313,nan,nan,nan,0,0,8,10.02,10.009423,0.9354805272106242,nan,43.66015625,0.11837013430457546,0.9515669515669516,0.6884035681328822,0.09227811846283687,1.3248314087242796,origin
haproxy-splice-auto,stream1-down,1,29.532618920028337,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.98,9.745233,0.2703355432066713,nan,40.23828125,0.18612747723620782,0.9379699248120301,0.08706208810267083,0.6914418421747642,0.23085334338816266,proxy
haproxy-splice,stream1-down,1,45.20745569639618,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.96,9.484789000000001,0.1762340398376784,nan,44.6015625,0.2248864209994952,0.924791086350975,0.14191761855313256,0.8562900706132912,0.34591034845458013,proxy
haproxy,stream1-down,1,13.280333707459034,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,10.001983,0.6023285462637666,nan,32.8359375,0.13882488479262672,0.9505703422053232,0.24791834542035993,0.5136100587673486,0.12826097080847915,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-1k,1,0.44711280639999995,44248.96,1.39,2.07,0,0,0,10.11,10.087575999999999,18.089394632020987,22.62276373644816,35.80859375,0.4535765895953757,0.9601139601139601,0.4662004662004662,0.6886438222525255,0.2945534754186057,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-ka-1k,1,0.44593840127999995,44132.54,1.39,2.1,0,0,0,10.1,10.087207,18.11909442382078,22.658491662348094,35.796875,0.45339366515837104,0.9600760456273765,0.46313603322949115,0.6945662425374509,0.3221811798409665,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1k,1,0.44862275584,44402.84,1.38,2.08,0,0,0,10.1,10.091105,18.01067800243666,22.52262297129146,29.70703125,0.45520100955471426,0.9600760456273765,0.4665288188162316,0.6924554721759041,0.29546388241465266,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-1m,1,5.906922209279999,703.12,22.55,26.06,0,0,0,10.09,10.096472,1.3665323012581037,1420.9266300521053,43.19921875,0.6057525951557093,0.9591254752851711,0.13498452012383902,1.2206981774202692,0.020907726724359123,client
haproxy-splice,http-ka-1m,1,28.00318676992,3338.12,4.72,6.53,0,0,0,10.0,9.953499,0.28568177135444134,299.43705833033897,52.203125,0.5647553686074829,0.9505703422053232,0.2257247396566282,1.6406109424173014,0.09314792662013098,client
haproxy,http-ka-1m,1,5.91371698176,704.32,22.55,25.24,0,0,0,10.09,10.092942,1.3649621760555857,1418.5294531140166,38.8359375,0.624,0.9600380589914367,0.15222623345367028,1.253629079008308,0.030413129775669574,client
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-50k-2000,1,4.0017854464000004,9573.19,198.04,506.2,0,0,0,10.08,10.040982,2.0151005365003662,104.48410970831519,184.0,0.5310818333642605,0.9581749049429658,0.29093886462882096,0.877336596256015,0.0921928976926707,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-ka-50k-2000,1,4.850209259520001,11724.01,164.56,467.97,0,0,0,10.11,10.057952,1.6675569170804037,85.57643473844591,132.6796875,0.5495367070563079,0.9610266159695817,0.48620045652625027,0.8827828822617122,0.11212372578867655,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-50k-2000,1,4.05740191744,9702.65,195.76,645.83,0,0,0,10.09,10.040626,1.9894504326288172,103.36843830676555,177.29296875,0.5312326227988878,0.9582146248812915,0.2982786444324906,0.8723025194799039,0.09122591365490804,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-close-1k,1,0.17246978048,16820.23,3.67,4.28,0,0,0,10.0,9.971963,46.384937568397376,59.415235254623994,35.59375,0.5402319681043857,0.9514747859181731,0.46653279785809904,0.812422387488307,0.20048900026686614,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-close-1k,1,0.17339252736000002,16905.08,3.65,4.24,0,0,0,10.11,10.064707,46.64560879955097,59.21318503681057,35.70703125,0.5444988218234548,0.959203036053131,0.4523154516276937,0.8220920443166914,0.22048409460256574,proxy
haproxy,http-close-1k,1,0.17221812224000002,16794.68,3.68,4.25,0,0,0,10.09,10.066023999999999,46.87079324178793,59.48731251768701,29.53515625,0.5452406804198335,0.9600380589914367,0.4732519422863485,0.8219748116165262,0.1681692979728716,proxy
haproxy-splice,stream1,2,44.025537299292175,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.98,9.64556,0.18131571189526788,nan,44.91796875,0.15224166866458883,0.9327102803738317,0.3000352982703848,0.3729495374137985,0.8229787358803089,proxy
haproxy,stream1,2,13.420193637999308,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,10.00282,0.5958974733855598,nan,31.4140625,0.05717791411042945,0.9514747859181731,0.19552609776304888,0.12086002113679797,0.5182343923337167,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,stream1,2,29.507297892950234,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.97,9.623803,0.2702392892979522,nan,44.4609375,0.07093881856540084,0.9774509803921568,0.27580772261623326,0.2157945829744378,0.7366131461399941,proxy
haproxy-splice,stream16,2,22.12554165032845,nan,nan,nan,0,0,2,10.02,10.003693,0.36212735525203216,nan,54.74609375,0.2913907284768212,0.9506641366223909,0.7249082007343941,0.23862270559995377,1.2426461145422065,origin
haproxy,stream16,2,8.580147028941548,nan,nan,nan,0,0,6,10.03,10.00947,0.9346185347163698,nan,51.703125,0.17872340425531916,0.9516129032258065,0.6840330983757279,0.09415712324018922,1.340238855783671,origin
haproxy-splice-auto,stream16,2,15.973129606882429,nan,nan,nan,0,0,13,10.03,10.012126,0.5019140976009596,nan,60.0,0.2711763538980361,0.9516129032258065,0.711083819465766,0.1807299535793587,1.3052893396648573,origin
haproxy-splice,stream1-down,2,48.59185309676415,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.93,9.026188000000001,0.16346198078264335,nan,44.9375,0.23901164172012354,0.9019073569482289,0.1280977312390925,0.9513393656065166,0.34494886912870415,client
haproxy,stream1-down,2,13.238887720464081,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.002078,0.6048169736106161,nan,31.21875,0.1375432525951557,0.9506172839506173,0.05361384458771632,0.49179301438541884,0.11592095587872998,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,stream1-down,2,30.76905592533716,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.99,9.65392,0.2597207502459875,nan,41.29296875,0.1940376569037657,0.9336448598130841,0.09265614275909403,0.7237916928519336,0.22990802153107426,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-ka-1k,2,0.44904218624000003,44444.43,1.38,2.08,0,0,0,10.1,10.094124,17.99385502653302,22.500796439081878,35.796875,0.4565061107117182,0.9591642924976258,0.46492363448097335,0.6905813584959353,0.3030430566697726,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1k,2,0.44568674304,44112.76,1.39,2.09,0,0,0,10.01,10.002418,17.967776975769922,22.674504207581574,29.71484375,0.44922797456857405,0.9515209125475285,0.4595788926436184,0.6905693150174204,0.3098286205277593,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-1k,2,0.44602228736,44139.96,1.39,2.11,0,0,0,10.01,10.00352,17.954259746523533,22.658695755512447,35.79296875,0.4514140681653372,0.9515209125475285,0.4600780234070221,0.6927552847361909,0.30133454145667854,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-ka-1m,2,27.4877906944,3276.96,4.78,6.88,0,0,0,9.99,9.923215,0.2907472662627697,304.7961923358555,52.234375,0.5973016235993597,0.999,0.22384066587395957,1.6187790952229908,0.10784169195139078,client
haproxy,http-ka-1m,2,5.767839088640001,687.06,23.09,26.32,0,0,0,10.11,10.097942,1.4022582592377886,1456.9822741028968,37.94140625,0.6142604074402126,0.9601139601139601,0.15242424242424243,1.2832361890399908,0.02660297986960112,client
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-1m,2,5.5785082060799995,663.85,23.81,28.12,0,0,0,10.1,10.099212000000001,1.4484159028741108,1506.3385533184191,43.671875,0.6274887604367373,0.9600760456273765,0.1124129195693477,1.2758842161775354,0.028503600136568153,client
haproxy-splice,http-ka-50k-2000,2,4.92235128832,11897.29,163.37,414.88,0,0,0,10.13,10.062857,1.6463676656376751,84.49552916054985,151.32421875,0.5455516014234876,0.9620132953466287,0.483153078202995,0.8592217872562844,0.11119336969404632,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-50k-2000,2,4.06822322176,9736.04,194.05,680.82,0,0,0,10.09,10.042601,1.984158577342735,102.92977516627903,177.98828125,0.5328911000552792,0.9582146248812915,0.29488220958570266,0.8649197963205894,0.09123941413633474,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-50k-2000,2,4.08936251392,9784.39,191.94,569.22,0,0,0,10.08,10.042211,1.9719454982409896,102.35684765279908,181.41796875,0.5373106760251201,0.9590865842055185,0.2985756517065305,0.8915635476483981,0.09314699784890836,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-close-1k,2,0.17230200832,16803.03,3.67,4.27,0,0,0,10.1,10.066593,46.894404068661764,59.51819724684141,35.89453125,0.5420374069366262,0.9600760456273765,0.4473441108545035,0.8136090213947146,0.18058427193404752,proxy
haproxy,http-close-1k,2,0.17431527424,16996.31,3.62,4.34,0,0,0,10.09,10.064283,46.30690015658836,58.78035140047537,29.65625,0.5434585374705135,0.9600380589914367,0.43952734012974976,0.8193729517211945,0.16926621774991768,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-close-1k,2,0.17079205888,16650.93,3.71,4.33,0,0,0,10.02,9.972787,46.93426645574963,60.12817743213077,35.7421875,0.5415685564209383,0.9515669515669516,0.4681848626925653,0.8173954622833055,0.1615753572679179,proxy
1 proxy scenario rep gbit rate p50_ms p99_ms errors timeouts retrans prx_cpu_s prx_task_s cpu_s_per_gb cpu_us_per_req peak_mb cli_util prx_util srv_util cli_thread srv_thread bound
2 haproxy stream1 0 12.470885279042667 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.000143 0.6420094931512967 nan 30.35546875 0.2060312568787145 0.999001996007984 0.20981165133596144 0.12689777512488556 0.5330982979381341 proxy
3 haproxy-splice-auto stream1 0 29.89117860621185 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.98 9.507242 0.2670286748118488 nan 44.9296875 0.07797029702970297 0.9257884972170687 0.267870036101083 0.22455002102003757 0.7289534887541377 proxy
4 haproxy-splice stream1 0 47.276622227678985 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.92 9.068391 0.16783182521748577 nan 44.9765625 0.1667447306791569 0.9042844120328167 0.3173747622067216 0.38251154639763685 0.9515244508907347 origin
5 haproxy stream16 0 9.126816993294865 nan nan nan 0 0 6 10.02 10.008672 0.87779780687716 nan 60.5625 0.12864186463469296 0.9515669515669516 0.7121966397013068 0.10178154529645375 1.3412808028682561 origin
6 haproxy-splice-auto stream16 0 15.665416161722957 nan nan nan 0 0 10 10.01 10.009196 0.5108377207880435 nan 50.41015625 0.20893278934936654 0.9515209125475285 0.7146831530139104 0.17028929067443577 1.279742158250854 origin
7 haproxy-splice stream16 0 21.84620025436062 nan nan nan 0 0 5 10.02 10.004629 0.3667854948979959 nan 60.96875 0.27884022208513265 0.9506641366223909 0.7257869249394673 0.24534597309840397 1.2156886451110003 origin
8 haproxy stream1-down 0 13.960123370583007 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 9.999398 0.5730096684278911 nan 35.16015625 0.142692750287687 0.9505703422053232 0.24893955461293743 0.5220067520499043 0.1168309458750056 proxy
9 haproxy-splice-auto stream1-down 0 30.440812819799515 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 9.77417 0.262794402388071 nan 40.4453125 0.19289074751698904 0.9398496240601504 0.2629094947251527 0.7307960970461047 0.270908729124504 proxy
10 haproxy-splice stream1-down 0 47.62696450489736 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.96 9.308399999999999 0.16728181803047182 nan 42.109375 0.2393629664844307 0.9162833486660533 0.21685991852083986 0.9514145276910632 0.38968830503606744 client
11 haproxy http-ka-1k 0 0.44224741376 43767.86 1.4 2.12 0 0 0 10.1 10.09507 18.270316000954335 22.847732306014834 29.75390625 0.4527994201848161 0.9600760456273765 0.4640539839086426 0.6925179771661301 0.3136237673521794 proxy
12 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-1k 0 0.4412407808 43668.11 1.4 2.13 0 0 0 10.09 10.089706000000001 18.2938666398081 22.879247909916078 35.796875 0.45099108928896164 0.9600380589914367 0.46659761781460385 0.6936018485235806 0.32032686619155504 proxy
13 haproxy-splice http-ka-1k 0 0.44400902144 43945.28 1.39 2.11 0 0 0 10.09 10.094142999999999 18.179810792630008 22.73300769632847 35.80078125 0.45607375271149675 0.9600380589914367 0.4628956927867151 0.698295986925665 0.3363989405582086 proxy
14 haproxy http-ka-1m 0 5.8981141708800005 702.88 22.52 26.65 0 0 0 10.09 10.100358 1.3685730330302601 1421.3269474573883 37.34765625 0.6215240925493526 0.9600380589914367 0.16199095022624435 1.2678542450703074 0.026603372180188496 client
15 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-1m 0 6.25806934016 745.21 21.17 25.1 0 0 0 10.11 10.097527999999999 1.2924113748783124 1343.343077331916 44.88671875 0.5915651781686965 0.9601139601139601 0.15641103364655956 1.2825439345426253 0.026609834615750023 client
16 haproxy-splice http-ka-1m 0 28.346784153599998 3382.78 4.66 5.72 0 0 0 9.99 9.951156 0.2819367430426858 295.2738450625129 52.44140625 0.5561823104693141 0.950523311132255 0.23213789268835142 1.6438977194646323 0.10547278904621821 client
17 haproxy http-ka-50k-2000 0 4.07166255104 9744.89 193.14 512.74 0 0 0 10.09 10.039950999999999 1.9824825605791467 102.71183680117268 176.00390625 0.5347850156855508 0.9591254752851711 0.2985718135273511 0.8752281070644606 0.09218093276895038 proxy
18 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-50k-2000 0 3.9366898483200004 9421.6 200.61 570.88 0 0 0 10.09 10.047718999999999 2.050453632623551 106.2228258008822 182.140625 0.5346644481419855 0.9591254752851711 0.2891137855579869 0.884949502988458 0.09027899200636934 proxy
19 haproxy-splice http-ka-50k-2000 0 4.9580867583999995 11984.65 161.23 393.17 0 0 0 10.12 10.072325999999999 1.6328879252231197 83.82826801852174 136.0390625 0.5424570111682325 0.9619771863117871 0.48020113136392206 0.844047476500976 0.11502621442719918 proxy
20 haproxy http-close-1k 0 0.17045651456 16623.35 3.69 4.55 0 0 0 10.11 10.062655000000001 47.44905186450387 60.217282538774924 29.53515625 0.5420985633751592 0.9601139601139601 0.4613646633529146 0.8191778310296798 0.1492330706128941 proxy
21 haproxy-splice-auto http-close-1k 0 0.169869312 16560.35 3.71 4.5 0 0 0 10.1 10.066307 47.565978250385804 60.38755657596575 35.7578125 0.5444001449800653 0.9600760456273765 0.46188850967007966 0.8210625053404907 0.1549161742184061 proxy
22 haproxy-splice http-close-1k 0 0.16978542591999998 16555.02 3.72 4.42 0 0 0 10.1 10.062906 47.58947922778224 60.405253462835816 35.625 0.5433996383363472 0.9600760456273765 0.46545536114849706 0.8136549127740669 0.19295717801130827 proxy
23 haproxy-splice-auto stream1 1 27.657705036907 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 9.833874 0.28919158401814893 nan 40.65234375 0.15907990314769976 0.9900990099009901 0.26803708182184605 0.23978301610049976 0.698794525197252 proxy
24 haproxy-splice stream1 1 44.66709383479124 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.96 9.483912 0.17835478491282797 nan 44.984375 0.09460154241645244 0.9239332096474954 0.303347280334728 0.32433711631255135 0.838195850298805 proxy
25 haproxy stream1 1 13.9130793718519 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 10.001526 0.5748229081905579 nan 31.44921875 0.13121361397223466 0.9514747859181731 0.1997513468711148 0.11609297064619445 0.5218641241285665 proxy
26 haproxy-splice-auto stream16 1 15.871037952656748 nan nan nan 0 0 11 10.04 10.011549 0.5056481486447681 nan 60.015625 0.22426160337552742 0.9516587677725118 0.7153581482639975 0.17497538300354495 1.2916249924400047 origin
27 haproxy-splice stream16 1 22.562433611542634 nan nan nan 0 0 3 10.03 10.008068 0.3554258363877096 nan 55.68359375 0.27662203913491246 0.9516129032258065 0.7242658423493045 0.2416265140565151 1.2786892962500593 origin
28 haproxy stream16 1 8.56274783754313 nan nan nan 0 0 8 10.02 10.009423 0.9354805272106242 nan 43.66015625 0.11837013430457546 0.9515669515669516 0.6884035681328822 0.09227811846283687 1.3248314087242796 origin
29 haproxy-splice-auto stream1-down 1 29.532618920028337 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.98 9.745233 0.2703355432066713 nan 40.23828125 0.18612747723620782 0.9379699248120301 0.08706208810267083 0.6914418421747642 0.23085334338816266 proxy
30 haproxy-splice stream1-down 1 45.20745569639618 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.96 9.484789000000001 0.1762340398376784 nan 44.6015625 0.2248864209994952 0.924791086350975 0.14191761855313256 0.8562900706132912 0.34591034845458013 proxy
31 haproxy stream1-down 1 13.280333707459034 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 10.001983 0.6023285462637666 nan 32.8359375 0.13882488479262672 0.9505703422053232 0.24791834542035993 0.5136100587673486 0.12826097080847915 proxy
32 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-1k 1 0.44711280639999995 44248.96 1.39 2.07 0 0 0 10.11 10.087575999999999 18.089394632020987 22.62276373644816 35.80859375 0.4535765895953757 0.9601139601139601 0.4662004662004662 0.6886438222525255 0.2945534754186057 proxy
33 haproxy-splice http-ka-1k 1 0.44593840127999995 44132.54 1.39 2.1 0 0 0 10.1 10.087207 18.11909442382078 22.658491662348094 35.796875 0.45339366515837104 0.9600760456273765 0.46313603322949115 0.6945662425374509 0.3221811798409665 proxy
34 haproxy http-ka-1k 1 0.44862275584 44402.84 1.38 2.08 0 0 0 10.1 10.091105 18.01067800243666 22.52262297129146 29.70703125 0.45520100955471426 0.9600760456273765 0.4665288188162316 0.6924554721759041 0.29546388241465266 proxy
35 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-1m 1 5.906922209279999 703.12 22.55 26.06 0 0 0 10.09 10.096472 1.3665323012581037 1420.9266300521053 43.19921875 0.6057525951557093 0.9591254752851711 0.13498452012383902 1.2206981774202692 0.020907726724359123 client
36 haproxy-splice http-ka-1m 1 28.00318676992 3338.12 4.72 6.53 0 0 0 10.0 9.953499 0.28568177135444134 299.43705833033897 52.203125 0.5647553686074829 0.9505703422053232 0.2257247396566282 1.6406109424173014 0.09314792662013098 client
37 haproxy http-ka-1m 1 5.91371698176 704.32 22.55 25.24 0 0 0 10.09 10.092942 1.3649621760555857 1418.5294531140166 38.8359375 0.624 0.9600380589914367 0.15222623345367028 1.253629079008308 0.030413129775669574 client
38 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-50k-2000 1 4.0017854464000004 9573.19 198.04 506.2 0 0 0 10.08 10.040982 2.0151005365003662 104.48410970831519 184.0 0.5310818333642605 0.9581749049429658 0.29093886462882096 0.877336596256015 0.0921928976926707 proxy
39 haproxy-splice http-ka-50k-2000 1 4.850209259520001 11724.01 164.56 467.97 0 0 0 10.11 10.057952 1.6675569170804037 85.57643473844591 132.6796875 0.5495367070563079 0.9610266159695817 0.48620045652625027 0.8827828822617122 0.11212372578867655 proxy
40 haproxy http-ka-50k-2000 1 4.05740191744 9702.65 195.76 645.83 0 0 0 10.09 10.040626 1.9894504326288172 103.36843830676555 177.29296875 0.5312326227988878 0.9582146248812915 0.2982786444324906 0.8723025194799039 0.09122591365490804 proxy
41 haproxy-splice-auto http-close-1k 1 0.17246978048 16820.23 3.67 4.28 0 0 0 10.0 9.971963 46.384937568397376 59.415235254623994 35.59375 0.5402319681043857 0.9514747859181731 0.46653279785809904 0.812422387488307 0.20048900026686614 proxy
42 haproxy-splice http-close-1k 1 0.17339252736000002 16905.08 3.65 4.24 0 0 0 10.11 10.064707 46.64560879955097 59.21318503681057 35.70703125 0.5444988218234548 0.959203036053131 0.4523154516276937 0.8220920443166914 0.22048409460256574 proxy
43 haproxy http-close-1k 1 0.17221812224000002 16794.68 3.68 4.25 0 0 0 10.09 10.066023999999999 46.87079324178793 59.48731251768701 29.53515625 0.5452406804198335 0.9600380589914367 0.4732519422863485 0.8219748116165262 0.1681692979728716 proxy
44 haproxy-splice stream1 2 44.025537299292175 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.98 9.64556 0.18131571189526788 nan 44.91796875 0.15224166866458883 0.9327102803738317 0.3000352982703848 0.3729495374137985 0.8229787358803089 proxy
45 haproxy stream1 2 13.420193637999308 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 10.00282 0.5958974733855598 nan 31.4140625 0.05717791411042945 0.9514747859181731 0.19552609776304888 0.12086002113679797 0.5182343923337167 proxy
46 haproxy-splice-auto stream1 2 29.507297892950234 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.97 9.623803 0.2702392892979522 nan 44.4609375 0.07093881856540084 0.9774509803921568 0.27580772261623326 0.2157945829744378 0.7366131461399941 proxy
47 haproxy-splice stream16 2 22.12554165032845 nan nan nan 0 0 2 10.02 10.003693 0.36212735525203216 nan 54.74609375 0.2913907284768212 0.9506641366223909 0.7249082007343941 0.23862270559995377 1.2426461145422065 origin
48 haproxy stream16 2 8.580147028941548 nan nan nan 0 0 6 10.03 10.00947 0.9346185347163698 nan 51.703125 0.17872340425531916 0.9516129032258065 0.6840330983757279 0.09415712324018922 1.340238855783671 origin
49 haproxy-splice-auto stream16 2 15.973129606882429 nan nan nan 0 0 13 10.03 10.012126 0.5019140976009596 nan 60.0 0.2711763538980361 0.9516129032258065 0.711083819465766 0.1807299535793587 1.3052893396648573 origin
50 haproxy-splice stream1-down 2 48.59185309676415 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.93 9.026188000000001 0.16346198078264335 nan 44.9375 0.23901164172012354 0.9019073569482289 0.1280977312390925 0.9513393656065166 0.34494886912870415 client
51 haproxy stream1-down 2 13.238887720464081 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.002078 0.6048169736106161 nan 31.21875 0.1375432525951557 0.9506172839506173 0.05361384458771632 0.49179301438541884 0.11592095587872998 proxy
52 haproxy-splice-auto stream1-down 2 30.76905592533716 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.99 9.65392 0.2597207502459875 nan 41.29296875 0.1940376569037657 0.9336448598130841 0.09265614275909403 0.7237916928519336 0.22990802153107426 proxy
53 haproxy-splice http-ka-1k 2 0.44904218624000003 44444.43 1.38 2.08 0 0 0 10.1 10.094124 17.99385502653302 22.500796439081878 35.796875 0.4565061107117182 0.9591642924976258 0.46492363448097335 0.6905813584959353 0.3030430566697726 proxy
54 haproxy http-ka-1k 2 0.44568674304 44112.76 1.39 2.09 0 0 0 10.01 10.002418 17.967776975769922 22.674504207581574 29.71484375 0.44922797456857405 0.9515209125475285 0.4595788926436184 0.6905693150174204 0.3098286205277593 proxy
55 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-1k 2 0.44602228736 44139.96 1.39 2.11 0 0 0 10.01 10.00352 17.954259746523533 22.658695755512447 35.79296875 0.4514140681653372 0.9515209125475285 0.4600780234070221 0.6927552847361909 0.30133454145667854 proxy
56 haproxy-splice http-ka-1m 2 27.4877906944 3276.96 4.78 6.88 0 0 0 9.99 9.923215 0.2907472662627697 304.7961923358555 52.234375 0.5973016235993597 0.999 0.22384066587395957 1.6187790952229908 0.10784169195139078 client
57 haproxy http-ka-1m 2 5.767839088640001 687.06 23.09 26.32 0 0 0 10.11 10.097942 1.4022582592377886 1456.9822741028968 37.94140625 0.6142604074402126 0.9601139601139601 0.15242424242424243 1.2832361890399908 0.02660297986960112 client
58 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-1m 2 5.5785082060799995 663.85 23.81 28.12 0 0 0 10.1 10.099212000000001 1.4484159028741108 1506.3385533184191 43.671875 0.6274887604367373 0.9600760456273765 0.1124129195693477 1.2758842161775354 0.028503600136568153 client
59 haproxy-splice http-ka-50k-2000 2 4.92235128832 11897.29 163.37 414.88 0 0 0 10.13 10.062857 1.6463676656376751 84.49552916054985 151.32421875 0.5455516014234876 0.9620132953466287 0.483153078202995 0.8592217872562844 0.11119336969404632 proxy
60 haproxy http-ka-50k-2000 2 4.06822322176 9736.04 194.05 680.82 0 0 0 10.09 10.042601 1.984158577342735 102.92977516627903 177.98828125 0.5328911000552792 0.9582146248812915 0.29488220958570266 0.8649197963205894 0.09123941413633474 proxy
61 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-50k-2000 2 4.08936251392 9784.39 191.94 569.22 0 0 0 10.08 10.042211 1.9719454982409896 102.35684765279908 181.41796875 0.5373106760251201 0.9590865842055185 0.2985756517065305 0.8915635476483981 0.09314699784890836 proxy
62 haproxy-splice http-close-1k 2 0.17230200832 16803.03 3.67 4.27 0 0 0 10.1 10.066593 46.894404068661764 59.51819724684141 35.89453125 0.5420374069366262 0.9600760456273765 0.4473441108545035 0.8136090213947146 0.18058427193404752 proxy
63 haproxy http-close-1k 2 0.17431527424 16996.31 3.62 4.34 0 0 0 10.09 10.064283 46.30690015658836 58.78035140047537 29.65625 0.5434585374705135 0.9600380589914367 0.43952734012974976 0.8193729517211945 0.16926621774991768 proxy
64 haproxy-splice-auto http-close-1k 2 0.17079205888 16650.93 3.71 4.33 0 0 0 10.02 9.972787 46.93426645574963 60.12817743213077 35.7421875 0.5415685564209383 0.9515669515669516 0.4681848626925653 0.8173954622833055 0.1615753572679179 proxy

169
bench/data/m4-main.csv Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,169 @@
proxy,scenario,rep,gbit,rate,p50_ms,p99_ms,errors,timeouts,retrans,prx_cpu_s,prx_task_s,cpu_s_per_gb,cpu_us_per_req,peak_mb,cli_util,prx_util,srv_util,cli_thread,srv_thread,bound
direct,stream1,0,61.59043807936239,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,0.07,0.0,0.0009090945904281307,nan,0.0,0.15914552736982643,0.010130246020260492,0.33659689399054693,0.542523909627398,0.9920184956182384,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,0,25.076815274321753,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.001756,0.3192535554117112,nan,4.5703125,0.14034676663542642,0.9506172839506173,0.3075668623613829,0.22547887021175553,0.8998971051200377,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,0,8.320864371719768,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.001265,0.9622296045989882,nan,2.171875,0.09806629834254144,0.9506172839506173,0.20161290322580644,0.08559402701932255,0.5118258825166938,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,0,21.129445707467838,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,9.998918,0.3789108481077464,nan,6.39453125,0.09235668789808917,0.9515209125475285,0.21260470682090146,0.19784026605014632,0.5586089505468658,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream1,0,22.045100293757027,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,10.001657,0.36277761019709465,nan,8.4375,0.08768520767549186,0.9505703422053232,0.22015073383577946,0.1892821448997447,0.5653165236592292,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream1,0,45.733864660192815,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.89,8.817747,0.17296129740164518,nan,11.4140625,0.10646866347847973,0.8925992779783394,0.3173747622067216,0.3453118000638853,0.9474347722871482,origin
nginx,stream1,0,13.502219260500269,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.002879,0.5928629926236841,nan,32.0390625,0.059215585747244295,0.9980059820538385,0.21870882740447958,0.11588387034324961,0.5469890694930801,proxy
haproxy,stream1,0,13.074724676255311,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.001975,0.6122991754617084,nan,30.234375,0.04035087719298246,0.9506172839506173,0.2,0.1122562984734366,0.5227224462734111,proxy
direct,stream16,0,141.16148088835325,nan,nan,nan,0,0,3723,0.31,0.0,0.0017563336806383245,nan,0.0,0.5459744830620326,0.05457746478873239,0.9503164556962025,1.5296777692959824,2.846258589236203,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,0,24.37506402915491,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1696,10.04,10.006798999999999,0.32865708613295747,nan,68.921875,0.1541483706956321,0.9534662867996201,0.32031517643028434,0.22920876854538716,0.8197928180249117,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,0,8.727871407167079,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1051,10.05,10.016788,0.9181255018866824,nan,24.5546875,0.08593930970581422,0.9544159544159544,0.2816796729840208,0.08276581520000051,0.632726762221158,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,0,20.882659266549513,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1816,10.05,10.004978999999999,0.3839491594428824,nan,76.11328125,0.13076923076923078,0.9535104364326376,0.26881720430107525,0.19778844727512063,0.5716611797506093,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream16,0,20.683068039219563,nan,nan,nan,0,0,2018,10.05,9.999567,0.387817586561441,nan,52.1328125,0.1397824577644064,0.9535104364326376,0.26135936913255725,0.19972138897003985,0.5632383924778547,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream16,0,36.88142111514797,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1729,10.02,9.981243,0.21714618962344945,nan,84.87890625,0.18587962962962962,0.9515669515669516,0.35127674258109043,0.35179881734362295,0.9295704072412715,origin
nginx,stream16,0,13.526442518804762,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1815,10.05,10.034925999999999,0.5925640285562345,nan,74.99609375,0.12301045929968167,0.9544159544159544,0.2937113776808433,0.13315927762132487,0.616550983411331,proxy
haproxy,stream16,0,9.500596986818456,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.03,10.006478,0.8442035098288654,nan,49.87890625,0.1736682546556951,0.9507109004739337,0.7012946979038225,0.11125250071463563,1.291515298093347,origin
