bench: grace delay and splice() over emulated client links

Results on both machines over per-connection emulated links: seven
grace delay settings with a fifth client CPU; the promising ones over
three link qualities (100 Mbit/s 2 ms 0.1%, 20 Mbit/s 5 ms 0.5%,
5 Mbit/s 25 ms 1%); copying against splice() with and without grace
delay, the CONNECT mix included; and the slow link with waits matched
to its rate (10 and 20 ms).

Grace delay saves 35-46% of 3proxy's CPU per gigabyte on streams at
20 Mbit/s and 21-29% at 5 Mbit/s with a 10 ms wait, does nothing on
fast links, and costs CPU with waits too short for the rate or once
the CPU is exhausted. Over these links splice() and copying cost about
the same in the mix scenarios. A caveat says that every scenario but
the mix ones is synthetic.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Vladimir DubrovinandClaude Opus 5.5 committed 2026-10-14 17:06:47 +03:00
1 parent 4ab9eb7c2b
commit 5a7399450b
19 files changed
+1272

No files matched your search

+64
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,64 @@
proxy,scenario,rep,gbit,rate,p50_ms,p90_ms,p99_ms,errors,timeouts,retrans,prx_cpu_s,prx_task_s,cpu_s_per_gb,cpu_us_per_req,peak_mb,cli_util,prx_util,srv_util,cli_thread,srv_thread,bound
nginx-halfclose,relay-stream16,0,0.2892081557591746,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1262,6.18,2.9135790000000004,17.070839320465243,nan,29.8984375,0.016046213093709884,0.48093385214007783,0.215878679750223,0.013010591748350585,0.25040826260559323,none
3proxy-devel,relay-stream16,0,0.2857842421598594,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1271,6.73,3.526554,18.814886476845913,nan,3.171875,0.0257645075848784,0.5842013888888888,0.2533202164289228,0.0133168886803674,0.2992370101026024,none
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2",relay-stream16,0,0.27937707876272416,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1182,4.82,2.446085,13.783238995736507,nan,3.25,0.009653356735410267,0.4426078971533517,0.08734491315136476,0.01141183699097601,0.11965156659370356,none
"3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2",relay-stream16,0,0.28396680158329063,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1146,5.97,3.022351,16.79479548361449,nan,3.3203125,0.02467143186534471,0.5316117542297417,0.17320099255583127,0.012364975689102067,0.20892504547800222,none
"3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2",relay-stream16,0,0.2790718268238828,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1234,4.95,2.4892909999999997,14.17092042389775,nan,3.3203125,0.010884051532652154,0.4532967032967033,0.11133102424542306,0.012364790345232298,0.1453103320113179,none
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1",relay-stream16,0,0.2814801860907315,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1232,5.82,3.96821,16.51900155203683,nan,3.375,0.012953967152440436,0.5617760617760618,0.15019762845849802,0.01046358908158917,0.17961636737722206,none
"3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2",relay-stream16,0,0.275939509376558,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1227,4.9,2.462958,14.187488881641366,nan,3.2734375,0.011715296198054819,0.44830741079597436,0.09772951628825272,0.012362681573786213,0.11966418365926669,none
nginx-halfclose,mix-relay-3k,0,0.48734861760000003,1939.8,2097.152,3670.016,6291.456,0,0,0,7.23,3.603543,11.868300824333764,372.7188369935045,747.0625,0.7756792577866136,0.598014888337469,0.23364075537988582,1.65836938436629,0.2858008215105866,client
3proxy-devel,mix-relay-3k,0,0.4561700352,1826.7,2228.224,3932.16,6553.6,0,0,0,8.68,5.198291,15.22239398507515,475.1738106968851,1522.1015625,0.792354474370113,0.7457044673539519,0.2690331620737973,1.6881498802673636,0.3566755117374211,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2",mix-relay-3k,0,0.46240552,1838.8,2097.152,3932.16,6815.744,0,0,0,8.53,4.983853,14.757609294975543,463.889493147705,1515.44921875,0.7767918088737201,0.7265758091993185,0.261070110701107,1.6391481952525777,0.3195964863435165,client
"3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2",mix-relay-3k,0,0.4576878896,1827.6,2228.224,3932.16,6553.6,0,0,0,8.53,4.994939,14.909723755120304,466.73232654847885,1519.34375,0.8,0.7469352014010507,0.24408703878902555,1.6707213049574532,0.3216726809904908,client
