Bench: the four versions against every proxy, 30 October results

3proxy 0.9.9.2, 1.0.2, devel (c3702866) and the experimental head (5de7ae2)
against nginx (with and without proxy_half_close), haproxy (plain and
splice-auto), envoy, squid, tinyproxy and dante on the M4 and the Skylake
host: the plain suite and the mix over a shaped link (20 Mbit/s, 5 ms,
0.5% loss), three runs a cell, proxy memory capped at 6 GB (--prx-mem-mb,
new). dante re-measured on the SOCKS scenarios only; its mix behaviour
stays in its own smaller-pool table. RESULTS.md rebuilt around six uniform
tables: throughput, memory and errors, p75/p90/p99.
This commit is contained in:
Vladimir Dubrovin committed 2026-10-30 12:21:40 +03:00
1 parent 5de7ae2dac
commit bb52a5fb0e
16 files changed
+2172 -1195

No files matched your search

@@ -0,0 +1,37 @@
proxy,scenario,rep,gbit,rate,p50_ms,p75_ms,p90_ms,p99_ms,errors,timeouts,retrans,prx_cpu_s,prx_task_s,cpu_s_per_gb,cpu_us_per_req,peak_mb,cli_util,prx_util,srv_util,cli_thread,srv_thread,bound
3proxy-bp,socks-stream1-down,0,54.95798518703387,nan,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,9.993529,0.14569523951370048,nan,30.90625,0.08743658609370338,0.9506172839506173,0.1853555005305978,0.5069158833069751,0.47970922709920055,proxy
dante,socks-stream1-down,0,10.755941861630104,nan,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.014462,0.7444363790873445,nan,13.26171875,0.017312206572769953,0.9515209125475285,0.05566801619433198,0.23402890534835158,0.11497876234460526,proxy
3proxy-bp,socks-stream16,0,44.85364033390902,nan,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,4243,10.04,10.023199,0.1788190827216997,nan,108.609375,0.28963876270819816,0.952561669829222,0.364088947892466,0.4812483481390654,0.5946620905582705,proxy
dante,socks-stream16,0,15.811853329382707,nan,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1,10.03,10.025917,0.5072910594144856,nan,123.98046875,0.13795439151049899,0.9534220532319392,0.48177399756986633,0.1626791975615335,0.5275027490734411,proxy
3proxy-bp,socks-ka-1k,0,0.34384904192000004,33632.84,1.91,2.84,4.07,7.07,0,0,0,10.06,10.040764000000001,23.405619963520063,29.75987977718547,29.02734375,0.5341772151898734,0.9544592030360531,0.5673880964092474,1.0978000360669382,0.3334424809956902,client
dante,socks-ka-1k,0,0.28059893760000004,27446.17,1.23,4.13,4.25,4.46,0,0,0,10.08,10.093356,28.73852648542601,36.443702072735555,42.5625,0.4736641947138239,0.9581749049429658,0.5043457267020763,0.8614987819440435,0.31052558332728447,proxy
3proxy-bp,socks-ka-50k-2000,0,8.67583393792,21075.79,94.94,95.64,97.08,118.93,0,0,0,10.1,10.095554000000002,0.9313225746154785,47.476461546416466,143.05078125,0.5037440435670524,0.9609895337773549,0.5467889908256881,0.6543105946993625,0.20327122665405828,proxy
dante,socks-ka-50k-2000,0,5.892493803520001,14314.31,184.84,188.03,191.02,199.88,0,0,0,10.2,10.196748999999999,1.384812656930663,70.58188536671442,785.1796875,0.4534053300818673,0.9695817490494296,0.4860180263461983,0.5306994172269507,0.16052484871987505,proxy
3proxy-bp,socks-ka-2k-50k-2000,0,8.1604378624,19877.51,95.82,96.67,100.72,120.87,0,0,0,10.12,10.107762999999998,0.9921036268535411,50.447899582757984,146.3203125,0.43484791588434096,0.9619771863117871,0.5286519492719587,0.5992455852093844,0.22334728215129124,proxy