direct,stream1-down,0,61.54374690443803,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,0.1,0.0,0.0012997464239230243,nan,0.0,0.251073503409952,0.014347202295552367,0.20786933927245732,0.9372038366817282,0.5728991681204915,client
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,0,47.863368062293,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.91,8.83401,0.1656195232648594,nan,10.67578125,0.25125,0.9349056603773584,0.2878605769230769,0.9472740801933867,0.4502748995413846,client
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,0,10.053500776066262,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,10.002113,0.7956568633457785,nan,2.84375,0.2219469903393609,0.9514747859181731,0.04069963000336361,0.8449148815408425,0.09219263446435975,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,0,22.432411451723134,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.002163,0.3569436671923783,nan,6.4296875,0.15131022823330514,0.9506172839506173,0.25606394707828006,0.5649721152037466,0.2128018914352686,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream1-down,0,22.1386177174921,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.002789,0.3616802866998139,nan,9.89453125,0.15313290250070244,0.9515209125475285,0.12183235867446393,0.5641362593700737,0.1938367623087162,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream1-down,0,47.3560956479822,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.93,8.989258999999999,0.16773134538475204,nan,11.23828125,0.41999521645539345,0.9010889292196007,0.2042907460774896,0.9401727710581673,0.3820936529645266,client
nginx,stream1-down,0,13.598172754592353,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,10.00013,0.5882475717441422,nan,34.21875,0.1541043637473299,0.998003992015968,0.10531628532974428,0.5263660973475165,0.12171259743303382,proxy
haproxy,stream1-down,0,13.04557020209267,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.99,10.001577000000001,0.6125540591772419,nan,30.6875,0.17640480849874196,0.9514285714285714,0.1926871735345328,0.5157725897846064,0.12262789874069302,proxy
direct,http-ka-1k,0,1.23874574336,120311.11,0.502,0.767,0,0,0,0.91,0.0,0.5876912222724234,0.7489317435130989,0.0,0.8062471706654595,0.2774390243902439,0.9533858267716535,2.502850504542173,0.9528021897151907,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,0,0.13597933568,13461.44,4.6,8.55,0,0,0,10.09,10.085132,59.36196084231376,74.21900859881279,5.3125,0.38467126770795496,0.9591254752851711,0.4049443757725587,0.38442310064795926,0.14444948982271436,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,0,0.14310965248,14160.83,4.36,8.29,0,0,0,10.09,10.103392,56.4043015975326,70.55105337127755,5.3125,0.3983276996975627,0.9600380589914367,0.4062111801242236,0.4053795728817735,0.15679788194444916,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,0,0.060565749759999996,5997.53,10.55,12.12,0,0,0,6.41,5.892927,84.66831534853273,106.56160125014546,9.4296875,0.15339163318364452,0.6296660117878192,0.1442687747035573,0.2739518353868087,0.10545455830369485,none
3proxy-devel,http-ka-1k,0,0.15980298240000002,15814.98,3.85,8.24,0,0,0,10.11,10.103257,50.61232198880413,63.3038207706661,9.3125,0.41626709287870717,0.9610266159695817,0.4333821376281113,0.4557657693361603,0.21004838330773956,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-1k,0,0.15015608319999998,14862.79,4.13,8.6,0,0,0,10.0,10.004617999999999,53.27789477129888,67.2436168996658,9.2578125,0.400362647325476,0.9514747859181731,0.4208969935929029,0.42725600771529987,0.15776746007234257,proxy
nginx,http-ka-1k,0,0.38545653760000004,37438.23,1.68,2.09,0,0,0,10.02,10.016202,20.79611893447361,26.716081641359267,30.16796875,0.4208509007282484,0.9524714828897338,0.45414118954974986,0.6185750236098108,0.30333217719531014,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1k,0,0.44862275584,44403.29,1.38,2.08,0,0,0,10.1,10.092595,18.01067800243666,22.52161852391974,29.7109375,0.44773933736042465,0.9600760456273765,0.4677210267046928,0.6925191237198265,0.31553329713730766,proxy
direct,http-ka-1m,0,71.38235645952001,8502.84,1.29,2.32,0,0,0,0.25,0.0,0.0028018127996855546,2.934203422454872,0.0,0.9309048178613396,0.044169611307420496,0.6012909632571996,3.6776368437892866,0.4544336356412374,client
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,0,32.55585210368,3883.29,3.89,8.53,0,0,0,10.02,9.985391,0.24622301313053013,257.6166602391053,16.984375,0.4876753081172971,0.9524714828897338,0.3697355533790402,1.4072569080833086,0.13684705872970046,client
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,0,8.33223655424,993.73,15.79,25.57,0,0,0,10.02,10.017144,0.9620466183141335,1006.6305003013864,12.5078125,0.23848726524311809,0.9515669515669516,0.08189519924694069,0.5907749255544233,0.03515967768304146,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,0,12.4554051584,1480.26,10.75,11.5,0,0,0,6.9,5.363434,0.4431810872308139,465.1162790697674,11.11328125,0.19615293279506055,0.6341911764705882,0.07758346581875994,0.5490367098688399,0.05132568508940509,none
3proxy-devel,http-ka-1m,0,21.990232555520002,2622.03,5.77,11.73,0,0,0,10.02,9.96345,0.3645254764705896,381.322068729307,19.0703125,0.38890097932535367,0.9533777354900095,0.21711079943899017,1.0049405487576604,0.12362131370626167,client
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-1m,0,35.30463117312,4202.74,3.53,8.65,0,0,0,10.02,9.947932000000002,0.22705236490625533,238.0952380952381,17.06640625,0.5084709868699704,0.9515669515669516,0.38868832731648617,1.4966583639715494,0.14539533846143493,client
nginx,http-ka-1m,0,12.627203850239999,1502.42,10.5,14.34,0,0,0,10.03,10.019086999999999,0.6354534301628061,666.3566303481265,45.60546875,0.29071499503475673,0.9525166191832859,0.08328173374613003,0.7798955597828292,0.04654943004942413,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1m,0,6.02226556928,717.05,22.13,26.28,0,0,0,10.09,10.100359,1.34035935598321,1393.2615299640984,39.10546875,0.6164913034142152,0.9600380589914367,0.15104009647271632,1.2611953734187002,0.02184922324712792,client
direct,http-ka-50k-2000,0,34.44563771392,83597.96,21.36,653.72,0,531,0,1.51,0.0,0.035069752809710045,1.789118604345307,0.0,0.8976982097186701,0.3793969849246231,0.9434920634920635,3.381443743187913,0.9475666754601523,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,0,3.72101873664,9041.86,67.48,190.21,0,481,0,10.43,10.38188,2.2423966635369466,114.5046548392763,100.265625,0.4756548288606781,0.9914448669201521,0.49294570329200516,0.45560365627383104,0.12353803865212871,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,0,3.11628398592,7572.42,81.79,246.09,0,503,0,10.41,10.363715,2.6724136945244994,136.4047328904438,132.41015625,0.47485399091499025,0.9895437262357415,0.4525371828521435,0.4234260960372297,0.1007558872384741,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,0,3.70499649536,9003.02,68.12,225.76,0,480,0,10.44,10.408701,2.2542531444927776,115.27377521613833,206.96875,0.30470390592188157,0.9933396764985728,0.324052812858783,0.4159046044059033,0.11412223049799855,proxy
3proxy-devel,http-ka-50k-2000,0,4.288340295679999,10420.37,57.75,172.75,0,496,0,10.39,10.361574,1.9382790139983448,98.97783239499681,193.98046875,0.4794651384909265,0.9885823025689819,0.5053464499572284,0.47278849098808134,0.13207793919829464,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-50k-2000,0,4.08466489344,9925.62,57.4,166.54,0,610,0,10.39,10.361924,2.0349282540531366,103.95821660129673,186.515625,0.47475231703419624,0.9876425855513308,0.4960120715671481,0.45559069014449605,0.127294880652316,proxy
nginx,http-ka-50k-2000,0,4.435895910399999,10774.0,66.87,85.03,0,338,0,10.14,10.102538999999998,1.8287173918985202,93.48982583601479,78.22265625,0.4268248175182482,0.9638783269961977,0.4438381082310141,0.47766825616381503,0.12164560872152692,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-50k-2000,0,3.9845888,9540.41,193.95,695.26,0,0,0,10.09,10.049517,2.025805021587171,104.97513473022742,178.3828125,0.5321375186846039,0.9591254752851711,0.29462832338578404,0.8962389296400717,0.09122410107872184,proxy
direct,http-close-1k,0,0.48494542848,47287.31,0.87,2.47,0,0,0,4.71,0.0,7.769946428426635,9.861912289701525,0.0,0.7769055980169387,0.5136314067611778,0.9360972568578554,2.2514680684726835,0.9028206642967048,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,0,0.049576673280000004,4833.7,13.05,18.02,0,0,0,10.01,9.908954,161.5275788024799,206.56637569904456,9.9765625,0.3274593338497289,0.9515209125475285,0.38796477495107634,0.27787220939323715,0.0845929270930012,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,0,0.05100273664,4976.02,12.7,17.47,0,0,0,10.03,9.919003,157.32489134135997,201.10678910855356,9.61328125,0.3289422704378148,0.9534220532319392,0.39449317738791423,0.2806871378622416,0.08744536686658436,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,0,0.04521459712,4406.68,14.25,22.13,0,0,0,10.02,9.868813000000001,177.2878784859114,227.02041371185175,29.73828125,0.24721030042918454,0.9524714828897338,0.2986904430203399,0.24834668257046094,0.07698453085959421,proxy
3proxy-devel,http-close-1k,0,0.0528482304,5152.66,12.21,17.34,0,0,0,10.01,9.894235,151.52825249565973,193.98097009863767,12.4296875,0.3351393188854489,0.9515209125475285,0.39799657952602,0.2920875794095629,0.08932091563637072,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-close-1k,0,0.05142216704,5014.24,12.55,17.78,0,0,0,10.01,9.888247,155.73050419619187,199.23173377385905,12.40234375,0.33603082851637767,0.9515209125475285,0.396240234375,0.2864431587240493,0.08747886553316407,proxy
nginx,http-close-1k,0,0.13639876608,13300.09,4.7,5.26,0,0,0,10.02,9.971497000000001,58.768860088503224,75.22296627728898,29.6953125,0.5281369513749772,0.9515669515669516,0.3856041131105398,0.7164067540389693,0.15395175858105878,proxy
haproxy,http-close-1k,0,0.17020485632,16591.82,3.71,4.39,0,0,0,10.09,10.066581000000001,47.42520380748676,60.21472008211641,29.796875,0.5440115440115441,0.9600380589914367,0.4718902169101372,0.8126631474982218,0.20339719368038653,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,1,24.128537890835506,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.001909,0.33182378356055536,nan,4.93359375,0.1204876882620129,0.9506172839506173,0.22343434343434343,0.21786695370343528,0.5833912195555127,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,1,10.155853300627914,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.003753999999999,0.7881915025627496,nan,4.94921875,0.11301446051167964,0.9506172839506173,0.27844950213371267,0.07801192476959028,0.7652136358644214,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,1,22.10263720326343,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,9.999949,0.36221549434084527,nan,11.078125,0.0581891146225232,0.9506172839506173,0.21894904458598727,0.18743641707799016,0.5654714009259497,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream1,1,22.282829232860685,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,10.002649,0.358900282309469,nan,8.23828125,0.11426437640029873,0.999000999000999,0.23177966101694916,0.18980949377395148,0.5949025878185107,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream1,1,40.75770404715078,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,9.873198,0.1962368540774464,nan,8.4453125,0.2007635302043566,0.9442870632672332,0.28341631558789737,0.3806346595691404,0.741593290863814,proxy
nginx,stream1,1,13.964509447397514,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.002995,0.5731866228689451,nan,33.765625,0.1125748502994012,0.9980059820538385,0.21826965305226176,0.11486668871228368,0.5516676626390851,proxy
haproxy,stream1,1,13.63586872669775,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,10.00288,0.5864614681340897,nan,31.8046875,0.06549482301950398,0.9505703422053232,0.19635459817729908,0.11602996350477843,0.5196638114746532,proxy
direct,stream1,1,62.67828350394503,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,0.05,0.0,0.0006380799654798943,nan,0.0,0.14424057084607544,0.006666666666666667,0.32005141388174807,0.5335400698475843,0.9461611344094641,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,1,24.521235105224097,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1684,10.04,10.00666,0.3266668134853958,nan,60.07421875,0.14476771468793995,0.952561669829222,0.3187907935417382,0.22818345621197217,0.8327313277144565,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,1,8.70824880716366,nan,nan,nan,0,0,845,10.05,10.016509000000001,0.9206278971143109,nan,30.8671875,0.07368421052631578,0.9535104364326376,0.2754831375521031,0.08085922800264037,0.6175168737432718,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,1,20.84771208887811,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1975,10.03,9.999493,0.38404855710296704,nan,54.4296875,0.14997713763145862,0.9534220532319392,0.2666420118343195,0.2016766859838979,0.5692024053152211,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream16,1,20.881245040836067,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1860,10.06,10.011274,0.38418114418047355,nan,69.71484375,0.14739488117001828,0.9544592030360531,0.25984251968503935,0.19977036487598687,0.5662202685144221,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream16,1,37.89353177859546,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1718,10.02,9.984601,0.21126347422751993,nan,80.5546875,0.18891454965357968,0.9524714828897338,0.3562113932738504,0.35383789918565955,0.9328252781932733,origin
nginx,stream16,1,13.664191780368505,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1668,10.05,10.034652999999999,0.5866115955218271,nan,78.25,0.10988505747126437,0.9535104364326376,0.2748868778280543,0.12557451766543334,0.5976091432016605,proxy
haproxy,stream16,1,8.682181566428659,nan,nan,nan,0,0,10,10.02,10.008988,0.9226321638862739,nan,46.30078125,0.15513074049659414,0.9506641366223909,0.6997140133460439,0.0950879825413525,1.3476021812629118,origin
direct,stream16,1,140.8321600374948,nan,nan,nan,0,0,3726,0.17,0.0,0.0009654514037505305,nan,0.0,0.5683407501589319,0.031423290203327174,0.95,1.5333419334256484,2.846455293599054,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,1,48.3383582245863,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.91,8.760173,0.1639922172051299,nan,10.6875,0.25131020713750934,0.9322671683913453,0.13392200147167035,0.9492117632457292,0.3594076287894674,client
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,1,8.780283833160503,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.001005000000001,0.9119378978782314,nan,1.96875,0.1502025553131817,0.9970119521912351,0.037181303116147306,0.5212892635387247,0.08478167370374819,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,1,22.492259081296943,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.002716,0.3559952605176645,nan,9.9453125,0.15742296918767507,0.9506172839506173,0.2569482288828338,0.5650504441492834,0.1957467321950951,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream1-down,1,22.2377952080391,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,10.0015,0.35970742721593585,nan,9.83984375,0.16259678379988088,0.998003992015968,0.07603186097031137,0.5644406198681341,0.2015559746727999,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream1-down,1,47.4263128032106,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.92,8.869871,0.16731498235848097,nan,11.2578125,0.2390011890606421,0.8953068592057761,0.12866108786610878,0.9515148702102105,0.34311731646818777,client
nginx,stream1-down,1,12.7216665185501,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.002332000000001,0.6294060283162803,nan,32.859375,0.1366906474820144,0.9515209125475285,0.044513457556935816,0.512918074155217,0.11406471357164742,proxy
haproxy,stream1-down,1,13.5949945831861,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,10.001486,0.588388207490784,nan,31.26171875,0.14853300733496333,0.999000999000999,0.2631140716069942,0.5165840531196128,0.13179059571121746,proxy
direct,stream1-down,1,61.83615689991757,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,0.1,0.0,0.0012936022698756653,nan,0.0,0.2505,0.013793103448275862,0.1908114116339385,0.948257342685464,0.5311648500355413,client
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,1,0.13564379136000002,13424.47,4.62,8.4,0,0,0,10.11,10.095007,59.626761526698736,74.56522059799684,5.3203125,0.3858439201451906,0.9601139601139601,0.40321384425216317,0.3844104465613866,0.15966589585638852,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,1,0.14285799424,14135.63,4.38,8.16,0,0,0,10.02,10.016059,56.1116655924288,70.79520966545377,5.11328125,0.39630353652034833,0.9524714828897338,0.4100171863491284,0.40630267493527505,0.1577425503570464,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,1,0.06073352192,6012.96,10.53,12.18,0,0,0,6.22,5.709776,81.93168850893474,103.29137467202497,9.42578125,0.14596640643482375,0.6110019646365422,0.1436065573770492,0.2692223356178073,0.10071710097566386,none
3proxy-devel,http-ka-1k,1,0.15879634943999998,15718.59,3.88,8.24,0,0,0,10.1,10.103434,50.88278180508782,63.62204724409449,9.24609375,0.4113551151580075,0.9600760456273765,0.4330225711481845,0.45388993305911707,0.1824608060725231,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-1k,1,0.15149826047999998,14991.62,4.09,8.26,0,0,0,10.09,10.089036,53.28113982579769,66.64068846633951,9.265625,0.3931059772643931,0.9600380589914367,0.42572552877520903,0.42635135778420247,0.17116313758023172,proxy
nginx,http-ka-1k,1,0.37966839807999997,36874.78,1.71,2.11,0,0,0,10.01,10.011303000000002,21.092089940845256,27.1114276969912,30.1484375,0.4200150206533984,0.9524262607040913,0.46948228882833787,0.6319238140289862,0.30050672677949675,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1k,1,0.44803555328,44346.04,1.38,2.08,0,0,0,10.1,10.09164,18.034283085008664,22.55083426923017,29.70703125,0.4550379198266522,0.9591642924976258,0.46507400675149313,0.6945284460716071,0.3049951885902933,proxy
direct,http-ka-1k,1,1.2410945536,120544.57,0.506,0.737,0,0,0,0.61,0.0,0.3932013065277543,0.5010443900688074,0.0,0.8031938821412505,0.20677966101694914,0.9582410629547612,2.486784427146756,0.9575474368758521,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,1,33.414845562880004,3983.52,3.79,8.25,0,0,0,10.01,9.983574,0.23965395814655369,251.00300902708125,13.94140625,0.49396825396825395,0.9515209125475285,0.3705695428990467,1.4224894309488278,0.12069466170148065,client
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,1,8.33223655424,993.03,15.8,26.0,0,0,0,10.02,10.015114,0.9620466183141335,1007.7441416071608,11.37890625,0.23741374904165602,0.9515669515669516,0.08197236180904523,0.620369821858343,0.04181882762724019,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,1,12.4554051584,1479.94,10.75,11.49,0,0,0,6.89,5.403439,0.44253879580004457,464.7868321640583,9.30078125,0.19624167459562322,0.6356088560885609,0.0799492385786802,0.5376147927466318,0.05037882843821314,none
3proxy-devel,http-ka-1m,1,21.904333209599997,2611.4,5.81,11.51,0,0,0,10.01,9.951078,0.3655897636039584,382.6452599388379,15.21484375,0.38804015713662154,0.9524262607040913,0.23330562482682182,0.9952619081101569,0.08552675106932976,client
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-1m,1,35.30463117312,4209.52,3.53,8.49,0,0,0,10.01,9.955867,0.22682576573968222,237.4175798112044,17.1015625,0.5100571670548381,0.9515209125475285,0.38613861386138615,1.5004169911523857,0.14729591443476903,client
nginx,http-ka-1m,1,12.884901888,1533.4,10.16,16.89,0,0,0,10.02,10.017987999999999,0.6221234798431396,652.4287016538611,44.5546875,0.3120173745173745,0.9524714828897338,0.0931023816888339,0.8494284894229014,0.06460517774355376,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1m,1,5.6199479296,669.51,23.77,26.75,0,0,0,10.1,10.10142,1.4377357408318718,1493.6409346347234,37.2578125,0.6189567430025446,0.9600760456273765,0.12264150943396226,1.2283878625213749,0.0313614380198913,client
direct,http-ka-1m,1,71.55415515136,8530.24,1.25,2.46,0,0,0,0.19,0.0,0.0021242651761937685,2.221312912842696,0.0,0.9348903043170559,0.034050179211469536,0.618208516886931,3.709405625590086,0.4019320096525814,client
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,1,3.7299945472,9063.64,63.09,514.63,0,468,0,10.42,10.374076,2.234855814000478,114.21055515975229,94.9921875,0.4750841211344336,0.9895536562203229,0.49168088737201365,0.45279435207006885,0.1178566516712031,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,1,3.12005885952,7581.55,81.16,398.47,0,390,0,10.41,10.364834,2.6691804145262847,136.2708136977694,125.58203125,0.4686014100672241,0.9886039886039886,0.4511393514460999,0.4206229326284934,0.09506761970676463,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,1,3.60827584512,8767.92,68.33,230.79,0,346,0,10.45,10.406272,2.3168960353478663,118.29965472349578,185.93359375,0.29191616766467066,0.9933460076045627,0.31209818819403856,0.41201669715464195,0.1178679391693439,proxy
3proxy-devel,http-ka-50k-2000,1,4.20487364608,10217.57,60.76,331.13,0,504,0,10.39,10.357021,1.9767538098912616,100.95415767892885,193.75,0.47977707006369424,0.9876425855513308,0.5068172134639966,0.46798553533834697,0.13115802493283865,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-50k-2000,1,4.0667971584,9881.81,58.4,705.73,0,477,0,10.38,10.356761,2.041901692305461,104.58016805368045,210.84375,0.4753313108733834,0.9866920152091255,0.4967769660507091,0.45276734577617156,0.1273064226807526,proxy
nginx,http-ka-50k-2000,1,4.5468771942399995,11043.67,84.37,97.94,0,286,0,10.15,10.112297,1.7858410625838863,91.21955603487014,89.875,0.4225095610999818,0.964828897338403,0.4383094751192911,0.4615353256566173,0.12074832703972761,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-50k-2000,1,4.0114323456,9599.12,199.49,658.75,0,0,0,10.09,10.040925000000001,2.0122488190169516,104.50110818816414,175.69140625,0.5358673374324576,0.9582146248812915,0.29649742058104805,0.9049228720587726,0.09122955969335238,client
direct,http-ka-50k-2000,1,34.7892350976,84498.48,22.55,104.66,0,0,0,1.47,0.0,0.033803560115672926,1.7289846038037662,0.0,0.8991793669402111,0.3594132029339853,0.9491150442477876,3.411000944715859,0.9445115666403817,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,1,0.049325015039999996,4811.08,13.11,18.27,0,0,0,10.01,9.903726,162.35169910249257,207.54286662105284,9.83203125,0.326150262085032,0.9524262607040913,0.3879901960784314,0.275967034101441,0.0846086070834202,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,1,0.050751078399999996,4948.36,12.78,17.57,0,0,0,10.02,9.903932,157.9473826510847,202.19141594527514,9.56640625,0.3271880457985639,0.9524714828897338,0.3943765281173594,0.28071457773240316,0.08747121119129994,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,1,0.044543508479999994,4340.06,14.47,22.66,0,0,0,10.0,9.849950999999999,179.59968293903015,230.0701714022777,32.5859375,0.2443584784010316,0.9514747859181731,0.29759238521836506,0.2464537962061136,0.07507722882722555,proxy
3proxy-devel,http-close-1k,1,0.051589939200000004,5026.27,12.5,18.05,0,0,0,10.03,9.88227,155.5342015212144,198.897437931308,14.99609375,0.33365570599613154,0.9534220532319392,0.39681762545899635,0.2901956692189265,0.08840241088415653,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-close-1k,1,0.0511705088,4990.09,12.61,18.07,0,0,0,10.0,9.881556,156.34005186987704,200.0120007200432,12.44921875,0.33634789301520107,0.9514747859181731,0.3950587084148728,0.2854849847075131,0.08744387075013657,proxy
nginx,http-close-1k,1,0.1367343104,13330.41,4.67,5.54,0,0,0,10.01,9.963383,58.566134400162966,75.0217345684564,29.76953125,0.5268738574040219,0.9515209125475285,0.37834328745780316,0.7183057481458207,0.1796215524167742,proxy
haproxy,http-close-1k,1,0.17062428672,16634.73,3.69,4.5,0,0,0,10.1,10.056046,47.355509320074354,60.1169005868838,29.83984375,0.5420510037981552,0.9591642924976258,0.45001149161112386,0.8084893552081557,0.16340300680257439,proxy
direct,http-close-1k,1,0.50432311296,49176.43,0.842,2.3,0,0,0,4.68,0.0,7.4238120438809885,9.422679665132462,0.0,0.7885857113101438,0.5246636771300448,0.9357254290171607,2.3239174095993884,0.8977134920844292,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,2,8.286605016341204,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,9.920733,0.9651597170390142,nan,1.359375,0.14385964912280702,0.949667616334283,0.19778817524457679,0.08846419733487249,0.5178944270022812,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,2,22.2233827907604,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.000335,0.36023357920119853,nan,9.625,0.11502958579881657,0.9506172839506173,0.22473246135552913,0.19502698520391007,0.5634104164845997,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream1,2,21.765111163589697,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.02,9.998705000000001,0.36822359918464515,nan,6.7578125,0.0948905109489051,0.9524714828897338,0.21693967239312825,0.19223268418501907,0.5609295079271684,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream1,2,46.73249807813627,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.92,9.003859,0.16977904591309106,nan,11.36328125,0.21421889616463985,0.9447619047619048,0.3312862504264756,0.41067798286675167,0.9694125806126206,origin
nginx,stream1,2,12.469062099793415,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,9.998698,0.6415083395345121,nan,29.8828125,0.11991682070240296,0.9505703422053232,0.2013945857260049,0.11984938068224997,0.5103005386978487,proxy
haproxy,stream1,2,13.624683206697599,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,10.000916,0.587057135368575,nan,34.87890625,0.12731326644370122,0.9505703422053232,0.20306672192291753,0.1122730340939643,0.5255302303974537,proxy
direct,stream1,2,62.00100565146528,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,0.08,0.0,0.001032088881843162,nan,0.0,0.16763463569165787,0.01171303074670571,0.33240901213171575,0.5925148906387202,0.9621577871938664,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,2,25.13459256422261,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,10.002671,0.3181990311989089,nan,8.390625,0.09686888454011741,0.9514747859181731,0.2643041712809155,0.20836226291557725,0.7175046811596728,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,2,8.987514810098146,nan,nan,nan,0,0,999,10.05,10.018224,0.891564226451582,nan,34.4765625,0.09099307159353348,0.9544159544159544,0.29216323582520765,0.08466374023601732,0.6719340718210135,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,2,21.071103752647087,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1750,10.04,10.004246,0.3802105630940858,nan,75.421875,0.14884887166628677,0.9534662867996201,0.27044025157232704,0.19874932036339213,0.5726167854729214,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream16,2,20.88356344300066,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1916,10.04,10.002035,0.3836478067402083,nan,62.578125,0.15109389243391066,0.952561669829222,0.2658937920718025,0.20069267100349697,0.5659629834079776,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream16,2,37.836379550825434,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1637,10.04,9.982891,0.2119675046593261,nan,90.01953125,0.1772983114446529,0.9516587677725118,0.35577924331829225,0.3470469663570807,0.9125012250895256,origin
nginx,stream16,2,13.526234749787726,nan,nan,nan,0,0,2714,10.03,10.026723,0.5918238758579852,nan,65.78515625,0.1294250281848929,0.9525166191832859,0.3106900250268144,0.1274306021910872,0.6039446697219155,proxy
haproxy,stream16,2,9.834126139401159,nan,nan,nan,0,0,44,10.02,10.008187,0.8146389446310781,nan,47.69921875,0.16695842450765863,0.9515669515669516,0.6993827160493827,0.10937241978106194,1.2993031629625964,origin
direct,stream16,2,141.1760211425275,nan,nan,nan,0,0,3740,0.28,0.0,0.0015863211409809627,nan,0.0,0.5678073510773131,0.05045045045045045,0.95,1.52668150425192,2.8462802363378126,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,2,24.55551544211028,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1644,10.04,10.005853,0.32629388551362054,nan,61.3984375,0.15359628770301625,0.9534662867996201,0.3163548163548164,0.23017459199529192,0.7998194470095865,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,2,8.77774998842636,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.02,10.002153,0.9131106078895976,nan,1.91015625,0.15555555555555556,0.99800796812749,0.03339253996447602,0.5352658303272034,0.07979041790151097,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,2,21.603287837877293,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,10.000727000000001,0.37027268069818686,nan,5.16015625,0.1575649059982095,0.998003992015968,0.07715023994093761,0.5524390397381199,0.20154594422907607,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream1-down,2,21.303928895665045,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,10.002455,0.3754771118572582,nan,5.984375,0.1503653738055087,0.9505703422053232,0.09543285616905249,0.552717440113428,0.1938354142227824,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream1-down,2,47.320203777706716,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.9,8.762285,0.16735206137277603,nan,11.29296875,0.2516209476309227,0.9304511278195489,0.13850110213078617,0.9492116954091504,0.3602838138755396,client