"3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2",mix-relay-3k,0,0.4715064288,1854.9,2228.224,3932.16,6815.744,0,0,0,8.32,4.654897999999999,14.116456517761058,448.54170036120547,1520.02734375,0.7975126992468033,0.7228496959165943,0.24113805970149255,1.665901488767502,0.3093643146353353,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1",mix-relay-3k,0,0.4748275576,1887.6,2097.152,3801.088,6553.6,1,0,0,8.79,5.299478000000001,14.809586948876783,465.6706929434202,1518.75,0.7847317744154058,0.7564543889845095,0.2646651270207852,1.647219301251118,0.3479913798101196,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2",mix-relay-3k,0,0.46063411839999996,1837.4,2097.152,3932.16,6553.6,0,0,0,8.26,4.7233730000000005,14.345441937633078,449.54827473604007,1516.03125,0.7935836418120924,0.7290379523389232,0.24764595103578155,1.6650004157980758,0.30901770580880855,client
nginx-halfclose,mix-http-3k,0,0.48807250560000004,1930.9,1835.008,3538.944,6291.456,0,0,0,6.78,3.2242699999999997,11.113102946317655,351.1315966647677,520.4296875,0.7681972789115646,0.5668896321070234,0.1662269129287599,1.4828577283342537,0.1998885059323661,client
3proxy-devel,mix-http-3k,0,0.4399745544,1778.3,2490.368,4194.304,6553.6,0,0,0,9.77,7.031374,17.764663710288424,549.401113422932,1761.34765625,0.7871011311835219,0.8357570573139436,0.27201112140871175,1.600300768099012,0.379132400217467,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2",mix-http-3k,0,0.45552811919999997,1693.2,2621.44,4718.592,6029.312,0,0,0,11.24,9.645756,19.73972543295852,663.8317977793527,1743.20703125,0.7945723119203023,0.9549702633814783,0.28978840846366144,1.832858262403009,0.4143100614146141,client
"3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2",mix-http-3k,0,0.4424801672,1785.7,2359.296,4194.304,6815.744,0,0,0,9.4,6.336798,16.99511200148543,526.4042112336899,1739.75390625,0.7588676103247294,0.7959356477561389,0.25362976406533577,1.485057992188199,0.3476775893076781,client
"3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2",mix-http-3k,0,0.44070801439999996,1802,2359.296,4194.304,6553.6,0,0,0,9.2,6.26368,16.700399719347605,510.5438401775805,1754.57421875,0.7848057152814079,0.8148804251550045,0.25204425204425207,1.549220942816068,0.3525920857986227,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1",mix-http-3k,0,0.4336608112,1768.9,2359.296,4194.304,6553.6,0,0,0,9.54,6.695874999999999,17.599007802621568,539.3182203629374,1771.83203125,0.776293540750761,0.8160821214713431,0.2532347504621072,1.5434444342847058,0.3551807030220406,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2",mix-http-3k,0,0.4642502376,1835.3,2228.224,4063.232,6553.6,0,0,0,8.69,5.5182970000000005,14.974682696855984,473.49207214079445,1746.6640625,0.7839012517385258,0.775200713648528,0.24483917426788285,1.5807728809297303,0.3289478197218446,client
3proxy-devel,relay-stream16,1,0.28532580551425396,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1365,6.69,3.440874,18.730513546444953,nan,3.1171875,0.020481066920695404,0.5802254986990459,0.2433758586849853,0.014267926755392481,0.2944763316181818,none
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2",relay-stream16,1,0.2702748108587897,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1279,4.71,2.421263,13.922684324753003,nan,3.20703125,0.014251260688445516,0.43530499075785584,0.08902077151335312,0.013316007481060037,0.11873668343165249,none
"3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2",relay-stream16,1,0.2856522195622739,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1166,6.0,3.073124,16.780193250549853,nan,3.1328125,0.015028901734104046,0.5328596802841918,0.17369727047146402,0.013314550345650752,0.21552423808124763,none
"3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2",relay-stream16,1,0.279634979521698,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1174,5.04,2.5484940000000003,14.396161900973418,nan,3.2734375,0.012305830139197095,0.4228187919463087,0.10712684894666069,0.011283149972845383,0.13347613597528635,none
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1",relay-stream16,1,0.28807749302908475,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1145,5.98,4.030689,16.58443449541076,nan,3.2734375,0.013547646383467279,0.5706106870229007,0.15167984189723321,0.011412329142925864,0.18137867953917422,none
"3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2",relay-stream16,1,0.28104054758598723,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1105,4.82,2.499747,13.7010736365965,nan,3.328125,0.013885827639409301,0.44423963133640554,0.09337944664031621,0.012362244602526258,0.12154311751012781,none
nginx-halfclose,relay-stream16,1,0.2889616860418096,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1246,6.05,2.9221209999999997,16.723853954370473,nan,29.984375,0.035454332002817564,0.5153321976149915,0.24341463414634146,0.012359583360675814,0.27810222085790864,none