dante,socks-ka-2k-50k-2000,0,5.84669200384,14203.17,185.11,188.19,191.16,199.78,0,0,0,10.18,10.171887,1.3929244083066405,71.19727520054832,782.421875,0.40569259962049337,0.9667616334283001,0.4985156428408312,0.5458227149016238,0.17290750139081254,proxy
3proxy-bp,socks-close-1k,0,0.05595201536,5493.93,4.09,6.79,8.89,11.87,8,0,0,10.08,10.078088000000001,144.1234948931784,181.69036932893528,29.0234375,0.5051143760461224,0.9581749049429658,0.4704411095952706,0.8941815686882505,0.10551339904505572,proxy
dante,socks-close-1k,0,0.03623878656,3561.9,6.84,11.28,14.6,19.49,1,0,0,10.1,10.099393000000001,222.96552304868342,280.7661301531704,58.53125,0.3834942267650956,0.9609895337773549,0.35838009270553794,0.5421806142150116,0.06650908130427907,proxy
dante,socks-stream1-down,1,11.2936958870653,nan,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.008063,0.7089896604789634,nan,13.44921875,0.032843560933448576,0.9515209125475285,0.10387547649301143,0.23593302423963355,0.11971520464136326,proxy
3proxy-bp,socks-stream1-down,1,61.03543774843403,nan,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,9.717065,0.13118743280519407,nan,34.75390625,0.19036926147704591,0.9506172839506173,0.22332015810276679,0.5832849272618086,0.5218081282560422,proxy
dante,socks-stream16,1,15.277981933652228,nan,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.05,10.029684,0.5260712793672943,nan,100.12109375,0.1431474373447731,0.9535104364326376,0.4986884290294375,0.17118687403026758,0.5166235126931561,proxy
3proxy-bp,socks-stream16,1,44.22535831987954,nan,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,4371,10.03,10.013959,0.18130578737501923,nan,73.66796875,0.30192674147787424,0.9516129032258065,0.3517959046659953,0.4555756586234994,0.582007752487401,proxy
dante,socks-ka-1k,1,0.28848422912,28212.88,1.19,4.1,4.21,4.38,0,0,0,10.07,10.069407,27.925270038415057,35.46074316139392,40.046875,0.46503563860527836,0.9581351094196003,0.5017064846416383,0.8533464366250856,0.2709403272752939,proxy
3proxy-bp,socks-ka-1k,1,0.35332816895999997,34560.58,1.83,2.72,3.9,6.9,0,0,0,10.05,10.040239,22.75504957237135,28.941934703539555,27.5859375,0.5268920476373415,0.9544159544159544,0.5679442508710801,1.0491695703001873,0.35042702607264375,client
dante,socks-ka-50k-2000,1,5.835954585600001,14177.04,181.81,187.99,190.95,202.99,1,0,0,10.19,10.187209,1.3968580256115692,71.18755370503622,782.33984375,0.4421553090332805,0.9686311787072244,0.48022206800832756,0.5200974832985292,0.1557799285387799,proxy
3proxy-bp,socks-ka-50k-2000,1,8.933531975680001,21690.49,94.2,95.21,95.89,99.92,0,0,0,10.1,10.076718000000001,0.9044575003477242,46.216430169719544,144.8828125,0.4941586748038361,0.9591642924976258,0.5393465255407272,0.6715851335669595,0.20617344426214845,proxy
dante,socks-ka-2k-50k-2000,1,5.69452265472,13833.46,185.58,188.35,191.29,206.28,0,0,0,10.22,10.208106,1.4357656463484583,73.2763565446828,787.03515625,0.4037386779726344,0.969639468690702,0.4955017301038062,0.5686355978781013,0.17373619902521278,proxy