nginx,stream1-down,2,14.106979062991007,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,10.000791000000001,0.5670304371051654,nan,35.7734375,0.15931894192763757,0.999000999000999,0.244173140954495,0.5245647078834085,0.1137764809547855,proxy
haproxy,stream1-down,2,13.730794831069057,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.002403,0.5831436303216366,nan,33.20703125,0.14322543683758235,0.9506172839506173,0.06225165562913907,0.533578834453824,0.11684576402124208,proxy
direct,stream1-down,2,61.970607058644724,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,0.07,0.0,0.0009035575299123102,nan,0.0,0.23823109843081314,0.00904392764857881,0.18501742160278745,0.9515401696214075,0.5065174918896649,client
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,2,47.00754139952631,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.92,9.164185,0.16880471450875434,nan,7.81640625,0.2354368932038835,0.9092575618698442,0.1350314026517795,0.9181941858744715,0.34314505326991174,client
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,2,0.14126415872,13977.54,4.41,8.57,0,0,0,10.11,10.103936000000001,57.25443787925883,71.61578239002621,5.26953125,0.39503305342147577,0.9601139601139601,0.4092140921409214,0.4044028381125424,0.1672592594808021,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,2,0.06073352192,6012.45,10.54,11.94,0,0,0,6.33,5.787432,83.38064119960721,105.05003568050185,9.265625,0.14845409487845174,0.6193737769080235,0.14365548980933596,0.2721064683401922,0.1206863596697095,none
3proxy-devel,http-ka-1k,2,0.15946743808000002,15785.92,3.86,8.19,0,0,0,10.1,10.103763,50.668651213588234,63.35108418167334,9.2734375,0.4144079885877318,0.9600760456273765,0.4346764346764347,0.45769850543007873,0.20054527218174723,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-1k,2,0.15082717184,14929.48,4.1,8.28,0,0,0,10.09,10.08355,53.51820830110713,66.91602668682769,9.44921875,0.40567732662594325,0.9591254752851711,0.4263016377413835,0.42724727426155973,0.1805576935586204,proxy
nginx,http-ka-1k,2,0.38109446144,37010.5,1.7,2.09,0,0,0,10.02,10.013575000000001,21.03415507459966,27.03570493846814,30.16796875,0.4271085458946193,0.9524714828897338,0.4704607046070461,0.6413979374063188,0.30332627013937496,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1k,2,0.44577062912,44116.19,1.39,2.09,0,0,0,10.01,9.999934999999999,17.964395760682276,22.676404759100013,29.703125,0.4526010512959942,0.9506172839506173,0.46119906566311963,0.6943160022023335,0.3182816361460946,proxy
direct,http-ka-1k,2,1.23790688256,120231.46,0.47300000000000003,0.88,0,0,0,0.64,0.0,0.413601384088907,0.527050886763117,0.0,0.8046082949308756,0.20846905537459284,0.957608351787409,2.4892068817789443,0.9574683332380854,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,2,0.13581156352,13441.73,4.61,8.49,0,0,0,10.08,10.08868,59.376387334002466,74.24703343326237,5.2734375,0.3856599674090168,0.9590865842055185,0.4054388133498146,0.3853053598739871,0.17577252336062021,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,2,8.76173328384,1043.83,15.05,25.04,0,0,0,10.02,10.018011,0.9148874703575584,958.3014537107881,8.79296875,0.24720812182741117,0.9524714828897338,0.09020458772473651,0.6430452902999537,0.030413724521814716,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,2,12.4554051584,1479.7,10.75,11.56,0,0,0,6.88,5.355506,0.4418965043692753,463.95576235754265,10.078125,0.1962594696969697,0.6317722681359045,0.08011399620012666,0.5603951058237995,0.05131653431277712,none
3proxy-devel,http-ka-1m,2,21.81843386368,2602.78,5.85,11.44,0,0,0,10.02,9.961265000000001,0.36739575581287776,384.2466541396633,16.15625,0.386041439476554,0.9533777354900095,0.22219116825041924,1.0010771720141753,0.11410175580144677,client
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-1m,2,34.96103378944,4165.09,3.57,8.69,0,0,0,10.01,9.958632000000001,0.2290550115946177,239.99616389748016,14.21484375,0.5072217502124045,0.9515209125475285,0.3882580333413868,1.4940993752813039,0.14542942821942076,client
nginx,http-ka-1m,2,12.54130450432,1497.64,10.45,16.55,0,0,0,10.02,10.019409000000001,0.6391679587429516,667.8664267146571,45.26953125,0.2984306032368808,0.9515669515669516,0.08904747130003103,0.7933676888279081,0.04370691621717513,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1m,2,6.294056468479999,749.32,21.2,24.21,0,0,0,10.09,10.100241,1.2824797553729876,1333.2452431289641,39.00390625,0.613958560523446,0.9600380589914367,0.09904761904761905,1.2948826327916734,0.02755697648841598,client
direct,http-ka-1m,2,72.06955122688001,8587.98,1.25,2.33,0,0,0,0.18,0.0,0.0019980698859450073,2.0933153463273944,0.0,0.9413997627520759,0.033271719038817,0.6151936444885799,3.754277127623124,0.46653177061824086,client
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,2,32.98534883328,3932.3,3.85,8.34,0,0,0,10.02,9.985841,0.24301698431372643,254.42449787979587,14.6015625,0.4930203045685279,0.9524714828897338,0.37142857142857144,1.4196693651925036,0.1539927098158036,client
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,2,3.14681851904,7646.69,78.46,598.72,0,497,0,10.41,10.359805000000001,2.6464824550926513,135.20885286783042,125.03125,0.472448646886208,0.9886039886039886,0.45147123407992973,0.4253535770225284,0.09884827589363786,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,2,3.6885548236799997,8963.07,66.91,268.78,0,425,0,10.46,10.413841999999999,2.268639182554269,115.97352344416973,199.2734375,0.3172043010752688,0.9942965779467681,0.3365439093484419,0.41968795136117204,0.12456576544886427,proxy
3proxy-devel,http-ka-50k-2000,2,4.27215028224,10381.1,57.98,217.64,0,471,0,10.41,10.362829,1.949369626490155,99.63820134382358,198.3359375,0.4785589032360912,0.9886039886039886,0.504708904109589,0.47274066039307266,0.13204040116340665,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-50k-2000,2,4.04892942336,9838.84,59.56,684.02,0,451,0,10.39,10.360715,2.0528883393334865,105.1332125836057,182.32421875,0.47179816808613206,0.9885823025689819,0.496881049688105,0.452020753762097,0.12450968328260942,proxy
nginx,http-ka-50k-2000,2,4.578082816,11119.51,82.36,97.03,0,291,0,10.15,10.113419,1.7736682201600436,90.59183691684294,89.765625,0.43762270212386223,0.9657469077069457,0.4379694969269292,0.4691141566268477,0.11783661140664521,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-50k-2000,2,4.071998095360001,9750.91,193.51,818.8,0,0,0,10.09,10.037085000000001,1.9823191983311483,102.87415503512403,176.203125,0.5370644922164566,0.9591254752851711,0.3017148981779207,0.8963847192577428,0.09029282753738208,proxy
direct,http-ka-50k-2000,2,35.13283248128,85332.97,22.77,52.86,0,0,0,1.59,0.0,0.03620544972221543,1.8452218618172533,0.0,0.91359177954227,0.38405797101449274,0.9541139240506329,3.4653449768624753,0.952137198533366,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,2,3.73888647168,9085.46,67.45,190.12,0,488,0,10.41,10.359068,2.227401142848279,113.8488795564159,96.58984375,0.46634146341463417,0.9876660341555977,0.491044776119403,0.45181039548726254,0.11590967543506979,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,2,0.0511705088,4985.36,12.65,17.84,0,0,0,10.03,9.914797,156.80907202548667,200.73650082055798,9.5703125,0.3288759689922481,0.9534220532319392,0.39224349533627884,0.2845225037643004,0.08744239251847147,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,2,0.0452984832,4420.66,14.18,21.97,0,0,0,10.03,9.879292,177.1361739547164,226.2882411334717,31.34765625,0.24989311671654554,0.9534220532319392,0.3030050083472454,0.2493314729842301,0.07890083260724257,proxy
3proxy-devel,http-close-1k,2,0.0528482304,5153.04,12.2,17.51,0,0,0,10.03,9.903379000000001,151.8310062468998,194.1390523381852,13.5390625,0.3364864864864865,0.9534220532319392,0.401609363569861,0.29404623857137496,0.09028827318898211,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-close-1k,2,0.05133828096,5005.62,12.56,17.8,0,0,0,10.03,9.89768,156.29662407769095,199.67748999621747,12.5390625,0.33513513513513515,0.9534220532319392,0.39515537068754586,0.28740050932892375,0.08842468920240701,proxy
nginx,http-close-1k,2,0.13690208256,13351.64,4.68,5.23,0,0,0,10.03,9.976531000000001,58.61123402913412,74.97888182042446,29.65625,0.5274785466496257,0.9525166191832859,0.38292934502320786,0.71732877140962,0.15297870495328245,proxy
haproxy,http-close-1k,2,0.171966464,16769.34,3.68,4.28,0,0,0,10.1,10.062629999999999,46.98590534489329,59.636629880903875,29.890625,0.5421119362434341,0.9600760456273765,0.4504463263904784,0.8094617760775544,0.16151087000273195,proxy
direct,http-close-1k,2,0.49970937856000003,48719.93,0.847,2.4,0,0,0,4.68,0.0,7.492354877927227,9.51134451390526,0.0,0.7908633696563285,0.527027027027027,0.9366614664586583,2.3234202233526995,0.900496417140032,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,2,0.04915724288,4789.91,13.15,18.65,0,0,0,10.0,9.888626,162.7430574072099,208.28993959591753,9.875,0.327005036807439,0.9514747859181731,0.38700980392156864,0.2768784280803077,0.0845814286769186,proxy
1 proxy scenario rep gbit rate p50_ms p99_ms errors timeouts retrans prx_cpu_s prx_task_s cpu_s_per_gb cpu_us_per_req peak_mb cli_util prx_util srv_util cli_thread srv_thread bound
2 direct stream1 0 61.59043807936239 nan nan nan 0 0 0 0.07 0.0 0.0009090945904281307 nan 0.0 0.15914552736982643 0.010130246020260492 0.33659689399054693 0.542523909627398 0.9920184956182384 origin
3 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 0 25.076815274321753 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.001756 0.3192535554117112 nan 4.5703125 0.14034676663542642 0.9506172839506173 0.3075668623613829 0.22547887021175553 0.8998971051200377 proxy
4 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 0 8.320864371719768 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.001265 0.9622296045989882 nan 2.171875 0.09806629834254144 0.9506172839506173 0.20161290322580644 0.08559402701932255 0.5118258825166938 proxy
5 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 0 21.129445707467838 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 9.998918 0.3789108481077464 nan 6.39453125 0.09235668789808917 0.9515209125475285 0.21260470682090146 0.19784026605014632 0.5586089505468658 proxy
6 3proxy-devel stream1 0 22.045100293757027 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 10.001657 0.36277761019709465 nan 8.4375 0.08768520767549186 0.9505703422053232 0.22015073383577946 0.1892821448997447 0.5653165236592292 proxy
7 3proxy-devel-s stream1 0 45.733864660192815 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.89 8.817747 0.17296129740164518 nan 11.4140625 0.10646866347847973 0.8925992779783394 0.3173747622067216 0.3453118000638853 0.9474347722871482 origin
8 nginx stream1 0 13.502219260500269 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.002879 0.5928629926236841 nan 32.0390625 0.059215585747244295 0.9980059820538385 0.21870882740447958 0.11588387034324961 0.5469890694930801 proxy
9 haproxy stream1 0 13.074724676255311 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.001975 0.6122991754617084 nan 30.234375 0.04035087719298246 0.9506172839506173 0.2 0.1122562984734366 0.5227224462734111 proxy
10 direct stream16 0 141.16148088835325 nan nan nan 0 0 3723 0.31 0.0 0.0017563336806383245 nan 0.0 0.5459744830620326 0.05457746478873239 0.9503164556962025 1.5296777692959824 2.846258589236203 origin
11 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 0 24.37506402915491 nan nan nan 0 0 1696 10.04 10.006798999999999 0.32865708613295747 nan 68.921875 0.1541483706956321 0.9534662867996201 0.32031517643028434 0.22920876854538716 0.8197928180249117 proxy
12 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 0 8.727871407167079 nan nan nan 0 0 1051 10.05 10.016788 0.9181255018866824 nan 24.5546875 0.08593930970581422 0.9544159544159544 0.2816796729840208 0.08276581520000051 0.632726762221158 proxy
13 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 0 20.882659266549513 nan nan nan 0 0 1816 10.05 10.004978999999999 0.3839491594428824 nan 76.11328125 0.13076923076923078 0.9535104364326376 0.26881720430107525 0.19778844727512063 0.5716611797506093 proxy
14 3proxy-devel stream16 0 20.683068039219563 nan nan nan 0 0 2018 10.05 9.999567 0.387817586561441 nan 52.1328125 0.1397824577644064 0.9535104364326376 0.26135936913255725 0.19972138897003985 0.5632383924778547 proxy
15 3proxy-devel-s stream16 0 36.88142111514797 nan nan nan 0 0 1729 10.02 9.981243 0.21714618962344945 nan 84.87890625 0.18587962962962962 0.9515669515669516 0.35127674258109043 0.35179881734362295 0.9295704072412715 origin
16 nginx stream16 0 13.526442518804762 nan nan nan 0 0 1815 10.05 10.034925999999999 0.5925640285562345 nan 74.99609375 0.12301045929968167 0.9544159544159544 0.2937113776808433 0.13315927762132487 0.616550983411331 proxy
17 haproxy stream16 0 9.500596986818456 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.03 10.006478 0.8442035098288654 nan 49.87890625 0.1736682546556951 0.9507109004739337 0.7012946979038225 0.11125250071463563 1.291515298093347 origin
18 direct stream1-down 0 61.54374690443803 nan nan nan 0 0 0 0.1 0.0 0.0012997464239230243 nan 0.0 0.251073503409952 0.014347202295552367 0.20786933927245732 0.9372038366817282 0.5728991681204915 client
19 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 0 47.863368062293 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.91 8.83401 0.1656195232648594 nan 10.67578125 0.25125 0.9349056603773584 0.2878605769230769 0.9472740801933867 0.4502748995413846 client
20 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 0 10.053500776066262 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 10.002113 0.7956568633457785 nan 2.84375 0.2219469903393609 0.9514747859181731 0.04069963000336361 0.8449148815408425 0.09219263446435975 proxy
21 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 0 22.432411451723134 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.002163 0.3569436671923783 nan 6.4296875 0.15131022823330514 0.9506172839506173 0.25606394707828006 0.5649721152037466 0.2128018914352686 proxy
22 3proxy-devel stream1-down 0 22.1386177174921 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.002789 0.3616802866998139 nan 9.89453125 0.15313290250070244 0.9515209125475285 0.12183235867446393 0.5641362593700737 0.1938367623087162 proxy
23 3proxy-devel-s stream1-down 0 47.3560956479822 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.93 8.989258999999999 0.16773134538475204 nan 11.23828125 0.41999521645539345 0.9010889292196007 0.2042907460774896 0.9401727710581673 0.3820936529645266 client
24 nginx stream1-down 0 13.598172754592353 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 10.00013 0.5882475717441422 nan 34.21875 0.1541043637473299 0.998003992015968 0.10531628532974428 0.5263660973475165 0.12171259743303382 proxy
25 haproxy stream1-down 0 13.04557020209267 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.99 10.001577000000001 0.6125540591772419 nan 30.6875 0.17640480849874196 0.9514285714285714 0.1926871735345328 0.5157725897846064 0.12262789874069302 proxy
26 direct http-ka-1k 0 1.23874574336 120311.11 0.502 0.767 0 0 0 0.91 0.0 0.5876912222724234 0.7489317435130989 0.0 0.8062471706654595 0.2774390243902439 0.9533858267716535 2.502850504542173 0.9528021897151907 origin
27 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 0 0.13597933568 13461.44 4.6 8.55 0 0 0 10.09 10.085132 59.36196084231376 74.21900859881279 5.3125 0.38467126770795496 0.9591254752851711 0.4049443757725587 0.38442310064795926 0.14444948982271436 proxy
28 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 0 0.14310965248 14160.83 4.36 8.29 0 0 0 10.09 10.103392 56.4043015975326 70.55105337127755 5.3125 0.3983276996975627 0.9600380589914367 0.4062111801242236 0.4053795728817735 0.15679788194444916 proxy
29 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 0 0.060565749759999996 5997.53 10.55 12.12 0 0 0 6.41 5.892927 84.66831534853273 106.56160125014546 9.4296875 0.15339163318364452 0.6296660117878192 0.1442687747035573 0.2739518353868087 0.10545455830369485 none
30 3proxy-devel http-ka-1k 0 0.15980298240000002 15814.98 3.85 8.24 0 0 0 10.11 10.103257 50.61232198880413 63.3038207706661 9.3125 0.41626709287870717 0.9610266159695817 0.4333821376281113 0.4557657693361603 0.21004838330773956 proxy
31 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-1k 0 0.15015608319999998 14862.79 4.13 8.6 0 0 0 10.0 10.004617999999999 53.27789477129888 67.2436168996658 9.2578125 0.400362647325476 0.9514747859181731 0.4208969935929029 0.42725600771529987 0.15776746007234257 proxy
32 nginx http-ka-1k 0 0.38545653760000004 37438.23 1.68 2.09 0 0 0 10.02 10.016202 20.79611893447361 26.716081641359267 30.16796875 0.4208509007282484 0.9524714828897338 0.45414118954974986 0.6185750236098108 0.30333217719531014 proxy
33 haproxy http-ka-1k 0 0.44862275584 44403.29 1.38 2.08 0 0 0 10.1 10.092595 18.01067800243666 22.52161852391974 29.7109375 0.44773933736042465 0.9600760456273765 0.4677210267046928 0.6925191237198265 0.31553329713730766 proxy
34 direct http-ka-1m 0 71.38235645952001 8502.84 1.29 2.32 0 0 0 0.25 0.0 0.0028018127996855546 2.934203422454872 0.0 0.9309048178613396 0.044169611307420496 0.6012909632571996 3.6776368437892866 0.4544336356412374 client
35 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 0 32.55585210368 3883.29 3.89 8.53 0 0 0 10.02 9.985391 0.24622301313053013 257.6166602391053 16.984375 0.4876753081172971 0.9524714828897338 0.3697355533790402 1.4072569080833086 0.13684705872970046 client
36 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 0 8.33223655424 993.73 15.79 25.57 0 0 0 10.02 10.017144 0.9620466183141335 1006.6305003013864 12.5078125 0.23848726524311809 0.9515669515669516 0.08189519924694069 0.5907749255544233 0.03515967768304146 proxy
37 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 0 12.4554051584 1480.26 10.75 11.5 0 0 0 6.9 5.363434 0.4431810872308139 465.1162790697674 11.11328125 0.19615293279506055 0.6341911764705882 0.07758346581875994 0.5490367098688399 0.05132568508940509 none
38 3proxy-devel http-ka-1m 0 21.990232555520002 2622.03 5.77 11.73 0 0 0 10.02 9.96345 0.3645254764705896 381.322068729307 19.0703125 0.38890097932535367 0.9533777354900095 0.21711079943899017 1.0049405487576604 0.12362131370626167 client
39 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-1m 0 35.30463117312 4202.74 3.53 8.65 0 0 0 10.02 9.947932000000002 0.22705236490625533 238.0952380952381 17.06640625 0.5084709868699704 0.9515669515669516 0.38868832731648617 1.4966583639715494 0.14539533846143493 client
40 nginx http-ka-1m 0 12.627203850239999 1502.42 10.5 14.34 0 0 0 10.03 10.019086999999999 0.6354534301628061 666.3566303481265 45.60546875 0.29071499503475673 0.9525166191832859 0.08328173374613003 0.7798955597828292 0.04654943004942413 proxy
41 haproxy http-ka-1m 0 6.02226556928 717.05 22.13 26.28 0 0 0 10.09 10.100359 1.34035935598321 1393.2615299640984 39.10546875 0.6164913034142152 0.9600380589914367 0.15104009647271632 1.2611953734187002 0.02184922324712792 client
42 direct http-ka-50k-2000 0 34.44563771392 83597.96 21.36 653.72 0 531 0 1.51 0.0 0.035069752809710045 1.789118604345307 0.0 0.8976982097186701 0.3793969849246231 0.9434920634920635 3.381443743187913 0.9475666754601523 origin
43 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 0 3.72101873664 9041.86 67.48 190.21 0 481 0 10.43 10.38188 2.2423966635369466 114.5046548392763 100.265625 0.4756548288606781 0.9914448669201521 0.49294570329200516 0.45560365627383104 0.12353803865212871 proxy
44 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 0 3.11628398592 7572.42 81.79 246.09 0 503 0 10.41 10.363715 2.6724136945244994 136.4047328904438 132.41015625 0.47485399091499025 0.9895437262357415 0.4525371828521435 0.4234260960372297 0.1007558872384741 proxy
45 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 0 3.70499649536 9003.02 68.12 225.76 0 480 0 10.44 10.408701 2.2542531444927776 115.27377521613833 206.96875 0.30470390592188157 0.9933396764985728 0.324052812858783 0.4159046044059033 0.11412223049799855 proxy
46 3proxy-devel http-ka-50k-2000 0 4.288340295679999 10420.37 57.75 172.75 0 496 0 10.39 10.361574 1.9382790139983448 98.97783239499681 193.98046875 0.4794651384909265 0.9885823025689819 0.5053464499572284 0.47278849098808134 0.13207793919829464 proxy
47 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-50k-2000 0 4.08466489344 9925.62 57.4 166.54 0 610 0 10.39 10.361924 2.0349282540531366 103.95821660129673 186.515625 0.47475231703419624 0.9876425855513308 0.4960120715671481 0.45559069014449605 0.127294880652316 proxy
48 nginx http-ka-50k-2000 0 4.435895910399999 10774.0 66.87 85.03 0 338 0 10.14 10.102538999999998 1.8287173918985202 93.48982583601479 78.22265625 0.4268248175182482 0.9638783269961977 0.4438381082310141 0.47766825616381503 0.12164560872152692 proxy
49 haproxy http-ka-50k-2000 0 3.9845888 9540.41 193.95 695.26 0 0 0 10.09 10.049517 2.025805021587171 104.97513473022742 178.3828125 0.5321375186846039 0.9591254752851711 0.29462832338578404 0.8962389296400717 0.09122410107872184 proxy
50 direct http-close-1k 0 0.48494542848 47287.31 0.87 2.47 0 0 0 4.71 0.0 7.769946428426635 9.861912289701525 0.0 0.7769055980169387 0.5136314067611778 0.9360972568578554 2.2514680684726835 0.9028206642967048 origin
51 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 0 0.049576673280000004 4833.7 13.05 18.02 0 0 0 10.01 9.908954 161.5275788024799 206.56637569904456 9.9765625 0.3274593338497289 0.9515209125475285 0.38796477495107634 0.27787220939323715 0.0845929270930012 proxy
52 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 0 0.05100273664 4976.02 12.7 17.47 0 0 0 10.03 9.919003 157.32489134135997 201.10678910855356 9.61328125 0.3289422704378148 0.9534220532319392 0.39449317738791423 0.2806871378622416 0.08744536686658436 proxy
53 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 0 0.04521459712 4406.68 14.25 22.13 0 0 0 10.02 9.868813000000001 177.2878784859114 227.02041371185175 29.73828125 0.24721030042918454 0.9524714828897338 0.2986904430203399 0.24834668257046094 0.07698453085959421 proxy
54 3proxy-devel http-close-1k 0 0.0528482304 5152.66 12.21 17.34 0 0 0 10.01 9.894235 151.52825249565973 193.98097009863767 12.4296875 0.3351393188854489 0.9515209125475285 0.39799657952602 0.2920875794095629 0.08932091563637072 proxy
55 3proxy-devel-s http-close-1k 0 0.05142216704 5014.24 12.55 17.78 0 0 0 10.01 9.888247 155.73050419619187 199.23173377385905 12.40234375 0.33603082851637767 0.9515209125475285 0.396240234375 0.2864431587240493 0.08747886553316407 proxy
56 nginx http-close-1k 0 0.13639876608 13300.09 4.7 5.26 0 0 0 10.02 9.971497000000001 58.768860088503224 75.22296627728898 29.6953125 0.5281369513749772 0.9515669515669516 0.3856041131105398 0.7164067540389693 0.15395175858105878 proxy
57 haproxy http-close-1k 0 0.17020485632 16591.82 3.71 4.39 0 0 0 10.09 10.066581000000001 47.42520380748676 60.21472008211641 29.796875 0.5440115440115441 0.9600380589914367 0.4718902169101372 0.8126631474982218 0.20339719368038653 proxy
58 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 1 24.128537890835506 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.001909 0.33182378356055536 nan 4.93359375 0.1204876882620129 0.9506172839506173 0.22343434343434343 0.21786695370343528 0.5833912195555127 proxy
59 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 1 10.155853300627914 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.003753999999999 0.7881915025627496 nan 4.94921875 0.11301446051167964 0.9506172839506173 0.27844950213371267 0.07801192476959028 0.7652136358644214 proxy
60 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 1 22.10263720326343 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 9.999949 0.36221549434084527 nan 11.078125 0.0581891146225232 0.9506172839506173 0.21894904458598727 0.18743641707799016 0.5654714009259497 proxy
61 3proxy-devel stream1 1 22.282829232860685 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 10.002649 0.358900282309469 nan 8.23828125 0.11426437640029873 0.999000999000999 0.23177966101694916 0.18980949377395148 0.5949025878185107 proxy
62 3proxy-devel-s stream1 1 40.75770404715078 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 9.873198 0.1962368540774464 nan 8.4453125 0.2007635302043566 0.9442870632672332 0.28341631558789737 0.3806346595691404 0.741593290863814 proxy
63 nginx stream1 1 13.964509447397514 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.002995 0.5731866228689451 nan 33.765625 0.1125748502994012 0.9980059820538385 0.21826965305226176 0.11486668871228368 0.5516676626390851 proxy
64 haproxy stream1 1 13.63586872669775 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 10.00288 0.5864614681340897 nan 31.8046875 0.06549482301950398 0.9505703422053232 0.19635459817729908 0.11602996350477843 0.5196638114746532 proxy
65 direct stream1 1 62.67828350394503 nan nan nan 0 0 0 0.05 0.0 0.0006380799654798943 nan 0.0 0.14424057084607544 0.006666666666666667 0.32005141388174807 0.5335400698475843 0.9461611344094641 origin
66 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 1 24.521235105224097 nan nan nan 0 0 1684 10.04 10.00666 0.3266668134853958 nan 60.07421875 0.14476771468793995 0.952561669829222 0.3187907935417382 0.22818345621197217 0.8327313277144565 proxy
67 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 1 8.70824880716366 nan nan nan 0 0 845 10.05 10.016509000000001 0.9206278971143109 nan 30.8671875 0.07368421052631578 0.9535104364326376 0.2754831375521031 0.08085922800264037 0.6175168737432718 proxy
68 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 1 20.84771208887811 nan nan nan 0 0 1975 10.03 9.999493 0.38404855710296704 nan 54.4296875 0.14997713763145862 0.9534220532319392 0.2666420118343195 0.2016766859838979 0.5692024053152211 proxy
69 3proxy-devel stream16 1 20.881245040836067 nan nan nan 0 0 1860 10.06 10.011274 0.38418114418047355 nan 69.71484375 0.14739488117001828 0.9544592030360531 0.25984251968503935 0.19977036487598687 0.5662202685144221 proxy
70 3proxy-devel-s stream16 1 37.89353177859546 nan nan nan 0 0 1718 10.02 9.984601 0.21126347422751993 nan 80.5546875 0.18891454965357968 0.9524714828897338 0.3562113932738504 0.35383789918565955 0.9328252781932733 origin
71 nginx stream16 1 13.664191780368505 nan nan nan 0 0 1668 10.05 10.034652999999999 0.5866115955218271 nan 78.25 0.10988505747126437 0.9535104364326376 0.2748868778280543 0.12557451766543334 0.5976091432016605 proxy
72 haproxy stream16 1 8.682181566428659 nan nan nan 0 0 10 10.02 10.008988 0.9226321638862739 nan 46.30078125 0.15513074049659414 0.9506641366223909 0.6997140133460439 0.0950879825413525 1.3476021812629118 origin
73 direct stream16 1 140.8321600374948 nan nan nan 0 0 3726 0.17 0.0 0.0009654514037505305 nan 0.0 0.5683407501589319 0.031423290203327174 0.95 1.5333419334256484 2.846455293599054 origin
74 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 1 48.3383582245863 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.91 8.760173 0.1639922172051299 nan 10.6875 0.25131020713750934 0.9322671683913453 0.13392200147167035 0.9492117632457292 0.3594076287894674 client
75 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 1 8.780283833160503 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.001005000000001 0.9119378978782314 nan 1.96875 0.1502025553131817 0.9970119521912351 0.037181303116147306 0.5212892635387247 0.08478167370374819 proxy
76 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 1 22.492259081296943 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.002716 0.3559952605176645 nan 9.9453125 0.15742296918767507 0.9506172839506173 0.2569482288828338 0.5650504441492834 0.1957467321950951 proxy
77 3proxy-devel stream1-down 1 22.2377952080391 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 10.0015 0.35970742721593585 nan 9.83984375 0.16259678379988088 0.998003992015968 0.07603186097031137 0.5644406198681341 0.2015559746727999 proxy
78 3proxy-devel-s stream1-down 1 47.4263128032106 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.92 8.869871 0.16731498235848097 nan 11.2578125 0.2390011890606421 0.8953068592057761 0.12866108786610878 0.9515148702102105 0.34311731646818777 client
79 nginx stream1-down 1 12.7216665185501 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.002332000000001 0.6294060283162803 nan 32.859375 0.1366906474820144 0.9515209125475285 0.044513457556935816 0.512918074155217 0.11406471357164742 proxy
80 haproxy stream1-down 1 13.5949945831861 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 10.001486 0.588388207490784 nan 31.26171875 0.14853300733496333 0.999000999000999 0.2631140716069942 0.5165840531196128 0.13179059571121746 proxy
81 direct stream1-down 1 61.83615689991757 nan nan nan 0 0 0 0.1 0.0 0.0012936022698756653 nan 0.0 0.2505 0.013793103448275862 0.1908114116339385 0.948257342685464 0.5311648500355413 client
82 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 1 0.13564379136000002 13424.47 4.62 8.4 0 0 0 10.11 10.095007 59.626761526698736 74.56522059799684 5.3203125 0.3858439201451906 0.9601139601139601 0.40321384425216317 0.3844104465613866 0.15966589585638852 proxy