3proxy-devel,mix-relay-3k,1,0.4574983208,1819.8,2359.296,4063.232,6815.744,1,0,0,8.66,5.409063,15.143224980335273,475.87646994175185,1520.26171875,0.7979940172444132,0.7629955947136564,0.27635327635327633,1.7425816130552065,0.3640361162921694,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2",mix-relay-3k,1,0.4495398776,1803.2,2097.152,4063.232,6553.6,0,0,0,8.33,4.828543,14.824046390673306,461.95652173913044,1511.69140625,0.7985828166519043,0.7345679012345679,0.2467718794835007,1.6845708948065459,0.3185059684717594,client
"3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2",mix-relay-3k,1,0.461419432,1833.6,2228.224,3932.16,6553.6,1,0,0,8.71,5.134652000000001,15.101227899738737,475.021815008726,1520.38671875,0.7812015837493544,0.7476394849785408,0.2633286972647195,1.6689879440885313,0.3467273349840476,client
"3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2",mix-relay-3k,1,0.4858724744,1906,2228.224,3801.088,6553.6,0,0,0,8.65,5.071873,14.242420315218418,453.83001049317943,1525.21484375,0.7696773092026635,0.7386848847139197,0.25393154486586494,1.637831289734135,0.3251126584004933,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1",mix-relay-3k,1,0.4704166152,1847.7,2097.152,3932.16,6553.6,0,0,0,8.62,5.023308999999999,14.659346156530058,466.5259511825513,1519.53125,0.7889593691068061,0.738013698630137,0.25301204819277107,1.4904834859454394,0.3184250881123435,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2",mix-relay-3k,1,0.4819001784,1894.4,2228.224,3932.16,6553.6,0,0,0,8.41,4.905828,13.96139761213253,443.9400337837838,1526.79296875,0.7834926151172893,0.7351398601398601,0.25777984208081745,1.636454817696407,0.32506435786198173,client
nginx-halfclose,mix-relay-3k,1,0.4600181784,1844.9,1966.08,3801.088,6291.456,0,0,0,7.38,3.8175760000000003,12.834275420451515,400.0216813919454,745.08203125,0.7921810699588477,0.6275510204081632,0.2393397524071527,1.6770109015291221,10.280941246630652,origin
3proxy-devel,mix-http-3k,1,0.43643382160000005,1790.8,2359.296,4194.304,6553.6,0,0,0,9.09,6.378599999999999,16.662320013009733,507.59437123073485,1764.296875,0.7794782608695652,0.8101604278074866,0.2686781609195402,1.5770360638874952,0.3831696688623796,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2",mix-http-3k,1,0.45135872,1792.6,2359.296,4194.304,6553.6,0,0,0,8.97,5.634254,15.898662598121513,500.39049425415595,1747.4375,0.7726729291204099,0.7752808988764045,0.24183006535947713,1.5433834543914702,0.3252550269432192,client
"3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2",mix-http-3k,1,0.429062892,1719.6,2490.368,4194.304,6815.744,0,0,0,8.99,5.898763999999999,16.76211141559173,522.795999069551,1737.31640625,0.7930200414651002,0.7906772207563765,0.25549188156638014,1.5725386096579324,0.36243958879611776,client
"3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2",mix-http-3k,1,0.45763454239999996,1808.3,2228.224,4063.232,6815.744,0,0,0,8.88,5.63954,15.52330373215289,491.06895979649397,1748.40234375,0.7893817673768774,0.7865367581930912,0.23770491803278687,1.6031953137632944,0.32759355932346773,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1",mix-http-3k,1,0.427012596,1728.3,2490.368,4456.448,7077.888,0,0,0,9.01,6.056203999999999,16.88006411876431,521.3215298269977,1734.49609375,0.787434554973822,0.8008888888888889,0.2584968884633796,1.621199855847695,0.36921810861051607,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2",mix-http-3k,1,0.44720677680000004,1776.1,2359.296,4194.304,6815.744,0,0,0,8.91,5.728802,15.93893556579038,501.66094251449806,1739.06640625,0.7881092291738679,0.784330985915493,0.24178962398857687,1.6189978686480972,0.335244150224765,client
nginx-halfclose,mix-http-3k,1,0.469133492,1849.1,2228.224,3932.16,6553.6,0,0,0,7.12,3.5936000000000003,12.14153348062389,385.05218755070035,518.41796875,0.780791538723985,0.5933333333333334,0.16768558951965065,1.730858128174371,0.2074958700946844,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2",relay-stream16,2,0.2737074595626636,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1214,4.88,2.515335,14.243093080527927,nan,3.36328125,0.014134275618374558,0.44894204231830726,0.09234567901234568,0.012362060181335163,0.12249393767711796,none
"3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2",relay-stream16,2,0.2814617468994316,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1205,5.92,3.003863,16.802833193824405,nan,3.23046875,0.013651087459509487,0.528099910793934,0.17053880375679684,0.013311760757871147,0.21180118523365457,none
"3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2",relay-stream16,2,0.27958139752256167,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1194,5.15,2.5934340000000002,14.715873346793073,nan,3.2734375,0.014808166928427194,0.46946216955332726,0.11489151873767259,0.01235378287297821,0.14802127849603053,none