3proxy-bp,socks-ka-2k-50k-2000,1,8.074538516479999,19579.43,95.9,96.57,101.74,120.62,0,0,0,10.12,10.108378,1.0026579207562387,51.19902863502985,141.765625,0.43322659634582783,0.9610636277302944,0.5235614492067251,0.6030420999415438,0.21186705673910358,proxy
dante,socks-close-1k,1,0.036154900479999995,3549.21,6.94,11.44,14.66,19.43,2,0,0,10.1,10.087703,223.48284444786833,282.004746614547,58.53125,0.3811881188118812,0.9591642924976258,0.3587487781036168,0.5421210358070141,0.06652521660649778,proxy
3proxy-bp,socks-close-1k,1,0.05469372416,5367.61,4.35,7.18,9.28,12.4,4,0,0,10.09,10.078190000000001,147.58548853587521,186.12115398804693,29.015625,0.5041922861934042,0.9582146248812915,0.4690346083788707,0.8912023606099028,0.10450568660088848,proxy
3proxy-bp,socks-stream1-down,2,57.36229887120687,nan,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.0,9.973225,0.13944875045923041,nan,34.98046875,0.10020570085218924,0.9505703422053232,0.1883139739528335,0.5222844706307754,0.48277207263414984,proxy
dante,socks-stream1-down,2,11.753604475365163,nan,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.01,10.008835999999999,0.6812506289556256,nan,13.6484375,0.17946927374301677,0.9515209125475285,0.1586410635155096,0.1988582845703688,0.10644563824153462,proxy
3proxy-bp,socks-stream16,2,43.675061631469575,nan,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,4421,10.01,10.013479,0.18323653504279785,nan,89.21875,0.2858690940615518,0.9515209125475285,0.3598800399866711,0.4755141671297322,0.5926556223721916,proxy
dante,socks-stream16,2,15.453823538696986,nan,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,0,10.04,10.023786,0.519573219924098,nan,116.46484375,0.14173228346456693,0.9534662867996201,0.5097706032285472,0.16362116338270416,0.4874334579230881,proxy
3proxy-bp,socks-ka-1k,2,0.35139878912,34366.01,1.85,2.74,3.91,6.77,0,0,0,10.04,10.037360000000001,22.85722162024051,29.07406066748715,27.49609375,0.5297757153905646,0.9543726235741445,0.5695233390960731,1.0691578110266728,0.31936298095471594,client
dante,socks-ka-1k,2,0.28890365951999997,28256.75,1.19,4.1,4.22,4.38,0,0,0,10.07,10.067013,27.88472812488658,35.44364390225016,39.55859375,0.47195284274576915,0.956315289648623,0.5075024201355276,0.8541140983970574,0.29068704547344687,proxy
3proxy-bp,socks-ka-50k-2000,2,8.84763262976,21420.74,94.41,95.37,97.0,112.25,0,0,0,10.11,10.092648,0.9141428378021831,46.72508457656259,144.76953125,0.5007789510126364,0.9610266159695817,0.5369685767097967,0.6809496892893266,0.20709911542400056,proxy
dante,socks-ka-50k-2000,2,6.01396084736,14609.44,180.74,187.97,191.06,206.98,0,0,0,10.19,10.186513999999999,1.3555126491351457,69.10770357610325,784.625,0.4472708002119767,0.9686311787072244,0.4841910916224325,0.5449257182858768,0.15672388946545585,proxy
3proxy-bp,socks-ka-2k-50k-2000,2,8.24633720832,20074.01,95.69,96.37,98.99,118.24,0,0,0,10.13,10.120194,0.9827393417557081,49.99876607191333,146.94140625,0.4375821287779238,0.9629277566539924,0.5272598536700496,0.6077319369455954,0.21756435670252475,proxy
dante,socks-ka-2k-50k-2000,2,5.82790152192,14157.47,185.43,188.18,191.09,197.4,0,0,0,10.19,10.17821,1.398788220655164,71.30860741777467,789.33203125,0.40357890729107176,0.9686311787072244,0.4997716894977169,0.536449313060721,0.17579235852888758,proxy