83 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 1 0.14285799424 14135.63 4.38 8.16 0 0 0 10.02 10.016059 56.1116655924288 70.79520966545377 5.11328125 0.39630353652034833 0.9524714828897338 0.4100171863491284 0.40630267493527505 0.1577425503570464 proxy
84 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 1 0.06073352192 6012.96 10.53 12.18 0 0 0 6.22 5.709776 81.93168850893474 103.29137467202497 9.42578125 0.14596640643482375 0.6110019646365422 0.1436065573770492 0.2692223356178073 0.10071710097566386 none
85 3proxy-devel http-ka-1k 1 0.15879634943999998 15718.59 3.88 8.24 0 0 0 10.1 10.103434 50.88278180508782 63.62204724409449 9.24609375 0.4113551151580075 0.9600760456273765 0.4330225711481845 0.45388993305911707 0.1824608060725231 proxy
86 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-1k 1 0.15149826047999998 14991.62 4.09 8.26 0 0 0 10.09 10.089036 53.28113982579769 66.64068846633951 9.265625 0.3931059772643931 0.9600380589914367 0.42572552877520903 0.42635135778420247 0.17116313758023172 proxy
87 nginx http-ka-1k 1 0.37966839807999997 36874.78 1.71 2.11 0 0 0 10.01 10.011303000000002 21.092089940845256 27.1114276969912 30.1484375 0.4200150206533984 0.9524262607040913 0.46948228882833787 0.6319238140289862 0.30050672677949675 proxy
88 haproxy http-ka-1k 1 0.44803555328 44346.04 1.38 2.08 0 0 0 10.1 10.09164 18.034283085008664 22.55083426923017 29.70703125 0.4550379198266522 0.9591642924976258 0.46507400675149313 0.6945284460716071 0.3049951885902933 proxy
89 direct http-ka-1k 1 1.2410945536 120544.57 0.506 0.737 0 0 0 0.61 0.0 0.3932013065277543 0.5010443900688074 0.0 0.8031938821412505 0.20677966101694914 0.9582410629547612 2.486784427146756 0.9575474368758521 origin
90 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 1 33.414845562880004 3983.52 3.79 8.25 0 0 0 10.01 9.983574 0.23965395814655369 251.00300902708125 13.94140625 0.49396825396825395 0.9515209125475285 0.3705695428990467 1.4224894309488278 0.12069466170148065 client
91 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 1 8.33223655424 993.03 15.8 26.0 0 0 0 10.02 10.015114 0.9620466183141335 1007.7441416071608 11.37890625 0.23741374904165602 0.9515669515669516 0.08197236180904523 0.620369821858343 0.04181882762724019 proxy
92 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 1 12.4554051584 1479.94 10.75 11.49 0 0 0 6.89 5.403439 0.44253879580004457 464.7868321640583 9.30078125 0.19624167459562322 0.6356088560885609 0.0799492385786802 0.5376147927466318 0.05037882843821314 none
93 3proxy-devel http-ka-1m 1 21.904333209599997 2611.4 5.81 11.51 0 0 0 10.01 9.951078 0.3655897636039584 382.6452599388379 15.21484375 0.38804015713662154 0.9524262607040913 0.23330562482682182 0.9952619081101569 0.08552675106932976 client
94 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-1m 1 35.30463117312 4209.52 3.53 8.49 0 0 0 10.01 9.955867 0.22682576573968222 237.4175798112044 17.1015625 0.5100571670548381 0.9515209125475285 0.38613861386138615 1.5004169911523857 0.14729591443476903 client
95 nginx http-ka-1m 1 12.884901888 1533.4 10.16 16.89 0 0 0 10.02 10.017987999999999 0.6221234798431396 652.4287016538611 44.5546875 0.3120173745173745 0.9524714828897338 0.0931023816888339 0.8494284894229014 0.06460517774355376 proxy
96 haproxy http-ka-1m 1 5.6199479296 669.51 23.77 26.75 0 0 0 10.1 10.10142 1.4377357408318718 1493.6409346347234 37.2578125 0.6189567430025446 0.9600760456273765 0.12264150943396226 1.2283878625213749 0.0313614380198913 client
97 direct http-ka-1m 1 71.55415515136 8530.24 1.25 2.46 0 0 0 0.19 0.0 0.0021242651761937685 2.221312912842696 0.0 0.9348903043170559 0.034050179211469536 0.618208516886931 3.709405625590086 0.4019320096525814 client
98 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 1 3.7299945472 9063.64 63.09 514.63 0 468 0 10.42 10.374076 2.234855814000478 114.21055515975229 94.9921875 0.4750841211344336 0.9895536562203229 0.49168088737201365 0.45279435207006885 0.1178566516712031 proxy
99 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 1 3.12005885952 7581.55 81.16 398.47 0 390 0 10.41 10.364834 2.6691804145262847 136.2708136977694 125.58203125 0.4686014100672241 0.9886039886039886 0.4511393514460999 0.4206229326284934 0.09506761970676463 proxy
100 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 1 3.60827584512 8767.92 68.33 230.79 0 346 0 10.45 10.406272 2.3168960353478663 118.29965472349578 185.93359375 0.29191616766467066 0.9933460076045627 0.31209818819403856 0.41201669715464195 0.1178679391693439 proxy
101 3proxy-devel http-ka-50k-2000 1 4.20487364608 10217.57 60.76 331.13 0 504 0 10.39 10.357021 1.9767538098912616 100.95415767892885 193.75 0.47977707006369424 0.9876425855513308 0.5068172134639966 0.46798553533834697 0.13115802493283865 proxy
102 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-50k-2000 1 4.0667971584 9881.81 58.4 705.73 0 477 0 10.38 10.356761 2.041901692305461 104.58016805368045 210.84375 0.4753313108733834 0.9866920152091255 0.4967769660507091 0.45276734577617156 0.1273064226807526 proxy
103 nginx http-ka-50k-2000 1 4.5468771942399995 11043.67 84.37 97.94 0 286 0 10.15 10.112297 1.7858410625838863 91.21955603487014 89.875 0.4225095610999818 0.964828897338403 0.4383094751192911 0.4615353256566173 0.12074832703972761 proxy
104 haproxy http-ka-50k-2000 1 4.0114323456 9599.12 199.49 658.75 0 0 0 10.09 10.040925000000001 2.0122488190169516 104.50110818816414 175.69140625 0.5358673374324576 0.9582146248812915 0.29649742058104805 0.9049228720587726 0.09122955969335238 client
105 direct http-ka-50k-2000 1 34.7892350976 84498.48 22.55 104.66 0 0 0 1.47 0.0 0.033803560115672926 1.7289846038037662 0.0 0.8991793669402111 0.3594132029339853 0.9491150442477876 3.411000944715859 0.9445115666403817 origin
106 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 1 0.049325015039999996 4811.08 13.11 18.27 0 0 0 10.01 9.903726 162.35169910249257 207.54286662105284 9.83203125 0.326150262085032 0.9524262607040913 0.3879901960784314 0.275967034101441 0.0846086070834202 proxy
107 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 1 0.050751078399999996 4948.36 12.78 17.57 0 0 0 10.02 9.903932 157.9473826510847 202.19141594527514 9.56640625 0.3271880457985639 0.9524714828897338 0.3943765281173594 0.28071457773240316 0.08747121119129994 proxy
108 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 1 0.044543508479999994 4340.06 14.47 22.66 0 0 0 10.0 9.849950999999999 179.59968293903015 230.0701714022777 32.5859375 0.2443584784010316 0.9514747859181731 0.29759238521836506 0.2464537962061136 0.07507722882722555 proxy
109 3proxy-devel http-close-1k 1 0.051589939200000004 5026.27 12.5 18.05 0 0 0 10.03 9.88227 155.5342015212144 198.897437931308 14.99609375 0.33365570599613154 0.9534220532319392 0.39681762545899635 0.2901956692189265 0.08840241088415653 proxy
110 3proxy-devel-s http-close-1k 1 0.0511705088 4990.09 12.61 18.07 0 0 0 10.0 9.881556 156.34005186987704 200.0120007200432 12.44921875 0.33634789301520107 0.9514747859181731 0.3950587084148728 0.2854849847075131 0.08744387075013657 proxy
111 nginx http-close-1k 1 0.1367343104 13330.41 4.67 5.54 0 0 0 10.01 9.963383 58.566134400162966 75.0217345684564 29.76953125 0.5268738574040219 0.9515209125475285 0.37834328745780316 0.7183057481458207 0.1796215524167742 proxy
112 haproxy http-close-1k 1 0.17062428672 16634.73 3.69 4.5 0 0 0 10.1 10.056046 47.355509320074354 60.1169005868838 29.83984375 0.5420510037981552 0.9591642924976258 0.45001149161112386 0.8084893552081557 0.16340300680257439 proxy
113 direct http-close-1k 1 0.50432311296 49176.43 0.842 2.3 0 0 0 4.68 0.0 7.4238120438809885 9.422679665132462 0.0 0.7885857113101438 0.5246636771300448 0.9357254290171607 2.3239174095993884 0.8977134920844292 origin
114 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 2 8.286605016341204 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 9.920733 0.9651597170390142 nan 1.359375 0.14385964912280702 0.949667616334283 0.19778817524457679 0.08846419733487249 0.5178944270022812 proxy
115 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 2 22.2233827907604 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.000335 0.36023357920119853 nan 9.625 0.11502958579881657 0.9506172839506173 0.22473246135552913 0.19502698520391007 0.5634104164845997 proxy
116 3proxy-devel stream1 2 21.765111163589697 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.02 9.998705000000001 0.36822359918464515 nan 6.7578125 0.0948905109489051 0.9524714828897338 0.21693967239312825 0.19223268418501907 0.5609295079271684 proxy
117 3proxy-devel-s stream1 2 46.73249807813627 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.92 9.003859 0.16977904591309106 nan 11.36328125 0.21421889616463985 0.9447619047619048 0.3312862504264756 0.41067798286675167 0.9694125806126206 origin
118 nginx stream1 2 12.469062099793415 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 9.998698 0.6415083395345121 nan 29.8828125 0.11991682070240296 0.9505703422053232 0.2013945857260049 0.11984938068224997 0.5103005386978487 proxy
119 haproxy stream1 2 13.624683206697599 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 10.000916 0.587057135368575 nan 34.87890625 0.12731326644370122 0.9505703422053232 0.20306672192291753 0.1122730340939643 0.5255302303974537 proxy
120 direct stream1 2 62.00100565146528 nan nan nan 0 0 0 0.08 0.0 0.001032088881843162 nan 0.0 0.16763463569165787 0.01171303074670571 0.33240901213171575 0.5925148906387202 0.9621577871938664 origin
121 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 2 25.13459256422261 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 10.002671 0.3181990311989089 nan 8.390625 0.09686888454011741 0.9514747859181731 0.2643041712809155 0.20836226291557725 0.7175046811596728 proxy
122 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 2 8.987514810098146 nan nan nan 0 0 999 10.05 10.018224 0.891564226451582 nan 34.4765625 0.09099307159353348 0.9544159544159544 0.29216323582520765 0.08466374023601732 0.6719340718210135 proxy
123 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 2 21.071103752647087 nan nan nan 0 0 1750 10.04 10.004246 0.3802105630940858 nan 75.421875 0.14884887166628677 0.9534662867996201 0.27044025157232704 0.19874932036339213 0.5726167854729214 proxy
124 3proxy-devel stream16 2 20.88356344300066 nan nan nan 0 0 1916 10.04 10.002035 0.3836478067402083 nan 62.578125 0.15109389243391066 0.952561669829222 0.2658937920718025 0.20069267100349697 0.5659629834079776 proxy
125 3proxy-devel-s stream16 2 37.836379550825434 nan nan nan 0 0 1637 10.04 9.982891 0.2119675046593261 nan 90.01953125 0.1772983114446529 0.9516587677725118 0.35577924331829225 0.3470469663570807 0.9125012250895256 origin
126 nginx stream16 2 13.526234749787726 nan nan nan 0 0 2714 10.03 10.026723 0.5918238758579852 nan 65.78515625 0.1294250281848929 0.9525166191832859 0.3106900250268144 0.1274306021910872 0.6039446697219155 proxy
127 haproxy stream16 2 9.834126139401159 nan nan nan 0 0 44 10.02 10.008187 0.8146389446310781 nan 47.69921875 0.16695842450765863 0.9515669515669516 0.6993827160493827 0.10937241978106194 1.2993031629625964 origin
128 direct stream16 2 141.1760211425275 nan nan nan 0 0 3740 0.28 0.0 0.0015863211409809627 nan 0.0 0.5678073510773131 0.05045045045045045 0.95 1.52668150425192 2.8462802363378126 origin
129 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 2 24.55551544211028 nan nan nan 0 0 1644 10.04 10.005853 0.32629388551362054 nan 61.3984375 0.15359628770301625 0.9534662867996201 0.3163548163548164 0.23017459199529192 0.7998194470095865 proxy
130 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 2 8.77774998842636 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.02 10.002153 0.9131106078895976 nan 1.91015625 0.15555555555555556 0.99800796812749 0.03339253996447602 0.5352658303272034 0.07979041790151097 proxy
131 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 2 21.603287837877293 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 10.000727000000001 0.37027268069818686 nan 5.16015625 0.1575649059982095 0.998003992015968 0.07715023994093761 0.5524390397381199 0.20154594422907607 proxy
132 3proxy-devel stream1-down 2 21.303928895665045 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 10.002455 0.3754771118572582 nan 5.984375 0.1503653738055087 0.9505703422053232 0.09543285616905249 0.552717440113428 0.1938354142227824 proxy
133 3proxy-devel-s stream1-down 2 47.320203777706716 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.9 8.762285 0.16735206137277603 nan 11.29296875 0.2516209476309227 0.9304511278195489 0.13850110213078617 0.9492116954091504 0.3602838138755396 client
134 nginx stream1-down 2 14.106979062991007 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 10.000791000000001 0.5670304371051654 nan 35.7734375 0.15931894192763757 0.999000999000999 0.244173140954495 0.5245647078834085 0.1137764809547855 proxy
135 haproxy stream1-down 2 13.730794831069057 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.002403 0.5831436303216366 nan 33.20703125 0.14322543683758235 0.9506172839506173 0.06225165562913907 0.533578834453824 0.11684576402124208 proxy
136 direct stream1-down 2 61.970607058644724 nan nan nan 0 0 0 0.07 0.0 0.0009035575299123102 nan 0.0 0.23823109843081314 0.00904392764857881 0.18501742160278745 0.9515401696214075 0.5065174918896649 client
137 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 2 47.00754139952631 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.92 9.164185 0.16880471450875434 nan 7.81640625 0.2354368932038835 0.9092575618698442 0.1350314026517795 0.9181941858744715 0.34314505326991174 client
138 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 2 0.14126415872 13977.54 4.41 8.57 0 0 0 10.11 10.103936000000001 57.25443787925883 71.61578239002621 5.26953125 0.39503305342147577 0.9601139601139601 0.4092140921409214 0.4044028381125424 0.1672592594808021 proxy
139 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 2 0.06073352192 6012.45 10.54 11.94 0 0 0 6.33 5.787432 83.38064119960721 105.05003568050185 9.265625 0.14845409487845174 0.6193737769080235 0.14365548980933596 0.2721064683401922 0.1206863596697095 none
140 3proxy-devel http-ka-1k 2 0.15946743808000002 15785.92 3.86 8.19 0 0 0 10.1 10.103763 50.668651213588234 63.35108418167334 9.2734375 0.4144079885877318 0.9600760456273765 0.4346764346764347 0.45769850543007873 0.20054527218174723 proxy
141 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-1k 2 0.15082717184 14929.48 4.1 8.28 0 0 0 10.09 10.08355 53.51820830110713 66.91602668682769 9.44921875 0.40567732662594325 0.9591254752851711 0.4263016377413835 0.42724727426155973 0.1805576935586204 proxy
142 nginx http-ka-1k 2 0.38109446144 37010.5 1.7 2.09 0 0 0 10.02 10.013575000000001 21.03415507459966 27.03570493846814 30.16796875 0.4271085458946193 0.9524714828897338 0.4704607046070461 0.6413979374063188 0.30332627013937496 proxy
143 haproxy http-ka-1k 2 0.44577062912 44116.19 1.39 2.09 0 0 0 10.01 9.999934999999999 17.964395760682276 22.676404759100013 29.703125 0.4526010512959942 0.9506172839506173 0.46119906566311963 0.6943160022023335 0.3182816361460946 proxy
144 direct http-ka-1k 2 1.23790688256 120231.46 0.47300000000000003 0.88 0 0 0 0.64 0.0 0.413601384088907 0.527050886763117 0.0 0.8046082949308756 0.20846905537459284 0.957608351787409 2.4892068817789443 0.9574683332380854 origin
145 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 2 0.13581156352 13441.73 4.61 8.49 0 0 0 10.08 10.08868 59.376387334002466 74.24703343326237 5.2734375 0.3856599674090168 0.9590865842055185 0.4054388133498146 0.3853053598739871 0.17577252336062021 proxy
146 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 2 8.76173328384 1043.83 15.05 25.04 0 0 0 10.02 10.018011 0.9148874703575584 958.3014537107881 8.79296875 0.24720812182741117 0.9524714828897338 0.09020458772473651 0.6430452902999537 0.030413724521814716 proxy
147 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 2 12.4554051584 1479.7 10.75 11.56 0 0 0 6.88 5.355506 0.4418965043692753 463.95576235754265 10.078125 0.1962594696969697 0.6317722681359045 0.08011399620012666 0.5603951058237995 0.05131653431277712 none
148 3proxy-devel http-ka-1m 2 21.81843386368 2602.78 5.85 11.44 0 0 0 10.02 9.961265000000001 0.36739575581287776 384.2466541396633 16.15625 0.386041439476554 0.9533777354900095 0.22219116825041924 1.0010771720141753 0.11410175580144677 client
149 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-1m 2 34.96103378944 4165.09 3.57 8.69 0 0 0 10.01 9.958632000000001 0.2290550115946177 239.99616389748016 14.21484375 0.5072217502124045 0.9515209125475285 0.3882580333413868 1.4940993752813039 0.14542942821942076 client
150 nginx http-ka-1m 2 12.54130450432 1497.64 10.45 16.55 0 0 0 10.02 10.019409000000001 0.6391679587429516 667.8664267146571 45.26953125 0.2984306032368808 0.9515669515669516 0.08904747130003103 0.7933676888279081 0.04370691621717513 proxy
151 haproxy http-ka-1m 2 6.294056468479999 749.32 21.2 24.21 0 0 0 10.09 10.100241 1.2824797553729876 1333.2452431289641 39.00390625 0.613958560523446 0.9600380589914367 0.09904761904761905 1.2948826327916734 0.02755697648841598 client
152 direct http-ka-1m 2 72.06955122688001 8587.98 1.25 2.33 0 0 0 0.18 0.0 0.0019980698859450073 2.0933153463273944 0.0 0.9413997627520759 0.033271719038817 0.6151936444885799 3.754277127623124 0.46653177061824086 client
153 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 2 32.98534883328 3932.3 3.85 8.34 0 0 0 10.02 9.985841 0.24301698431372643 254.42449787979587 14.6015625 0.4930203045685279 0.9524714828897338 0.37142857142857144 1.4196693651925036 0.1539927098158036 client
154 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 2 3.14681851904 7646.69 78.46 598.72 0 497 0 10.41 10.359805000000001 2.6464824550926513 135.20885286783042 125.03125 0.472448646886208 0.9886039886039886 0.45147123407992973 0.4253535770225284 0.09884827589363786 proxy
155 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 2 3.6885548236799997 8963.07 66.91 268.78 0 425 0 10.46 10.413841999999999 2.268639182554269 115.97352344416973 199.2734375 0.3172043010752688 0.9942965779467681 0.3365439093484419 0.41968795136117204 0.12456576544886427 proxy
156 3proxy-devel http-ka-50k-2000 2 4.27215028224 10381.1 57.98 217.64 0 471 0 10.41 10.362829 1.949369626490155 99.63820134382358 198.3359375 0.4785589032360912 0.9886039886039886 0.504708904109589 0.47274066039307266 0.13204040116340665 proxy
157 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-50k-2000 2 4.04892942336 9838.84 59.56 684.02 0 451 0 10.39 10.360715 2.0528883393334865 105.1332125836057 182.32421875 0.47179816808613206 0.9885823025689819 0.496881049688105 0.452020753762097 0.12450968328260942 proxy
158 nginx http-ka-50k-2000 2 4.578082816 11119.51 82.36 97.03 0 291 0 10.15 10.113419 1.7736682201600436 90.59183691684294 89.765625 0.43762270212386223 0.9657469077069457 0.4379694969269292 0.4691141566268477 0.11783661140664521 proxy
159 haproxy http-ka-50k-2000 2 4.071998095360001 9750.91 193.51 818.8 0 0 0 10.09 10.037085000000001 1.9823191983311483 102.87415503512403 176.203125 0.5370644922164566 0.9591254752851711 0.3017148981779207 0.8963847192577428 0.09029282753738208 proxy
160 direct http-ka-50k-2000 2 35.13283248128 85332.97 22.77 52.86 0 0 0 1.59 0.0 0.03620544972221543 1.8452218618172533 0.0 0.91359177954227 0.38405797101449274 0.9541139240506329 3.4653449768624753 0.952137198533366 origin
161 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 2 3.73888647168 9085.46 67.45 190.12 0 488 0 10.41 10.359068 2.227401142848279 113.8488795564159 96.58984375 0.46634146341463417 0.9876660341555977 0.491044776119403 0.45181039548726254 0.11590967543506979 proxy
162 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 2 0.0511705088 4985.36 12.65 17.84 0 0 0 10.03 9.914797 156.80907202548667 200.73650082055798 9.5703125 0.3288759689922481 0.9534220532319392 0.39224349533627884 0.2845225037643004 0.08744239251847147 proxy
163 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 2 0.0452984832 4420.66 14.18 21.97 0 0 0 10.03 9.879292 177.1361739547164 226.2882411334717 31.34765625 0.24989311671654554 0.9534220532319392 0.3030050083472454 0.2493314729842301 0.07890083260724257 proxy
164 3proxy-devel http-close-1k 2 0.0528482304 5153.04 12.2 17.51 0 0 0 10.03 9.903379000000001 151.8310062468998 194.1390523381852 13.5390625 0.3364864864864865 0.9534220532319392 0.401609363569861 0.29404623857137496 0.09028827318898211 proxy
165 3proxy-devel-s http-close-1k 2 0.05133828096 5005.62 12.56 17.8 0 0 0 10.03 9.89768 156.29662407769095 199.67748999621747 12.5390625 0.33513513513513515 0.9534220532319392 0.39515537068754586 0.28740050932892375 0.08842468920240701 proxy
166 nginx http-close-1k 2 0.13690208256 13351.64 4.68 5.23 0 0 0 10.03 9.976531000000001 58.61123402913412 74.97888182042446 29.65625 0.5274785466496257 0.9525166191832859 0.38292934502320786 0.71732877140962 0.15297870495328245 proxy
167 haproxy http-close-1k 2 0.171966464 16769.34 3.68 4.28 0 0 0 10.1 10.062629999999999 46.98590534489329 59.636629880903875 29.890625 0.5421119362434341 0.9600760456273765 0.4504463263904784 0.8094617760775544 0.16151087000273195 proxy
168 direct http-close-1k 2 0.49970937856000003 48719.93 0.847 2.4 0 0 0 4.68 0.0 7.492354877927227 9.51134451390526 0.0 0.7908633696563285 0.527027027027027 0.9366614664586583 2.3234202233526995 0.900496417140032 origin
169 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 2 0.04915724288 4789.91 13.15 18.65 0 0 0 10.0 9.888626 162.7430574072099 208.28993959591753 9.875 0.327005036807439 0.9514747859181731 0.38700980392156864 0.2768784280803077 0.0845814286769186 proxy

27
bench/data/skylake-env.txt Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,27 @@
bench/bench.py --reps 3 --duration 10 --out bench/results-final --proxy none --proxy 3proxy:bench/bin/3proxy-0.9.4:-ocTCP_NODELAY -osTCP_NODELAY --proxy 3proxy:bench/bin/3proxy-0.9.4:-s0 -ocTCP_NODELAY -osTCP_NODELAY --proxy 3proxy:bench/bin/3proxy-1.0.1:-ocTCP_NODELAY -osTCP_NODELAY --proxy 3proxy:bench/bin/3proxy-devel --proxy 3proxy:bench/bin/3proxy-devel:-s --proxy nginx --proxy haproxy
Linux almalinux10-standard-4-8-60gb.novalocal 6.12.0-211.56.1.el10_2.x86_64 #1 SMP PREEMPT_DYNAMIC Fri Sep 18 09:20:51 EDT 2026 x86_64 GNU/Linux
Architecture: x86_64
CPU op-mode(s): 32-bit, 64-bit
Address sizes: 46 bits physical, 48 bits virtual
Byte Order: Little Endian
CPU(s): 8
On-line CPU(s) list: 0-7
Vendor ID: GenuineIntel
BIOS Vendor ID: Red Hat
Model name: Intel Xeon Processor (Skylake, IBRS, no TSX)
BIOS Model name: RHEL 7.6.0 PC (i440FX + PIIX, 1996) CPU @ 2.0GHz
BIOS CPU family: 1
CPU family: 6
Model: 85
Thread(s) per core: 1
Core(s) per socket: 8
Socket(s): 1
Stepping: 4
BogoMIPS: 3999.99
Flags: fpu vme de pse tsc msr pae mce cx8 apic sep mtrr pge mca cmov pat pse36 clflush mmx fxsr sse sse2 ht syscall nx pdpe1gb rdtscp lm constant_tsc rep_good nopl xtopology cpuid tsc_known_freq pni pclmulqdq vmx ssse3 fma cx16 pcid sse4_1 sse4_2 x2apic movbe popcnt tsc_deadline_timer aes xsave avx f16c rdrand hypervisor lahf_lm abm 3dnowprefetch cpuid_fault pti ibrs ibpb tpr_shadow flexpriority ept vpid ept_ad fsgsbase bmi1 hle avx2 smep bmi2 erms invpcid rtm avx512f avx512dq rdseed adx smap clwb avx512cd avx512bw avx512vl xsaveopt xsavec xgetbv1 arat vnmi
Virtualization: VT-x
8
iperf 3.17.1 (cJSON 1.7.15)
wrk 4.2.0 [epoll] Copyright (C) 2012 Will Glozer
nginx version: nginx/1.26.3
HAProxy version 3.0.5-8e879a5 2024/09/19 - https://haproxy.org/

64
bench/data/skylake-haproxy-splice.csv Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,64 @@
proxy,scenario,rep,gbit,rate,p50_ms,p99_ms,errors,timeouts,retrans,prx_cpu_s,prx_task_s,cpu_s_per_gb,cpu_us_per_req,peak_mb,cli_util,prx_util,srv_util,cli_thread,srv_thread,bound
haproxy,stream1,0,8.636023560599849,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,6.456637,0.9269245337210678,nan,29.3984375,0.07061340941512126,0.9515209125475285,0.24744645799011533,0.15128875361032273,0.43167728422806495,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,stream1,0,30.611932766052398,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.93,5.2854019999999995,0.25943390074416994,nan,44.5,0.1944509757818011,0.9421252371916509,0.3456072351421189,0.5290081009456566,0.7130405540273751,proxy
haproxy-splice,stream1,0,32.295125067580315,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,5.2640080000000005,0.24764329171806024,nan,41.53125,0.19405204460966544,0.998003992015968,0.3641304347826087,0.49750945375038863,0.7417937263750758,proxy
haproxy,stream16,0,8.975699379090585,nan,nan,nan,0,0,3,10.0,6.335483,0.8908785169432152,nan,55.21484375,0.08196721311475409,0.9505703422053232,0.35294117647058826,0.16825135888154763,0.6038510349593467,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,stream16,0,30.70114078562312,nan,nan,nan,0,0,2,10.02,4.988116,0.26092213690457905,nan,116.16796875,0.23837620958225159,0.9506641366223909,0.6298920377867746,0.5768980619413072,1.2478655398254854,origin
haproxy-splice,stream16,0,29.456167449165562,nan,nan,nan,0,0,4,10.03,5.074315,0.2722999713491997,nan,65.875,0.2509478672985782,0.9507109004739337,0.590633423180593,0.5901256910688761,1.1679225384141474,origin
haproxy,stream1-down,0,9.71949743551696,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,6.511801999999999,0.8230021500345193,nan,31.82421875,0.21313868613138687,0.9514747859181731,0.09317751105495894,0.478663320593844,0.16547365860611024,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,stream1-down,0,31.00868765885829,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,5.240513,0.258223041719991,nan,43.22265625,0.2701674277016743,0.9980059820538385,0.24851876234364714,0.6953832692567568,0.5182059322959283,proxy
haproxy-splice,stream1-down,0,33.757359052958186,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.97,5.335453,0.236248915975285,nan,45.9296875,0.28209673335021523,0.9950099800399201,0.26517150395778366,0.7461118994574448,0.5789178306200043,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1k,0,0.38411436032,38288.69,1.6,2.44,0,0,0,10.1,6.9868310000000005,21.035402043466096,26.11931613940991,29.515625,0.22426120114394663,0.9600760456273765,0.3888716195212931,0.5774480768673774,0.3174880340636772,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-1k,0,0.37337694208,37215.98,1.59,2.7,0,0,0,10.02,6.934507,21.46892080519125,26.88842912000773,35.7578125,0.22675250357653792,0.9524714828897338,0.39981331673926573,0.5860667227322501,0.35081340003140254,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-ka-1k,0,0.33839644672,33732.09,1.63,2.86,0,0,0,10.1,7.012256,23.877319275416767,29.646502153040526,37.640625,0.20993818354731336,0.9600760456273765,0.3632982021078735,0.5327315573575286,0.3107425066142848,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1m,0,7.64504178688,915.04,18.09,27.05,0,0,0,10.1,5.303821,1.0568941577097002,1092.8370482579528,45.69140625,0.3432569974554707,0.9591642924976258,0.06386342080303509,0.8391557223251773,0.04848889431509182,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-1m,0,25.42620639232,3031.45,5.02,7.67,0,0,0,10.1,5.868972,0.31778236498703827,329.86054410660046,56.6484375,0.47657004830917876,0.957345971563981,0.18699186991869918,1.5361296511527163,0.13559013225354133,client
haproxy-splice,http-ka-1m,0,27.23009265664,3249.18,4.64,7.3,0,0,0,10.0,5.868414,0.2937926102887945,307.48416456552485,57.0859375,0.48881942774705456,0.9514747859181731,0.20784069695084006,1.6306896191455449,0.14737385727345867,client
haproxy,http-ka-50k-2000,0,2.8534688972800004,6906.74,276.3,681.8,0,0,0,10.2,6.084704,2.859677218762861,146.49279025679326,178.5078125,0.23274021352313168,0.9714285714285714,0.15208529319535904,0.4699910580882655,0.08936918162684704,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-50k-2000,0,3.24857233408,7771.56,246.18,603.78,0,0,0,10.12,6.03259,2.4921716887959637,129.2679499789237,184.7890625,0.25380228136882127,0.9628924833491912,0.16338028169014085,0.5252002261718258,0.10173884560652446,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-ka-50k-2000,0,3.58302613504,8678.56,208.1,547.39,0,0,0,10.15,6.076625,2.266240795899009,116.16462186412745,195.13671875,0.23034908572785562,0.964828897338403,0.1783479349186483,0.503275064933598,0.10838375617258414,proxy
haproxy,http-close-1k,0,0.16433283072,16140.4,3.76,5.86,0,0,0,10.01,5.7080839999999995,48.7303721655261,61.96722732253292,31.26953125,0.33586517920721576,0.9515209125475285,0.20309977397481432,0.7744119890475171,0.19014590192179193,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-close-1k,0,0.1627389952,15977.37,3.83,5.24,0,0,0,10.09,5.748422,49.60089614710857,62.52672413258888,35.50390625,0.3480427046263345,0.9600380589914367,0.20148052784036047,0.7972497298403712,0.20249463581851396,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-close-1k,0,0.1577058304,15487.67,3.91,5.72,0,0,0,10.1,5.771373,51.23463082820811,64.56850974600921,38.03515625,0.3353024574669187,0.9600760456273765,0.19872,0.758164543686981,0.1948691154509875,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,stream1,1,27.72697911951139,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,5.298265000000001,0.28841974759379113,nan,41.41015625,0.1533713200379867,0.9505703422053232,0.3315059658174782,0.4329284133394816,0.6826743269197528,proxy