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1",relay-stream16,2,0.2806145636429178,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1281,5.75,3.9473710000000004,16.369036774137125,nan,3.35546875,0.022909507445589918,0.5571705426356589,0.14666666666666667,0.012362469390810819,0.18041976805992418,none
"3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2",relay-stream16,2,0.2768497310275595,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1193,4.65,2.472749,13.417808082569024,nan,3.2734375,0.01013312139876813,0.39709649871904357,0.08213644524236983,0.011283611356455963,0.11181577197242125,none
nginx-halfclose,relay-stream16,2,0.2891098263864097,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1290,5.93,2.805394,16.386204118186345,nan,30.1640625,0.01694915254237288,0.5042517006802721,0.23549323017408125,0.010459937979017753,0.26885311427797254,none
3proxy-devel,relay-stream16,2,0.2874825622841177,nan,nan,nan,nan,0,0,1241,6.88,3.57187,19.115161826292788,nan,3.13671875,0.01707317073170732,0.5941278065630398,0.24729064039408866,0.013309449865399937,0.30466999304951253,none
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2",mix-relay-3k,2,0.47745696,1883.6,2097.152,3670.016,6291.456,0,0,0,8.82,5.111566999999999,14.778295409077291,468.2522828626035,1520.8359375,0.7710662439512765,0.7325581395348837,0.25769059295586266,1.6291479123651906,0.3369951505135265,client
"3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2",mix-relay-3k,2,0.4719242952,1861.6,2228.224,3932.16,6553.6,1,0,0,8.66,5.0573310000000005,14.680320700725813,465.19123334765794,1515.8671875,0.8030223159374451,0.757655293088364,0.2579737335834897,1.6950724964446464,0.3351330219983602,client
"3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2",mix-relay-3k,2,0.4443138568,1803.5,2359.296,4063.232,6815.744,1,0,0,9.2,5.931938999999999,16.56486712570158,510.11921264208485,1522.3203125,0.775985054347826,0.782312925170068,0.2736746714997734,1.6149264560448517,0.3653693275035307,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1",mix-relay-3k,2,0.4610125848,1822.5,2228.224,4063.232,6553.6,0,0,0,8.86,5.368497999999999,15.374851432906045,486.14540466392316,1518.23046875,0.7901342164894544,0.7731239092495636,0.2676980778246601,1.6422592525356117,0.35842743929196375,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2",mix-relay-3k,2,0.46656139680000003,1847.8,2097.152,3932.16,6553.6,0,0,0,8.45,4.984871999999999,14.488982685590244,457.3005736551575,1524.44140625,0.8001058574453069,0.7477876106194691,0.2558139534883721,1.6636909099337416,0.33667274014473014,client
nginx-halfclose,mix-relay-3k,2,0.4746159848,1879.4,2097.152,3801.088,6815.744,0,0,0,7.11,3.4781779999999998,11.98442568763647,378.3122273065872,736.421875,0.7918338858837899,0.6134598792062123,0.22984244670991658,1.5694621703101475,0.2848124834784775,client
3proxy-devel,mix-relay-3k,2,0.44558276960000004,1790.6,2359.296,4194.304,6815.744,0,0,0,9.26,5.953845000000001,16.62541845289522,517.1450910309394,1511.48046875,0.7757166947723441,0.7788057190916736,0.2783551739719837,1.6233861455530738,0.3701087189332951,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2",mix-http-3k,2,0.42168975760000005,1739.2,2490.368,4194.304,6815.744,0,0,0,10.03,7.381878,19.028207006183163,576.7019319227231,1748.36328125,0.765518417462483,0.8602058319039451,0.28278114792347175,1.5683754046843221,0.40388280366201684,client
"3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2",mix-http-3k,2,0.442154568,1774.3,2359.296,4194.304,6553.6,0,0,0,9.1,6.202287,16.4648304617312,512.8783182099983,1753.69140625,0.7923317140874393,0.8074534161490683,0.2557915057915058,1.5672393608993933,0.35872871036448695,client
"3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2",mix-http-3k,2,0.4377386536,1749.7,2359.296,4194.304,6553.6,0,0,0,9.9,7.101688000000001,18.092987527752562,565.8112819340458,1743.640625,0.7647654404319946,0.8396946564885496,0.2689463955637708,1.5459925754116635,0.3656838552784408,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1",mix-http-3k,2,0.4339557912,1762,2359.296,4194.304,6815.744,0,0,0,9.04,6.064204,16.66529205659786,513.0533484676504,1746.5859375,0.7860473147988257,0.7985865724381626,0.2564717162032598,1.545191722504236,0.35735820774528226,client
"3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2",mix-http-3k,2,0.4556308208,1793.1,2228.224,4194.304,6815.744,0,0,0,9.31,6.104365000000001,16.346567571795838,519.2125369471864,1739.10546875,0.7729566094853683,0.7896522476675149,0.23800738007380073,1.5638531639855764,0.3272982896809508,client