3proxy-bp,socks-close-1k,2,0.05519704064,5419.44,4.33,7.12,9.19,12.18,4,0,0,10.1,10.089447,146.38465950916606,184.5389267508359,29.03125,0.5039149888143176,0.9591642924976258,0.46954140999315536,0.892010453570365,0.10449202988381376,proxy
dante,socks-close-1k,2,0.03623878656,3554.32,6.76,11.11,14.43,19.38,3,0,0,10.12,10.096798,223.40703893590853,281.8627450980392,58.18359375,0.3843968945275516,0.9610636277302944,0.35881778212017584,0.5461040851901602,0.06558136489931111,proxy
1 proxy scenario rep gbit rate p50_ms p75_ms p90_ms p99_ms errors timeouts retrans prx_cpu_s prx_task_s cpu_s_per_gb cpu_us_per_req peak_mb cli_util prx_util srv_util cli_thread srv_thread bound
2 3proxy-bp socks-stream1-down 0 54.95798518703387 nan nan nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 9.993529 0.14569523951370048 nan 30.90625 0.08743658609370338 0.9506172839506173 0.1853555005305978 0.5069158833069751 0.47970922709920055 proxy
3 dante socks-stream1-down 0 10.755941861630104 nan nan nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.014462 0.7444363790873445 nan 13.26171875 0.017312206572769953 0.9515209125475285 0.05566801619433198 0.23402890534835158 0.11497876234460526 proxy
4 3proxy-bp socks-stream16 0 44.85364033390902 nan nan nan nan nan 0 0 4243 10.04 10.023199 0.1788190827216997 nan 108.609375 0.28963876270819816 0.952561669829222 0.364088947892466 0.4812483481390654 0.5946620905582705 proxy
5 dante socks-stream16 0 15.811853329382707 nan nan nan nan nan 0 0 1 10.03 10.025917 0.5072910594144856 nan 123.98046875 0.13795439151049899 0.9534220532319392 0.48177399756986633 0.1626791975615335 0.5275027490734411 proxy
6 3proxy-bp socks-ka-1k 0 0.34384904192000004 33632.84 1.91 2.84 4.07 7.07 0 0 0 10.06 10.040764000000001 23.405619963520063 29.75987977718547 29.02734375 0.5341772151898734 0.9544592030360531 0.5673880964092474 1.0978000360669382 0.3334424809956902 client
7 dante socks-ka-1k 0 0.28059893760000004 27446.17 1.23 4.13 4.25 4.46 0 0 0 10.08 10.093356 28.73852648542601 36.443702072735555 42.5625 0.4736641947138239 0.9581749049429658 0.5043457267020763 0.8614987819440435 0.31052558332728447 proxy
8 3proxy-bp socks-ka-50k-2000 0 8.67583393792 21075.79 94.94 95.64 97.08 118.93 0 0 0 10.1 10.095554000000002 0.9313225746154785 47.476461546416466 143.05078125 0.5037440435670524 0.9609895337773549 0.5467889908256881 0.6543105946993625 0.20327122665405828 proxy
9 dante socks-ka-50k-2000 0 5.892493803520001 14314.31 184.84 188.03 191.02 199.88 0 0 0 10.2 10.196748999999999 1.384812656930663 70.58188536671442 785.1796875 0.4534053300818673 0.9695817490494296 0.4860180263461983 0.5306994172269507 0.16052484871987505 proxy
10 3proxy-bp socks-ka-2k-50k-2000 0 8.1604378624 19877.51 95.82 96.67 100.72 120.87 0 0 0 10.12 10.107762999999998 0.9921036268535411 50.447899582757984 146.3203125 0.43484791588434096 0.9619771863117871 0.5286519492719587 0.5992455852093844 0.22334728215129124 proxy
11 dante socks-ka-2k-50k-2000 0 5.84669200384 14203.17 185.11 188.19 191.16 199.78 0 0 0 10.18 10.171887 1.3929244083066405 71.19727520054832 782.421875 0.40569259962049337 0.9667616334283001 0.4985156428408312 0.5458227149016238 0.17290750139081254 proxy