haproxy-splice,stream1,1,25.259917191538477,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,5.304781,0.3166249390458997,nan,40.5703125,0.13542713567839196,0.998003992015968,0.3241869918699187,0.3736710258412311,0.6569701634810317,proxy
haproxy,stream1,1,8.97739337317577,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,6.459627,0.8915507734976943,nan,30.5546875,0.07047935453251068,0.9506172839506173,0.2743479696269396,0.15889727704554032,0.4535318084754292,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,stream16,1,24.50452714128379,nan,nan,nan,0,0,3,10.01,5.107268,0.32669244403773184,nan,106.9140625,0.18821022727272727,0.9506172839506173,0.5097184986595175,0.45240115885144244,1.017156339826392,origin
haproxy-splice,stream16,1,32.36733783383577,nan,nan,nan,0,0,4,10.01,5.100031,0.24728732533485034,nan,61.6328125,0.2641019589332075,0.9506172839506173,0.6491582491582492,0.6177741317623673,1.2802634652904543,origin
haproxy,stream16,1,8.456644318404319,nan,nan,nan,0,0,26,10.03,6.2616879999999995,0.9483557708320423,nan,44.66015625,0.08347166231918425,0.9507109004739337,0.3497726477789437,0.16730166589010056,0.6173393459154463,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,stream1-down,1,32.654824884137405,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,5.360761,0.2452055175332874,nan,44.07421875,0.28249873545776427,0.9980059820538385,0.22348993288590605,0.7503397345799475,0.520184755689371,proxy
haproxy-splice,stream1-down,1,33.6711816615982,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.88,5.429733,0.23471624511127306,nan,48.19921875,0.2860394537177542,0.987012987012987,0.25493476078956173,0.7552797811001567,0.5947510707364736,proxy
haproxy,stream1-down,1,9.193921085142536,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.02,6.505828,0.8718214219273887,nan,34.24609375,0.21614052953156823,0.9990029910269193,0.08519134775374376,0.4615832075876959,0.14676573421621225,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-1k,1,0.38302384127999994,38180.75,1.59,2.68,0,0,0,10.09,6.987365,21.074406159743898,26.165791015979543,37.48828125,0.23172183853298403,0.9600380589914367,0.39881693648816935,0.593606479932167,0.36409712451339626,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-ka-1k,1,0.38134611968,38013.2,1.61,2.48,0,0,0,10.12,7.003999,21.230057373583918,26.36110018520496,40.32421875,0.22574493444576876,0.9601518026565465,0.39486054528361014,0.5803486312482636,0.39833478017772117,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1k,1,0.36859543551999996,36741.31,1.63,2.57,0,0,0,10.1,7.011394999999999,21.921052789492773,27.21616370657203,36.09375,0.23055028462998103,0.9600760456273765,0.39416745061147695,0.5803059171812233,0.37743602204595855,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-1m,1,22.67742732288,2707.56,5.45,8.93,0,0,0,10.0,5.837529,0.35277370250586304,369.1671588895452,52.64453125,0.45167557066537156,0.9505703422053232,0.16556499842618821,1.4441986379884721,0.19100520442700733,client
haproxy-splice,http-ka-1m,1,26.54289788928,3163.17,4.76,7.99,0,0,0,10.01,5.864967,0.30170029035278123,316.28171506208724,52.71484375,0.48157070585401107,0.9515209125475285,0.20536828963795256,1.6011162092391507,0.2024190894499686,client
haproxy,http-ka-1m,1,7.21638391808,859.52,19.33,26.96,0,0,0,10.08,5.265218,1.1174571768273547,1161.1565487847022,50.41015625,0.3324892377817169,0.9590865842055185,0.07151858853182104,0.8115160024471539,0.05322013952053731,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-50k-2000,1,3.1873354956799997,7677.61,251.41,585.69,0,0,0,10.14,6.021116,2.5450725256235853,131.16535371958554,183.2890625,0.2536214675848967,0.9638783269961977,0.17430620517617712,0.5241598614639942,0.10361413296906273,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-ka-50k-2000,1,3.7184182681599998,8996.51,210.85,602.01,0,0,0,10.15,6.061004,2.1837242113211897,111.96170137663255,192.88671875,0.24253908100426338,0.9639126305792972,0.19096573208722742,0.5232345742100818,0.11598547197242452,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-50k-2000,1,3.12484036608,7518.29,252.7,648.02,0,0,0,10.15,6.005745,2.5985327404696354,133.9863241545001,179.36328125,0.248039914468995,0.9639126305792972,0.16108852048795747,0.5089801023366467,0.0960256982062013,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-close-1k,1,0.15384707072,15109.44,3.98,5.91,0,0,0,10.1,5.770323,52.51968699947178,66.18437262457078,41.54296875,0.34202417634510546,0.9609895337773549,0.20878768441308532,0.7762975883879896,0.16921538087178775,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-close-1k,1,0.15929966592,15642.48,3.86,5.76,0,0,0,10.01,5.679019,50.27003637296769,63.939599115959986,38.8671875,0.33823878471398056,0.9515209125475285,0.20263326910725754,0.7762450148988013,0.23575367001202807,proxy
haproxy,http-close-1k,1,0.15627976704,15346.24,3.91,5.74,0,0,0,10.1,5.724976,51.702150272158484,65.16255153325548,32.55859375,0.3458985301090564,0.9600760456273765,0.20880179890780598,0.7876778009132015,0.19011328892797952,proxy
haproxy-splice,stream1,2,32.45617312914042,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.85,5.248609,0.24269970330969026,nan,44.18359375,0.19387027797576623,0.9363117870722434,0.3499357326478149,0.5747021134715621,0.7445076104861466,proxy
haproxy,stream1,2,9.28810840332464,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.02,6.456582,0.8626134955555618,nan,29.859375,0.0957472083630316,0.9515669515669516,0.2776138970829236,0.15319241362388406,0.46971923546880867,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,stream1,2,31.85471336838318,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.88,5.301953,0.248049972913184,nan,44.15625,0.15957955088389872,0.9382716049382716,0.34575835475578404,0.48624400940567974,0.7312259723779009,proxy
haproxy-splice,stream16,2,31.514131973225886,nan,nan,nan,0,0,7,10.02,5.157584,0.25422265927672116,nan,57.03515625,0.2527810650887574,0.9515669515669516,0.6095684175309468,0.6025479138310235,1.190953924333449,origin
haproxy,stream16,2,9.350857051229056,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1,10.02,6.433688,0.8569758780687742,nan,70.76171875,0.08295697646779178,0.9506641366223909,0.3730769230769231,0.17868690758330755,0.6363144611780939,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,stream16,2,30.307529254304857,nan,nan,nan,0,0,9,10.02,4.946842,0.26433245922672766,nan,98.953125,0.23379081874112637,0.9515669515669516,0.6213823629553966,0.5607323347821974,1.2278466149840286,origin
haproxy-splice,stream1-down,2,33.000699897631,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.96,5.289995,0.24142349566564897,nan,44.18359375,0.27838179519595446,0.9920318725099602,0.2844006568144499,0.7453594176547956,0.617017741879391,proxy
haproxy,stream1-down,2,9.332150181039376,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.02,6.583239,0.858891908445779,nan,31.47265625,0.20446956075006423,0.99800796812749,0.09235880398671097,0.44451786978406393,0.1697062158911314,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,stream1-down,2,23.774348262310063,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,5.300676999999999,0.3364612986430228,nan,40.53125,0.24302384576357178,0.998003992015968,0.17775537634408603,0.6164387492428759,0.38736611953700967,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-ka-1k,2,0.38696648704000003,38569.82,1.59,2.48,0,0,0,10.11,7.004851,20.901034768842806,25.953489088496006,40.4765625,0.22875505831944776,0.9601139601139601,0.40641544690127684,0.5850673135537179,0.37169449371051916,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1k,2,0.37396414464,37275.14,1.6,2.51,0,0,0,10.1,7.001749,21.606349474435007,26.82752557247549,33.2734375,0.21854146806482364,0.9600760456273765,0.38234379857009637,0.5622510786690808,0.3374843664678539,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-1k,2,0.35785801728,35673.23,1.66,2.88,0,0,0,10.09,6.999706,22.55643190937427,28.004518469382376,39.62109375,0.21902497027348394,0.9600380589914367,0.38287309959664906,0.5536707074905639,0.32416551347995487,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-ka-1m,2,26.71469658112,3188.33,4.76,7.88,0,0,0,10.02,5.856622,0.3000595561944403,314.1262775095617,52.75,0.4805101058710298,0.9506641366223909,0.20299812617114305,1.4984939928822527,0.18160881999388917,client
haproxy,http-ka-1m,2,6.82631364608,813.17,19.58,27.04,0,0,0,10.09,5.114019,1.1824830235621144,1228.5401193230246,43.87109375,0.30809859154929575,0.9591254752851711,0.08501896333754741,0.7553756037312992,0.039911132866994076,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-1m,2,24.223615549439998,2891.26,5.31,7.76,0,0,0,10.01,5.819121,0.3305864883652816,345.9836858841421,53.85546875,0.47541777670138047,0.9515209125475285,0.19135609145004698,1.5260201984587785,0.13972952745627013,client
haproxy-splice,http-ka-50k-2000,2,3.8916430233600003,9416.49,198.46,531.3,0,0,0,10.15,6.0941860000000005,2.086522312364942,107.07089886810763,196.22265625,0.24123957091775924,0.964828897338403,0.1859594383775351,0.5346888517433345,0.11599435072099394,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-50k-2000,2,3.11569678336,7541.37,251.49,698.44,0,0,0,10.17,6.088383,2.6112938985115397,133.79114373668008,182.0,0.2491069302214813,0.9658119658119658,0.16033887668653907,0.513701830080388,0.09601239403300997,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-ka-50k-2000,2,2.7044033331199997,6528.24,264.27,695.02,0,0,0,10.15,5.990472,3.002510720408027,154.4454419574248,184.8828125,0.22211675367821548,0.964828897338403,0.14858934169278998,0.4480748449726689,0.08841104873739809,proxy
haproxy-splice,http-close-1k,2,0.15409872896000001,15129.27,3.97,6.08,0,0,0,10.01,5.701479,51.966684307166915,66.11624834874505,37.29296875,0.3454415954415954,0.9515209125475285,0.20836033700583279,0.7914972973071054,0.18823474885391117,proxy
haproxy,http-close-1k,2,0.15468593152000001,15192.54,3.98,5.51,0,0,0,10.1,5.72345,52.234873078650345,65.82591977058689,35.4609375,0.3456702253855279,0.9600760456273765,0.20811855670103094,0.7867352605196705,0.20723811513137558,proxy
haproxy-splice-auto,http-close-1k,2,0.15208546303999998,14935.9,4.04,6.46,0,0,0,10.03,5.685684,52.75980912054433,67.09389131190967,39.921875,0.32976699952448885,0.9525166191832859,0.19832851173256189,0.7592032193502162,0.1958527694972338,proxy
1 proxy scenario rep gbit rate p50_ms p99_ms errors timeouts retrans prx_cpu_s prx_task_s cpu_s_per_gb cpu_us_per_req peak_mb cli_util prx_util srv_util cli_thread srv_thread bound
2 haproxy stream1 0 8.636023560599849 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 6.456637 0.9269245337210678 nan 29.3984375 0.07061340941512126 0.9515209125475285 0.24744645799011533 0.15128875361032273 0.43167728422806495 proxy
3 haproxy-splice-auto stream1 0 30.611932766052398 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.93 5.2854019999999995 0.25943390074416994 nan 44.5 0.1944509757818011 0.9421252371916509 0.3456072351421189 0.5290081009456566 0.7130405540273751 proxy
4 haproxy-splice stream1 0 32.295125067580315 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 5.2640080000000005 0.24764329171806024 nan 41.53125 0.19405204460966544 0.998003992015968 0.3641304347826087 0.49750945375038863 0.7417937263750758 proxy
5 haproxy stream16 0 8.975699379090585 nan nan nan 0 0 3 10.0 6.335483 0.8908785169432152 nan 55.21484375 0.08196721311475409 0.9505703422053232 0.35294117647058826 0.16825135888154763 0.6038510349593467 proxy
6 haproxy-splice-auto stream16 0 30.70114078562312 nan nan nan 0 0 2 10.02 4.988116 0.26092213690457905 nan 116.16796875 0.23837620958225159 0.9506641366223909 0.6298920377867746 0.5768980619413072 1.2478655398254854 origin
7 haproxy-splice stream16 0 29.456167449165562 nan nan nan 0 0 4 10.03 5.074315 0.2722999713491997 nan 65.875 0.2509478672985782 0.9507109004739337 0.590633423180593 0.5901256910688761 1.1679225384141474 origin
8 haproxy stream1-down 0 9.71949743551696 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 6.511801999999999 0.8230021500345193 nan 31.82421875 0.21313868613138687 0.9514747859181731 0.09317751105495894 0.478663320593844 0.16547365860611024 proxy
9 haproxy-splice-auto stream1-down 0 31.00868765885829 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 5.240513 0.258223041719991 nan 43.22265625 0.2701674277016743 0.9980059820538385 0.24851876234364714 0.6953832692567568 0.5182059322959283 proxy
10 haproxy-splice stream1-down 0 33.757359052958186 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.97 5.335453 0.236248915975285 nan 45.9296875 0.28209673335021523 0.9950099800399201 0.26517150395778366 0.7461118994574448 0.5789178306200043 proxy
11 haproxy http-ka-1k 0 0.38411436032 38288.69 1.6 2.44 0 0 0 10.1 6.9868310000000005 21.035402043466096 26.11931613940991 29.515625 0.22426120114394663 0.9600760456273765 0.3888716195212931 0.5774480768673774 0.3174880340636772 proxy
12 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-1k 0 0.37337694208 37215.98 1.59 2.7 0 0 0 10.02 6.934507 21.46892080519125 26.88842912000773 35.7578125 0.22675250357653792 0.9524714828897338 0.39981331673926573 0.5860667227322501 0.35081340003140254 proxy
13 haproxy-splice http-ka-1k 0 0.33839644672 33732.09 1.63 2.86 0 0 0 10.1 7.012256 23.877319275416767 29.646502153040526 37.640625 0.20993818354731336 0.9600760456273765 0.3632982021078735 0.5327315573575286 0.3107425066142848 proxy
14 haproxy http-ka-1m 0 7.64504178688 915.04 18.09 27.05 0 0 0 10.1 5.303821 1.0568941577097002 1092.8370482579528 45.69140625 0.3432569974554707 0.9591642924976258 0.06386342080303509 0.8391557223251773 0.04848889431509182 proxy
15 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-1m 0 25.42620639232 3031.45 5.02 7.67 0 0 0 10.1 5.868972 0.31778236498703827 329.86054410660046 56.6484375 0.47657004830917876 0.957345971563981 0.18699186991869918 1.5361296511527163 0.13559013225354133 client
16 haproxy-splice http-ka-1m 0 27.23009265664 3249.18 4.64 7.3 0 0 0 10.0 5.868414 0.2937926102887945 307.48416456552485 57.0859375 0.48881942774705456 0.9514747859181731 0.20784069695084006 1.6306896191455449 0.14737385727345867 client
17 haproxy http-ka-50k-2000 0 2.8534688972800004 6906.74 276.3 681.8 0 0 0 10.2 6.084704 2.859677218762861 146.49279025679326 178.5078125 0.23274021352313168 0.9714285714285714 0.15208529319535904 0.4699910580882655 0.08936918162684704 proxy
18 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-50k-2000 0 3.24857233408 7771.56 246.18 603.78 0 0 0 10.12 6.03259 2.4921716887959637 129.2679499789237 184.7890625 0.25380228136882127 0.9628924833491912 0.16338028169014085 0.5252002261718258 0.10173884560652446 proxy
19 haproxy-splice http-ka-50k-2000 0 3.58302613504 8678.56 208.1 547.39 0 0 0 10.15 6.076625 2.266240795899009 116.16462186412745 195.13671875 0.23034908572785562 0.964828897338403 0.1783479349186483 0.503275064933598 0.10838375617258414 proxy
20 haproxy http-close-1k 0 0.16433283072 16140.4 3.76 5.86 0 0 0 10.01 5.7080839999999995 48.7303721655261 61.96722732253292 31.26953125 0.33586517920721576 0.9515209125475285 0.20309977397481432 0.7744119890475171 0.19014590192179193 proxy
21 haproxy-splice-auto http-close-1k 0 0.1627389952 15977.37 3.83 5.24 0 0 0 10.09 5.748422 49.60089614710857 62.52672413258888 35.50390625 0.3480427046263345 0.9600380589914367 0.20148052784036047 0.7972497298403712 0.20249463581851396 proxy
22 haproxy-splice http-close-1k 0 0.1577058304 15487.67 3.91 5.72 0 0 0 10.1 5.771373 51.23463082820811 64.56850974600921 38.03515625 0.3353024574669187 0.9600760456273765 0.19872 0.758164543686981 0.1948691154509875 proxy
23 haproxy-splice-auto stream1 1 27.72697911951139 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 5.298265000000001 0.28841974759379113 nan 41.41015625 0.1533713200379867 0.9505703422053232 0.3315059658174782 0.4329284133394816 0.6826743269197528 proxy
24 haproxy-splice stream1 1 25.259917191538477 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 5.304781 0.3166249390458997 nan 40.5703125 0.13542713567839196 0.998003992015968 0.3241869918699187 0.3736710258412311 0.6569701634810317 proxy
25 haproxy stream1 1 8.97739337317577 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 6.459627 0.8915507734976943 nan 30.5546875 0.07047935453251068 0.9506172839506173 0.2743479696269396 0.15889727704554032 0.4535318084754292 proxy
26 haproxy-splice-auto stream16 1 24.50452714128379 nan nan nan 0 0 3 10.01 5.107268 0.32669244403773184 nan 106.9140625 0.18821022727272727 0.9506172839506173 0.5097184986595175 0.45240115885144244 1.017156339826392 origin
27 haproxy-splice stream16 1 32.36733783383577 nan nan nan 0 0 4 10.01 5.100031 0.24728732533485034 nan 61.6328125 0.2641019589332075 0.9506172839506173 0.6491582491582492 0.6177741317623673 1.2802634652904543 origin
28 haproxy stream16 1 8.456644318404319 nan nan nan 0 0 26 10.03 6.2616879999999995 0.9483557708320423 nan 44.66015625 0.08347166231918425 0.9507109004739337 0.3497726477789437 0.16730166589010056 0.6173393459154463 proxy
29 haproxy-splice-auto stream1-down 1 32.654824884137405 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 5.360761 0.2452055175332874 nan 44.07421875 0.28249873545776427 0.9980059820538385 0.22348993288590605 0.7503397345799475 0.520184755689371 proxy
30 haproxy-splice stream1-down 1 33.6711816615982 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.88 5.429733 0.23471624511127306 nan 48.19921875 0.2860394537177542 0.987012987012987 0.25493476078956173 0.7552797811001567 0.5947510707364736 proxy
31 haproxy stream1-down 1 9.193921085142536 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.02 6.505828 0.8718214219273887 nan 34.24609375 0.21614052953156823 0.9990029910269193 0.08519134775374376 0.4615832075876959 0.14676573421621225 proxy
32 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-1k 1 0.38302384127999994 38180.75 1.59 2.68 0 0 0 10.09 6.987365 21.074406159743898 26.165791015979543 37.48828125 0.23172183853298403 0.9600380589914367 0.39881693648816935 0.593606479932167 0.36409712451339626 proxy
33 haproxy-splice http-ka-1k 1 0.38134611968 38013.2 1.61 2.48 0 0 0 10.12 7.003999 21.230057373583918 26.36110018520496 40.32421875 0.22574493444576876 0.9601518026565465 0.39486054528361014 0.5803486312482636 0.39833478017772117 proxy
34 haproxy http-ka-1k 1 0.36859543551999996 36741.31 1.63 2.57 0 0 0 10.1 7.011394999999999 21.921052789492773 27.21616370657203 36.09375 0.23055028462998103 0.9600760456273765 0.39416745061147695 0.5803059171812233 0.37743602204595855 proxy
35 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-1m 1 22.67742732288 2707.56 5.45 8.93 0 0 0 10.0 5.837529 0.35277370250586304 369.1671588895452 52.64453125 0.45167557066537156 0.9505703422053232 0.16556499842618821 1.4441986379884721 0.19100520442700733 client
36 haproxy-splice http-ka-1m 1 26.54289788928 3163.17 4.76 7.99 0 0 0 10.01 5.864967 0.30170029035278123 316.28171506208724 52.71484375 0.48157070585401107 0.9515209125475285 0.20536828963795256 1.6011162092391507 0.2024190894499686 client
37 haproxy http-ka-1m 1 7.21638391808 859.52 19.33 26.96 0 0 0 10.08 5.265218 1.1174571768273547 1161.1565487847022 50.41015625 0.3324892377817169 0.9590865842055185 0.07151858853182104 0.8115160024471539 0.05322013952053731 proxy
38 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-50k-2000 1 3.1873354956799997 7677.61 251.41 585.69 0 0 0 10.14 6.021116 2.5450725256235853 131.16535371958554 183.2890625 0.2536214675848967 0.9638783269961977 0.17430620517617712 0.5241598614639942 0.10361413296906273 proxy
39 haproxy-splice http-ka-50k-2000 1 3.7184182681599998 8996.51 210.85 602.01 0 0 0 10.15 6.061004 2.1837242113211897 111.96170137663255 192.88671875 0.24253908100426338 0.9639126305792972 0.19096573208722742 0.5232345742100818 0.11598547197242452 proxy
40 haproxy http-ka-50k-2000 1 3.12484036608 7518.29 252.7 648.02 0 0 0 10.15 6.005745 2.5985327404696354 133.9863241545001 179.36328125 0.248039914468995 0.9639126305792972 0.16108852048795747 0.5089801023366467 0.0960256982062013 proxy
41 haproxy-splice-auto http-close-1k 1 0.15384707072 15109.44 3.98 5.91 0 0 0 10.1 5.770323 52.51968699947178 66.18437262457078 41.54296875 0.34202417634510546 0.9609895337773549 0.20878768441308532 0.7762975883879896 0.16921538087178775 proxy
42 haproxy-splice http-close-1k 1 0.15929966592 15642.48 3.86 5.76 0 0 0 10.01 5.679019 50.27003637296769 63.939599115959986 38.8671875 0.33823878471398056 0.9515209125475285 0.20263326910725754 0.7762450148988013 0.23575367001202807 proxy
43 haproxy http-close-1k 1 0.15627976704 15346.24 3.91 5.74 0 0 0 10.1 5.724976 51.702150272158484 65.16255153325548 32.55859375 0.3458985301090564 0.9600760456273765 0.20880179890780598 0.7876778009132015 0.19011328892797952 proxy
44 haproxy-splice stream1 2 32.45617312914042 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.85 5.248609 0.24269970330969026 nan 44.18359375 0.19387027797576623 0.9363117870722434 0.3499357326478149 0.5747021134715621 0.7445076104861466 proxy
45 haproxy stream1 2 9.28810840332464 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.02 6.456582 0.8626134955555618 nan 29.859375 0.0957472083630316 0.9515669515669516 0.2776138970829236 0.15319241362388406 0.46971923546880867 proxy
46 haproxy-splice-auto stream1 2 31.85471336838318 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.88 5.301953 0.248049972913184 nan 44.15625 0.15957955088389872 0.9382716049382716 0.34575835475578404 0.48624400940567974 0.7312259723779009 proxy
47 haproxy-splice stream16 2 31.514131973225886 nan nan nan 0 0 7 10.02 5.157584 0.25422265927672116 nan 57.03515625 0.2527810650887574 0.9515669515669516 0.6095684175309468 0.6025479138310235 1.190953924333449 origin
48 haproxy stream16 2 9.350857051229056 nan nan nan 0 0 1 10.02 6.433688 0.8569758780687742 nan 70.76171875 0.08295697646779178 0.9506641366223909 0.3730769230769231 0.17868690758330755 0.6363144611780939 proxy
49 haproxy-splice-auto stream16 2 30.307529254304857 nan nan nan 0 0 9 10.02 4.946842 0.26433245922672766 nan 98.953125 0.23379081874112637 0.9515669515669516 0.6213823629553966 0.5607323347821974 1.2278466149840286 origin
50 haproxy-splice stream1-down 2 33.000699897631 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.96 5.289995 0.24142349566564897 nan 44.18359375 0.27838179519595446 0.9920318725099602 0.2844006568144499 0.7453594176547956 0.617017741879391 proxy
51 haproxy stream1-down 2 9.332150181039376 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.02 6.583239 0.858891908445779 nan 31.47265625 0.20446956075006423 0.99800796812749 0.09235880398671097 0.44451786978406393 0.1697062158911314 proxy
52 haproxy-splice-auto stream1-down 2 23.774348262310063 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 5.300676999999999 0.3364612986430228 nan 40.53125 0.24302384576357178 0.998003992015968 0.17775537634408603 0.6164387492428759 0.38736611953700967 proxy
53 haproxy-splice http-ka-1k 2 0.38696648704000003 38569.82 1.59 2.48 0 0 0 10.11 7.004851 20.901034768842806 25.953489088496006 40.4765625 0.22875505831944776 0.9601139601139601 0.40641544690127684 0.5850673135537179 0.37169449371051916 proxy
54 haproxy http-ka-1k 2 0.37396414464 37275.14 1.6 2.51 0 0 0 10.1 7.001749 21.606349474435007 26.82752557247549 33.2734375 0.21854146806482364 0.9600760456273765 0.38234379857009637 0.5622510786690808 0.3374843664678539 proxy
55 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-1k 2 0.35785801728 35673.23 1.66 2.88 0 0 0 10.09 6.999706 22.55643190937427 28.004518469382376 39.62109375 0.21902497027348394 0.9600380589914367 0.38287309959664906 0.5536707074905639 0.32416551347995487 proxy
56 haproxy-splice http-ka-1m 2 26.71469658112 3188.33 4.76 7.88 0 0 0 10.02 5.856622 0.3000595561944403 314.1262775095617 52.75 0.4805101058710298 0.9506641366223909 0.20299812617114305 1.4984939928822527 0.18160881999388917 client
57 haproxy http-ka-1m 2 6.82631364608 813.17 19.58 27.04 0 0 0 10.09 5.114019 1.1824830235621144 1228.5401193230246 43.87109375 0.30809859154929575 0.9591254752851711 0.08501896333754741 0.7553756037312992 0.039911132866994076 proxy
58 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-1m 2 24.223615549439998 2891.26 5.31 7.76 0 0 0 10.01 5.819121 0.3305864883652816 345.9836858841421 53.85546875 0.47541777670138047 0.9515209125475285 0.19135609145004698 1.5260201984587785 0.13972952745627013 client
59 haproxy-splice http-ka-50k-2000 2 3.8916430233600003 9416.49 198.46 531.3 0 0 0 10.15 6.0941860000000005 2.086522312364942 107.07089886810763 196.22265625 0.24123957091775924 0.964828897338403 0.1859594383775351 0.5346888517433345 0.11599435072099394 proxy
60 haproxy http-ka-50k-2000 2 3.11569678336 7541.37 251.49 698.44 0 0 0 10.17 6.088383 2.6112938985115397 133.79114373668008 182.0 0.2491069302214813 0.9658119658119658 0.16033887668653907 0.513701830080388 0.09601239403300997 proxy
61 haproxy-splice-auto http-ka-50k-2000 2 2.7044033331199997 6528.24 264.27 695.02 0 0 0 10.15 5.990472 3.002510720408027 154.4454419574248 184.8828125 0.22211675367821548 0.964828897338403 0.14858934169278998 0.4480748449726689 0.08841104873739809 proxy
62 haproxy-splice http-close-1k 2 0.15409872896000001 15129.27 3.97 6.08 0 0 0 10.01 5.701479 51.966684307166915 66.11624834874505 37.29296875 0.3454415954415954 0.9515209125475285 0.20836033700583279 0.7914972973071054 0.18823474885391117 proxy
63 haproxy http-close-1k 2 0.15468593152000001 15192.54 3.98 5.51 0 0 0 10.1 5.72345 52.234873078650345 65.82591977058689 35.4609375 0.3456702253855279 0.9600760456273765 0.20811855670103094 0.7867352605196705 0.20723811513137558 proxy
64 haproxy-splice-auto http-close-1k 2 0.15208546303999998 14935.9 4.04 6.46 0 0 0 10.03 5.685684 52.75980912054433 67.09389131190967 39.921875 0.32976699952448885 0.9525166191832859 0.19832851173256189 0.7592032193502162 0.1958527694972338 proxy

169
bench/data/skylake-main.csv Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,169 @@
proxy,scenario,rep,gbit,rate,p50_ms,p99_ms,errors,timeouts,retrans,prx_cpu_s,prx_task_s,cpu_s_per_gb,cpu_us_per_req,peak_mb,cli_util,prx_util,srv_util,cli_thread,srv_thread,bound
direct,stream1,0,43.94218560876057,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,6.14,0.0,0.11176599723683582,nan,0.0,0.2714785214785215,0.6375908618899273,0.34114848793747876,0.7093557466411603,0.7677126968039654,none
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,0,28.29906719758348,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.99,5.642289,0.2823608023087004,nan,8.28515625,0.18638613861386139,0.996011964107677,0.34114848793747876,0.4875220793405474,0.7017296502032296,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,0,5.5253553114021905,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,6.226614,1.4476205398649034,nan,3.0234375,0.051818634778276036,0.999000999000999,0.29378925331472433,0.10590895116421987,0.4492709035255843,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,0,19.14664078851784,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,6.844423,0.41773771497678447,nan,5.03515625,0.1300148588410104,0.999000999000999,0.2714236940935473,0.31270573943067576,0.4901693435525649,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream1,0,19.8696182749667,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,7.011065,0.4029305056944686,nan,7.8046875,0.10659655831739961,0.9515209125475285,0.26653696498054474,0.2978079331340094,0.47533737667963033,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream1,0,32.832108216195635,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,5.25863,0.24361752944078474,nan,7.15234375,0.17372775131611934,0.999000999000999,0.37533875338753386,0.507535555131982,0.7727085060025145,proxy
nginx,stream1,0,9.562232619939449,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,6.469755,0.8363088264713298,nan,34.30078125,0.06774423579748039,0.9514747859181731,0.27742998352553544,0.15795959930948786,0.46692001711780395,proxy
haproxy,stream1,0,9.72057688006905,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.02,6.535721,0.8242036096593605,nan,29.609375,0.0635260528194147,0.9515669515669516,0.26005888125613347,0.14178342556893786,0.4591503253841818,proxy
direct,stream16,0,147.7220505652621,nan,nan,nan,0,0,3766,8.74,0.0,0.04732058850676409,nan,0.0,0.9378121878121878,0.8855116514690983,0.9720930232558139,3.0634424105815397,2.510424936668355,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,0,27.99043137406809,nan,nan,nan,0,0,783,10.02,5.605625,0.28591396835589206,nan,71.03125,0.18067724366564053,0.9515669515669516,0.3380417335473515,0.5046938551122888,0.7208465723862956,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,0,5.732471205111505,nan,nan,nan,0,0,197,10.04,6.289962,1.397156791495668,nan,93.3125,0.04843304843304843,0.9534662867996201,0.2989859339221459,0.10929789097392564,0.46724437122251294,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,0,18.886082493858858,nan,nan,nan,0,0,818,10.05,7.086829,0.4244418214174509,nan,98.0,0.13839285714285715,0.95260663507109,0.262987012987013,0.3383729659173314,0.4698905401852417,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream16,0,18.75490180600116,nan,nan,nan,0,0,806,10.03,7.100816999999999,0.42647019861696284,nan,97.57421875,0.1466261965911744,0.9534220532319392,0.2682452156989945,0.353601950334539,0.47673192496314026,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream16,0,30.455126533025485,nan,nan,nan,0,0,755,10.02,5.1583939999999995,0.2626929332675569,nan,87.84765625,0.20339382512373322,0.9515669515669516,0.3482858058314643,0.5749151856694169,0.7593291404137741,proxy