nginx-halfclose,mix-http-3k,2,0.4955415328,1952,1900.544,3538.944,6029.312,0,0,0,6.74,3.146,10.881025389603833,345.28688524590166,523.42578125,0.7624047417442845,0.5635451505016722,0.16363636363636364,1.4527324981602945,0.2004719441200723,client
3proxy-devel,mix-http-3k,2,0.4493320152,1826.7,2490.368,4194.304,6815.744,0,0,0,9.2,6.232328000000001,16.379870009315997,503.6404445174358,1760.32421875,0.7772337821297429,0.8141592920353983,0.2698643410852713,1.5775183261443408,0.37932599622895097,client
1 proxy scenario rep gbit rate p50_ms p90_ms p99_ms errors timeouts retrans prx_cpu_s prx_task_s cpu_s_per_gb cpu_us_per_req peak_mb cli_util prx_util srv_util cli_thread srv_thread bound
2 nginx-halfclose relay-stream16 0 0.2892081557591746 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1262 6.18 2.9135790000000004 17.070839320465243 nan 29.8984375 0.016046213093709884 0.48093385214007783 0.215878679750223 0.013010591748350585 0.25040826260559323 none
3 3proxy-devel relay-stream16 0 0.2857842421598594 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1271 6.73 3.526554 18.814886476845913 nan 3.171875 0.0257645075848784 0.5842013888888888 0.2533202164289228 0.0133168886803674 0.2992370101026024 none
4 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2 relay-stream16 0 0.27937707876272416 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1182 4.82 2.446085 13.783238995736507 nan 3.25 0.009653356735410267 0.4426078971533517 0.08734491315136476 0.01141183699097601 0.11965156659370356 none
5 3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2 relay-stream16 0 0.28396680158329063 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1146 5.97 3.022351 16.79479548361449 nan 3.3203125 0.02467143186534471 0.5316117542297417 0.17320099255583127 0.012364975689102067 0.20892504547800222 none
6 3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2 relay-stream16 0 0.2790718268238828 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1234 4.95 2.4892909999999997 14.17092042389775 nan 3.3203125 0.010884051532652154 0.4532967032967033 0.11133102424542306 0.012364790345232298 0.1453103320113179 none
7 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1 relay-stream16 0 0.2814801860907315 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1232 5.82 3.96821 16.51900155203683 nan 3.375 0.012953967152440436 0.5617760617760618 0.15019762845849802 0.01046358908158917 0.17961636737722206 none
8 3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2 relay-stream16 0 0.275939509376558 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1227 4.9 2.462958 14.187488881641366 nan 3.2734375 0.011715296198054819 0.44830741079597436 0.09772951628825272 0.012362681573786213 0.11966418365926669 none
9 nginx-halfclose mix-relay-3k 0 0.48734861760000003 1939.8 2097.152 3670.016 6291.456 0 0 0 7.23 3.603543 11.868300824333764 372.7188369935045 747.0625 0.7756792577866136 0.598014888337469 0.23364075537988582 1.65836938436629 0.2858008215105866 client
10 3proxy-devel mix-relay-3k 0 0.4561700352 1826.7 2228.224 3932.16 6553.6 0 0 0 8.68 5.198291 15.22239398507515 475.1738106968851 1522.1015625 0.792354474370113 0.7457044673539519 0.2690331620737973 1.6881498802673636 0.3566755117374211 client
11 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2 mix-relay-3k 0 0.46240552 1838.8 2097.152 3932.16 6815.744 0 0 0 8.53 4.983853 14.757609294975543 463.889493147705 1515.44921875 0.7767918088737201 0.7265758091993185 0.261070110701107 1.6391481952525777 0.3195964863435165 client
12 3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2 mix-relay-3k 0 0.4576878896 1827.6 2228.224 3932.16 6553.6 0 0 0 8.53 4.994939 14.909723755120304 466.73232654847885 1519.34375 0.8 0.7469352014010507 0.24408703878902555 1.6707213049574532 0.3216726809904908 client
13 3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2 mix-relay-3k 0 0.4715064288 1854.9 2228.224 3932.16 6815.744 0 0 0 8.32 4.654897999999999 14.116456517761058 448.54170036120547 1520.02734375 0.7975126992468033 0.7228496959165943 0.24113805970149255 1.665901488767502 0.3093643146353353 client
14 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1 mix-relay-3k 0 0.4748275576 1887.6 2097.152 3801.088 6553.6 1 0 0 8.79 5.299478000000001 14.809586948876783 465.6706929434202 1518.75 0.7847317744154058 0.7564543889845095 0.2646651270207852 1.647219301251118 0.3479913798101196 client
15 3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2 mix-relay-3k 0 0.46063411839999996 1837.4 2097.152 3932.16 6553.6 0 0 0 8.26 4.7233730000000005 14.345441937633078 449.54827473604007 1516.03125 0.7935836418120924 0.7290379523389232 0.24764595103578155 1.6650004157980758 0.30901770580880855 client