12 3proxy-bp socks-close-1k 0 0.05595201536 5493.93 4.09 6.79 8.89 11.87 8 0 0 10.08 10.078088000000001 144.1234948931784 181.69036932893528 29.0234375 0.5051143760461224 0.9581749049429658 0.4704411095952706 0.8941815686882505 0.10551339904505572 proxy
13 dante socks-close-1k 0 0.03623878656 3561.9 6.84 11.28 14.6 19.49 1 0 0 10.1 10.099393000000001 222.96552304868342 280.7661301531704 58.53125 0.3834942267650956 0.9609895337773549 0.35838009270553794 0.5421806142150116 0.06650908130427907 proxy
14 dante socks-stream1-down 1 11.2936958870653 nan nan nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.008063 0.7089896604789634 nan 13.44921875 0.032843560933448576 0.9515209125475285 0.10387547649301143 0.23593302423963355 0.11971520464136326 proxy
15 3proxy-bp socks-stream1-down 1 61.03543774843403 nan nan nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 9.717065 0.13118743280519407 nan 34.75390625 0.19036926147704591 0.9506172839506173 0.22332015810276679 0.5832849272618086 0.5218081282560422 proxy
16 dante socks-stream16 1 15.277981933652228 nan nan nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.05 10.029684 0.5260712793672943 nan 100.12109375 0.1431474373447731 0.9535104364326376 0.4986884290294375 0.17118687403026758 0.5166235126931561 proxy
17 3proxy-bp socks-stream16 1 44.22535831987954 nan nan nan nan nan 0 0 4371 10.03 10.013959 0.18130578737501923 nan 73.66796875 0.30192674147787424 0.9516129032258065 0.3517959046659953 0.4555756586234994 0.582007752487401 proxy
18 dante socks-ka-1k 1 0.28848422912 28212.88 1.19 4.1 4.21 4.38 0 0 0 10.07 10.069407 27.925270038415057 35.46074316139392 40.046875 0.46503563860527836 0.9581351094196003 0.5017064846416383 0.8533464366250856 0.2709403272752939 proxy
19 3proxy-bp socks-ka-1k 1 0.35332816895999997 34560.58 1.83 2.72 3.9 6.9 0 0 0 10.05 10.040239 22.75504957237135 28.941934703539555 27.5859375 0.5268920476373415 0.9544159544159544 0.5679442508710801 1.0491695703001873 0.35042702607264375 client
20 dante socks-ka-50k-2000 1 5.835954585600001 14177.04 181.81 187.99 190.95 202.99 1 0 0 10.19 10.187209 1.3968580256115692 71.18755370503622 782.33984375 0.4421553090332805 0.9686311787072244 0.48022206800832756 0.5200974832985292 0.1557799285387799 proxy
21 3proxy-bp socks-ka-50k-2000 1 8.933531975680001 21690.49 94.2 95.21 95.89 99.92 0 0 0 10.1 10.076718000000001 0.9044575003477242 46.216430169719544 144.8828125 0.4941586748038361 0.9591642924976258 0.5393465255407272 0.6715851335669595 0.20617344426214845 proxy
22 dante socks-ka-2k-50k-2000 1 5.69452265472 13833.46 185.58 188.35 191.29 206.28 0 0 0 10.22 10.208106 1.4357656463484583 73.2763565446828 787.03515625 0.4037386779726344 0.969639468690702 0.4955017301038062 0.5686355978781013 0.17373619902521278 proxy
23 3proxy-bp socks-ka-2k-50k-2000 1 8.074538516479999 19579.43 95.9 96.57 101.74 120.62 0 0 0 10.12 10.108378 1.0026579207562387 51.19902863502985 141.765625 0.43322659634582783 0.9610636277302944 0.5235614492067251 0.6030420999415438 0.21186705673910358 proxy
24 dante socks-close-1k 1 0.036154900479999995 3549.21 6.94 11.44 14.66 19.43 2 0 0 10.1 10.087703 223.48284444786833 282.004746614547 58.53125 0.3811881188118812 0.9591642924976258 0.3587487781036168 0.5421210358070141 0.06652521660649778 proxy