nginx,stream16,0,9.96210022136924,nan,nan,nan,0,0,634,10.1,6.678844,0.8035212542948832,nan,111.4765625,0.07841743662639185,0.9591642924976258,0.2879084967320261,0.1834119622066088,0.4690910571132587,proxy
haproxy,stream16,0,9.197518509317366,nan,nan,nan,0,0,3,10.02,6.322018,0.8709473557445826,nan,59.1640625,0.08803986710963455,0.9506641366223909,0.3649737302977233,0.18629361152888832,0.6316235684873117,proxy
direct,stream1-down,0,45.647288189692524,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,6.19,0.0,0.10847239527586117,nan,0.0,0.27171152869476894,0.6447916666666667,0.3575717144763175,0.7333099099289225,0.7417750103981438,none
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,0,34.870015744513765,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.99,5.292173999999999,0.22916950215942986,nan,10.63671875,0.2690550613128156,0.9496197718631179,0.25235109717868337,0.7136899543083228,0.5505873541310307,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,0,5.602349221864972,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,6.135136,1.4278164710203243,nan,1.99609375,0.23190279214064116,0.998003992015968,0.06281156530408774,0.4386119914214682,0.10084248890934187,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,0,19.678813251012862,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,6.833243,0.40689128603143715,nan,7.9375,0.20449601160261058,0.9515209125475285,0.141994917407878,0.4852622577380805,0.2909466155722971,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream1-down,0,20.287587429291236,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,6.877286,0.3946823184622709,nan,8.859375,0.21173469387755103,0.999001996007984,0.1775731667214732,0.4925085135378208,0.33840632309755886,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream1-down,0,31.955023215450773,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.98,5.232906,0.24982481542978685,nan,11.48828125,0.26596000963623223,0.9477682811016145,0.23147561747941736,0.7288831597684343,0.5113277193991893,proxy
nginx,stream1-down,0,9.79548777575188,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.99,6.544494,0.8157989806714065,nan,32.234375,0.21067487811136773,0.999,0.09574468085106383,0.4574657832607243,0.1686745348268016,proxy
haproxy,stream1-down,0,9.319587948765866,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,6.52505,0.8591737833882246,nan,30.12109375,0.21124694376528116,0.9515209125475285,0.09274447949526814,0.4500690759527404,0.15784557865976825,proxy
direct,http-ka-1k,0,1.22188464128,119514.52,0.49,0.8200000000000001,0,0,0,7.71,0.0,5.047939708562534,6.387627058684149,0.0,0.5640961442163245,0.750730282375852,0.9591125198098257,1.6139796321059274,0.8291503007549478,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,0,0.142606336,14217.61,4.2,8.74,0,0,0,10.1,7.8545300000000005,56.659474092371326,70.3357312478673,5.3125,0.1492040864813495,0.9591642924976258,0.22826430603857098,0.3225315295098274,0.17208480681672234,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,0,0.20946354175999998,20876.06,2.94,5.91,0,0,0,10.1,7.4359470000000005,38.57473206128605,47.90044296053193,5.375,0.19053254437869824,0.9609895337773549,0.28996517885406775,0.41955115652675273,0.22437098434992847,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,0,0.06157238272,6141.27,10.34,11.36,0,0,0,4.47,3.14774,58.077986298854725,72.69356491193834,9.6953125,0.07090348589044344,0.42329545454545453,0.103207367418228,0.14557638541524176,0.09318412301266239,none
3proxy-devel,http-ka-1k,0,0.19226689536000002,19169.41,3.16,5.9,0,0,0,10.1,7.510120000000001,42.02491533901887,52.16699636897045,9.88671875,0.18420430361787657,0.9600760456273765,0.27784810126582277,0.40053296910233444,0.27846989769837954,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-1k,0,0.15032385536,14984.94,4.11,8.55,0,0,0,10.0,7.84878,53.2184328351702,66.66177813627,9.6875,0.15639810426540285,0.949667616334283,0.23356510745891276,0.33585181945622733,0.1786828625382035,proxy
nginx,http-ka-1k,0,0.37044092928,36230.03,1.72,2.39,0,0,0,10.02,6.753332,21.63907755976138,27.642675656513546,31.453125,0.23075100687040986,0.9515669515669516,0.426969791342261,0.5755808388889219,0.32324231089215627,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1k,0,0.35995516928,35876.98,1.65,2.79,0,0,0,10.1,7.017473000000001,22.447239794227745,27.873987498102636,29.55078125,0.22531884742560226,0.9600760456273765,0.3981366459627329,0.5622085505479247,0.31845939009516416,proxy
direct,http-ka-1m,0,67.51688589312,8043.82,1.35,2.58,0,0,0,6.18,0.0,0.07322612609572082,76.67018175051176,0.0,0.9465685110425077,0.5982575024201355,0.5430899404575368,3.560523412785333,0.4551360718861913,client
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,0,24.99670966272,2979.22,5.03,12.1,0,0,0,10.0,6.173425,0.3200421218609891,335.1992759695639,16.78515625,0.44590780809031044,0.9523809523809523,0.20799500312304808,1.4870074439093754,0.15591340186519673,client
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,0,5.835954585600001,695.5,22.47,50.95,0,0,0,10.0,6.227775,1.3708125864686647,1436.7816091954023,14.21484375,0.2531615366261036,0.9514747859181731,0.05625790139064475,0.5526401143338306,0.04562272677057892,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,0,12.36950581248,1475.55,10.74,11.9,0,0,0,8.15,5.242551000000001,0.5271027071608438,551.5327874399404,9.34765625,0.2432049160954857,0.7703213610586012,0.11586508432229857,0.7430855753377406,0.07796468499366345,none
3proxy-devel,http-ka-1m,0,18.29656068096,2175.51,7.03,14.86,0,0,0,10.02,6.95438,0.43811512665009844,459.84396512161544,16.9375,0.3576299083000235,0.9524714828897338,0.1453287197231834,1.114991713418537,0.10837593685332784,client
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-1m,0,23.45052143616,2790.01,5.36,13.66,0,0,0,10.01,6.273167,0.3414849440256755,358.3959899749373,17.57421875,0.4259346900141978,0.9524262607040913,0.19731920199501246,1.4203952920899983,0.16542876082448071,client
nginx,http-ka-1m,0,6.0280537088,718.42,22.02,30.01,0,0,0,10.01,6.239152,1.3284553168976567,1392.21140472879,44.73828125,0.2618595825426945,0.9515209125475285,0.060825716987078476,0.5707924206056916,0.040878219423396464,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1m,0,6.72002998272,800.5,20.03,31.46,0,0,0,10.08,5.202046,1.1999946459667454,1246.7532467532467,45.22265625,0.31741643629052524,0.9590865842055185,0.06862745098039216,0.7667876855487537,0.04183266925588077,proxy
direct,http-ka-50k-2000,0,35.991825940480005,87401.38,20.85,32.92,0,0,0,8.61,0.0,0.19137678681239303,9.758607635968799,0.0,0.8615125240847784,0.8482758620689655,0.9534957291996203,2.8137727978226663,0.7692009026679565,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,0,3.8871970611199997,9447.4,59.62,121.52,0,281,0,10.47,7.33171,2.1547659838955173,110.16066412045075,91.94140625,0.19929577464788734,0.9961941008563273,0.2252027448533999,0.4481119733502381,0.1359548037023942,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,0,2.80498274304,6817.05,64.89,170.52,0,246,0,10.47,6.92724,2.9861146279004243,152.45722606479796,171.80078125,0.19711992445703494,0.9943019943019943,0.17001885606536768,0.39576669135250814,0.10457313967013684,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,0,4.13407379456,10047.51,47.31,95.57,0,325,0,10.48,7.348655999999999,2.0280237887945907,103.67102256427505,133.34375,0.18839896250884225,0.9971455756422455,0.2352205192367845,0.47094639884576445,0.1511659166447872,proxy
3proxy-devel,http-ka-50k-2000,0,4.334813184,10535.29,36.58,89.02,0,217,0,10.48,7.494909000000001,1.9341087249032414,98.85020609513388,104.4765625,0.1919811320754717,0.9952516619183286,0.2352386934673367,0.48617878992348906,0.1502187969426634,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-50k-2000,0,3.69744674816,8986.28,56.49,131.1,0,278,0,10.49,7.663372,2.2696743378863267,115.96285651116516,163.875,0.18351440717997167,0.997148288973384,0.21916952856696847,0.43191933814893463,0.13690098735210118,proxy
nginx,http-ka-50k-2000,0,3.5584475136,8644.47,127.17,159.61,0,137,0,10.2,6.9846140000000005,2.293134848501591,117.12694493885284,111.48046875,0.1927796130250118,0.9686609686609686,0.1699181875393329,0.4119689291215604,0.10648114028799606,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-50k-2000,0,3.01134249984,7277.23,261.46,803.19,0,0,0,10.18,6.057987,2.704441623771693,138.83017169664652,177.1640625,0.24276908487434803,0.967680608365019,0.16573208722741434,0.49376391215017,0.09697167338018714,proxy
direct,http-close-1k,0,0.53108277248,52147.64,0.733,3.79,0,0,0,8.55,0.0,12.879348294540259,16.233242262629176,0.0,0.7378545006165228,0.9038054968287527,0.8912415784408084,2.041091324801681,0.5730997647090921,client
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,0,0.04286578688,4205.68,14.45,27.55,0,0,0,10.03,7.027548,187.18891181124633,238.17439209726444,24.2578125,0.13195925136223643,0.9516129032258065,0.14860583016476553,0.2568869570846952,0.0741601460789961,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,0,0.042781900799999995,4198.03,14.4,26.5,0,0,0,9.99,6.893052,186.80796903722427,237.61952333380904,14.6015625,0.1328439497987213,0.9532442748091603,0.15257469802924348,0.26163964201916406,0.0770072155740437,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,0,0.04051697664,3981.6,15.33,26.5,0,0,0,10.02,7.319014,197.84299483210404,251.44291091593476,22.5859375,0.1254725897920605,0.9524714828897338,0.1512179689971528,0.24451500342681542,0.07130340729423489,proxy
3proxy-devel,http-close-1k,0,0.048234496,4737.08,12.57,23.9,0,0,0,10.02,7.008174,166.18811565896738,211.0895761355018,53.35546875,0.14417613636363635,0.9533777354900095,0.16883116883116883,0.29112139474568055,0.08271276801194205,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-close-1k,0,0.04286578688,4208.46,14.35,25.42,0,0,0,10.01,7.117795,186.81565376177224,237.55280269590392,34.671875,0.1333175467677007,0.9515209125475285,0.15182250396196514,0.2635367130382308,0.07225341515917486,proxy
nginx,http-close-1k,0,0.1308622848,12847.5,4.6,6.91,0,0,0,10.01,5.414315,61.19410196940104,77.84249531467498,31.26171875,0.2969047619047619,0.9515209125475285,0.17742966751918157,0.6478938205044057,0.13689735065744207,proxy
haproxy,http-close-1k,0,0.16097738752000001,15806.42,3.86,5.66,0,0,0,10.02,5.679621999999999,49.795813707090275,63.34675711386611,29.22265625,0.3452914798206278,0.9515669515669516,0.20858505564387916,0.7857354029966487,0.1882130006120697,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,1,29.197936831775145,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.99,5.64714,0.2736513633341382,nan,10.65625,0.17688846791380536,0.9496197718631179,0.3423772609819121,0.5023860496182423,0.7197181448896807,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,1,5.54073610574154,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,6.130356,1.4435121055096212,nan,2.44921875,0.05010686297791499,0.9505703422053232,0.29360852197070575,0.10466706550123972,0.44310229377669036,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,1,18.746271170960057,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1,10.0,6.923991,0.4266378787899969,nan,8.3515625,0.11147213196700825,0.9970089730807578,0.26810109289617484,0.2806287257999571,0.48901023992781184,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream1,1,19.81979353775472,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.99,7.0106139999999995,0.40314001569442237,nan,10.01953125,0.12717852096090437,0.9514285714285714,0.2719869706840391,0.3254262212161135,0.49544393857855856,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream1,1,31.449077260376534,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1,9.99,5.090237999999999,0.25408424631525656,nan,8.16015625,0.17983446200150488,0.996011964107677,0.37170830519918974,0.5165425469182663,0.7767505112411156,proxy
nginx,stream1,1,9.75871712437566,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.96,6.438269,0.8162760444640786,nan,32.1171875,0.0738541914034671,0.9485714285714286,0.2553261225827598,0.1684169055869681,0.4430885623004122,proxy
haproxy,stream1,1,9.705190165858776,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,6.665984999999999,0.8247415118717535,nan,33.25,0.06956315289648624,0.9515209125475285,0.2513911620294599,0.16841994688587877,0.451663677897488,proxy
direct,stream1,1,44.389174005677766,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,6.11,0.0,0.11010085402569145,nan,0.0,0.27168207948012996,0.63579604578564,0.341156462585034,0.7055619791558234,0.7569537921450805,none
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,1,28.313349968601848,nan,nan,nan,0,0,715,10.03,5.574904,0.28275288543033045,nan,79.04296875,0.17958412098298676,0.9534220532319392,0.33697047496790755,0.5009326678550153,0.7237895955738057,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,1,5.220472839007376,nan,nan,nan,0,0,218,10.04,6.353164,1.5318292389511048,nan,90.90234375,0.04395343311950582,0.9543726235741445,0.279445727482679,0.1007633566748517,0.43027320887726855,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,1,19.45533354602417,nan,nan,nan,0,0,800,10.05,7.085894000000001,0.41200968849744224,nan,96.3671875,0.13925541941564562,0.9535104364326376,0.27069133398247325,0.35168473303999015,0.48249681827517704,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream16,1,18.39162729099409,nan,nan,nan,0,0,760,10.04,7.069515,0.435301424655335,nan,91.24609375,0.1399157697707066,0.9534662867996201,0.26216742375081115,0.33556020635175227,0.4635384590647387,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream16,1,31.17476043469111,nan,nan,nan,0,0,736,10.03,5.186141,0.25696391875121727,nan,78.16015625,0.19976415094339622,0.9516129032258065,0.3471153846153846,0.5627102631145084,0.7579234983022293,proxy
nginx,stream16,1,9.8879687300405,nan,nan,nan,0,0,793,10.06,6.656875,0.8088578126481994,nan,106.50390625,0.07914691943127962,0.9562737642585551,0.2852950766221063,0.1853321555368441,0.4710581767296116,proxy
haproxy,stream16,1,9.06324421500613,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,6.360863,0.8822353120157729,nan,43.74609375,0.08736942070275404,0.949667616334283,0.3759239704329461,0.18528769253357383,0.6447168750791342,proxy
direct,stream16,1,150.5436199716137,nan,nan,nan,0,0,2979,8.73,0.0,0.04636292994657669,nan,0.0,0.9280095351609058,0.8643564356435643,0.9206500956022945,3.132650750865739,2.3573073422163286,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,1,34.421534596346625,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,5.279381,0.2326204958142834,nan,9.14453125,0.28669201520912546,0.999001996007984,0.262532981530343,0.7363497102351947,0.5701253817662152,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,1,5.68308757694169,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.98,6.1640939999999995,1.404718423398181,nan,3.4765625,0.23745473357475427,0.998,0.06478405315614617,0.4556058002831393,0.10783116416423337,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,1,18.76186496047368,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,6.9654750000000005,0.426351778259922,nan,8.29296875,0.21130346232179226,0.999000999000999,0.16032064128256512,0.47446544493197773,0.3234040436283094,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream1-down,1,19.407222444299062,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,6.874936,0.41258685397600503,nan,8.10546875,0.2106789079487799,0.9515209125475285,0.1537488136665612,0.5109912024594101,0.30616434104576695,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream1-down,1,30.315632395779144,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,5.31313,0.26386141615423453,nan,11.015625,0.2855336368234699,0.9970089730807578,0.26199868507560814,0.7239105366514909,0.5307853186414291,proxy
nginx,stream1-down,1,8.99227992603171,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,6.4409849999999995,0.8904488871792143,nan,33.703125,0.1990661096092406,0.9506172839506173,0.08106396453451552,0.43483866547690797,0.13787238607400534,proxy
haproxy,stream1-down,1,7.972846936017637,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.98,6.4551240000000005,1.0012934447861737,nan,31.41015625,0.1769738450256661,0.9477682811016145,0.08895899053627761,0.4100967688119522,0.14928029456271036,proxy
direct,stream1-down,1,43.03125206765854,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,5.99,0.0,0.11135061313932085,nan,0.0,0.2553462321792261,0.6233090530697191,0.35671342685370744,0.6913574830367858,0.7337909946328378,none
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,1,0.1543503872,15382.41,3.97,8.24,0,0,0,10.1,7.841647,52.34842715056046,65.00611443650641,5.45703125,0.16579819990525818,0.9600760456273765,0.24175126903553298,0.3548422914975592,0.20343066587099787,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,1,0.15778971647999998,15732.7,4.15,7.16,0,0,0,10.02,7.39028,50.801789741576954,63.65946632782719,5.3125,0.1624762808349146,0.9515669515669516,0.2529467983434215,0.3576936548081277,0.23861608017200606,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,1,0.06132072448,6115.4,10.37,11.47,0,0,0,4.43,3.1102,57.79449003665783,72.32534979020751,9.6328125,0.06727099236641221,0.4179245283018868,0.10871632329635499,0.1512653710931258,0.08365170503307336,none
3proxy-devel,http-ka-1k,1,0.18186502144,18127.79,3.38,6.93,0,0,0,10.1,7.545032,44.42855440822474,55.164126932109895,9.64453125,0.17972459639126306,0.9600760456273765,0.27223461906279883,0.3957398792392991,0.2129571928034147,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-1k,1,0.13136560128,13091.9,4.44,12.45,0,0,0,10.07,7.858653,61.32503426699194,76.16382407442423,9.6328125,0.13705463182897862,0.959047619047619,0.20592923175007968,0.29398122075887145,0.1644634519513459,proxy
nginx,http-ka-1k,1,0.37681627136,36852.74,1.7,2.38,0,0,0,10.09,6.851237,21.421580259436915,27.108352811584858,33.3046875,0.22628951747088186,0.9600380589914367,0.42213883677298314,0.5698967203608523,0.32218882343684097,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1k,1,0.38428213248000004,38308.04,1.58,2.52,0,0,0,10.11,6.98455,21.047036321473886,26.130985766237526,35.27734375,0.22018129770992367,0.9610266159695817,0.3912231559290383,0.5708629736448012,0.3803347283370004,proxy
direct,http-ka-1k,1,1.2993114931199998,127083.66,0.446,0.9,0,0,0,8.05,0.0,4.956471203480091,6.271780803987762,0.0,0.5751699823721984,0.7884427032321254,0.9597336715282181,1.6598135341106777,0.8250448349215003,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,1,26.6287972352,3170.38,4.82,10.1,0,0,0,10.01,6.1380669999999995,0.30072706360970775,315.44448996312985,14.65234375,0.47986814221803625,0.9524262607040913,0.22940627914205783,1.611560807138693,0.15495728739800543,client
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,1,5.84509816832,696.55,22.4,50.84,0,0,0,10.0,6.226949,1.3686682019062415,1434.5144168698896,14.84375,0.2573266619013581,0.9505703422053232,0.06021437578814628,0.5603873643301619,0.047520125478480744,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,1,12.4554051584,1488.76,10.67,11.65,0,0,0,7.89,5.007377,0.5067679388769741,529.1040772532189,14.453125,0.24579682690030782,0.7353215284249767,0.11694809255784866,0.7601212220516859,0.07890382086512121,none
3proxy-devel,http-ka-1m,1,17.95296329728,2135.69,7.15,15.42,0,0,0,10.02,6.958351,0.4465001051505787,468.5527238718728,16.7734375,0.3585394581861013,0.9524714828897338,0.14647887323943662,1.1235757517264,0.12169227662114614,client
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-1m,1,23.88001816576,2841.95,5.32,12.15,0,0,0,10.02,6.296048,0.3356781366060106,352.0607146621693,18.421875,0.4209658421672556,0.9524714828897338,0.19906396255850234,1.3956319115522724,0.15210879832264515,client
nginx,http-ka-1m,1,5.697961984,678.94,23.17,31.9,0,0,0,10.01,6.2512799999999995,1.4054147820723684,1472.7085478887745,45.2265625,0.24433849821215733,0.9524262607040913,0.05767412543334384,0.537569986659097,0.03613231195441436,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1m,1,7.8168404787200005,932.13,19.22,25.69,0,0,0,10.08,5.341355,1.0316188518817608,1070.7456978967496,45.265625,0.3439797211660329,0.9590865842055185,0.06424050632911392,0.8458070930285073,0.04468246285480473,proxy
direct,http-ka-1m,1,65.11170420736,7759.81,1.35,2.54,0,0,0,5.78,0.0,0.0710164179588056,74.36474750723706,0.0,0.9477434679334917,0.5611650485436893,0.5395436073773054,3.565522936440097,0.3801393834013302,client
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,1,3.9781295718400003,9668.41,47.93,107.82,0,249,0,10.46,7.426947,2.103501117518794,107.46943388472208,90.640625,0.19607379375591297,0.9942965779467681,0.22061596480201132,0.4671315845709273,0.14356348171893302,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,1,2.88953991168,7022.56,75.15,168.82,0,260,0,10.39,6.890688,2.8765825197297037,147.04841700043875,184.97265625,0.2051948051948052,0.9885823025689819,0.1771356783919598,0.4109788110193551,0.11309148962381269,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,1,4.24404844544,10314.75,37.17,79.09,0,213,0,10.5,7.425437,1.9792422513520895,101.22238075039525,136.828125,0.18817966903073285,0.9962049335863378,0.23074504872681548,0.484267061635251,0.15109501793648356,proxy
3proxy-devel,http-ka-50k-2000,1,4.28968247296,10425.55,43.96,89.49,0,290,0,10.47,7.431873,1.9525920747743197,99.65069907773135,154.01953125,0.19166074389954987,0.9961941008563273,0.23486986516149264,0.49093727956987104,0.14736809129390788,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-50k-2000,1,3.7090230271999998,9014.32,44.25,99.94,0,227,0,10.49,7.671449,2.262590428384386,115.61139582300105,151.26953125,0.16959619952494062,0.9962013295346629,0.20578071002199183,0.4262453302210737,0.1283609164204057,proxy
nginx,http-ka-50k-2000,1,3.8542298316799997,9362.93,114.16,140.83,0,148,0,10.16,6.996789000000001,2.1088519250179565,107.82128833704765,112.546875,0.20461502236873086,0.9676190476190476,0.17531645569620252,0.4423896322732737,0.11408052048570191,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-50k-2000,1,2.92519149568,7083.85,267.2,699.76,0,0,0,10.22,6.18439,2.795030688443657,143.2737060505804,181.3828125,0.24078039495598383,0.9714828897338403,0.15698587127158556,0.4975794705248003,0.09412579090413156,proxy
direct,http-ka-50k-2000,1,32.12635537408,77949.47,22.83,253.1,0,0,0,8.68,0.0,0.21614652266476883,11.028187946749608,0.0,0.8535534816941852,0.8732394366197183,0.9489698890649763,2.7479492355354154,0.7406260418585973,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,1,0.04722786304,4635.03,13.53,22.13,0,0,0,10.01,7.054996,169.56092197560503,215.81648053124056,22.484375,0.14018470281790196,0.9515209125475285,0.15318471337579617,0.27684962035949096,0.0779553615801043,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,1,0.04840226816,4752.74,13.05,21.72,0,0,0,10.02,6.926434,165.6120736636157,210.53958648512355,15.8828125,0.1408284023668639,0.9524714828897338,0.15801210576616756,0.28065207052631486,0.07985926045370434,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,1,0.0406847488,3994.83,15.24,26.67,0,0,0,10.0,7.331008,196.63387967139175,249.9687539057618,23.88671875,0.12150639507342492,0.9514747859181731,0.14584654407102093,0.24070421729799868,0.07035422611007631,proxy
3proxy-devel,http-close-1k,1,0.04857004032,4770.82,12.53,23.84,0,0,0,10.03,6.992661,165.20472182305159,210.0435583849891,58.0546875,0.13873788702434411,0.9543292102759277,0.157475294867708,0.27874189040152336,0.07795755793030464,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-close-1k,1,0.04437573632,4357.14,13.83,24.3,0,0,0,10.02,7.1140419999999995,180.6392561510515,229.69007885567578,42.3984375,0.13633136094674556,0.9524714828897338,0.15423675023801967,0.26923580671822467,0.07412890809039178,proxy
nginx,http-close-1k,1,0.13111394304,12877.89,4.72,6.45,0,0,0,9.99,5.414659,60.95461561675263,77.43765842163603,31.125,0.29959514170040485,0.9496197718631179,0.1822534312160868,0.6545699582024739,0.16352007152430625,proxy
haproxy,http-close-1k,1,0.15091105791999998,14821.45,4.0,6.14,0,0,0,10.04,5.688575,53.22340264990967,67.62536624793722,29.26953125,0.3219016083254494,0.952561669829222,0.19182891796999682,0.7296755721909792,0.1825184532448331,proxy
direct,http-close-1k,1,0.4957667328,48677.01,0.771,4.53,0,0,0,8.6,0.0,13.87749428273054,17.492225112733323,0.0,0.7192467595989239,0.8695652173913043,0.87146529562982,1.9742833278308116,0.5751161170829755,client
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,2,5.2332908750732585,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.98,6.122593,1.525267576559996,nan,1.8125,0.04260890264222804,0.9486692015209125,0.29589490968801313,0.0884953417978474,0.473542543900258,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,2,19.341902517040023,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,6.742953999999999,0.41353749132749024,nan,5.359375,0.12767014406358668,0.998003992015968,0.2851763094830537,0.29972885580120884,0.5341388304202673,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream1,2,20.304971867303262,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.02,6.725144,0.3946931280687556,nan,5.8828125,0.12396694214876033,0.9515669515669516,0.2688939344794032,0.3045047155583558,0.49449600638530344,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream1,2,31.048725596793666,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.98,5.2500789999999995,0.2571005538398097,nan,7.94140625,0.1964729259811227,0.998998998998999,0.3573859768550034,0.48747074787814915,0.7007486845439365,proxy
nginx,stream1,2,9.764799238472945,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.02,6.635033,0.820312185628863,nan,36.8359375,0.06830080913850547,0.9515669515669516,0.27189242374549033,0.15796012252227382,0.48308451627315624,proxy
haproxy,stream1,2,9.25175358380877,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,6.426913000000001,0.8654047599697726,nan,29.515625,0.07548065511511987,0.9506172839506173,0.27123647097408987,0.16651177811617382,0.4715793459434357,proxy
direct,stream1,2,44.86820902742214,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,6.4,0.0,0.11409506729600898,nan,0.0,0.27506876719179796,0.6708595387840671,0.34313055365686945,0.7173018870274938,0.7447722624832959,none
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1,2,30.314863444991524,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.98,5.659764,0.26327450882190734,nan,10.125,0.176109537299339,0.9495718363463368,0.34419354838709676,0.4786358136310057,0.7151016072164642,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,2,5.584721557635198,nan,nan,nan,0,0,192,10.05,6.303241,1.4342308419046128,nan,92.55078125,0.04938271604938271,0.9535104364326376,0.2946194225721785,0.10930335475181782,0.4596076379008132,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,2,18.88211540354059,nan,nan,nan,0,0,830,10.05,7.102328,0.42420934577265995,nan,91.62109375,0.14465996728207525,0.9544159544159544,0.2680077871512005,0.3431706867766449,0.4749079929623601,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream16,2,18.933899805662048,nan,nan,nan,0,0,782,10.05,7.063448,0.42325861852591706,nan,91.12109375,0.14064697609001406,0.9535104364326376,0.2669477781381771,0.3431366081170437,0.47484368993419285,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream16,2,32.04857042305418,nan,nan,nan,0,0,739,10.02,5.177363,0.24975915918702893,nan,90.00390625,0.20089601509078048,0.9515669515669516,0.3553559974342527,0.5732179897999251,0.7826352396066084,proxy
nginx,stream16,2,9.842346910241341,nan,nan,nan,0,0,735,10.07,6.6343890000000005,0.8134854137383131,nan,102.75,0.0755883052056097,0.956315289648623,0.2804560260586319,0.18060985937425528,0.46538880798689947,proxy
haproxy,stream16,2,9.34405922985948,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,6.374752,0.8567064441556639,nan,73.91015625,0.08592451934488488,0.9506172839506173,0.38666666666666666,0.17967752023981196,0.6621181680636408,proxy
direct,stream16,2,155.4265189491131,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1628,8.99,0.0,0.046253784447393496,nan,0.0,0.9818678589170392,0.9108409321175278,0.9660791486531427,3.2390959837193067,2.4937244359650834,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream16,2,28.58071441605949,nan,nan,nan,0,0,768,10.03,5.608255,0.2802623320701637,nan,86.23828125,0.18632075471698112,0.9516129032258065,0.338050820199421,0.5189085529627563,0.7283341465979575,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,2,5.538202205406668,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,6.147093,1.4443592691018894,nan,2.828125,0.23238341968911916,0.999000999000999,0.060132890365448506,0.44856270979307344,0.09783169922215046,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,2,18.766204715865502,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,6.793089,0.4262517337056116,nan,6.515625,0.20747520976353928,0.998003992015968,0.17022674991784423,0.46757087818658555,0.31350096864291566,proxy