16 nginx-halfclose mix-http-3k 0 0.48807250560000004 1930.9 1835.008 3538.944 6291.456 0 0 0 6.78 3.2242699999999997 11.113102946317655 351.1315966647677 520.4296875 0.7681972789115646 0.5668896321070234 0.1662269129287599 1.4828577283342537 0.1998885059323661 client
17 3proxy-devel mix-http-3k 0 0.4399745544 1778.3 2490.368 4194.304 6553.6 0 0 0 9.77 7.031374 17.764663710288424 549.401113422932 1761.34765625 0.7871011311835219 0.8357570573139436 0.27201112140871175 1.600300768099012 0.379132400217467 client
18 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2 mix-http-3k 0 0.45552811919999997 1693.2 2621.44 4718.592 6029.312 0 0 0 11.24 9.645756 19.73972543295852 663.8317977793527 1743.20703125 0.7945723119203023 0.9549702633814783 0.28978840846366144 1.832858262403009 0.4143100614146141 client
19 3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2 mix-http-3k 0 0.4424801672 1785.7 2359.296 4194.304 6815.744 0 0 0 9.4 6.336798 16.99511200148543 526.4042112336899 1739.75390625 0.7588676103247294 0.7959356477561389 0.25362976406533577 1.485057992188199 0.3476775893076781 client
20 3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2 mix-http-3k 0 0.44070801439999996 1802 2359.296 4194.304 6553.6 0 0 0 9.2 6.26368 16.700399719347605 510.5438401775805 1754.57421875 0.7848057152814079 0.8148804251550045 0.25204425204425207 1.549220942816068 0.3525920857986227 client
21 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1 mix-http-3k 0 0.4336608112 1768.9 2359.296 4194.304 6553.6 0 0 0 9.54 6.695874999999999 17.599007802621568 539.3182203629374 1771.83203125 0.776293540750761 0.8160821214713431 0.2532347504621072 1.5434444342847058 0.3551807030220406 client
22 3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2 mix-http-3k 0 0.4642502376 1835.3 2228.224 4063.232 6553.6 0 0 0 8.69 5.5182970000000005 14.974682696855984 473.49207214079445 1746.6640625 0.7839012517385258 0.775200713648528 0.24483917426788285 1.5807728809297303 0.3289478197218446 client
23 3proxy-devel relay-stream16 1 0.28532580551425396 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1365 6.69 3.440874 18.730513546444953 nan 3.1171875 0.020481066920695404 0.5802254986990459 0.2433758586849853 0.014267926755392481 0.2944763316181818 none
24 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2 relay-stream16 1 0.2702748108587897 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1279 4.71 2.421263 13.922684324753003 nan 3.20703125 0.014251260688445516 0.43530499075785584 0.08902077151335312 0.013316007481060037 0.11873668343165249 none
25 3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2 relay-stream16 1 0.2856522195622739 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1166 6.0 3.073124 16.780193250549853 nan 3.1328125 0.015028901734104046 0.5328596802841918 0.17369727047146402 0.013314550345650752 0.21552423808124763 none
26 3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2 relay-stream16 1 0.279634979521698 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1174 5.04 2.5484940000000003 14.396161900973418 nan 3.2734375 0.012305830139197095 0.4228187919463087 0.10712684894666069 0.011283149972845383 0.13347613597528635 none
27 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1 relay-stream16 1 0.28807749302908475 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1145 5.98 4.030689 16.58443449541076 nan 3.2734375 0.013547646383467279 0.5706106870229007 0.15167984189723321 0.011412329142925864 0.18137867953917422 none
28 3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2 relay-stream16 1 0.28104054758598723 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1105 4.82 2.499747 13.7010736365965 nan 3.328125 0.013885827639409301 0.44423963133640554 0.09337944664031621 0.012362244602526258 0.12154311751012781 none
29 nginx-halfclose relay-stream16 1 0.2889616860418096 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1246 6.05 2.9221209999999997 16.723853954370473 nan 29.984375 0.035454332002817564 0.5153321976149915 0.24341463414634146 0.012359583360675814 0.27810222085790864 none
30 3proxy-devel mix-relay-3k 1 0.4574983208 1819.8 2359.296 4063.232 6815.744 1 0 0 8.66 5.409063 15.143224980335273 475.87646994175185 1520.26171875 0.7979940172444132 0.7629955947136564 0.27635327635327633 1.7425816130552065 0.3640361162921694 client
31 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2 mix-relay-3k 1 0.4495398776 1803.2 2097.152 4063.232 6553.6 0 0 0 8.33 4.828543 14.824046390673306 461.95652173913044 1511.69140625 0.7985828166519043 0.7345679012345679 0.2467718794835007 1.6845708948065459 0.3185059684717594 client