25 3proxy-bp socks-close-1k 1 0.05469372416 5367.61 4.35 7.18 9.28 12.4 4 0 0 10.09 10.078190000000001 147.58548853587521 186.12115398804693 29.015625 0.5041922861934042 0.9582146248812915 0.4690346083788707 0.8912023606099028 0.10450568660088848 proxy
26 3proxy-bp socks-stream1-down 2 57.36229887120687 nan nan nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.0 9.973225 0.13944875045923041 nan 34.98046875 0.10020570085218924 0.9505703422053232 0.1883139739528335 0.5222844706307754 0.48277207263414984 proxy
27 dante socks-stream1-down 2 11.753604475365163 nan nan nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.01 10.008835999999999 0.6812506289556256 nan 13.6484375 0.17946927374301677 0.9515209125475285 0.1586410635155096 0.1988582845703688 0.10644563824153462 proxy
28 3proxy-bp socks-stream16 2 43.675061631469575 nan nan nan nan nan 0 0 4421 10.01 10.013479 0.18323653504279785 nan 89.21875 0.2858690940615518 0.9515209125475285 0.3598800399866711 0.4755141671297322 0.5926556223721916 proxy
29 dante socks-stream16 2 15.453823538696986 nan nan nan nan nan 0 0 0 10.04 10.023786 0.519573219924098 nan 116.46484375 0.14173228346456693 0.9534662867996201 0.5097706032285472 0.16362116338270416 0.4874334579230881 proxy
30 3proxy-bp socks-ka-1k 2 0.35139878912 34366.01 1.85 2.74 3.91 6.77 0 0 0 10.04 10.037360000000001 22.85722162024051 29.07406066748715 27.49609375 0.5297757153905646 0.9543726235741445 0.5695233390960731 1.0691578110266728 0.31936298095471594 client
31 dante socks-ka-1k 2 0.28890365951999997 28256.75 1.19 4.1 4.22 4.38 0 0 0 10.07 10.067013 27.88472812488658 35.44364390225016 39.55859375 0.47195284274576915 0.956315289648623 0.5075024201355276 0.8541140983970574 0.29068704547344687 proxy
32 3proxy-bp socks-ka-50k-2000 2 8.84763262976 21420.74 94.41 95.37 97.0 112.25 0 0 0 10.11 10.092648 0.9141428378021831 46.72508457656259 144.76953125 0.5007789510126364 0.9610266159695817 0.5369685767097967 0.6809496892893266 0.20709911542400056 proxy
33 dante socks-ka-50k-2000 2 6.01396084736 14609.44 180.74 187.97 191.06 206.98 0 0 0 10.19 10.186513999999999 1.3555126491351457 69.10770357610325 784.625 0.4472708002119767 0.9686311787072244 0.4841910916224325 0.5449257182858768 0.15672388946545585 proxy
34 3proxy-bp socks-ka-2k-50k-2000 2 8.24633720832 20074.01 95.69 96.37 98.99 118.24 0 0 0 10.13 10.120194 0.9827393417557081 49.99876607191333 146.94140625 0.4375821287779238 0.9629277566539924 0.5272598536700496 0.6077319369455954 0.21756435670252475 proxy
35 dante socks-ka-2k-50k-2000 2 5.82790152192 14157.47 185.43 188.18 191.09 197.4 0 0 0 10.19 10.17821 1.398788220655164 71.30860741777467 789.33203125 0.40357890729107176 0.9686311787072244 0.4997716894977169 0.536449313060721 0.17579235852888758 proxy
36 3proxy-bp socks-close-1k 2 0.05519704064 5419.44 4.33 7.12 9.19 12.18 4 0 0 10.1 10.089447 146.38465950916606 184.5389267508359 29.03125 0.5039149888143176 0.9591642924976258 0.46954140999315536 0.892010453570365 0.10449202988381376 proxy
37 dante socks-close-1k 2 0.03623878656 3554.32 6.76 11.11 14.43 19.38 3 0 0 10.12 10.096798 223.40703893590853 281.8627450980392 58.18359375 0.3843968945275516 0.9610636277302944 0.35881778212017584 0.5461040851901602 0.06558136489931111 proxy