3proxy-devel,stream1-down,2,16.947169569957758,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.99,6.718148,0.47153300193758585,nan,5.828125,0.19190633749045558,0.998001998001998,0.15262636273538158,0.43857089251787307,0.2884982736212551,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,stream1-down,2,32.06821899943276,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,9.99,5.256309,0.24919211586772827,nan,10.71875,0.27856420626895856,0.9970059880239521,0.2637290365011509,0.7383214412946932,0.5717778826855451,proxy
nginx,stream1-down,2,9.731295486532868,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,6.509569,0.8220001649787211,nan,32.0078125,0.2014887063655031,0.998003992015968,0.09314703925482369,0.45555368966541926,0.15872726169228166,proxy
haproxy,stream1-down,2,9.51980461846781,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,6.500072,0.8411004565938953,nan,31.67578125,0.21156812339331618,0.9980059820538385,0.0990691489361702,0.4645744810619603,0.17571034610865963,proxy
direct,stream1-down,2,43.08145136317145,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,6.01,0.0,0.11159080343833658,nan,0.0,0.25057471264367814,0.6253902185223725,0.35557038025350235,0.6853975344586273,0.7338633116744461,none
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,stream1-down,2,32.79585310487371,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,5.229983,0.24390725453885723,nan,9.10546875,0.2811630847029077,0.998003992015968,0.2751721876024926,0.737283758067936,0.5937444079458339,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,2,0.19310575616,19245.58,3.16,5.83,0,0,0,10.12,7.467772,41.925213214731755,52.064844397112765,5.328125,0.18834399431414356,0.9610636277302944,0.27850947638933504,0.41288227734956645,0.24244064661567213,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,2,0.06190792704,6167.93,10.28,11.29,0,0,0,4.41,3.031855,56.9878554925686,71.34421561807387,9.7734375,0.06806282722513089,0.4160377358490566,0.10178117048346055,0.14747456737509307,0.08747202217081224,none
3proxy-devel,http-ka-1k,2,0.17414750208000002,17360.46,3.59,6.16,0,0,0,10.11,7.5113199999999996,46.443387952154076,57.65808924171913,9.64453125,0.1690844233055886,0.9601139601139601,0.2596491228070175,0.37481763577097954,0.21103923831677388,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-1k,2,0.13874757631999998,13830.61,4.32,10.06,0,0,0,10.1,7.905252,58.23525148550862,72.30192136987085,9.77734375,0.14448940728398,0.9591642924976258,0.21398914084956883,0.31394659783486856,0.20249958826286457,proxy
nginx,http-ka-1k,2,0.37354471424,36534.88,1.67,2.59,0,0,0,10.11,6.817792,21.652026361704888,27.397854241247455,31.984375,0.23551847437425508,0.9610266159695817,0.425645872715816,0.591746976997383,0.3498530274178688,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1k,2,0.37463523328,37343.11,1.6,2.56,0,0,0,10.1,7.0220910000000005,21.567645758403774,26.77936980983996,32.0625,0.22820390662220105,0.9609895337773549,0.4024352169840774,0.5850687732766127,0.3241671225153865,proxy
direct,http-ka-1k,2,1.34393888768,131447.97,0.464,0.8280000000000001,0,0,0,8.27,0.0,4.92284289162954,6.229215548182267,0.0,0.5882798686537004,0.827,0.9594423320659062,1.7134239544062406,0.8396328062725547,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1k,2,0.14663286784000001,14614.1,4.07,8.41,0,0,0,10.07,7.836468999999999,54.939933445142664,68.22816800254755,5.46875,0.15499643959173987,0.959047619047619,0.22573435504469988,0.33298171555015793,0.18823815787075818,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,2,5.7926693683199995,690.24,22.59,50.97,0,0,0,10.01,6.263898,1.382436919979518,1449.0445859872611,14.0703125,0.25708164722685073,0.9515209125475285,0.05943724312361682,0.5565685981319265,0.049436068741999364,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,2,12.28360646656,1464.4,10.76,13.16,0,0,0,8.28,5.305255,0.5392553089381932,564.7251398172145,16.0859375,0.24982256919801277,0.7774647887323943,0.11619166927654244,0.7639679990621957,0.09127157422851138,none
3proxy-devel,http-ka-1m,2,18.4683593728,2200.14,6.99,14.63,0,0,0,10.03,6.945708000000001,0.43447281039038366,455.32958053386596,16.44921875,0.3606403013182674,0.9525166191832859,0.15324349733625822,1.125470054947697,0.13974994262108514,client
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-1m,2,25.08260900864,2993.0,5.07,11.01,0,0,0,10.02,6.269207000000001,0.3195839793714758,334.45709135818953,16.375,0.45086024039594624,0.9515669515669516,0.2076059850374065,1.5060664790437657,0.15585024003804937,client
nginx,http-ka-1m,2,5.770691215359999,687.66,22.14,33.24,0,0,0,10.0,6.2515019999999994,1.386315729163638,1453.0659691950013,44.62109375,0.248565965583174,0.9514747859181731,0.058341217281614635,0.5469670989643747,0.03612232881070914,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-1m,2,7.55914244096,897.6,19.52,26.08,0,0,0,10.09,5.342491,1.0678459974852474,1113.0722559293988,45.265625,0.35175751400916966,0.9582146248812915,0.07000946073793755,0.8571238353168774,0.049433855788615914,proxy
direct,http-ka-1m,2,68.2899800064,8135.22,1.36,2.52,0,0,0,6.22,0.0,0.07286574105796573,76.37712124561016,0.0,0.9457917261055635,0.6027131782945736,0.5558685446009389,3.5569066191599092,0.4276846374703534,client
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-1m,2,27.23009265664,3246.22,4.69,10.01,0,0,0,10.0,6.150595,0.2937926102887945,307.5787401574803,14.9140625,0.4767962308598351,0.9523809523809523,0.2260761845772685,1.60782723791093,0.15016149713022064,client
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,2,3.04607133696,7401.59,55.49,127.73,0,156,0,10.43,6.952964000000001,2.739266115916829,139.966182667275,186.984375,0.21029029974038235,0.9895635673624289,0.17494463777285668,0.42908503204486165,0.11313894277477532,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,2,4.24404844544,10314.79,44.85,83.59,0,340,0,10.48,7.356861,1.975472266111419,100.9643638185339,163.07421875,0.19290780141843972,0.9961977186311787,0.23137626262626262,0.4899881292691311,0.15401082853641726,proxy
3proxy-devel,http-ka-50k-2000,2,4.44545892352,10804.25,44.97,91.56,0,259,0,10.47,7.481303,1.8841699235335014,96.33078168703076,153.4453125,0.19966840360018948,0.9961941008563273,0.2383192223267482,0.5032929194218212,0.1597193318527747,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-ka-50k-2000,2,3.75155326976,9117.77,53.89,123.67,0,273,0,10.48,7.666092,2.234807664222865,114.1587329252086,160.36328125,0.17714014702395067,0.9961977186311787,0.21087366436203644,0.43956600531979256,0.12835740140699384,proxy
nginx,http-ka-50k-2000,2,3.7748736,9170.06,128.05,170.86,0,149,0,10.16,6.959331000000001,2.1531846788194446,110.05676155812644,117.90625,0.19673295454545456,0.9676190476190476,0.18250710451531418,0.4328918916871282,0.12265368734492328,proxy
haproxy,http-ka-50k-2000,2,3.1594853171199997,7574.99,250.12,655.86,0,0,0,10.12,5.9886479999999995,2.5624426725868865,132.74742572309307,178.28125,0.24488338886244645,0.9628924833491912,0.16421645292461684,0.5042265728118315,0.09697061395084475,proxy
direct,http-ka-50k-2000,2,35.30463117312,85685.01,21.27,36.67,0,0,0,8.62,0.0,0.19532848158602004,9.979369794693568,0.0,0.8780429594272077,0.8509378084896347,0.9493670886075949,2.881269048940997,0.7601708550679486,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-ka-50k-2000,2,3.7587674726399998,9135.22,60.3,138.02,0,213,0,10.47,7.323282,2.2283900403440096,113.84023224712138,89.19140625,0.19254365266635207,0.9952471482889734,0.21062558943728388,0.44430267293857023,0.1321569527241605,proxy
3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,2,0.049492787200000006,4857.78,12.72,22.24,0,0,0,10.02,6.936956,161.96299407441737,205.96517914037287,17.265625,0.14106211474632527,0.9524714828897338,0.16012759170653906,0.2816279185193257,0.08177031679065315,proxy
3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,2,0.04076863488,3999.48,15.26,26.26,0,0,0,10.01,7.335698,196.42551249437372,249.87518721917124,22.41015625,0.12088172552737615,0.9515209125475285,0.14326647564469913,0.240705565907949,0.07032923750437718,proxy
3proxy-devel,http-close-1k,2,0.04898947072,4813.56,12.47,22.45,0,0,0,10.03,7.012631,163.79029783484052,207.97909841164517,57.1015625,0.13994307400379508,0.9525166191832859,0.1618349792927684,0.2854371070108317,0.08176458934385525,proxy
3proxy-devel-s,http-close-1k,2,0.0457179136,4486.2,13.4,23.73,0,0,0,10.02,7.100395,175.33608532826835,223.09798944626277,43.3046875,0.13423616060822047,0.9524714828897338,0.15428571428571428,0.2702042939891719,0.07511191663704278,proxy
nginx,http-close-1k,2,0.13925089280000003,13675.06,4.51,6.4,0,0,0,10.02,5.443326000000001,57.56516054452183,73.18355780186391,31.19921875,0.3175355450236967,0.9515669515669516,0.1783644558918223,0.6915439272144824,0.1549395985775604,proxy
haproxy,http-close-1k,2,0.15376318464,15099.95,3.88,5.8,0,0,0,10.11,5.723803,52.600367369706426,66.29160437485247,31.42578125,0.32397048321828137,0.9610266159695817,0.1992950977250881,0.7411587259582854,0.1711375145721106,proxy
direct,http-close-1k,2,0.5313344307200001,52176.86,0.801,4.19,0,0,0,8.55,0.0,12.873248192727246,16.224493862207556,0.0,0.7426470588235294,0.8841778697001034,0.9006750241080038,2.0493023589890185,0.581545963141801,origin
3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY,http-close-1k,2,0.04479516672,4395.49,14.03,24.39,0,0,0,10.08,7.067226000000001,180.0194215238764,228.91402098378526,17.19921875,0.13733396584440227,0.9581749049429658,0.15014344915524386,0.27021049078751624,0.07510797345845058,proxy
1 proxy scenario rep gbit rate p50_ms p99_ms errors timeouts retrans prx_cpu_s prx_task_s cpu_s_per_gb cpu_us_per_req peak_mb cli_util prx_util srv_util cli_thread srv_thread bound
2 direct stream1 0 43.94218560876057 nan nan nan 0 0 0 6.14 0.0 0.11176599723683582 nan 0.0 0.2714785214785215 0.6375908618899273 0.34114848793747876 0.7093557466411603 0.7677126968039654 none
3 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 0 28.29906719758348 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.99 5.642289 0.2823608023087004 nan 8.28515625 0.18638613861386139 0.996011964107677 0.34114848793747876 0.4875220793405474 0.7017296502032296 proxy
4 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 0 5.5253553114021905 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 6.226614 1.4476205398649034 nan 3.0234375 0.051818634778276036 0.999000999000999 0.29378925331472433 0.10590895116421987 0.4492709035255843 proxy
5 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 0 19.14664078851784 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 6.844423 0.41773771497678447 nan 5.03515625 0.1300148588410104 0.999000999000999 0.2714236940935473 0.31270573943067576 0.4901693435525649 proxy
6 3proxy-devel stream1 0 19.8696182749667 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 7.011065 0.4029305056944686 nan 7.8046875 0.10659655831739961 0.9515209125475285 0.26653696498054474 0.2978079331340094 0.47533737667963033 proxy
7 3proxy-devel-s stream1 0 32.832108216195635 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 5.25863 0.24361752944078474 nan 7.15234375 0.17372775131611934 0.999000999000999 0.37533875338753386 0.507535555131982 0.7727085060025145 proxy
8 nginx stream1 0 9.562232619939449 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 6.469755 0.8363088264713298 nan 34.30078125 0.06774423579748039 0.9514747859181731 0.27742998352553544 0.15795959930948786 0.46692001711780395 proxy
9 haproxy stream1 0 9.72057688006905 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.02 6.535721 0.8242036096593605 nan 29.609375 0.0635260528194147 0.9515669515669516 0.26005888125613347 0.14178342556893786 0.4591503253841818 proxy
10 direct stream16 0 147.7220505652621 nan nan nan 0 0 3766 8.74 0.0 0.04732058850676409 nan 0.0 0.9378121878121878 0.8855116514690983 0.9720930232558139 3.0634424105815397 2.510424936668355 origin
11 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 0 27.99043137406809 nan nan nan 0 0 783 10.02 5.605625 0.28591396835589206 nan 71.03125 0.18067724366564053 0.9515669515669516 0.3380417335473515 0.5046938551122888 0.7208465723862956 proxy
12 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 0 5.732471205111505 nan nan nan 0 0 197 10.04 6.289962 1.397156791495668 nan 93.3125 0.04843304843304843 0.9534662867996201 0.2989859339221459 0.10929789097392564 0.46724437122251294 proxy
13 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 0 18.886082493858858 nan nan nan 0 0 818 10.05 7.086829 0.4244418214174509 nan 98.0 0.13839285714285715 0.95260663507109 0.262987012987013 0.3383729659173314 0.4698905401852417 proxy
14 3proxy-devel stream16 0 18.75490180600116 nan nan nan 0 0 806 10.03 7.100816999999999 0.42647019861696284 nan 97.57421875 0.1466261965911744 0.9534220532319392 0.2682452156989945 0.353601950334539 0.47673192496314026 proxy
15 3proxy-devel-s stream16 0 30.455126533025485 nan nan nan 0 0 755 10.02 5.1583939999999995 0.2626929332675569 nan 87.84765625 0.20339382512373322 0.9515669515669516 0.3482858058314643 0.5749151856694169 0.7593291404137741 proxy
16 nginx stream16 0 9.96210022136924 nan nan nan 0 0 634 10.1 6.678844 0.8035212542948832 nan 111.4765625 0.07841743662639185 0.9591642924976258 0.2879084967320261 0.1834119622066088 0.4690910571132587 proxy
17 haproxy stream16 0 9.197518509317366 nan nan nan 0 0 3 10.02 6.322018 0.8709473557445826 nan 59.1640625 0.08803986710963455 0.9506641366223909 0.3649737302977233 0.18629361152888832 0.6316235684873117 proxy
18 direct stream1-down 0 45.647288189692524 nan nan nan 0 0 0 6.19 0.0 0.10847239527586117 nan 0.0 0.27171152869476894 0.6447916666666667 0.3575717144763175 0.7333099099289225 0.7417750103981438 none
19 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 0 34.870015744513765 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.99 5.292173999999999 0.22916950215942986 nan 10.63671875 0.2690550613128156 0.9496197718631179 0.25235109717868337 0.7136899543083228 0.5505873541310307 proxy
20 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 0 5.602349221864972 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 6.135136 1.4278164710203243 nan 1.99609375 0.23190279214064116 0.998003992015968 0.06281156530408774 0.4386119914214682 0.10084248890934187 proxy
21 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 0 19.678813251012862 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 6.833243 0.40689128603143715 nan 7.9375 0.20449601160261058 0.9515209125475285 0.141994917407878 0.4852622577380805 0.2909466155722971 proxy
22 3proxy-devel stream1-down 0 20.287587429291236 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 6.877286 0.3946823184622709 nan 8.859375 0.21173469387755103 0.999001996007984 0.1775731667214732 0.4925085135378208 0.33840632309755886 proxy
23 3proxy-devel-s stream1-down 0 31.955023215450773 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.98 5.232906 0.24982481542978685 nan 11.48828125 0.26596000963623223 0.9477682811016145 0.23147561747941736 0.7288831597684343 0.5113277193991893 proxy
24 nginx stream1-down 0 9.79548777575188 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.99 6.544494 0.8157989806714065 nan 32.234375 0.21067487811136773 0.999 0.09574468085106383 0.4574657832607243 0.1686745348268016 proxy
25 haproxy stream1-down 0 9.319587948765866 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 6.52505 0.8591737833882246 nan 30.12109375 0.21124694376528116 0.9515209125475285 0.09274447949526814 0.4500690759527404 0.15784557865976825 proxy
26 direct http-ka-1k 0 1.22188464128 119514.52 0.49 0.8200000000000001 0 0 0 7.71 0.0 5.047939708562534 6.387627058684149 0.0 0.5640961442163245 0.750730282375852 0.9591125198098257 1.6139796321059274 0.8291503007549478 origin
27 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 0 0.142606336 14217.61 4.2 8.74 0 0 0 10.1 7.8545300000000005 56.659474092371326 70.3357312478673 5.3125 0.1492040864813495 0.9591642924976258 0.22826430603857098 0.3225315295098274 0.17208480681672234 proxy
28 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 0 0.20946354175999998 20876.06 2.94 5.91 0 0 0 10.1 7.4359470000000005 38.57473206128605 47.90044296053193 5.375 0.19053254437869824 0.9609895337773549 0.28996517885406775 0.41955115652675273 0.22437098434992847 proxy
29 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 0 0.06157238272 6141.27 10.34 11.36 0 0 0 4.47 3.14774 58.077986298854725 72.69356491193834 9.6953125 0.07090348589044344 0.42329545454545453 0.103207367418228 0.14557638541524176 0.09318412301266239 none
30 3proxy-devel http-ka-1k 0 0.19226689536000002 19169.41 3.16 5.9 0 0 0 10.1 7.510120000000001 42.02491533901887 52.16699636897045 9.88671875 0.18420430361787657 0.9600760456273765 0.27784810126582277 0.40053296910233444 0.27846989769837954 proxy
31 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-1k 0 0.15032385536 14984.94 4.11 8.55 0 0 0 10.0 7.84878 53.2184328351702 66.66177813627 9.6875 0.15639810426540285 0.949667616334283 0.23356510745891276 0.33585181945622733 0.1786828625382035 proxy
32 nginx http-ka-1k 0 0.37044092928 36230.03 1.72 2.39 0 0 0 10.02 6.753332 21.63907755976138 27.642675656513546 31.453125 0.23075100687040986 0.9515669515669516 0.426969791342261 0.5755808388889219 0.32324231089215627 proxy
33 haproxy http-ka-1k 0 0.35995516928 35876.98 1.65 2.79 0 0 0 10.1 7.017473000000001 22.447239794227745 27.873987498102636 29.55078125 0.22531884742560226 0.9600760456273765 0.3981366459627329 0.5622085505479247 0.31845939009516416 proxy
34 direct http-ka-1m 0 67.51688589312 8043.82 1.35 2.58 0 0 0 6.18 0.0 0.07322612609572082 76.67018175051176 0.0 0.9465685110425077 0.5982575024201355 0.5430899404575368 3.560523412785333 0.4551360718861913 client
35 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 0 24.99670966272 2979.22 5.03 12.1 0 0 0 10.0 6.173425 0.3200421218609891 335.1992759695639 16.78515625 0.44590780809031044 0.9523809523809523 0.20799500312304808 1.4870074439093754 0.15591340186519673 client
36 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 0 5.835954585600001 695.5 22.47 50.95 0 0 0 10.0 6.227775 1.3708125864686647 1436.7816091954023 14.21484375 0.2531615366261036 0.9514747859181731 0.05625790139064475 0.5526401143338306 0.04562272677057892 proxy
37 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 0 12.36950581248 1475.55 10.74 11.9 0 0 0 8.15 5.242551000000001 0.5271027071608438 551.5327874399404 9.34765625 0.2432049160954857 0.7703213610586012 0.11586508432229857 0.7430855753377406 0.07796468499366345 none
38 3proxy-devel http-ka-1m 0 18.29656068096 2175.51 7.03 14.86 0 0 0 10.02 6.95438 0.43811512665009844 459.84396512161544 16.9375 0.3576299083000235 0.9524714828897338 0.1453287197231834 1.114991713418537 0.10837593685332784 client
39 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-1m 0 23.45052143616 2790.01 5.36 13.66 0 0 0 10.01 6.273167 0.3414849440256755 358.3959899749373 17.57421875 0.4259346900141978 0.9524262607040913 0.19731920199501246 1.4203952920899983 0.16542876082448071 client
40 nginx http-ka-1m 0 6.0280537088 718.42 22.02 30.01 0 0 0 10.01 6.239152 1.3284553168976567 1392.21140472879 44.73828125 0.2618595825426945 0.9515209125475285 0.060825716987078476 0.5707924206056916 0.040878219423396464 proxy
41 haproxy http-ka-1m 0 6.72002998272 800.5 20.03 31.46 0 0 0 10.08 5.202046 1.1999946459667454 1246.7532467532467 45.22265625 0.31741643629052524 0.9590865842055185 0.06862745098039216 0.7667876855487537 0.04183266925588077 proxy
42 direct http-ka-50k-2000 0 35.991825940480005 87401.38 20.85 32.92 0 0 0 8.61 0.0 0.19137678681239303 9.758607635968799 0.0 0.8615125240847784 0.8482758620689655 0.9534957291996203 2.8137727978226663 0.7692009026679565 origin
43 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 0 3.8871970611199997 9447.4 59.62 121.52 0 281 0 10.47 7.33171 2.1547659838955173 110.16066412045075 91.94140625 0.19929577464788734 0.9961941008563273 0.2252027448533999 0.4481119733502381 0.1359548037023942 proxy
44 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 0 2.80498274304 6817.05 64.89 170.52 0 246 0 10.47 6.92724 2.9861146279004243 152.45722606479796 171.80078125 0.19711992445703494 0.9943019943019943 0.17001885606536768 0.39576669135250814 0.10457313967013684 proxy
45 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 0 4.13407379456 10047.51 47.31 95.57 0 325 0 10.48 7.348655999999999 2.0280237887945907 103.67102256427505 133.34375 0.18839896250884225 0.9971455756422455 0.2352205192367845 0.47094639884576445 0.1511659166447872 proxy
46 3proxy-devel http-ka-50k-2000 0 4.334813184 10535.29 36.58 89.02 0 217 0 10.48 7.494909000000001 1.9341087249032414 98.85020609513388 104.4765625 0.1919811320754717 0.9952516619183286 0.2352386934673367 0.48617878992348906 0.1502187969426634 proxy
47 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-50k-2000 0 3.69744674816 8986.28 56.49 131.1 0 278 0 10.49 7.663372 2.2696743378863267 115.96285651116516 163.875 0.18351440717997167 0.997148288973384 0.21916952856696847 0.43191933814893463 0.13690098735210118 proxy
48 nginx http-ka-50k-2000 0 3.5584475136 8644.47 127.17 159.61 0 137 0 10.2 6.9846140000000005 2.293134848501591 117.12694493885284 111.48046875 0.1927796130250118 0.9686609686609686 0.1699181875393329 0.4119689291215604 0.10648114028799606 proxy
49 haproxy http-ka-50k-2000 0 3.01134249984 7277.23 261.46 803.19 0 0 0 10.18 6.057987 2.704441623771693 138.83017169664652 177.1640625 0.24276908487434803 0.967680608365019 0.16573208722741434 0.49376391215017 0.09697167338018714 proxy
50 direct http-close-1k 0 0.53108277248 52147.64 0.733 3.79 0 0 0 8.55 0.0 12.879348294540259 16.233242262629176 0.0 0.7378545006165228 0.9038054968287527 0.8912415784408084 2.041091324801681 0.5730997647090921 client
51 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 0 0.04286578688 4205.68 14.45 27.55 0 0 0 10.03 7.027548 187.18891181124633 238.17439209726444 24.2578125 0.13195925136223643 0.9516129032258065 0.14860583016476553 0.2568869570846952 0.0741601460789961 proxy
52 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 0 0.042781900799999995 4198.03 14.4 26.5 0 0 0 9.99 6.893052 186.80796903722427 237.61952333380904 14.6015625 0.1328439497987213 0.9532442748091603 0.15257469802924348 0.26163964201916406 0.0770072155740437 proxy
53 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 0 0.04051697664 3981.6 15.33 26.5 0 0 0 10.02 7.319014 197.84299483210404 251.44291091593476 22.5859375 0.1254725897920605 0.9524714828897338 0.1512179689971528 0.24451500342681542 0.07130340729423489 proxy
54 3proxy-devel http-close-1k 0 0.048234496 4737.08 12.57 23.9 0 0 0 10.02 7.008174 166.18811565896738 211.0895761355018 53.35546875 0.14417613636363635 0.9533777354900095 0.16883116883116883 0.29112139474568055 0.08271276801194205 proxy
55 3proxy-devel-s http-close-1k 0 0.04286578688 4208.46 14.35 25.42 0 0 0 10.01 7.117795 186.81565376177224 237.55280269590392 34.671875 0.1333175467677007 0.9515209125475285 0.15182250396196514 0.2635367130382308 0.07225341515917486 proxy
56 nginx http-close-1k 0 0.1308622848 12847.5 4.6 6.91 0 0 0 10.01 5.414315 61.19410196940104 77.84249531467498 31.26171875 0.2969047619047619 0.9515209125475285 0.17742966751918157 0.6478938205044057 0.13689735065744207 proxy
57 haproxy http-close-1k 0 0.16097738752000001 15806.42 3.86 5.66 0 0 0 10.02 5.679621999999999 49.795813707090275 63.34675711386611 29.22265625 0.3452914798206278 0.9515669515669516 0.20858505564387916 0.7857354029966487 0.1882130006120697 proxy
58 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 1 29.197936831775145 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.99 5.64714 0.2736513633341382 nan 10.65625 0.17688846791380536 0.9496197718631179 0.3423772609819121 0.5023860496182423 0.7197181448896807 proxy
59 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 1 5.54073610574154 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 6.130356 1.4435121055096212 nan 2.44921875 0.05010686297791499 0.9505703422053232 0.29360852197070575 0.10466706550123972 0.44310229377669036 proxy
60 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 1 18.746271170960057 nan nan nan 0 0 1 10.0 6.923991 0.4266378787899969 nan 8.3515625 0.11147213196700825 0.9970089730807578 0.26810109289617484 0.2806287257999571 0.48901023992781184 proxy
61 3proxy-devel stream1 1 19.81979353775472 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.99 7.0106139999999995 0.40314001569442237 nan 10.01953125 0.12717852096090437 0.9514285714285714 0.2719869706840391 0.3254262212161135 0.49544393857855856 proxy
62 3proxy-devel-s stream1 1 31.449077260376534 nan nan nan 0 0 1 9.99 5.090237999999999 0.25408424631525656 nan 8.16015625 0.17983446200150488 0.996011964107677 0.37170830519918974 0.5165425469182663 0.7767505112411156 proxy
63 nginx stream1 1 9.75871712437566 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.96 6.438269 0.8162760444640786 nan 32.1171875 0.0738541914034671 0.9485714285714286 0.2553261225827598 0.1684169055869681 0.4430885623004122 proxy
64 haproxy stream1 1 9.705190165858776 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 6.665984999999999 0.8247415118717535 nan 33.25 0.06956315289648624 0.9515209125475285 0.2513911620294599 0.16841994688587877 0.451663677897488 proxy
65 direct stream1 1 44.389174005677766 nan nan nan 0 0 0 6.11 0.0 0.11010085402569145 nan 0.0 0.27168207948012996 0.63579604578564 0.341156462585034 0.7055619791558234 0.7569537921450805 none
66 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 1 28.313349968601848 nan nan nan 0 0 715 10.03 5.574904 0.28275288543033045 nan 79.04296875 0.17958412098298676 0.9534220532319392 0.33697047496790755 0.5009326678550153 0.7237895955738057 proxy
67 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 1 5.220472839007376 nan nan nan 0 0 218 10.04 6.353164 1.5318292389511048 nan 90.90234375 0.04395343311950582 0.9543726235741445 0.279445727482679 0.1007633566748517 0.43027320887726855 proxy
68 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 1 19.45533354602417 nan nan nan 0 0 800 10.05 7.085894000000001 0.41200968849744224 nan 96.3671875 0.13925541941564562 0.9535104364326376 0.27069133398247325 0.35168473303999015 0.48249681827517704 proxy
69 3proxy-devel stream16 1 18.39162729099409 nan nan nan 0 0 760 10.04 7.069515 0.435301424655335 nan 91.24609375 0.1399157697707066 0.9534662867996201 0.26216742375081115 0.33556020635175227 0.4635384590647387 proxy
70 3proxy-devel-s stream16 1 31.17476043469111 nan nan nan 0 0 736 10.03 5.186141 0.25696391875121727 nan 78.16015625 0.19976415094339622 0.9516129032258065 0.3471153846153846 0.5627102631145084 0.7579234983022293 proxy
71 nginx stream16 1 9.8879687300405 nan nan nan 0 0 793 10.06 6.656875 0.8088578126481994 nan 106.50390625 0.07914691943127962 0.9562737642585551 0.2852950766221063 0.1853321555368441 0.4710581767296116 proxy
72 haproxy stream16 1 9.06324421500613 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 6.360863 0.8822353120157729 nan 43.74609375 0.08736942070275404 0.949667616334283 0.3759239704329461 0.18528769253357383 0.6447168750791342 proxy
73 direct stream16 1 150.5436199716137 nan nan nan 0 0 2979 8.73 0.0 0.04636292994657669 nan 0.0 0.9280095351609058 0.8643564356435643 0.9206500956022945 3.132650750865739 2.3573073422163286 origin
74 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 1 34.421534596346625 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 5.279381 0.2326204958142834 nan 9.14453125 0.28669201520912546 0.999001996007984 0.262532981530343 0.7363497102351947 0.5701253817662152 proxy
75 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 1 5.68308757694169 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.98 6.1640939999999995 1.404718423398181 nan 3.4765625 0.23745473357475427 0.998 0.06478405315614617 0.4556058002831393 0.10783116416423337 proxy
76 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 1 18.76186496047368 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 6.9654750000000005 0.426351778259922 nan 8.29296875 0.21130346232179226 0.999000999000999 0.16032064128256512 0.47446544493197773 0.3234040436283094 proxy
77 3proxy-devel stream1-down 1 19.407222444299062 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 6.874936 0.41258685397600503 nan 8.10546875 0.2106789079487799 0.9515209125475285 0.1537488136665612 0.5109912024594101 0.30616434104576695 proxy
78 3proxy-devel-s stream1-down 1 30.315632395779144 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 5.31313 0.26386141615423453 nan 11.015625 0.2855336368234699 0.9970089730807578 0.26199868507560814 0.7239105366514909 0.5307853186414291 proxy
79 nginx stream1-down 1 8.99227992603171 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 6.4409849999999995 0.8904488871792143 nan 33.703125 0.1990661096092406 0.9506172839506173 0.08106396453451552 0.43483866547690797 0.13787238607400534 proxy