32 3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2 mix-relay-3k 1 0.461419432 1833.6 2228.224 3932.16 6553.6 1 0 0 8.71 5.134652000000001 15.101227899738737 475.021815008726 1520.38671875 0.7812015837493544 0.7476394849785408 0.2633286972647195 1.6689879440885313 0.3467273349840476 client
33 3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2 mix-relay-3k 1 0.4858724744 1906 2228.224 3801.088 6553.6 0 0 0 8.65 5.071873 14.242420315218418 453.83001049317943 1525.21484375 0.7696773092026635 0.7386848847139197 0.25393154486586494 1.637831289734135 0.3251126584004933 client
34 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1 mix-relay-3k 1 0.4704166152 1847.7 2097.152 3932.16 6553.6 0 0 0 8.62 5.023308999999999 14.659346156530058 466.5259511825513 1519.53125 0.7889593691068061 0.738013698630137 0.25301204819277107 1.4904834859454394 0.3184250881123435 client
35 3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2 mix-relay-3k 1 0.4819001784 1894.4 2228.224 3932.16 6553.6 0 0 0 8.41 4.905828 13.96139761213253 443.9400337837838 1526.79296875 0.7834926151172893 0.7351398601398601 0.25777984208081745 1.636454817696407 0.32506435786198173 client
36 nginx-halfclose mix-relay-3k 1 0.4600181784 1844.9 1966.08 3801.088 6291.456 0 0 0 7.38 3.8175760000000003 12.834275420451515 400.0216813919454 745.08203125 0.7921810699588477 0.6275510204081632 0.2393397524071527 1.6770109015291221 10.280941246630652 origin
37 3proxy-devel mix-http-3k 1 0.43643382160000005 1790.8 2359.296 4194.304 6553.6 0 0 0 9.09 6.378599999999999 16.662320013009733 507.59437123073485 1764.296875 0.7794782608695652 0.8101604278074866 0.2686781609195402 1.5770360638874952 0.3831696688623796 client
38 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2 mix-http-3k 1 0.45135872 1792.6 2359.296 4194.304 6553.6 0 0 0 8.97 5.634254 15.898662598121513 500.39049425415595 1747.4375 0.7726729291204099 0.7752808988764045 0.24183006535947713 1.5433834543914702 0.3252550269432192 client
39 3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2 mix-http-3k 1 0.429062892 1719.6 2490.368 4194.304 6815.744 0 0 0 8.99 5.898763999999999 16.76211141559173 522.795999069551 1737.31640625 0.7930200414651002 0.7906772207563765 0.25549188156638014 1.5725386096579324 0.36243958879611776 client
40 3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2 mix-http-3k 1 0.45763454239999996 1808.3 2228.224 4063.232 6815.744 0 0 0 8.88 5.63954 15.52330373215289 491.06895979649397 1748.40234375 0.7893817673768774 0.7865367581930912 0.23770491803278687 1.6031953137632944 0.32759355932346773 client
41 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1 mix-http-3k 1 0.427012596 1728.3 2490.368 4456.448 7077.888 0 0 0 9.01 6.056203999999999 16.88006411876431 521.3215298269977 1734.49609375 0.787434554973822 0.8008888888888889 0.2584968884633796 1.621199855847695 0.36921810861051607 client
42 3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2 mix-http-3k 1 0.44720677680000004 1776.1 2359.296 4194.304 6815.744 0 0 0 8.91 5.728802 15.93893556579038 501.66094251449806 1739.06640625 0.7881092291738679 0.784330985915493 0.24178962398857687 1.6189978686480972 0.335244150224765 client
43 nginx-halfclose mix-http-3k 1 0.469133492 1849.1 2228.224 3932.16 6553.6 0 0 0 7.12 3.5936000000000003 12.14153348062389 385.05218755070035 518.41796875 0.780791538723985 0.5933333333333334 0.16768558951965065 1.730858128174371 0.2074958700946844 client
44 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2 relay-stream16 2 0.2737074595626636 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1214 4.88 2.515335 14.243093080527927 nan 3.36328125 0.014134275618374558 0.44894204231830726 0.09234567901234568 0.012362060181335163 0.12249393767711796 none
45 3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2 relay-stream16 2 0.2814617468994316 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1205 5.92 3.003863 16.802833193824405 nan 3.23046875 0.013651087459509487 0.528099910793934 0.17053880375679684 0.013311760757871147 0.21180118523365457 none
46 3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2 relay-stream16 2 0.27958139752256167 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1194 5.15 2.5934340000000002 14.715873346793073 nan 3.2734375 0.014808166928427194 0.46946216955332726 0.11489151873767259 0.01235378287297821 0.14802127849603053 none
47 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1 relay-stream16 2 0.2806145636429178 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1281 5.75 3.9473710000000004 16.369036774137125 nan 3.35546875 0.022909507445589918 0.5571705426356589 0.14666666666666667 0.012362469390810819 0.18041976805992418 none
48 3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2 relay-stream16 2 0.2768497310275595 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1193 4.65 2.472749 13.417808082569024 nan 3.2734375 0.01013312139876813 0.39709649871904357 0.08213644524236983 0.011283611356455963 0.11181577197242125 none
49 nginx-halfclose relay-stream16 2 0.2891098263864097 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1290 5.93 2.805394 16.386204118186345 nan 30.1640625 0.01694915254237288 0.5042517006802721 0.23549323017408125 0.010459937979017753 0.26885311427797254 none
50 3proxy-devel relay-stream16 2 0.2874825622841177 nan nan nan nan 0 0 1241 6.88 3.57187 19.115161826292788 nan 3.13671875 0.01707317073170732 0.5941278065630398 0.24729064039408866 0.013309449865399937 0.30466999304951253 none
51 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2 mix-relay-3k 2 0.47745696 1883.6 2097.152 3670.016 6291.456 0 0 0 8.82 5.111566999999999 14.778295409077291 468.2522828626035 1520.8359375 0.7710662439512765 0.7325581395348837 0.25769059295586266 1.6291479123651906 0.3369951505135265 client
52 3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2 mix-relay-3k 2 0.4719242952 1861.6 2228.224 3932.16 6553.6 1 0 0 8.66 5.0573310000000005 14.680320700725813 465.19123334765794 1515.8671875 0.8030223159374451 0.757655293088364 0.2579737335834897 1.6950724964446464 0.3351330219983602 client
53 3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2 mix-relay-3k 2 0.4443138568 1803.5 2359.296 4063.232 6815.744 1 0 0 9.2 5.931938999999999 16.56486712570158 510.11921264208485 1522.3203125 0.775985054347826 0.782312925170068 0.2736746714997734 1.6149264560448517 0.3653693275035307 client
54 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1 mix-relay-3k 2 0.4610125848 1822.5 2228.224 4063.232 6553.6 0 0 0 8.86 5.368497999999999 15.374851432906045 486.14540466392316 1518.23046875 0.7901342164894544 0.7731239092495636 0.2676980778246601 1.6422592525356117 0.35842743929196375 client
55 3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2 mix-relay-3k 2 0.46656139680000003 1847.8 2097.152 3932.16 6553.6 0 0 0 8.45 4.984871999999999 14.488982685590244 457.3005736551575 1524.44140625 0.8001058574453069 0.7477876106194691 0.2558139534883721 1.6636909099337416 0.33667274014473014 client
56 nginx-halfclose mix-relay-3k 2 0.4746159848 1879.4 2097.152 3801.088 6815.744 0 0 0 7.11 3.4781779999999998 11.98442568763647 378.3122273065872 736.421875 0.7918338858837899 0.6134598792062123 0.22984244670991658 1.5694621703101475 0.2848124834784775 client
57 3proxy-devel mix-relay-3k 2 0.44558276960000004 1790.6 2359.296 4194.304 6815.744 0 0 0 9.26 5.953845000000001 16.62541845289522 517.1450910309394 1511.48046875 0.7757166947723441 0.7788057190916736 0.2783551739719837 1.6233861455530738 0.3701087189332951 client
58 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,2 mix-http-3k 2 0.42168975760000005 1739.2 2490.368 4194.304 6815.744 0 0 0 10.03 7.381878 19.028207006183163 576.7019319227231 1748.36328125 0.765518417462483 0.8602058319039451 0.28278114792347175 1.5683754046843221 0.40388280366201684 client
59 3proxy-devel-g4000,3,2 mix-http-3k 2 0.442154568 1774.3 2359.296 4194.304 6553.6 0 0 0 9.1 6.202287 16.4648304617312 512.8783182099983 1753.69140625 0.7923317140874393 0.8074534161490683 0.2557915057915058 1.5672393608993933 0.35872871036448695 client
60 3proxy-devel-g6000,3,2 mix-http-3k 2 0.4377386536 1749.7 2359.296 4194.304 6553.6 0 0 0 9.9 7.101688000000001 18.092987527752562 565.8112819340458 1743.640625 0.7647654404319946 0.8396946564885496 0.2689463955637708 1.5459925754116635 0.3656838552784408 client
61 3proxy-devel-g8000,3,1 mix-http-3k 2 0.4339557912 1762 2359.296 4194.304 6815.744 0 0 0 9.04 6.064204 16.66529205659786 513.0533484676504 1746.5859375 0.7860473147988257 0.7985865724381626 0.2564717162032598 1.545191722504236 0.35735820774528226 client
62 3proxy-devel-g8000,2,2 mix-http-3k 2 0.4556308208 1793.1 2228.224 4194.304 6815.744 0 0 0 9.31 6.104365000000001 16.346567571795838 519.2125369471864 1739.10546875 0.7729566094853683 0.7896522476675149 0.23800738007380073 1.5638531639855764 0.3272982896809508 client
63 nginx-halfclose mix-http-3k 2 0.4955415328 1952 1900.544 3538.944 6029.312 0 0 0 6.74 3.146 10.881025389603833 345.28688524590166 523.42578125 0.7624047417442845 0.5635451505016722 0.16363636363636364 1.4527324981602945 0.2004719441200723 client
64 3proxy-devel mix-http-3k 2 0.4493320152 1826.7 2490.368 4194.304 6815.744 0 0 0 9.2 6.232328000000001 16.379870009315997 503.6404445174358 1760.32421875 0.7772337821297429 0.8141592920353983 0.2698643410852713 1.5775183261443408 0.37932599622895097 client