80 haproxy stream1-down 1 7.972846936017637 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.98 6.4551240000000005 1.0012934447861737 nan 31.41015625 0.1769738450256661 0.9477682811016145 0.08895899053627761 0.4100967688119522 0.14928029456271036 proxy
81 direct stream1-down 1 43.03125206765854 nan nan nan 0 0 0 5.99 0.0 0.11135061313932085 nan 0.0 0.2553462321792261 0.6233090530697191 0.35671342685370744 0.6913574830367858 0.7337909946328378 none
82 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 1 0.1543503872 15382.41 3.97 8.24 0 0 0 10.1 7.841647 52.34842715056046 65.00611443650641 5.45703125 0.16579819990525818 0.9600760456273765 0.24175126903553298 0.3548422914975592 0.20343066587099787 proxy
83 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 1 0.15778971647999998 15732.7 4.15 7.16 0 0 0 10.02 7.39028 50.801789741576954 63.65946632782719 5.3125 0.1624762808349146 0.9515669515669516 0.2529467983434215 0.3576936548081277 0.23861608017200606 proxy
84 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 1 0.06132072448 6115.4 10.37 11.47 0 0 0 4.43 3.1102 57.79449003665783 72.32534979020751 9.6328125 0.06727099236641221 0.4179245283018868 0.10871632329635499 0.1512653710931258 0.08365170503307336 none
85 3proxy-devel http-ka-1k 1 0.18186502144 18127.79 3.38 6.93 0 0 0 10.1 7.545032 44.42855440822474 55.164126932109895 9.64453125 0.17972459639126306 0.9600760456273765 0.27223461906279883 0.3957398792392991 0.2129571928034147 proxy
86 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-1k 1 0.13136560128 13091.9 4.44 12.45 0 0 0 10.07 7.858653 61.32503426699194 76.16382407442423 9.6328125 0.13705463182897862 0.959047619047619 0.20592923175007968 0.29398122075887145 0.1644634519513459 proxy
87 nginx http-ka-1k 1 0.37681627136 36852.74 1.7 2.38 0 0 0 10.09 6.851237 21.421580259436915 27.108352811584858 33.3046875 0.22628951747088186 0.9600380589914367 0.42213883677298314 0.5698967203608523 0.32218882343684097 proxy
88 haproxy http-ka-1k 1 0.38428213248000004 38308.04 1.58 2.52 0 0 0 10.11 6.98455 21.047036321473886 26.130985766237526 35.27734375 0.22018129770992367 0.9610266159695817 0.3912231559290383 0.5708629736448012 0.3803347283370004 proxy
89 direct http-ka-1k 1 1.2993114931199998 127083.66 0.446 0.9 0 0 0 8.05 0.0 4.956471203480091 6.271780803987762 0.0 0.5751699823721984 0.7884427032321254 0.9597336715282181 1.6598135341106777 0.8250448349215003 origin
90 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 1 26.6287972352 3170.38 4.82 10.1 0 0 0 10.01 6.1380669999999995 0.30072706360970775 315.44448996312985 14.65234375 0.47986814221803625 0.9524262607040913 0.22940627914205783 1.611560807138693 0.15495728739800543 client
91 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 1 5.84509816832 696.55 22.4 50.84 0 0 0 10.0 6.226949 1.3686682019062415 1434.5144168698896 14.84375 0.2573266619013581 0.9505703422053232 0.06021437578814628 0.5603873643301619 0.047520125478480744 proxy
92 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 1 12.4554051584 1488.76 10.67 11.65 0 0 0 7.89 5.007377 0.5067679388769741 529.1040772532189 14.453125 0.24579682690030782 0.7353215284249767 0.11694809255784866 0.7601212220516859 0.07890382086512121 none
93 3proxy-devel http-ka-1m 1 17.95296329728 2135.69 7.15 15.42 0 0 0 10.02 6.958351 0.4465001051505787 468.5527238718728 16.7734375 0.3585394581861013 0.9524714828897338 0.14647887323943662 1.1235757517264 0.12169227662114614 client
94 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-1m 1 23.88001816576 2841.95 5.32 12.15 0 0 0 10.02 6.296048 0.3356781366060106 352.0607146621693 18.421875 0.4209658421672556 0.9524714828897338 0.19906396255850234 1.3956319115522724 0.15210879832264515 client
95 nginx http-ka-1m 1 5.697961984 678.94 23.17 31.9 0 0 0 10.01 6.2512799999999995 1.4054147820723684 1472.7085478887745 45.2265625 0.24433849821215733 0.9524262607040913 0.05767412543334384 0.537569986659097 0.03613231195441436 proxy
96 haproxy http-ka-1m 1 7.8168404787200005 932.13 19.22 25.69 0 0 0 10.08 5.341355 1.0316188518817608 1070.7456978967496 45.265625 0.3439797211660329 0.9590865842055185 0.06424050632911392 0.8458070930285073 0.04468246285480473 proxy
97 direct http-ka-1m 1 65.11170420736 7759.81 1.35 2.54 0 0 0 5.78 0.0 0.0710164179588056 74.36474750723706 0.0 0.9477434679334917 0.5611650485436893 0.5395436073773054 3.565522936440097 0.3801393834013302 client
98 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 1 3.9781295718400003 9668.41 47.93 107.82 0 249 0 10.46 7.426947 2.103501117518794 107.46943388472208 90.640625 0.19607379375591297 0.9942965779467681 0.22061596480201132 0.4671315845709273 0.14356348171893302 proxy
99 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 1 2.88953991168 7022.56 75.15 168.82 0 260 0 10.39 6.890688 2.8765825197297037 147.04841700043875 184.97265625 0.2051948051948052 0.9885823025689819 0.1771356783919598 0.4109788110193551 0.11309148962381269 proxy
100 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 1 4.24404844544 10314.75 37.17 79.09 0 213 0 10.5 7.425437 1.9792422513520895 101.22238075039525 136.828125 0.18817966903073285 0.9962049335863378 0.23074504872681548 0.484267061635251 0.15109501793648356 proxy
101 3proxy-devel http-ka-50k-2000 1 4.28968247296 10425.55 43.96 89.49 0 290 0 10.47 7.431873 1.9525920747743197 99.65069907773135 154.01953125 0.19166074389954987 0.9961941008563273 0.23486986516149264 0.49093727956987104 0.14736809129390788 proxy
102 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-50k-2000 1 3.7090230271999998 9014.32 44.25 99.94 0 227 0 10.49 7.671449 2.262590428384386 115.61139582300105 151.26953125 0.16959619952494062 0.9962013295346629 0.20578071002199183 0.4262453302210737 0.1283609164204057 proxy
103 nginx http-ka-50k-2000 1 3.8542298316799997 9362.93 114.16 140.83 0 148 0 10.16 6.996789000000001 2.1088519250179565 107.82128833704765 112.546875 0.20461502236873086 0.9676190476190476 0.17531645569620252 0.4423896322732737 0.11408052048570191 proxy
104 haproxy http-ka-50k-2000 1 2.92519149568 7083.85 267.2 699.76 0 0 0 10.22 6.18439 2.795030688443657 143.2737060505804 181.3828125 0.24078039495598383 0.9714828897338403 0.15698587127158556 0.4975794705248003 0.09412579090413156 proxy
105 direct http-ka-50k-2000 1 32.12635537408 77949.47 22.83 253.1 0 0 0 8.68 0.0 0.21614652266476883 11.028187946749608 0.0 0.8535534816941852 0.8732394366197183 0.9489698890649763 2.7479492355354154 0.7406260418585973 origin
106 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 1 0.04722786304 4635.03 13.53 22.13 0 0 0 10.01 7.054996 169.56092197560503 215.81648053124056 22.484375 0.14018470281790196 0.9515209125475285 0.15318471337579617 0.27684962035949096 0.0779553615801043 proxy
107 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 1 0.04840226816 4752.74 13.05 21.72 0 0 0 10.02 6.926434 165.6120736636157 210.53958648512355 15.8828125 0.1408284023668639 0.9524714828897338 0.15801210576616756 0.28065207052631486 0.07985926045370434 proxy
108 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 1 0.0406847488 3994.83 15.24 26.67 0 0 0 10.0 7.331008 196.63387967139175 249.9687539057618 23.88671875 0.12150639507342492 0.9514747859181731 0.14584654407102093 0.24070421729799868 0.07035422611007631 proxy
109 3proxy-devel http-close-1k 1 0.04857004032 4770.82 12.53 23.84 0 0 0 10.03 6.992661 165.20472182305159 210.0435583849891 58.0546875 0.13873788702434411 0.9543292102759277 0.157475294867708 0.27874189040152336 0.07795755793030464 proxy
110 3proxy-devel-s http-close-1k 1 0.04437573632 4357.14 13.83 24.3 0 0 0 10.02 7.1140419999999995 180.6392561510515 229.69007885567578 42.3984375 0.13633136094674556 0.9524714828897338 0.15423675023801967 0.26923580671822467 0.07412890809039178 proxy
111 nginx http-close-1k 1 0.13111394304 12877.89 4.72 6.45 0 0 0 9.99 5.414659 60.95461561675263 77.43765842163603 31.125 0.29959514170040485 0.9496197718631179 0.1822534312160868 0.6545699582024739 0.16352007152430625 proxy
112 haproxy http-close-1k 1 0.15091105791999998 14821.45 4.0 6.14 0 0 0 10.04 5.688575 53.22340264990967 67.62536624793722 29.26953125 0.3219016083254494 0.952561669829222 0.19182891796999682 0.7296755721909792 0.1825184532448331 proxy
113 direct http-close-1k 1 0.4957667328 48677.01 0.771 4.53 0 0 0 8.6 0.0 13.87749428273054 17.492225112733323 0.0 0.7192467595989239 0.8695652173913043 0.87146529562982 1.9742833278308116 0.5751161170829755 client
114 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 2 5.2332908750732585 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.98 6.122593 1.525267576559996 nan 1.8125 0.04260890264222804 0.9486692015209125 0.29589490968801313 0.0884953417978474 0.473542543900258 proxy
115 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 2 19.341902517040023 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 6.742953999999999 0.41353749132749024 nan 5.359375 0.12767014406358668 0.998003992015968 0.2851763094830537 0.29972885580120884 0.5341388304202673 proxy
116 3proxy-devel stream1 2 20.304971867303262 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.02 6.725144 0.3946931280687556 nan 5.8828125 0.12396694214876033 0.9515669515669516 0.2688939344794032 0.3045047155583558 0.49449600638530344 proxy
117 3proxy-devel-s stream1 2 31.048725596793666 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.98 5.2500789999999995 0.2571005538398097 nan 7.94140625 0.1964729259811227 0.998998998998999 0.3573859768550034 0.48747074787814915 0.7007486845439365 proxy
118 nginx stream1 2 9.764799238472945 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.02 6.635033 0.820312185628863 nan 36.8359375 0.06830080913850547 0.9515669515669516 0.27189242374549033 0.15796012252227382 0.48308451627315624 proxy
119 haproxy stream1 2 9.25175358380877 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 6.426913000000001 0.8654047599697726 nan 29.515625 0.07548065511511987 0.9506172839506173 0.27123647097408987 0.16651177811617382 0.4715793459434357 proxy
120 direct stream1 2 44.86820902742214 nan nan nan 0 0 0 6.4 0.0 0.11409506729600898 nan 0.0 0.27506876719179796 0.6708595387840671 0.34313055365686945 0.7173018870274938 0.7447722624832959 none
121 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1 2 30.314863444991524 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.98 5.659764 0.26327450882190734 nan 10.125 0.176109537299339 0.9495718363463368 0.34419354838709676 0.4786358136310057 0.7151016072164642 proxy
122 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 2 5.584721557635198 nan nan nan 0 0 192 10.05 6.303241 1.4342308419046128 nan 92.55078125 0.04938271604938271 0.9535104364326376 0.2946194225721785 0.10930335475181782 0.4596076379008132 proxy
123 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 2 18.88211540354059 nan nan nan 0 0 830 10.05 7.102328 0.42420934577265995 nan 91.62109375 0.14465996728207525 0.9544159544159544 0.2680077871512005 0.3431706867766449 0.4749079929623601 proxy
124 3proxy-devel stream16 2 18.933899805662048 nan nan nan 0 0 782 10.05 7.063448 0.42325861852591706 nan 91.12109375 0.14064697609001406 0.9535104364326376 0.2669477781381771 0.3431366081170437 0.47484368993419285 proxy
125 3proxy-devel-s stream16 2 32.04857042305418 nan nan nan 0 0 739 10.02 5.177363 0.24975915918702893 nan 90.00390625 0.20089601509078048 0.9515669515669516 0.3553559974342527 0.5732179897999251 0.7826352396066084 proxy
126 nginx stream16 2 9.842346910241341 nan nan nan 0 0 735 10.07 6.6343890000000005 0.8134854137383131 nan 102.75 0.0755883052056097 0.956315289648623 0.2804560260586319 0.18060985937425528 0.46538880798689947 proxy
127 haproxy stream16 2 9.34405922985948 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 6.374752 0.8567064441556639 nan 73.91015625 0.08592451934488488 0.9506172839506173 0.38666666666666666 0.17967752023981196 0.6621181680636408 proxy
128 direct stream16 2 155.4265189491131 nan nan nan 0 0 1628 8.99 0.0 0.046253784447393496 nan 0.0 0.9818678589170392 0.9108409321175278 0.9660791486531427 3.2390959837193067 2.4937244359650834 origin
129 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream16 2 28.58071441605949 nan nan nan 0 0 768 10.03 5.608255 0.2802623320701637 nan 86.23828125 0.18632075471698112 0.9516129032258065 0.338050820199421 0.5189085529627563 0.7283341465979575 proxy
130 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 2 5.538202205406668 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 6.147093 1.4443592691018894 nan 2.828125 0.23238341968911916 0.999000999000999 0.060132890365448506 0.44856270979307344 0.09783169922215046 proxy
131 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 2 18.766204715865502 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 6.793089 0.4262517337056116 nan 6.515625 0.20747520976353928 0.998003992015968 0.17022674991784423 0.46757087818658555 0.31350096864291566 proxy
132 3proxy-devel stream1-down 2 16.947169569957758 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.99 6.718148 0.47153300193758585 nan 5.828125 0.19190633749045558 0.998001998001998 0.15262636273538158 0.43857089251787307 0.2884982736212551 proxy
133 3proxy-devel-s stream1-down 2 32.06821899943276 nan nan nan 0 0 0 9.99 5.256309 0.24919211586772827 nan 10.71875 0.27856420626895856 0.9970059880239521 0.2637290365011509 0.7383214412946932 0.5717778826855451 proxy
134 nginx stream1-down 2 9.731295486532868 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 6.509569 0.8220001649787211 nan 32.0078125 0.2014887063655031 0.998003992015968 0.09314703925482369 0.45555368966541926 0.15872726169228166 proxy
135 haproxy stream1-down 2 9.51980461846781 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 6.500072 0.8411004565938953 nan 31.67578125 0.21156812339331618 0.9980059820538385 0.0990691489361702 0.4645744810619603 0.17571034610865963 proxy
136 direct stream1-down 2 43.08145136317145 nan nan nan 0 0 0 6.01 0.0 0.11159080343833658 nan 0.0 0.25057471264367814 0.6253902185223725 0.35557038025350235 0.6853975344586273 0.7338633116744461 none
137 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY stream1-down 2 32.79585310487371 nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 5.229983 0.24390725453885723 nan 9.10546875 0.2811630847029077 0.998003992015968 0.2751721876024926 0.737283758067936 0.5937444079458339 proxy
138 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 2 0.19310575616 19245.58 3.16 5.83 0 0 0 10.12 7.467772 41.925213214731755 52.064844397112765 5.328125 0.18834399431414356 0.9610636277302944 0.27850947638933504 0.41288227734956645 0.24244064661567213 proxy
139 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 2 0.06190792704 6167.93 10.28 11.29 0 0 0 4.41 3.031855 56.9878554925686 71.34421561807387 9.7734375 0.06806282722513089 0.4160377358490566 0.10178117048346055 0.14747456737509307 0.08747202217081224 none
140 3proxy-devel http-ka-1k 2 0.17414750208000002 17360.46 3.59 6.16 0 0 0 10.11 7.5113199999999996 46.443387952154076 57.65808924171913 9.64453125 0.1690844233055886 0.9601139601139601 0.2596491228070175 0.37481763577097954 0.21103923831677388 proxy
141 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-1k 2 0.13874757631999998 13830.61 4.32 10.06 0 0 0 10.1 7.905252 58.23525148550862 72.30192136987085 9.77734375 0.14448940728398 0.9591642924976258 0.21398914084956883 0.31394659783486856 0.20249958826286457 proxy
142 nginx http-ka-1k 2 0.37354471424 36534.88 1.67 2.59 0 0 0 10.11 6.817792 21.652026361704888 27.397854241247455 31.984375 0.23551847437425508 0.9610266159695817 0.425645872715816 0.591746976997383 0.3498530274178688 proxy
143 haproxy http-ka-1k 2 0.37463523328 37343.11 1.6 2.56 0 0 0 10.1 7.0220910000000005 21.567645758403774 26.77936980983996 32.0625 0.22820390662220105 0.9609895337773549 0.4024352169840774 0.5850687732766127 0.3241671225153865 proxy
144 direct http-ka-1k 2 1.34393888768 131447.97 0.464 0.8280000000000001 0 0 0 8.27 0.0 4.92284289162954 6.229215548182267 0.0 0.5882798686537004 0.827 0.9594423320659062 1.7134239544062406 0.8396328062725547 origin
145 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1k 2 0.14663286784000001 14614.1 4.07 8.41 0 0 0 10.07 7.836468999999999 54.939933445142664 68.22816800254755 5.46875 0.15499643959173987 0.959047619047619 0.22573435504469988 0.33298171555015793 0.18823815787075818 proxy
146 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 2 5.7926693683199995 690.24 22.59 50.97 0 0 0 10.01 6.263898 1.382436919979518 1449.0445859872611 14.0703125 0.25708164722685073 0.9515209125475285 0.05943724312361682 0.5565685981319265 0.049436068741999364 proxy
147 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 2 12.28360646656 1464.4 10.76 13.16 0 0 0 8.28 5.305255 0.5392553089381932 564.7251398172145 16.0859375 0.24982256919801277 0.7774647887323943 0.11619166927654244 0.7639679990621957 0.09127157422851138 none
148 3proxy-devel http-ka-1m 2 18.4683593728 2200.14 6.99 14.63 0 0 0 10.03 6.945708000000001 0.43447281039038366 455.32958053386596 16.44921875 0.3606403013182674 0.9525166191832859 0.15324349733625822 1.125470054947697 0.13974994262108514 client
149 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-1m 2 25.08260900864 2993.0 5.07 11.01 0 0 0 10.02 6.269207000000001 0.3195839793714758 334.45709135818953 16.375 0.45086024039594624 0.9515669515669516 0.2076059850374065 1.5060664790437657 0.15585024003804937 client
150 nginx http-ka-1m 2 5.770691215359999 687.66 22.14 33.24 0 0 0 10.0 6.2515019999999994 1.386315729163638 1453.0659691950013 44.62109375 0.248565965583174 0.9514747859181731 0.058341217281614635 0.5469670989643747 0.03612232881070914 proxy
151 haproxy http-ka-1m 2 7.55914244096 897.6 19.52 26.08 0 0 0 10.09 5.342491 1.0678459974852474 1113.0722559293988 45.265625 0.35175751400916966 0.9582146248812915 0.07000946073793755 0.8571238353168774 0.049433855788615914 proxy
152 direct http-ka-1m 2 68.2899800064 8135.22 1.36 2.52 0 0 0 6.22 0.0 0.07286574105796573 76.37712124561016 0.0 0.9457917261055635 0.6027131782945736 0.5558685446009389 3.5569066191599092 0.4276846374703534 client
153 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-1m 2 27.23009265664 3246.22 4.69 10.01 0 0 0 10.0 6.150595 0.2937926102887945 307.5787401574803 14.9140625 0.4767962308598351 0.9523809523809523 0.2260761845772685 1.60782723791093 0.15016149713022064 client
154 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 2 3.04607133696 7401.59 55.49 127.73 0 156 0 10.43 6.952964000000001 2.739266115916829 139.966182667275 186.984375 0.21029029974038235 0.9895635673624289 0.17494463777285668 0.42908503204486165 0.11313894277477532 proxy
155 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 2 4.24404844544 10314.79 44.85 83.59 0 340 0 10.48 7.356861 1.975472266111419 100.9643638185339 163.07421875 0.19290780141843972 0.9961977186311787 0.23137626262626262 0.4899881292691311 0.15401082853641726 proxy
156 3proxy-devel http-ka-50k-2000 2 4.44545892352 10804.25 44.97 91.56 0 259 0 10.47 7.481303 1.8841699235335014 96.33078168703076 153.4453125 0.19966840360018948 0.9961941008563273 0.2383192223267482 0.5032929194218212 0.1597193318527747 proxy
157 3proxy-devel-s http-ka-50k-2000 2 3.75155326976 9117.77 53.89 123.67 0 273 0 10.48 7.666092 2.234807664222865 114.1587329252086 160.36328125 0.17714014702395067 0.9961977186311787 0.21087366436203644 0.43956600531979256 0.12835740140699384 proxy
158 nginx http-ka-50k-2000 2 3.7748736 9170.06 128.05 170.86 0 149 0 10.16 6.959331000000001 2.1531846788194446 110.05676155812644 117.90625 0.19673295454545456 0.9676190476190476 0.18250710451531418 0.4328918916871282 0.12265368734492328 proxy
159 haproxy http-ka-50k-2000 2 3.1594853171199997 7574.99 250.12 655.86 0 0 0 10.12 5.9886479999999995 2.5624426725868865 132.74742572309307 178.28125 0.24488338886244645 0.9628924833491912 0.16421645292461684 0.5042265728118315 0.09697061395084475 proxy
160 direct http-ka-50k-2000 2 35.30463117312 85685.01 21.27 36.67 0 0 0 8.62 0.0 0.19532848158602004 9.979369794693568 0.0 0.8780429594272077 0.8509378084896347 0.9493670886075949 2.881269048940997 0.7601708550679486 origin
161 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-ka-50k-2000 2 3.7587674726399998 9135.22 60.3 138.02 0 213 0 10.47 7.323282 2.2283900403440096 113.84023224712138 89.19140625 0.19254365266635207 0.9952471482889734 0.21062558943728388 0.44430267293857023 0.1321569527241605 proxy
162 3proxy-0.9.4-s0-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 2 0.049492787200000006 4857.78 12.72 22.24 0 0 0 10.02 6.936956 161.96299407441737 205.96517914037287 17.265625 0.14106211474632527 0.9524714828897338 0.16012759170653906 0.2816279185193257 0.08177031679065315 proxy
163 3proxy-1.0.1-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 2 0.04076863488 3999.48 15.26 26.26 0 0 0 10.01 7.335698 196.42551249437372 249.87518721917124 22.41015625 0.12088172552737615 0.9515209125475285 0.14326647564469913 0.240705565907949 0.07032923750437718 proxy
164 3proxy-devel http-close-1k 2 0.04898947072 4813.56 12.47 22.45 0 0 0 10.03 7.012631 163.79029783484052 207.97909841164517 57.1015625 0.13994307400379508 0.9525166191832859 0.1618349792927684 0.2854371070108317 0.08176458934385525 proxy
165 3proxy-devel-s http-close-1k 2 0.0457179136 4486.2 13.4 23.73 0 0 0 10.02 7.100395 175.33608532826835 223.09798944626277 43.3046875 0.13423616060822047 0.9524714828897338 0.15428571428571428 0.2702042939891719 0.07511191663704278 proxy
166 nginx http-close-1k 2 0.13925089280000003 13675.06 4.51 6.4 0 0 0 10.02 5.443326000000001 57.56516054452183 73.18355780186391 31.19921875 0.3175355450236967 0.9515669515669516 0.1783644558918223 0.6915439272144824 0.1549395985775604 proxy
167 haproxy http-close-1k 2 0.15376318464 15099.95 3.88 5.8 0 0 0 10.11 5.723803 52.600367369706426 66.29160437485247 31.42578125 0.32397048321828137 0.9610266159695817 0.1992950977250881 0.7411587259582854 0.1711375145721106 proxy
168 direct http-close-1k 2 0.5313344307200001 52176.86 0.801 4.19 0 0 0 8.55 0.0 12.873248192727246 16.224493862207556 0.0 0.7426470588235294 0.8841778697001034 0.9006750241080038 2.0493023589890185 0.581545963141801 origin
169 3proxy-0.9.4-ocTCP_NODELAY-osTCP_NODELAY http-close-1k 2 0.04479516672 4395.49 14.03 24.39 0 0 0 10.08 7.067226000000001 180.0194215238764 228.91402098378526 17.19921875 0.13733396584440227 0.9581749049429658 0.15014344915524386 0.27021049078751624 0.07510797345845058 proxy

169
bench/report.py Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,169 @@
#!/usr/bin/env python3
"""Markdown tables from a bench.py CSV: throughput, the proxy's CPU per unit
of work, and its peak memory, a scenario per row and a proxy per column, each
cell the median of the repetitions.
Proxies given with --splice (those using splice()) form a group of their own
after the others, the two separated by a ‖ column. The best proxy of each
group in each row is in bold, and so is any other of the group whose
repetitions overlap the best one's (the range of the repetitions stands for
the error): the measurement cannot tell them apart. "direct", no proxy, comes
first and is not ranked.
A value marked ‡ was limited by the client or the origin rather than by the
proxy (most of its repetitions were), so the proxy can do at least that much.
bench/report.py bench/results/20261011-155353.csv > tables.md
Several CSVs make one set of tables: a proxy is taken from the first file it
appears in, so a later run can add proxies, and a proxy it repeats (run again
to see how much the conditions moved between the runs) is left out.
--label old=new renames a column, e.g. --label 3proxy-devel-s="devel, splice".
"""
import argparse
import csv
import statistics
STREAM = ("stream1", "stream1-down", "stream16")
def values(rows, key):
xs = []
for r in rows:
try:
x = float(r[key])
except (KeyError, ValueError):
continue
if x == x:
xs.append(x)
return xs
def median(rows, key):
xs = values(rows, key)
return statistics.median(xs) if xs else None
def winners(by, scenario, proxies, key, higher):
"""Proxies tied for best: the best median, and those whose range of
repetitions overlaps the best one's."""
ranges = {}
for p in proxies:
if p == "direct":
continue
xs = values(by.get((scenario, p), []), key)
if xs:
ranges[p] = (min(xs), statistics.median(xs), max(xs))
if not ranges:
return set()
if higher:
best = max(ranges, key=lambda p: ranges[p][1])
return {p for p, r in ranges.items() if r[2] >= ranges[best][0]}
best = min(ranges, key=lambda p: ranges[p][1])
return {p for p, r in ranges.items() if r[0] <= ranges[best][2]}
def fmt(x, digits):
if x is None:
return "–"
return f"{x:,.{digits}f}"
def table(title, scenarios, groups, labels, cell, best):
"""groups: lists of proxies, each ranked on its own, shown in order with
a separator column between them."""
head, rule = [], []
for i, g in enumerate(groups):
if i:
head.append("‖")
rule.append(":-:")
head += [labels.get(p, p) for p in g]
rule += ["---:"] * len(g)
out = [f"**{title}**", "", "| scenario | " + " | ".join(head) + " |",
"|---|" + "|".join(rule) + "|"]
for s in scenarios:
cells = []
for i, g in enumerate(groups):
if i:
cells.append("‖")
win = best(s, g)
cells += [f"**{cell(s, p)}**" if p in win else cell(s, p) for p in g]
out.append(f"| {s} | " + " | ".join(cells) + " |")
return "\n".join(out) + "\n"
def main():
ap = argparse.ArgumentParser()
ap.add_argument("csv", nargs="+")
ap.add_argument("--label", action="append", default=[], help="old=new")
ap.add_argument("--title", default="")
ap.add_argument("--splice", action="append", default=[],
help="a proxy (as named in the CSV) using splice(); repeat")
args = ap.parse_args()
labels = dict(l.split("=", 1) for l in args.label)
rows, seen = [], set()
for path in args.csv:
new = list(csv.DictReader(open(path)))
rows += [r for r in new if r["proxy"] not in seen]
seen |= {r["proxy"] for r in new}
proxies, scenarios = [], []
for r in rows:
if r["proxy"] not in proxies:
proxies.append(r["proxy"])
if r["scenario"] not in scenarios:
scenarios.append(r["scenario"])
by = {}
for r in rows:
by.setdefault((r["scenario"], r["proxy"]), []).append(r)
def limited(s, p):
if p == "direct":
return ""
bounds = [r.get("bound", "") for r in by.get((s, p), [])]
other = sum(b in ("client", "origin") for b in bounds)
return " ‡" if bounds and other * 2 > len(bounds) else ""
def throughput(s, p):
sel = by.get((s, p), [])
g = median(sel, "gbit")
if s in STREAM:
return fmt(g, 1) + limited(s, p)
rate = median(sel, "rate")
return f"{fmt(g, 2)} ({fmt(rate / 1000 if rate else None, 1)}k/s)" + limited(s, p)
def cpu(s, p):
sel = by.get((s, p), [])
if p == "direct":
return "–"
if s in STREAM or s in ("http-ka-1m", "http-ka-50k-2000"):
return fmt(median(sel, "cpu_s_per_gb"), 2) + " s/GB"
return fmt(median(sel, "cpu_us_per_req"), 0) + " µs/req"
def peak(s, p):
if p == "direct":
return "–"
return fmt(median(by.get((s, p), []), "peak_mb"), 0)
def cpukey(s):
return "cpu_s_per_gb" if s in STREAM or s in ("http-ka-1m", "http-ka-50k-2000") \
else "cpu_us_per_req"
plain = [p for p in proxies if p != "direct" and p not in args.splice]
spliced = [p for p in proxies if p in args.splice]
groups = [g for g in ([p for p in proxies if p == "direct"], plain, spliced) if g]
prefix = f"{args.title}: " if args.title else ""
print(table(prefix + "throughput, Gbit/s (thousands of requests per second for HTTP)",
scenarios, groups, labels, throughput,
lambda s, g: winners(by, s, g, "gbit", True)))
print(table(prefix + "proxy CPU time per gigabyte or per request",
scenarios, groups, labels, cpu,
lambda s, g: winners(by, s, g, cpukey(s), False)))
print(table(prefix + "proxy peak memory, MB", scenarios, groups, labels, peak,
lambda s, g: winners(by, s, g, "peak_mb", False)))
if __name__ == "__main__":
main()

4
doc/html/highload.html
View File

@ -669,8 +669,8 @@ tcppm -s 8080 192.168.1.1 80
-s0 turns it off explicitly. In builds without it (CMake option 3PROXY_USE_SPLICE=OFF, -s0 turns it off explicitly. In builds without it (CMake option 3PROXY_USE_SPLICE=OFF,
or -DWITHSPLICE removed from the Makefile) -s is accepted and ignored. or -DWITHSPLICE removed from the Makefile) -s is accepted and ignored.
<p>splice() pays off when most of the traffic is large transfers: in the <p>splice() pays off when most of the traffic is large transfers: in the
<a href="https://github.com/3proxy/3proxy/tree/master/bench">benchmarks</a> it moved <a href="https://github.com/3proxy/3proxy/blob/master/bench/RESULTS.md">benchmarks</a> it moved
1.4 to 1.7 times more data than the read/write path at about half the CPU per gigabyte. 1.3 to 2.1 times more data than the read/write path at 40-55% less CPU per gigabyte.
It does not help small requests and short connections, which go slower with it, and It does not help small requests and short connections, which go slower with it, and
every spliced connection needs two more pipes (file descriptors) and more kernel every spliced connection needs two more pipes (file descriptors) and more kernel
buffer memory. Data filters are not applied to spliced data. buffer memory. Data filters are not applied to spliced data.